Comparison of latent nystagmus and nasotemporal asymmetries of optokinetic nystagmus in adult humans and macaque monkeys who have infantile strabismus

Inter-Ocular Fixation Instability of Amblyopia: Relationship to Visual Acuity, Strabismus, Nystagmus, Stereopsis, Vergence And Age

PURPOSE

Amblyopia damages visual sensory and ocular motor functions. One manifestation of the damage is abnormal fixational eye movements. Tiny fixation movements are normal; but when these exceed a normal range, the behavior is labeled "fixation instability(FI)." Here we compare FI between normal and amblyopic subjects, and evaluate the relationship between FI and severity of amblyopia, strabismus angle, nystagmus, stereopsis, vergence, and subject age.

DESIGN AND METHODS

Fixation Eye Movements were recorded using infra-red video-oculography from 47 controls(15.3±12.2y) and 104 amblyopic subjects(13.3±11.2y) during binocular and monocular viewing. FI and vergence instability were quantified as Bivariate Contour Ellipse Area (BCEA). We also calculated the ratio of FI between the two eyes: right eye/left eye for controls, amblyopic eye/fellow eye for amblyopes. Multiple regression analysis evaluated how FI related to a range of visuo-motor measures.

RESULTS

During binocular viewing, the FI of fellow and amblyopic eye, vergence instability and inter-ocular FI ratios were least in anisometropic and most in mixed amblyopia(p<0.05). Each correlated positively with the strabismus angle(p<0.01). During monocular viewing, subjects with deeper amblyopia(p<.01) and larger strabismus angles(p<.05) had higher inter-ocular FI ratios. 27% of anisometropic and >65% of strabismic/mixed amblyopes had nystagmus. Younger age and nystagmus increased FI and vergence instability(p<0.05), but did not affect the Inter-ocular FI ratios(p>0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Quantitative recording of perturbed eye movements in children reveal a major functional deficit linked to amblyopia. Imprecise fixation - measured as inter-ocular FI ratios- may be used as a robust marker for amblyopia and strabismus severity.

Contrast sensitivity, optotype acuity and fixation eye movement abnormalities in amblyopia under binocular viewing

INTRODUCTION

Visual function deficits are seen in amblyopic subjects during fellow and binocular viewing. The purpose of the study was to examine the relationship between Fixation Eye Movement (FEM) abnormalities and binocular contrast sensitivity and optotype acuity deficits in amblyopia.

METHODS

We recruited 10 controls and 25 amblyopic subjects [Anisometropic = 6, Strabismic = 10, Mixed = 9]. We measured binocular contrast sensitivity at spatial frequencies 1,2, 4, 8, 12 and 16 and binocular and monocular optotype acuity using a staircase procedure. We recorded FEMs using high-resolution video-oculography and classified subjects as having no nystagmus(None = 9) or nystagmus without FMN(n = 7) and with Fusion Maldevelopment Nystagmus (FMN)(n = 9). We computed the fixation instability, amplitude and velocity of the fast and slow FEMs.

RESULTS

Amblyopic subjects with and without nystagmus had worse binocular contrast sensitivity at spatial frequencies 12 and 16 and binocular optotype acuity than controls. The abnormalities were most pronounced in amblyopic subjects with FMN. Fixation instability of the Fellow Eye and Amblyopic Eye and vergence instability, amplitude of fast FEMs and velocity of slow FEMs were increased with reduced binocular contrast sensitivity and reduced optotype acuity in amblyopic subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

Fixation instability of Fellow Eye and Amblyopic Eye, optotype acuity and contrast sensitivity deficits are seen under binocular viewing in amblyopic subjects with and without nystagmus but are most pronounced in those with FMN. FEMs abnormalities correlate with both lower order (contrast sensitivity) and higher order (optotype acuity) visual function impairment in amblyopia.

Reading difficulties in amblyopia: Consequence of visual sensory and oculomotor dysfunction

INTRODUCTION

Reading is a vision-reliant task, requiring sequential eye movements. Binocularly discordant input results in visual sensory and oculomotor dysfunction in amblyopia, which may contribute to reading difficulties. This study aims to determine the contributions of fixation eye movement (FEM) abnormalities, clinical type and severity of amblyopia to reading performance under binocular and monocular viewing conditions.

