Late recurrence of neuroblastoma: a report of five cases and review of the literature

An Unusual Case of Late Recurrence of MS Neuroblastoma in a Young Adult

This case describes an unusual presentation of a young adult with a very late recurrence of stage MS neuroblastoma over 20 years after initial diagnosis. Tumor histology at relapse demonstrated ganglioneuromatous foci within her undifferentiated tumor. In combination with evidence of altered catecholamine metabolism, it proposes a case for dedifferentiation of unresected ganglioneuromatous lesions as the etiology of her recurrence of the disease. An additional, compelling component of the case is the overall positive treatment response of the patient with relapsed neuroblastoma despite the poor prognostic factors of late relapse and adult age.

Late recurrence in pediatric cancer: a report from the Childhood Cancer Survivor Study

BACKGROUND

An increasing percentage of childhood cancer patients are surviving their disease, but there is limited research on late recurrence. We sought to estimate late recurrence rates for the most common pediatric cancers and to determine risk factors for late recurrence.

METHODS

The incidence of late recurrences, or first recurrences that occurred more than 5 years after diagnosis, was analyzed for the most common pediatric cancers using data from the Childhood Cancer Survivor Study, a retrospective cohort of 5-year survivors of childhood and adolescent cancers who were diagnosed between 1970 and 1986. A total of 12,795 survivors with no history of recurrence within 5 years after their original cancer diagnosis were included in the analysis, with a total of 217,127 person-years of follow-up. Cumulative incidence of late recurrence at 5, 10, 15, and 20 years after diagnosis was calculated using death as a competing risk. Adjusted relative rates of late recurrence were obtained using multivariable Poisson regression. All statistical tests were two-sided.

RESULTS

Overall, 5-year survivors of pediatric cancers experienced a cumulative incidence of recurrent disease of 4.4%, 5.6%, and 6.2% at 10, 15, and 20 years, respectively. Cumulative incidence varied by diagnosis: Survivors of Ewing sarcoma and astrocytoma had the highest 20-year cumulative incidences at 13.0% (95% confidence interval [CI] = 9.4 to 16.5) and 14.4% (95% CI = 12.3 to 16.6), respectively. In multivariable analysis, the greatest risk factors for late recurrence included diagnosis, combination treatment with chemotherapy and radiation, earlier treatment era, and fewer years since diagnosis (P < .001 for all).

CONCLUSION

Late recurrence is a risk for some pediatric cancers. By understanding diagnosis-specific risks, patients, families, and their medical providers can be better informed of the probability of cure.

Chronic metastatic neuroblastoma

The diversity of neuroblastoma and its clinical course depends on histology, biology and clinical features. We report a male presenting at 4 months of age with an abdominal mass and multiple subcutaneous nodules. The diagnosis was made by histological examination of a subcutaneous nodule and elevated urinary markers. The patient remained well during the subsequent 9 years. During that time no cytostatic treatment was given. Attempt to treat with cis-retinoic acid 10 years later did not result in any significant change of the clinical course. The patient has remained in good clinical condition for a 15-year observation period, having both progressing and regressing distant subcutaneous metastases. Skin nodules are the hallmarks of the indolent clinical course of the disease. We suggest the use of the "chronic neuroblastoma" as a term to describe patients with neuroblastoma showing indolent disease course over a very long period of time, but never achieving complete remission.

4S neuroblastoma: the long-term outcome

BACKGROUND

Stage 4S neuroblastoma is associated with a high rate of spontaneous maturation and involution, with survival rates of 70-90%. There is little long-term follow-up data describing the disease status or late effects. The aim of this study was to assess the clinical outcome and imaging findings in long-term survivors of 4S neuroblastoma.

METHODS

The patient population was identified from a single centre over 26 years. Twenty-five of 31 consecutive patients were long-term survivors. Five died from disease progression and one from cerebral palsy related complications. All survivors underwent clinical examination. Abdominal ultrasound scanning, liver function tests, hepatitis viral screen, and urinary catecholamines were performed.

