Aminoacylation of RNA minihelices: implications for tRNA synthetase structural design and evolution

A Translation-Independent Directed Evolution Strategy to Engineer Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetases

Using directed evolution, aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) have been engineered to incorporate numerous noncanonical amino acids (ncAAs). Until now, the selection of such novel aaRS mutants has relied on the expression of a selectable reporter protein. However, such translation-dependent selections are incompatible with exotic monomers that are suboptimal substrates for the ribosome. A two-step solution is needed to overcome this limitation: (A) engineering an aaRS to charge the exotic monomer, without ribosomal translation; (B) subsequent engineering of the ribosome to accept the resulting acyl-tRNA for translation. Here, we report a platform for aaRS engineering that directly selects tRNA-acylation without ribosomal translation (START). In START, each distinct aaRS mutant is correlated to a cognate tRNA containing a unique sequence barcode. Acylation by an active aaRS mutant protects the corresponding barcode-containing tRNAs from oxidative treatment designed to damage the 3'-terminus of the uncharged tRNAs. Sequencing of these surviving barcode-containing tRNAs is then used to reveal the identity of the aaRS mutants that acylated the correlated tRNA sequences. The efficacy of START was demonstrated by identifying novel mutants of the Methanomethylophilus alvus pyrrolysyl-tRNA synthetase from a naïve library that enables incorporation of ncAAs into proteins in living cells.

A discriminator code-based DTD surveillance ensures faithful glycine delivery for protein biosynthesis in bacteria

D-aminoacyl-tRNA deacylase (DTD) acts on achiral glycine, in addition to D-amino acids, attached to tRNA. We have recently shown that this activity enables DTD to clear non-cognate Gly-tRNA^Ala with 1000-fold higher efficiency than its activity on Gly-tRNA^Gly, indicating tRNA-based modulation of DTD (Pawar et al., 2017). Here, we show that tRNA's discriminator base predominantly accounts for this activity difference and is the key to selection by DTD. Accordingly, the uracil discriminator base, serving as a negative determinant, prevents Gly-tRNA^Gly misediting by DTD and this protection is augmented by EF-Tu. Intriguingly, eukaryotic DTD has inverted discriminator base specificity and uses only G3•U70 for tRNA^Gly/Ala discrimination. Moreover, DTD prevents alanine-to-glycine misincorporation in proteins rather than only recycling mischarged tRNA^Ala. Overall, the study reveals the unique co-evolution of DTD and discriminator base, and suggests DTD's strong selection pressure on bacterial tRNA^Glys to retain a pyrimidine discriminator code.

tRNA acceptor-stem and anticodon bases embed separate features of amino acid chemistry

The universal genetic code is a translation table by which nucleic acid sequences can be interpreted as polypeptides with a wide range of biological functions. That information is used by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases to translate the code. Moreover, amino acid properties dictate protein folding. We recently reported that digital correlation techniques could identify patterns in tRNA identity elements that govern recognition by synthetases. Our analysis, and the functionality of truncated synthetases that cannot recognize the tRNA anticodon, support the conclusion that the tRNA acceptor stem houses an independent code for the same 20 amino acids that likely functioned earlier in the emergence of genetics. The acceptor-stem code, related to amino acid size, is distinct from a code in the anticodon that is related to amino acid polarity. Details of the acceptor-stem code suggest that it was useful in preserving key properties of stereochemically-encoded peptides that had developed the capacity to interact catalytically with RNA. The quantitative embedding of the chemical properties of amino acids into tRNA bases has implications for the origins of molecular biology.

GTPases and the origin of the ribosome

Background

This paper is an attempt to trace the evolution of the ribosome through the evolution of the universal P-loop GTPases that are involved with the ribosome in translation and with the attachment of the ribosome to the membrane. The GTPases involved in translation in Bacteria/Archaea are the elongation factors EFTu/EF1, the initiation factors IF2/aeIF5b + aeIF2, and the elongation factors EFG/EF2. All of these GTPases also contain the OB fold also found in the non GTPase IF1 involved in initiation. The GTPase involved in the signal recognition particle in most Bacteria and Archaea is SRP54.

Results

1) The Elongation Factors of the Archaea based on structural considerations of the domains have the following evolutionary path: EF1→ aeIF2 → EF2. The evolution of the aeIF5b was a later event; 2) the Elongation Factors of the Bacteria based on the topological considerations of the GTPase domain have a similar evolutionary path: EFTu→ IF→2→EFG. These evolutionary sequences reflect the evolution of the LSU followed by the SSU to form the ribosome; 3) the OB-fold IF1 is a mimic of an ancient tRNA minihelix.