METHODS

Twenty-three amblyopic patients and nine healthy controls were recruited. Eye movements elicited during fixation and reading of preselected passages were collected for each subject using infrared video-oculography. Subjects were classified as having no nystagmus (n = 9), fusion maldevelopment nystagmus (FMN, n = 5), or nystagmus without structural anomalies that does not meet criteria for FMN or infantile nystagmus (n = 9). Reading rate (words/min), the number of forward and regressive saccades (per 100 words) and fixation duration (s) were computed.

RESULTS

Amblyopic patients with and without nystagmus exhibited greater vergence and fixation instability. In patients without nystagmus, the instability arises from increased amplitude and velocity of fast and slow FEMs respectively. Amblyopic patients with and without nystagmus exhibited lower reading speeds with increased fixation duration, regressive and progressive saccades than controls in all viewing conditions. Mixed etiology, greater amblyopic eye visual acuity and stereopsis deficits were associated with greater reading difficulties under binocular viewing.

CONCLUSIONS

The presence of oculomotor dysfunction and the extent of visual acuity and stereoacuity deficits contribute to reading difficulties in patients with amblyopia, with and without nystagmus. The understanding of reading difficulties is essential to devise accommodations to limit long-term academic and vocational consequences of amblyopia.

Effect of Viewing Conditions on Fixation Eye Movements and Eye Alignment in Amblyopia

Purpose

Patients with amblyopia are known to have fixation instability, which arises from alteration of physiologic fixation eye movements (FEMs) and nystagmus. We assessed the effects of monocular, binocular, and dichoptic viewing on FEMs and eye alignment in patients with and without fusion maldevelopment nystagmus (FMN).

Methods

Thirty-four patients with amblyopia and seven healthy controls were recruited for this study. Eye movements were recorded using infrared video-oculography during (1) fellow eye viewing (FEV), (2) amblyopic eye viewing (AEV), (3) both eye viewing (BEV), and (4) dichoptic viewing (DcV) at varying fellow eye (FE) contrasts. The patients were classified per the clinical type of amblyopia and FEM waveforms into those without nystagmus, those with nystagmus with and without FMN. Fixational saccades and intersaccadic drifts, quick and slow phases of nystagmus, and bivariate contour ellipse area were analyzed in the FE and amblyopic eye (AE).

Results

We found that FEMs are differentially affected with increased amplitude of quick phases of FMN observed during AEV than BEV and during DcV at lower FE contrasts. Increased fixation instability was seen in anisometropic patients at lower FE contrasts. Incomitance of eye misalignment was seen with the greatest increase during FEV. Strabismic/mixed amblyopia patients without FMN were more likely to demonstrate a fixation switch where the AE attends to the target during DcV than patients with FMN.

Conclusions

Our findings suggest that FEM abnormalities modulate with different viewing conditions as used in various amblyopia therapies. Increased FEM abnormalities could affect the visual function deficits and may have treatment implications.

Fixational Eye Movement Waveforms in Amblyopia: Characteristics of Fast and Slow Eye Movements

Fixational eye movements comprise of fast microsaccades alternating with slow intersaccadic drifts. These physiologic eye movements play an important role in visual perception. Amblyopic patients are known to have fixation instability, particularly of the amblyopic eye. We examined eye movement abnormalities that contribute to this instability. We found that fixation stability is affected by the presence of fusion maldevelopment nystagmus (FMN). However, some amblyopes can have nystagmus without nasally directed slow phases and reversal in direction of the quick phase on ocular occlusion, features seen in FMN. In patients without nystagmus, we found increased amplitude of fixational saccades and inter-saccadic drifts. We categorized amblyopia patients by type (anisometropic, strabismic, or mixed) and eye movement waveform (no nystagmus, nystagmus without FMN, and FMN). We found specific fast and slow eye movement abnormalities of the fellow and amblyopic eye during fellow, amblyopic and both eyes viewing conditions across eye movement waveforms and types of amblyopia. These eye movement abnormalities can serve as biomarkers that can predict the impact of amblyopia as measured by visual acuity and stereopsis. Evaluation of fixational eye movements in amblyopia could be important to diagnose these common eye diseases and predict treatment effectiveness.

