The Bergen Blood Pressure Study: blood pressure changes, target organ damage and mortality in subjects with high and low blood pressure over 27 years

What should be the optimal levels of blood pressure: Does the J-curve phenomenon really exist?

INTRODUCTION

The blood pressure (BP) J-curve debate has lasted for over 30 years and we still cannot definitively answer all the questions. However, recent studies suggest that BP should be reduced carefully in patients with hypertension and coronary artery disease. BP should not fall below 110 - 115/70 - 75 mmHg, because this may be associated with more cardiovascular events.

AREAS COVERED

A retrospective analysis of the INVEST Trial and the results of the BP arm of the ACCORD Trial shows that care is needed in patients with hypertension and diabetes. Although the ACCORD BP Trial suggests important benefits connected with the significant reduction of stroke in patients being treated intensively, it also shows the lack of advantage of such therapy on each main and other additional endpoints. The ACCORD Trial also confirmed the increased risk of adverse events that might appear when intensive treatment was used in this group of patients.

EXPERT OPINION

Most available studies were observational and randomized trials (BBB, HOT, ACCORD BP), do not have or have lost their statistical power and were inconclusive. Further studies are therefore needed to provide definitive conclusions on the subject. In the meantime, it seems that in high-risk patients with hypertension, it is necessary to carefully select those who might suffer adverse events and those who may benefit from intensive BP lowering.

Beta-2 adrenoceptor genetic variation is associated with genetic predisposition to essential hypertension: The Bergen Blood Pressure Study

We tested the hypothesis that genetic variation in the beta-2 adrenoceptor gene is associated with a genetic predisposition to hypertension. Offspring of two hypertensive parents were compared with offspring of two normotensive parents. The subjects were participants of the Bergen Blood Pressure Study, where couples were recruited in 1963 to 1964 and re-examined in 1990. We studied offspring of those couples in which both partners were either hypertensive or normotensive in both examinations. Twenty-three hypertensive and 22 normotensive families met the inclusion criteria. DNA samples from the first born of hypertensive family-history offspring and normotensive family-history offspring were analyzed. We used multiplex sequencing and specifically examined the promoter and the N-terminal portion of the beta-2 adrenoceptor gene. We found four genetic variants: at position -47, a C-->T substitution in the 5' leader cistron causing an Arg-->Cys exchange, at -20, a T-->C substitution, at +46 an A-->G substitution leading to an Arg16-->Gly exchange, and at +79, a C-->G substitution leading to a Gln27-->Glu exchange. The frequency of the Arg16 allele was significantly higher in the hypertensive family-history offspring compared to normotensive family-history offspring (58% vs. 28% P < 0.011). We constructed haplotypes for the four intragenic variants and found significant linkage dysequilibrium. In particular, the 5' leader cistron mutant with the wild type alleles at the other loci was significantly more frequent in offspring of hypertensive parents, compared to offspring of normotensive parents. We also performed a relative risk analysis comparing the Gly/Gly, Arg/Gly, and Arg/Arg alleles, which implicated the Arg-containing allele. Finally, we analyzed the effect of genotype on blood pressure in the offspring. We found a significant step-wise effect for all four polymorphisms examined. Our data suggest that the Arg variant of the Arg-->Gly exchange is associated with parental hypertension and higher blood pressure values in this northern European population.

Diastolic pressure underestimates age-related hemodynamic impairment

It has been hypothesized that as large arteries become more rigid with age, the pattern of hypertension changes from diastolic to systolic. Thus, diastolic blood pressure (DBP) may lose its ability to reflect the increase in vascular resistance with age. To assess this, we studied the age-related changes in blood pressure pattern and its steady-state and pulsatile determinants. We performed an epidemiological analysis based on a national survey of 10,462 subjects from Argentina. A hemodynamic analysis (impedance cardiography) was then carried out in 636 consecutive hypertensive patients (age, 25 to 74 years). Whereas the rate of increment in the prevalence of mild to moderate hypertension (MMH) reached a plateau after the sixth decade, isolated and borderline systolic forms of hypertension began a steep and sustained rise. Among patients with MMH, DBP remained stable from the third to the seventh decade, whereas SBP maintained a sustained increase. Despite similar DBP, the systemic vascular resistance index increased 47% (P<.01) and the cardiac index decreased 27% (P<.01), whereas the ratio of stroke volume to pulse pressure, an index of arterial compliance, decreased 45% (P<.01). However, there were no significant differences between older patients with MMH and those with isolated systolic hypertension in the level of SBP, vascular resistance, stroke volume, and cardiac index. Compared with age-matched normotensive control subjects, the ratio of stroke volume to pulse pressure was much more reduced in isolated systolic hypertension (48%) than in MMH (30%). In summary, the present study, carried out in a large sample of hypertensive subjects with a wide age range, showed a simultaneous impairment in vascular resistance and arterial compliance associated with aging in different patterns of hypertension. The magnitude of these changes, with opposite effects on DBP but additive effects on SBP, suggests that a hemodynamic mechanism could determine the transition in the prevalence of diastolic hypertension toward a systolic pattern of hypertension with aging. Also, the results suggest that SBP, but not DBP, is a reliable indicator of the underlying hemodynamic abnormalities (high resistance and low arterial compliance) in the elderly.

The case for a greater blood pressure fall

Several large intervention trials in hypertension have shown that treated hypertensive patients are at increased risk of cardiovascular morbidity and mortality in spite of being treated. One possible explanation for this is the fact that the treated blood pressure rarely if ever is brought down to strictly normotensive levels. Against this view is the J-curve argument that suggests that too vigorous lowering of blood pressure may increase cardiovascular risks. Two prospective intervention trials have addressed this problem, the BBB Study, which has been published, and the much larger HOT Study which is still ongoing. Some of the findings in these two trials will be discussed with an emphasis on giving an up-date of the HOT Study.

The Bergen Blood Pressure Study: prehypertensive changes in cardiac structure and function in offspring of hypertensive families

Cardiac morphology and function were determined by echocardiography in normotensive offspring of 23 hypertensive and 22 normotensive families. The family histories of hypertension or normotension were based on 27 years' observation of parental blood pressure. Pulsed Doppler and M-mode echocardiography were performed in standard views. Out of the total 109 offspring, 94 participated in the present study (age (mean +/- SD) 36 +/- 7 years). Left ventricular posterior wall thickness was higher in offspring of hypertensive than normotensive families (10.1 +/- 1.7 vs. 9.3 +/- 1.5 mm; p < 0.05). Offspring of hypertensive families had lower transmitral early/late peak flow velocities (p < 0.001) and higher transmitral late peak flow velocities (p < 0.001) than offspring of normotensive families, but the differences between groups became inconsistent after adjustment for confounding variables (including left ventricular structural parameters). On the other hand, the family history of hypertension was consistently associated with increased transmitral early peak flow velocity and increased transmitral acceleration and deceleration slopes p < 0.05), a pattern suggesting increased left ventricular stiffness. Increased posterior wall thickness and diastolic functional changes may indicate cardiac hypertrophy and decreased left ventricular compliance and precede the development of hypertension in offspring of hypertensive families.