Conclusion

The evolution of translational GTPases of both the Archaea and Bacteria point to the evolution of the ribosome. The elongation factors, EFTu/EF1, began as a Ras-like GTPase bringing the activated minihelix tRNA to the Large Subunit Unit. The initiation factors and elongation factor would then have evolved from the EFTu/EF1 as the small subunit was added to the evolving ribosome. The SRP has an SRP54 GTPase and a specific RNA fold in its RNA component similar to the PTC. We consider the SRP to be a remnant of an ancient form of an LSU bound to a membrane.

Reviewers

This article was reviewed by George Fox, Leonid Mirny and Chris Sander.

The evolution and functional repertoire of translation proteins following the origin of life

Background

The RNA world hypothesis posits that the earliest genetic system consisted of informational RNA molecules that directed the synthesis of modestly functional RNA molecules. Further evidence suggests that it was within this RNA-based genetic system that life developed the ability to synthesize proteins by translating genetic code. Here we investigate the early development of the translation system through an evolutionary survey of protein architectures associated with modern translation.

Results

Our analysis reveals a structural expansion of translation proteins immediately following the RNA world and well before the establishment of the DNA genome. Subsequent functional annotation shows that representatives of the ten most ancestral protein architectures are responsible for all of the core protein functions found in modern translation.

Conclusions

We propose that this early robust translation system evolved by virtue of a positive feedback cycle in which the system was able to create increasingly complex proteins to further enhance its own function.

Reviewers

This article was reviewed by Janet Siefert, George Fox, and Antonio Lazcano (nominated by Laura Landweber)

Diversity and similarity in the tRNA world: overall view and case study on malaria-related tRNAs

Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) are ancient macromolecules that have evolved under various environmental pressures as adaptors in translation in all forms of life but also towards alternative structures and functions. The present knowledge on both "canonical" and "deviating" signature motifs retrieved from vertical and horizontal sequence comparisons is briefly reviewed. Novel characteristics, proper to tRNAs from a given translation system, are revealed by a case study on the nuclear and organellar tRNA sets from malaria-related organisms. Unprecedented distinctive features for Plasmodium falciparum apicoplastic tRNAs appear, which provide novel routes to be explored towards anti-malarial drugs. The ongoing high-throughput sequencing programs are expected to allow for further horizontal comparisons and to reveal other signatures of either full or restricted sets of tRNAs.

A chimaeric glutamyl:glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase: implications for evolution

aaRSs (aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases) are multi-domain proteins that have evolved by domain acquisition. The anti-codon binding domain was added to the more ancient catalytic domain during aaRS evolution. Unlike in eukaryotes, the anti-codon binding domains of GluRS (glutamyl-tRNA synthetase) and GlnRS (glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase) in bacteria are structurally distinct. This originates from the unique evolutionary history of GlnRSs. Starting from the catalytic domain, eukaryotic GluRS evolved by acquiring the archaea/eukaryote-specific anti-codon binding domain after branching away from the eubacteria family. Subsequently, eukaryotic GlnRS evolved from GluRS by gene duplication and horizontally transferred to bacteria. In order to study the properties of the putative ancestral GluRS in eukaryotes, formed immediately after acquiring the anti-codon binding domain, we have designed and constructed a chimaeric protein, cGluGlnRS, consisting of the catalytic domain, Ec GluRS (Escherichia coli GluRS), and the anti-codon binding domain of EcGlnRS (E. coli GlnRS). In contrast to the isolated EcN-GluRS, cGluGlnRS showed detectable activity of glutamylation of E. coli tRNAglu and was capable of complementing an E. coli ts (temperature-sensitive)-GluRS strain at non-permissive temperatures. Both cGluGlnRS and EcN-GluRS were found to bind E. coli tRNAglu with native EcGluRS-like affinity, suggesting that the anticodon-binding domain in cGluGlnRS enhances kcat for glutamylation. This was further confirmed from similar experiments with a chimaera between EcN-GluRS and the substrate-binding domain of EcDnaK (E. coli DnaK). We also show that an extended loop, present in the anticodon-binding domains of GlnRSs, is absent in archaeal GluRS, suggesting that the loop was a later addition, generating additional anti-codon discrimination capability in GlnRS as it evolved from GluRS in eukaryotes.