Visual Search in Amblyopia: Abnormal Fixational Eye Movements and Suboptimal Sampling Strategies

Purpose

Microsaccades shift the image on the fovea and counteract visual fading. They are also thought to serve as an optimal sampling strategy while viewing complex visual scenes. The goal of our study was to assess visual search in amblyopic children.

Methods

Twenty-one amblyopic children with varying severity of amblyopia and 10 healthy controls were recruited. Eye movements were recorded using infrared video-oculography during amblyopic and fellow eye viewing while the subjects performed (1) visual fixation, (2) exploration of a blank scene, and (3) visual search task (spot the difference between two images). The number of correctly identified picture differences and reaction time were recorded. Microsaccade, saccades, and intersaccadic drifts were analyzed in patients without latent nystagmus (LN). Slow phase velocities were computed for patients with LN.

Results

Both patients with and without LN were able to spot the same number of differences but took longer during fellow eye viewing compared to controls. The ability to identify differences was diminished during amblyopic eye viewing particularly those with LN and severe amblyopia. We found reduced frequencies of microsaccades and saccades in both amblyopic and fellow eyes during fixation and visual search but not during exploration of blank scene. Across all tasks, amblyopes with LN had increased intersaccadic drifts.

Conclusions

Our findings suggest that deficient microsaccade and saccadic activity contributes to poorer sampling strategy in amblyopia, which is seen in both amblyopic and fellow eye. These deficits are more notable among subjects who experienced binocular decorrelation earlier in life, with subsequent development of LN.

Neural mechanisms of oculomotor abnormalities in the infantile strabismus syndrome

Infantile strabismus is characterized by numerous visual and oculomotor abnormalities. Recently nonhuman primate models of infantile strabismus have been established, with characteristics that closely match those observed in human patients. This has made it possible to study the neural basis for visual and oculomotor symptoms in infantile strabismus. In this review, we consider the available evidence for neural abnormalities in structures related to oculomotor pathways ranging from visual cortex to oculomotor nuclei. These studies provide compelling evidence that a disturbance of binocular vision during a sensitive period early in life, whatever the cause, results in a cascade of abnormalities through numerous brain areas involved in visual functions and eye movements.

Influence of Target Parameters on Fixation Stability in Normal and Strabismic Monkeys

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to assess the effect of fixation target parameters on fixation instability in strabismic monkeys.

METHODS

One normal and three exotropic monkeys were presented with four differently shaped fixation targets, with three diameters, during monocular or binocular viewing. Fixation targets were white on a black background or vice versa. Binocular eye movements were recorded using the magnetic search coil technique and fixation stability quantified by calculating the bivariate contour ellipse area (BCEA).

RESULTS

Fixation instability was greater in all the strabismic monkeys compared with the normal monkey. During monocular viewing, strabismic monkeys showed significantly greater instability in the covered eye compared to the fixating eye. Multifactorial ANOVA suggested statistically significant target parameter influences, although effect sizes were small. Thus, a disk-shaped target resulted in greater instability than other target shapes in the viewing eyes of the normal monkey and two of three strabismic monkeys. A similar target-shape effect was also observed in the covered eye. Least instability was elicited with a 0.5° target in the normal monkey and a 1.0° target in the strabismic monkeys, both in the viewing and the covered eye. Target/background polarity effects were idiosyncratic. In strabismic monkeys, stability of the fixating eye during binocular viewing was not different from the stability of the same eye during monocular viewing.

CONCLUSIONS

Abnormal drifts and nystagmus contribute to increased fixation instability in strabismic monkeys. Target parameters (shape and size) that influence fixation stability in a normal animal also affected fixation stability in our sample of strabismic monkeys.

Horizontal and vertical optokinetic eye movements in macaque monkeys with infantile strabismus: directional bias and crosstalk

PURPOSE

Optokinetic eye movements stabilize gaze by tracking motion of the visual scene during sustained movement of a creature's body. The purpose of this study was to describe vertical and horizontal optokinetic nystagmus (OKN) in nonhuman primates (NHPs) with normal binocular vision, and to compare their responses to NHPs with binocular maldevelopment induced by prism-rearing.