RESULTS

The mean age at diagnosis was 8 +/- 9 weeks with a mean age when studied of 11 years and 10 months +/- 8 years. Twenty of 25 had no significant clinical findings, three had disease associated clinical abnormalities (neurological, multiple subcutaneous nodules). Three patients had treatment related effects (small testes, urethral stricture, radiation induced soft tissue hypoplasia, post-surgical Horners syndrome). Persistant adrenal enlargement and calcification was noted in three patients. Twelve patients had abnormal liver ultrasound findings ranging from mildly coarse echotexture to structural changes without evidence of hepatic dysfunction or infection. Treatment did not correlate with abnormal hepatic ultrasound findings.

CONCLUSIONS

The majority of long-term survivors of stage 4S neuroblastoma have no clinically or radiologically significant sequelae but do have residual abnormalities. These findings have implications for subsequent management of unrelated medical conditions in this patient group.

Chronic neuroblastoma

BACKGROUND

An indolent course is associated with neuroblastoma (NB) in adolescents and adults. In the current study, the authors analyzed this phenomenon in a large series of children with metastatic NB.

METHODS

The authors studied 38 patients who were diagnosed with NB in the first decade of life and had metastatic disease 5 years or more from diagnosis.

RESULTS

The median age at diagnosis was 3 years 10 months. MYCN was amplified in 2 of 28 patients tested. Of 30 patients with classic Stage 4 NB, 9 had a late first recurrence of disease (4.3-13 years from diagnosis). Of eight patients who had atypical cases at diagnosis (one isolated mandibular lesion, two Stage 4-N, five non-Stage 4), six had a late first distant recurrence of disease (4 years 11 months-38 years 8 months). Nineteen patients were off therapy continuously for 3 years or more before disease recurred a first or second time. Myeloablative therapy was used to consolidate a first or second response in 27 patients. High-dose conventional therapy helped to achieve a second remission of disease in 9 of 20 patients assessable for response of first recurrence but achieved no major responses of second or third relapse in 10 of 11 patients. The combination of anti-G(D2) immunotherapy and/or cis-retinoic acid, targeted radiotherapy, and multiple cycles of chemotherapy with modest toxicity helped prolong survival. Twelve patients survive at 5 years 6 months+ to 19 years 4 months+ from diagnosis (median, 6 years 10 months+), including four with complete remission of disease; 10 received anti-G(D2) immunotherapy after recurrence. The other 26 patients died of disease (n = 22) or toxicity (n = 4) at 5 years-41 years 5 months from diagnosis (median, 6 years 5 months).

CONCLUSIONS

The concept of indolent or smoldering NB should not be limited to adolescents/adults. The expanding repertoire of anti-NB treatments, including biologic therapies and chemotherapy regimens of modest toxicity, can convert childhood NB into a chronic disease with prolonged survival after recurrence.

Late recurrence of neuroblastoma stage 4S with unusual clinicopathologic findings

The authors present unusual clinicopathologic findings of a patient with neuroblastoma stage 4S that recurred 11 years after induction of complete remission with chemotherapy. A 12-year-old girl presented with recurrent tumor in the liver. Urinary catecholamine metabolites were within normal range in contrast to the increased values at initial presentation. She underwent left lateral segmentectomy and biopsy of the right lobe. Histologic analysis of the recurrent tumor showed undifferentiated neuroblastoma intermingled with mature ganglioneuromatous lesions. There also were scattered ganglioneuromatous lesions throughout nontumorous area of the liver. Although multimodal intensified treatments including autologous bone marrow transplantation were performed, the patient died of obstinate recurrent tumor at age 14 years. The clinicopathologic findings suggested dedifferentiation from the ganglioneuromatous lesion rather than ordinary recurrence of the primary tumor. The current case and the literature review may indicate that long-term follow-up would be necessary for neuroblastoma stage 4/4S cases. J Pediatr Surg 36:953-955.

