Examining the validity of Poissonian models against the birth and death TCP model for various radiotherapy fractionation schemes

Reciprocal interactions between tumour cell populations enhance growth and reduce radiation sensitivity in prostate cancer

Intratumoural heterogeneity (ITH) contributes to local recurrence following radiotherapy in prostate cancer. Recent studies also show that ecological interactions between heterogeneous tumour cell populations can lead to resistance in chemotherapy. Here, we evaluated whether interactions between heterogenous populations could impact growth and response to radiotherapy in prostate cancer. Using mixed 3D cultures of parental and radioresistant populations from two prostate cancer cell lines and a predator-prey mathematical model to investigate various types of ecological interactions, we show that reciprocal interactions between heterogeneous populations enhance overall growth and reduce radiation sensitivity. The type of interaction influences the time of regrowth after radiation, and, at the population level, alters the survival and cell cycle of each population without eliminating either one. These interactions can arise from oxygen constraints and from cellular cross-talk that alter the tumour microenvironment. These findings suggest that ecological-type interactions are important in radiation response and could be targeted to reduce local recurrence.

In the linear quadratic model, the Poisson approximation and the Zaider-Minerbo formula agree on the ranking of tumor control probabilities, up to a critical cell birth rate

PURPOSE

To provide a rule for the agreement or disagreement of the Poisson approximation (PA) and the Zaider-Minerbo formula (ZM) on the ranking of treatment alternatives in terms of tumor control probability (TCP) in the linear quadratic model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A general criterion involving a critical cell birth rate was formally derived. For demonstration, the criterion was applied to a distinct radiobiological model of fast growing head and neck tumors and a respective range of 22 conventional and nonconventional head and neck schedules.

RESULTS

There is a critical cell birth rate b_crit below which PA and ZM agree on which one out of two alternative treatment schemes with single-cell survival curves S'(t) and S''(t) offers better TCP: [Formula: see text] For cell birth rates b above this critical cell birth rate, PA and ZM disagree if and only if b >b_crit > 0. In case of the exemplary head and neck schedules, out of 231 possible combinations, only 16 or 7% were found where PA and ZM disagreed. In all 231 cases the prediction of the criterion was numerically confirmed, and cell birth rates at crossovers between schedules matched the calculated critical cell birth rates.

CONCLUSIONS

TCP estimated by PA and ZM almost never numerically coincide. Still, in many cases both formulas at least agree about which one out of two alternative fractionation schemes offers better TCP. In case of fast growing tumors featuring a high cell birth rate, however, ZM may suggest a re-evaluation of treatment options.

Stochastic model for tumor control probability: effects of cell cycle and (a)symmetric proliferation

BACKGROUND

Estimating the required dose in radiotherapy is of crucial importance since the administrated dose should be sufficient to eradicate the tumor and at the same time should inflict minimal damage on normal cells. The probability that a given dose and schedule of ionizing radiation eradicates all the tumor cells in a given tissue is called the tumor control probability (TCP), and is often used to compare various treatment strategies used in radiation therapy.

METHOD

In this paper, we aim to investigate the effects of including cell-cycle phase on the TCP by analyzing a stochastic model of a tumor comprised of actively dividing cells and quiescent cells with different radiation sensitivities. Moreover, we use a novel numerical approach based on the method of characteristics for partial differential equations, validated by the Gillespie algorithm, to compute the TCP as a function of time.

RESULTS

We derive an exact phase-diagram for the steady-state TCP of the model and show that at high, clinically-relevant doses of radiation, the distinction between active and quiescent tumor cells (i.e. accounting for cell-cycle effects) becomes of negligible importance in terms of its effect on the TCP curve. However, for very low doses of radiation, these proportions become significant determinants of the TCP. We also present the results of TCP as a function of time for different values of asymmetric division factor.

CONCLUSION

We observe that our results differ from the results in the literature using similar existing models, even though similar parameters values are used, and the reasons for this are discussed.