METHODS

Optical strabismus was created in infant macaques (n = 6) by fitting them with prism goggles. The goggles were removed after 3, 6, 9, or 12 weeks to determine the effects of increasing durations of binocular noncorrespondence. Infant NHPs (n = 2) reared wearing plano goggles served as controls. OKN was evoked by horizontal or vertical stripe motion. Eye movements were recorded by using binocular search coils.

RESULTS

NHPs reared in early infancy under conditions of binocular noncorrespondence for durations of 6 weeks or longer had horizontal OKN responses biased directionally in favor of nasalward motion. NHPs reared with prisms for any duration had vertical OKN responses more biased than normal NHPs in favor of upward motion. Diagonal "crosstalk" during horizontal or vertical OKN (vertical slow phases during horizontal stimulus motion, and vice versa) was present to some degree in all NHPs. However, crosstalk-upward during horizontal OKN and nasalward during vertical OKN-was most pronounced in NHPs reared with prism for durations long enough to induce a permanent esotropic strabismus (longer than 3 weeks).

CONCLUSIONS

With fusion maldevelopment, the OKN pathways retain a nasalward and upward bias. During forward locomotion, optic flow excites temporalward and downward visual motion in each eye. The OKN biases would act in counterbalance. The biases attenuate with emergence of fusion, but may persist and crosstalk when fusion is impeded.

Decorrelation of cerebral visual inputs as the sufficient cause of infantile esotropia

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Human infants at greatest risk for esotropia are those who suffer cerebral insults that could decorrelate signals from the two eyes during an early critical period of binocular, visuomotor development. The authors reared normal infant monkeys under conditions of binocular decorrelation to determine if this alone was sufficient to cause esotropia, and associated behavioral as well as neuroanatomic deficits.

METHODS

Binocular decorrelation was imposed using prism-goggles for durations of 3-24 weeks (control monkeys wore plano goggles), emulating unrepaired strabismus of durations 3 months to 2 years in human infants. Behavioral recordings were obtained, followed by neuroanatomic analysis of ocular dominance columns and binocular, horizontal connections in the striate visual cortex (area V1).

RESULTS

Concomitant, constant esotropia developed in each monkey exposed to decorrelation for a duration of 6-24 weeks. The severity of ocular motor signs (esotropia angle; dissociated vertical deviation; latent nystagmus; pursuit / optokinetic tracking asymmetry; fusional vergence deficits), and the loss of V1 binocular connections increased as a function of decorrelation duration. Stereopsis was deficient and motion visually evoked potentials were asymmetric. Monkeys exposed to decorrelation for 3 weeks showed transient esotropia, but regained normal alignment, visuomotor behaviors, and binocular V1 connections.

CONCLUSIONS

Binocular decorrelation is a sufficient cause of infantile esotropia when imposed during a critical period of visuomotor development. The systematic relationship between severity of visuomotor signs and severity of V1 connectivity deficits provides a neuroanatomic mechanism for these signs. Restoration of binocular fusion and V1 connections after short durations of decorrelation helps explain the benefits of early strabismus repair in humans.

The neural mechanism for Latent (fusion maldevelopment) nystagmus

Latent nystagmus (LN) is the by-product of fusion maldevelopment in infancy. Because fusion maldevelopment--in the form of strabismus and amblyopia--is common, LN is a prevalent form of pathologic nystagmus encountered in clinical practice. It originates as an afferent visual pathway disorder. To unravel the mechanism for LN, we studied patients and nonhuman primates with maldeveloped fusion. These experiments have revealed that loss of binocular connections within striate cortex (area V1) in the first months of life is the necessary and sufficient cause of LN. The severity of LN increases systematically with longer durations of binocular decorrelation and greater losses of V1 connections. Decorrelation durations that exceed the equivalent of 2-3 months in human development result in an LN prevalence of 100%. No manipulation of brain stem motor pathways is required. The binocular maldevelopment originating in area V1 is passed on to downstream extrastriate regions of cerebral cortex that drive conjugate gaze, notably MSTd. Conjugate gaze is stable when MSTd neurons of the right and left cerebral hemispheres have balanced binocular activity. Fusion maldevelopment in infancy causes unbalanced monocular activity. If input from one eye dominates and the other is suppressed, MSTd in one hemisphere becomes more active. Acting through downstream projections to the ipsilateral nucleus of the optic tract, the eyes are driven conjugately to that side. The unbalanced MSTd drive is evident as the nasalward gaze-holding bias of LN when viewing with either eye.

