Ia- macrophages and cytokine networks contribute to tumor-induced suppression of CD4+ autoreactive T cells

CD40 ligation restores cytolytic T lymphocyte response and eliminates fibrosarcoma in the peritoneum of mice lacking CD4+ T cells

Absence of CD4(+) T cell help has been suggested as a mechanism for failed anti-tumor cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) response. We examined the requirement for CD4(+) T cells to eliminate an immunogenic murine fibrosarcoma (6132A) inoculated into the peritoneal cavity. Immunocompetent C3H mice eliminated both single and repeat intraperitoneal (IP) inoculums, and developed high frequency of 6132A-specific interferon-gamma (IFNgamma)-producing CTL in the peritoneal cavity. Adoptive transfer of peritoneal exudate cells (PEC) isolated from control mice, protected SCID mice from challenge with 6132A. In contrast, CD4 depleted mice had diminished ability to eliminate tumor and succumbed to repeat IP challenges. Mice depleted of CD4(+) T cells lacked tumor-specific IFNgamma producing CTL in the peritoneal cavity. Adoptive transfer of PEC from CD4 depleted mice failed to protect SCID mice from 6132A. However, splenocytes isolated from same CD4 depleted mice prevented tumor growth in SCID mice, suggesting that 6132A-specific CTL response was generated, but was not sustained in the peritoneum. Treating CD4 depleted mice with agonist anti-CD40 antibody, starting on days 3 or 8 after initiating tumor challenge, led to persistence of 6132A-specific IFNgamma producing CTL in the peritoneum, and eliminated 6132A tumor. The findings suggest that CTL can be activated in the absence of CD4(+) T cells, but CD4(+) T cells are required for a persistent CTL response at the tumor site. Exogenous stimulation through CD40 can restore tumor-specific CTL activity to the peritoneum and promote tumor clearance in the absence of CD4(+) T cells.

Tumor-derived cytokines dysregulate macrophage interferon-gamma responsiveness and interferon regulatory factor-8 expression

Tumors can evade immune responses through suppressor signals that dysregulate host effector cell function. In this study we demonstrate that tumor-derived suppressor molecules impede host antitumor immune activity through dysregulation of multiple macrophage (Mphi) pathways, including suppressed production of cytotoxic and immunostimulatory agents and impaired expression of the interferon regulatory factor-8 (IRF-8) protein, a critical transducer of interferon-gamma-mediated activation pathways. The tumor-derived immunosuppressive cytokines interleukin-10 and transforming growth factor-beta(1) constrain IRF-8 production by normal Mphis, regardless of priming, and IRF-8 is also dysregulated in primary Mphis from tumor-burdened hosts. Collectively, these data describe a new mechanism by which tumors disrupt immune function and suggest that abrogation of tumor-derived immunoregulatory factors in situ can restore immune function and enhance antitumor efficacy.

MHC expression in nonlymphoid tissues of the developing embryo: strongest class I or class II expression in separate populations of potential antigen-presenting cells in the skin, lung, gut, and inter-organ connective tissue

We define expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens in the nonlymphoid tissues of the developing rat. Antibodies to class I heavy and light chains (b2-m), and to class II MHC proteins were used. Strongest MHC expression was by individual cells in the skin, lung, gut, and inter-organ connective tissue. The class I+ and class II+ cells were distinct populations, differing in morphology, distribution, and expression of macrophage-associated antigens. A nonimmunologic role for MHC proteins in development has been proposed. Yet the distributions and antigenic profiles lead us to emphasize immunologic functions that may be served by the early presence of MHC+ cells outside the forming lymphoid organs. Potential contributions to establishment of extrathymic or maternal/fetal tolerance are discussed. Localization of strongest MHC expression to individual connective tissue cells of the developing organs, rather than parenchymal cells, is of clinical relevance to transplantation of fetal tissue.

Promotion of macrophage-stimulated autoreactive T cell proliferation by interleukin-10: counteraction of macrophage suppressor activity during tumor growth

CD4+ autoreactive T cells are a major cell population in regulating immune responses to altered autologous neoplastic cells. Normal autoreactive T cells recognize major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules in association with self-peptides on antigen-presenting cells, such as macrophages (M phi). Tumor-bearing hosts (TBH) have decreased autoreactivity partly because tumors increase M phi secretion of suppressor molecules like prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) and decrease M phi MHC class II expression. Because interleukin (IL)-10, a cytokine produced by T cells, M phi, and tumor cells, inhibits production of most M phi suppressor molecules, we determined if IL-10 could reverse tumor-induced murine splenic M phi-mediated suppression of autoreactive T cell proliferation. Tumor growth enhanced activated M phi production of PGE2, nitric oxide, and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha). IL-10 strongly reduced or inhibited M phi production of these molecules. When added to pure normal host (NH) CD4+ T cells, NH syngeneic splenic M phi stimulated autoreactive T cell proliferation more than did TBH splenic M phi. Exogenous IL-10 or M phi preincubation with IL-10 restored TBH M phi-stimulated autoreactivity to normal levels. IL-10 treatment had little or no effect on NH M phi-stimulated autoreactivity. IL-10 inhibited TBH M phi secretion of suppressor molecules in T cell proliferation assays because supernatants from IL-10-pretreated TBH M phi-syngeneic NH T cell cultures had decreased levels of suppressor molecules. When endogenous IL-10 activity was neutralized with anti-IL-10 monoclonal antibody, autoreactive T cell proliferation stimulated by NH or TBH M phi was slightly, but significantly decreased. Although IL-10 is known to inhibit M phi foreign antigen-presenting cell-dependent T cell proliferation, this study shows that IL-10 restores autoreactive T cell functions during tumor growth by counteracting M phi production of inhibitory molecules. These data suggest that IL-10 up-regulates anti-cancer autoreactive T cell responses by down-regulating suppressor M phi activity.