Late relapse and prognosis for neuroblastoma patients surviving 5 years or more: a report from the European Neuroblastoma Study Group "Survey"

BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURE

Most deaths from neuroblastoma occur within 2 years of diagnosis but there have been several anecdotal reports of relapse and death after much longer periods of follow up. In order to investigate and quantify the risk of late events we analysed data for patients registered with the European Neuroblastoma Study Group between 1982 and 1990. Out of a total of 1,277 children registered, 427 were alive with follow-up beyond 5 years from diagnosis (median follow-up of 8.8 years, range 5-14 years). Of these 406 were in remission with no prior recurrence, 16 were in remission having experienced a relapse prior to 5 years, and 5 were alive with progressive disease.

RESULTS

For the 406 patients in remission with no prior relapse the 10 year progression free survival (PFS) was 96% (CI 94-98). For those aged over 1 year with stage 4 disease at diagnosis 10 year PFS was 88% (CI 79-96) compared to 98% (CI 97-99) for other patients combined, P< 0.001. In a multivariate analysis of all 422 patients in remission at 5 years, significant risk factors for subsequent relapse were age > 1 yr with stage 4 disease at diagnosis (relative risk 10.5, P < 0.001) and prior relapse (RR 4.2, P= 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study emphasise the importance of longterm follow-up of patients and the need for late monitoring of clinical trials in children with neuroblastoma. They also provide a baseline for comparison with future and hopefully more effective treatment programmes.

Clinical prognostic factors in 1277 patients with neuroblastoma: results of The European Neuroblastoma Study Group 'Survey' 1982-1992

In 1982 the European Neuroblastoma Study Group (ENSG) established a prospective registry for patients with newly diagnosed neuroblastoma ('The ENSG Survey'). Clinical information was collected primarily to: (a) establish an ENSG database; and (b) investigate prognostic factors in neuroblastoma. This paper summarises the results of the survey. By 1992, 1277 patients with a median age of 26 months (range: 0-289 months), gender ratio of 1.19 M:F had been registered from 30 centres. The median follow-up of survivors is 9.7 years (range: 1-14 years). Overall 5-year survival (S) is 45% (95% CI 42-48%), and event-free survival (EFS) is 43% (95% CI 40-45%). For both survival and EFS the key established prognostic factors, stage and age, are highly significant (P<0.001). In particular, patients under 1 year of age at diagnosis, whatever the disease stage, had a more favourable prognosis than older patients; stage 2 (EFS 93% (95% (CI 85-97) versus 76% (95% CI 67-86), P=0.02), stage 3 (EFS 91% (95% CI 82-96) versus 52% (95% CI 44-60), P<0.001) and stage 4 (EFS 59% (95% CI 48-69) versus 16% (95% CI 13-19), P<0.001). Multivariate analysis established that the anatomical location of the primary tumour (i.e. abdominal versus other sites) and primary tumour volume also conferred a statistically significant difference. In stage 4 disease the 20% of patients without demonstrable bone marrow involvement had a more favourable prognosis than those with infiltrated marrow (EFS 36% (95% CI 13-19) versus 16% (95% CI 29-45), P<0.001). Urine catecholamine metabolite levels (raised versus normal), histology (ganglioneuroblastoma versus neuroblastoma) and gender had no significant effect on outcome after stage and age were accounted for. 5-year survival following first relapse is only 5.6% (95% CI 2.8-8.4). This ENSG Survey provides secure data for future comparisons with new prognostic factors and treatment programmes.

Secondary central nervous system metastases in children with neuroblastoma

Cerebral and meningeal involvement in patients with primary extracranial neuroblastoma (NB) is unusual although it is generally present in disseminated disease. The intensification of chemotherapy that has prolonged survival in these children has changed the pattern of relapse presentation, as occurs with isolated central nervous system (CNS) disease. We report 4 patients with secondary CNS metastases. Three infants of 16, 14, and 10 months of age, diagnosed with primary abdominal NB stage 4, presented neuromeningeal metastases during maintenance chemotherapy with seizures and cranial hypertension as the first manifestation. Another 8-year-old patient diagnosed with NB stage 3 presented local relapse with later neuromeningeal metastases. All died in the following 3 months. The possibility of CNS relapse in patients with NB should be considered when neurological symptoms and signs appear. These new relapse forms overshadow the prognosis of these children.