Duration of binocular decorrelation in infancy predicts the severity of nasotemporal pursuit asymmetries in strabismic macaque monkeys

PURPOSE

Strabismus in human infants is linked strongly to nasotemporal asymmetries of smooth pursuit, but many features of this co-morbidity are unknown. The purpose of this study was to determine how the duration of early-onset strabismus (or timeliness of repair) affects the severity of pursuit asymmetries in a primate model.

METHODS

Binocular image decorrelation was imposed on infant macaques by fitting them with prism goggles on day 1 of life. The goggles were removed after 3 weeks (n=2), 12 weeks (n=2) or 24 weeks (n=3), emulating surgical repair of strabismus in humans at 3, 12, and 24 months of age, respectively. Two control monkeys wore plano lenses. Several months after the goggles were removed, horizontal smooth pursuit was recorded using binocular search coils and a nasal-bias index (NBI) was calculated.

RESULTS

Each animal in the 12- and 24-week groups developed a constant, alternating esotropic strabismus and a nasotemporal asymmetry of pursuit when viewing with either eye. Spatial vision was normal (no amblyopia). The 3-week duration monkeys were indistinguishable from control animals; they had normal eye alignment and symmetric pursuit. In the 12- and 24-week monkeys, the longer the duration of binocular decorrelation, the greater the pursuit asymmetry: for 15 degrees /s target motion, the NBI in the 12-week and 24-week animals was 16x and 22x greater respectively, than that in the 3-week animals (ANOVA, P=0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Binocular decorrelation in primates during an early period of fusion development causes permanent smooth pursuit asymmetries when the duration exceeds the equivalent of 3 months in human. These findings support the conclusion that early correction of infantile strabismus promotes normal development of cerebral gaze pathways.

Ocular motor outcomes after bilateral and unilateral infantile cataracts

We wished to study how the severity and duration of early onset visual deprivation affects eye alignment and ocular stability. Thirty-three patients (aged 1 week to 12.8 years) with infantile cataracts (16 bilateral, 17 unilateral) were examined for periods up to 61 months. Twenty-three patients were considered to have cataracts, which were a major obstacle to vision (major form deprivation), 9 of whom underwent surgery within 8 weeks of birth (mean and SD=5.2+/-2.3 weeks) and 10 after 8 weeks (mean and SD=33.9+/-29.7 months). Eye alignment and fixation stability was measured using infrared recording systems and video. Visual acuity was assessed using forced-choice preferential looking techniques in the neonates and infants and with optotypes in the children. Fifteen of the 23 (65%) patients who experienced major form deprivation exhibited a nystagmus, of which 11 (73%) were manifest latent nystagmus (MLN). Nineteen of the 23 (85%) had strabismus. Of the nine patients who underwent early surgery (< or =8 weeks), two displayed a preoperative nystagmus whilst between 10 and 39 months post-operatively 8 (89%) exhibited a nystagmus. Of the group of 10 patients with minor cataracts only 2 (1 late surgery, 1 no surgery) had nystagmus and 2 strabismus. We conclude that following optimal post-operative management of infantile cataracts a sustained nystagmus--typically an MLN--is the most likely ocular motor outcome, even when the period of deprivation is as short as 3 weeks.

Disorders of vertical optokinetic nystagmus in patients with ocular misalignment

PURPOSE

To compare responses to vertical and horizontal optokinetic (OK) stimulation in patients with disorders of ocular alignment.

METHODS

Using the magnetic search coil technique, we measured horizontal and vertical rotations of both eyes in six patients with strabismus since childhood and eight normal subjects. The OK stimulus subtended 72 degrees horizontally and 60 degrees vertically, consisted of black-and-white stripes with a spatial frequency of 0.04 cycles/degree, and moved either vertically or horizontally at 22.5 or 12 degrees/s. All patients and controls were tested with both eyes viewing and monocularly.