L-5178-Y lymphoma associated immunosuppression in Balb/c mice

Lymphoma L-5178-Y bearing Balb/c mice were unable to mount a delayed-type hypersensitivity reaction to dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB). A suppressor factor present in the ascitis of these mice inhibited the response if given during DNFB sensitization, but not during challenge. The factor was not present in lymphoma-bearing Balb/c nu/nu mice. It appeared to be a 35-66 kDa protein. Non-specific esterase staining indicated that the spleens of tumor-bearing and ascitis-injected mice contained a large excess of macrophages. Our observation that the suppressor factor prevented the very start of the immune response may indicate why immunostimulation is difficult to obtain in cancer bearing hosts.

Eicosanoids and the immunology of cancer

Studies in both cancer patients and in animal tumor models have shown that immune defenses can mediate destruction of tumor, but these defenses are often functioning at a suppressed or suboptimal level. Frequently, prostaglandins, mainly PGE2, have been implicated in this tumor-associated subversion of immune function, with immune reactivities to tumor typically being enhanced by prostaglandin synthesis inhibitor. Both the tumor and tumor-induced host immune suppressive macrophages have the capacity to suppress immune functions through their production of PGE2. Although the inhibitory functions have been more widely studied, recent evaluations of the effects of PGE2 have led to the surprising realization that not all of the PGE2's effects are inhibitory to immune function. Summarized below are some of the well characterized inhibitory effects of PGE2, as well as the lesser studied stimulatory effects of PGE2 toward the effector cells that are considered to be important in the immune defense against cancer.

Tumor-induced macrophage tumor necrosis factor-alpha production suppresses autoreactive T cell proliferation

T cells can react to self-cells bearing the syngenic major histocompatibility complex class II molecule Ia. Decreased autoreactive T cell responses are associated with cancer. Tumor growth causes syngeneic macrophages (M phi) to suppress autoreactive T cell proliferation by decreasing M phi Ia expression and increasing M phi production of the suppressor molecule prostaglandin E2 (PGE2). Because M phi produce tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) during cancer, and TNF-alpha stimulates M phi PGE2 synthesis, we determined if TNF-alpha mediates tumor-induced suppression of autoreactive T cell proliferation stimulated by syngeneic M phi. We showed that tumor growth increases TNF-alpha production because tumor-bearing host (TBH) M phi synthesized more TNF-alpha than normal host (NH) M phi when cultured with lipopolysaccharide. Exogenous TNF-alpha increased NH CD4+ autoreactive T cell proliferation stimulated by syngeneic NH M phi but not by TBH M phi. When endogenous TNF-alpha activity was neutralized by anti-TNF-alpha antibody addition, T cell proliferation decreased when stimulated by NH M phi but increased when stimulated by TBH M phi. Kinetic studies showed that TNF-alpha affected M phi-stimulated T cell proliferation during the first few hours (4h) of the 96 h culture time. Indomethacin-treatment allowed TNF-alpha to increase T cell proliferation stimulated by TBH M phi. A PGE2-specific enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay showed that TBH M phi T cell cultures contained significantly more PGE2 than those containing NH M phi, and that exogenous TNF-alpha increased PGE2 production in TBH M phi cultures more than in NH M phi cultures. Short-term (4h) pretreatment of M phi with TNF-alpha increased T cell proliferation stimulated by NH, but not TBH, M phi. However, long-term (16 h) TNF-alpha pretreatment reversed TBH M phi-mediated suppression, suggesting that early suppressor molecular production inhibits synthesis or activity of TNF-alpha-induced stimulatory monokines. Although TNF-alpha is known to increase T cell proliferation, these results show that the tumor-induced increase in M phi TNF-alpha synthesis suppress autoreactive T cell proliferation, which is mediated by PGE2 production.

Tumor growth alters macrophage responsiveness to macrophage colony-stimulating factor during reactivity against allogeneic and syngeneic MHC class II molecules

Tumor-induced changes in macrophage (M phi)2 accessory activities significantly suppress T-cell recognition of allogeneic and syngeneic major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules. Because these changes are often associated with altered responses to stimulatory and inhibitory cytokines, we investigated the possibility that tumor growth alters the contribution of a macrophage regulatory cytokine, macrophage colony-stimulating factor (M-CSF), during reactivity against allogeneic and syngeneic MHC class II molecules. T-cell reactivity against allogeneic MHC class II molecules was significantly suppressed by tumor-bearing host (TBH) M phi in the presence of M-CSF. M-CSF-induced suppression was independent of TBH M phi prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) synthesis. T-cell reactivity against syngeneic MHC class II molecules increased in the presence of M-CSF when normal host (NH) M phi served as the source of syngeneic molecules. However, T-cell reactivity against syngeneic MHC class II molecules in the presence of M-CSF did not change when TBH M phi served as stimulator/accessory cells. Although T-cell reactivity against NH syngeneic MHC class II molecules was additively increased by M-CSF and indomethacin (a PGE2 synthesis inhibitor) treatment, reactivity against TBH syngeneic MHC class II molecules increased solely through PGE2 synthesis inhibition. Admixtures of both NH and TBH M phi in the absence or presence of M-CSF suggest that tumor-induced suppression was not strictly due to decreased expression of MHC class II molecules. Collectively, these data suggest that TBH M phi are partly suppressive through altered responsiveness to M-CSF.