Urinary biomarkers to detect significant effects of environmental and occupational exposure to nephrotoxins. III. Minimal battery of tests to assess subclinical nephrotoxicity for epidemiological studies based on current knowledge

The Use of Biomarkers as Alternatives to Current Animal Tests on Food Chemicals

Recent developments in biomarkers relating to the interrelationship of diet, disease and health were surveyed. Most emphasis was placed on biomarkers of deleterious effects, since these are of greatest relevance to the subject of this review. The area of greatest activity was found to be that relating to biomarkers of mutagenic, genotoxic and carcinogenic effects. This is also one of the major areas of concern in considerations of the beneficial and deleterious effects of dietary components, and also the area in which regulatory testing requires studies of the longest duration. A degree of progress has also been made in the identification and development of biomarkers relating to certain classes of target organ toxicity. Biomarkers for other types of toxicity, such as immunotoxicity, neurotoxicity, reproductive toxicity and developmental toxicity, are less developed, and further investigation in these areas is required before a comprehensive biomarker strategy can be established. A criticism that recurs constantly in the biomarker literature is the lack of standardisation in the methods used, and the lack of reference standards for the purposes of validation and quality control. It is encouraging to note the growing acknowledgement of the need for validation of biomarkers and biomarker assays. Some validation studies have already been initiated. This review puts forward proposals for criteria to be used in biomarker validation. More discussion on this subject is required. It is concluded that the use of biomarkers can, in some cases, facilitate the implementation of the Three Rs with respect to the testing of food chemicals and studies on the effects of diet on health. The greatest potential is seen to be in the refinement of animal testing, in which biomarkers could serve as early and sensitive endpoints, in order to reduce the duration of the studies and also reduce the number of animals required. Biomarkers could also contribute to establishing a mechanistic basis for in vitro test systems and to facilitating their validation and acceptance. Finally, the increased information that could result from the incorporation of biomarker determinations into population studies could reduce the need for supplementary animal studies. This review makes a number of recommendations concerning the prioritisation of future activities on dietary biomarkers in relation to the Three Rs. It is emphasised, however, that further discussions will be required among toxicologists, epidemiologists and others researching the relationship between diet and health.

Chronic exposure of mice to environmentally relevant, low doses of cadmium leads to early renal damage, not predicted by blood or urine cadmium levels

Mice were exposed to cadmium (Cd) concentrations ranging from 0 to 100mg CdCl(2)/l in the drinking water for 1, 4, 8, 16 and 23 weeks. Urine samples were taken regularly, Cd content was determined in blood, liver, kidney and urine and histological analyses of the kidney were performed. Kidney cortex Cd content increased linearly with time and dose, while blood levels reached a plateau at 8 weeks and liver at 16 weeks in mice exposed to 100mg CdCl(2)/l after which both started to decrease. Urinary Cd levels were not correlated with the kidney Cd content. A multivariate regression model taking into account the actual Cd intake, calculated from the volume of water taken in by each animal and the exposure concentration, confirmed that blood is an indicator of acute exposure, while kidney Cd content is a reliable indicator of chronic exposure. The urinary protein content was significantly increased from 16 weeks on in mice exposed to 100mg CdCl(2)/l (p<0.05), while other signs of proximal tubular damage (glucosuria, enzymuria) were not detected. Histologically more vacuoles and lysosomes were present in the proximal tubule cells with increasing time and dose. The results indicate that chronic exposure to low doses of Cd induced functional and histological signs of early damage at concentrations in or below the ones generally accepted as safe. Our study does not corroborate the statement that urine Cd levels are a reliable indicator of total Cd body burden, at least when the body burden is low.

Assessment of renal injury in vivo

The ICH S7A (Safety Pharmacology for Human Pharmaceuticals) guidelines specify that potential adverse pharmacologic effects of a test substance on renal function should be evaluated in supplemental studies when there is a cause for concern (ICH, 2001). For the most part, this can easily be accomplished by examination of the appropriate analytes in urine and blood collected as part of the routine preclinical safety studies. This review will serve as an overview of the selection, interpretation and limitations of standard clinical pathology methods (serum chemistry and urinalysis) for assessment of renal function in such studies, as well as provide some information on emerging biomarkers of renal function.

Urinalysis to exclude and monitor nephrotoxicity

A large number of compounds, which are in common usage in industry and medicine, are potentially nephrotoxic. Renal damage and disease resulting from toxic exposure is progressive and will, if unarrested, culminate in irreversible renal disease. There is, therefore, a need to develop a battery of tests with which to monitor and characterise the nephrotoxic cascade. A European-wide study compared biomarker profiles of adult male workers who were exposed to heavy metals or solvents. It became apparent that the urinary profiles varied with the nature of the toxin, reflecting the functional region of the kidney affected and also the severity of the damage. Children are a particularly vulnerable group and the investigation of range of biomarkers indicated that they were indeed susceptible to nephrotoxic pollutants in their environment. It is proposed that a small cohort of tests should be used to monitor the early (pre-clinical stages) of renal damage or dysfunction; these can be supplemented if necessary by additional specific tests. In the future better information on at-risk populations and genetic information will enable the determination of individual susceptibility to be assessed more precisely.

Early markers of nephrotoxicity: detection of children at risk from environmental pollution

The current investigation is the largest to date concerned with the assessment of the value of different urinary biomarkers to detect nephrotoxic effects in children exposed to cadmium and lead. A battery of tests which had proved valuable in previous studies on men and women where used, together with a number of more recently developed biomarkers. No significant effect of sex and age were found but the location of the children (site) was important. The results indicated that there might have been variability in either the assay procedures or sample handling between the different sites. A small group of tests were found to be elevated following toxic exposure and should be used in future studies. However, there was considerable variation in the degree of exposure amongst the control groups from different countries and in the test groups. This made pooling of the data difficult but the study does highlight the way forward and demonstrates that children can be at risk from environmental exposure to toxins at a lower level than is acceptable for adults.