RESULTS

Vertical OK responses were asymmetric in most normals and patients. The direction of this asymmetry varied between individuals, but upward stimuli more commonly elicited a greater response than downward stimuli. Monocular horizontal OK responses were symmetric in normals; patients showed either an asymmetry with greater responses for nasal motion, or a directional bias. During monocular and binocular viewing, vertical OK stimulation induced vertical nystagmus in normal subjects, but all patients showed diagonal responses, with horizontal components that were significantly greater than controls. The inappropriate horizontal component of the response increased at the higher stimulus speed, and was not simply due to latent nystagmus.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with disorders of ocular alignment since childhood show an inappropriate horizontal response to vertical OK stimuli, indicating directional abnormality of either motion vision pathways or the ocular motor response.

Gaze-stabilizing deficits and latent nystagmus in monkeys with brief, early-onset visual deprivation: eye movement recordings

The normal development and the capacity to calibrate gaze-stabilizing systems may depend on normal vision during infancy. At the end of 1 yr of dark rearing, cats have gaze-stabilizing deficits similar to that of the newborn human infant including decreased monocular optokinetic nystagmus (OKN) in the nasal to temporal (N-T) direction and decreased velocity storage in the vestibuloocular reflex (VOR). The purpose of this study is to determine to what extent restricted vision during the first 2 mo of life in monkeys affects the development of gaze-stabilizing systems. The eyelids of both eyes were sutured closed in three rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) at birth. Eyelids were opened at 25 days in one monkey and 40 and 55 days in the other two animals. Eye movements were recorded from each eye using scleral search coils. The VOR, OKN, and fixation were examined at 6 and 12 mo of age. We also examined ocular alignment, refraction, and visual acuity in these animals. At 1 yr of age, visual acuity ranged from 0.3 to 0.6 LogMAR (20/40-20/80). All animals showed a defect in monocular OKN in the N-T direction. The velocity-storage component of OKN (i.e., OKAN) was the most impaired. All animals had a mild reduction in VOR gain but had a normal time constant. The animals deprived for 40 and 55 days had a persistent strabismus. All animals showed a nystagmus similar to latent nystagmus (LN) in human subjects. The amount of LN and OKN defect correlated positively with the duration of deprivation. In addition, the animal deprived for 55 days demonstrated a pattern of nystagmus similar to congenital nystagmus in human subjects. We found that restricted visual input during the first 2 mo of life impairs certain gaze-stabilizing systems and causes LN in primates.

Asymmetric motion visually evoked potentials in infantile strabismus are not an artifact of latent nystagmus

BACKGROUND

Patients who have infantile strabismus exhibit a directional asymmetry of motion visually evoked potentials (MVEPs) recorded under conditions of monocular viewing. The majority of these patients also have latent nystagmus, raising the possibility that the MVEP asymmetry is an artifact of the nystagmus. To explore this issue, we correlated MVEPs and eye movements under conditions that eliminated or increased latent nystagmus.

METHODS

MVEPs and eye movements were recorded under conditions of monocular viewing in three adults who had combined infantile-onset strabismus and latent nystagmus. The subjects viewed vertically oriented grating stimuli that oscillated horizontally at temporal frequencies of 6.6 to 11.0 Hz by use of spatial frequencies of 1 to 3 cycles/degree. Quantitative eye movement recordings of latent nystagmus and horizontal pursuit/optokinetic nystagmus were also obtained.

RESULTS

Eye movement recordings showed that the latent nystagmus was absent or markedly diminished when the viewing eye was in a 45-degree adducted position, whereas nystagmus velocity increased 10 to 40 times (to 2.2 to 4.5 degrees/second) when the viewing eye was in an abducted position (p < 0.05). MVEPs were abnormal (asymmetry indices > 0.40) when the viewing eye was in an adducted or abducted position of gaze. No correlation was found between the MVEP asymmetry index and the velocity of latent nystagmus.

CONCLUSIONS

MVEP asymmetries in infantile strabismus remain robust under conditions that eliminate or greatly reduce the oscillations of latent nystagmus. MVEP asymmetries and ocular motor abnormalities both characterize infantile strabismus, but the ocular motor defects do not cause the MVEP asymmetries. The nasotemporal asymmetry of MVEPs and the nasotemporal asymmetry of pursuit and latent nystagmus are likely caused by deficits in related but separate binocular visual cortical circuits.