Arc1p is required for cytoplasmic confinement of synthetases and tRNA

In yeast, Arc1p interacts with ScMetRS and ScGluRS and operates as a tRNA-Interacting Factor (tIF) in trans of these two synthetases. Its N-terminal domain (N-Arc1p) binds the two synthetases and its C-terminal domain is an EMAPII-like domain organized around an OB-fold-based tIF. ARC1 is not an essential gene but its deletion (arc1- cells) is accompanied by a growth retardation phenotype. Here, we show that expression of N-Arc1p or of C-Arc1p alone palliates the growth defect of arc1- cells, and that bacterial Trbp111 or human p43, two proteins containing EMAPII-like domains, also improve the growth of an arc1- strain. The synthetic lethality of an arc1-los1- strain can be complemented with either ARC1 or LOS1. Expression of N-Arc1p or C-Arc1p alone does not complement an arc1-los1- phenotype, but coexpression of the two domains does. Our data demonstrate that Trbp111 or p43 may replace C-Arc1p to complement an arc1-los1- strain. The two functional domains of Arc1p (N-Arc1p and C-Arc1p) are required to get rid of the synthetic lethal phenotype but do not need to be physically linked. To get some clues to the discrete functions of N-Arc1p and C-Arc1p, we targeted ScMetRS or tIF domains to the nuclear compartment and analyzed their cellular localization by using GFP fusions, and their ability to sustain growth. Our results are consistent with a model according to which Arc1p is a bifunctional protein involved in the subcellular localization of ScMetRS and ScGluRS via its N-terminal domain and of tRNA via its C-terminal domain.

Identity elements for specific aminoacylation of a tRNA by mammalian lysyl-tRNA synthetase bearing a nonspecific tRNA-interacting factor

Mammalian lysyl-tRNA synthetase (LysRS) has an N-terminal polypeptide chain extension appended to a prokaryotic-like synthetase domain. This extension, termed a tRNA-interacting factor (tIF), possesses a RNA-binding motif [KxxxK(K/R)xxK] that binds nonspecifically the acceptor TPsiC stem-loop domain of tRNA and provides a potent tRNA binding capacity to this enzyme. Consequently, native LysRS aminoacylates a RNA minihelix mimicking the amino acid acceptor stem-loop domain of tRNA(3)(Lys). Here, examination of minihelix recognition showed that mammalian LysRS aminoacylates RNA minihelices without specificity of sequence, revealing that none of the nucleotides from the acceptor TPsiC stem-loop domain are essential determinants of tRNA(Lys) acceptor identity. To test whether the tIF domain reduces the specificity of the synthetase with regard to complete tRNA molecules, aminoacylation of wild-type and mutant noncognate tRNAs by wild-type or N-terminally truncated LysRS was examined. The presence of the UUU anticodon of tRNA(Lys) appeared to be necessary and sufficient to transform yeast tRNA(Asp) or tRNA(i)(Met) into potent lysine acceptor tRNAs. Thus, nonspecific RNA-protein interactions between the acceptor stem of tRNA and the tIF domain do not relax the tRNA specificity of mammalian LysRS. The possibility that interaction of the full-length cognate tRNA with the synthetase is required to induce the catalytic center of the enzyme into a productive conformation is discussed.

Leucyl-tRNA synthetase from the ancestral bacterium Aquifex aeolicus contains relics of synthetase evolution

The editing reactions catalyzed by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are critical for the faithful protein synthesis by correcting misactivated amino acids and misaminoacylated tRNAs. We report that the isolated editing domain of leucyl-tRNA synthetase from the deep-rooted bacterium Aquifex aeolicus (alphabeta-LeuRS) catalyzes the hydrolytic editing of both mischarged tRNA(Leu) and minihelix(Leu). Within the domain, we have identified a crucial 20-amino-acid peptide that confers editing capacity when transplanted into the inactive Escherichia coli LeuRS editing domain. Likewise, fusion of the beta-subunit of alphabeta-LeuRS to the E. coli editing domain activates its editing function. These results suggest that alphabeta-LeuRS still carries the basic features from a primitive synthetase molecule. It has a remarkable capacity to transfer autonomous active modules, which is consistent with the idea that modern synthetases arose after exchange of small idiosyncratic domains. It also has a unique alphabeta-heterodimeric structure with separated catalytic and tRNA-binding sites. Such an organization supports the tRNA/synthetase coevolution theory that predicts sequential addition of tRNA and synthetase domains.

Complementation of yeast Arc1p by the p43 component of the human multisynthetase complex does not require its association with yeast MetRS and GluRS

Yeast Arc1p, human p43 and plant methionyl-tRNA synthetase (MetRS) possess an EMAPII-like domain capable of non-specific interactions with tRNA. Arc1p interacts with MetRS (MES1) and GluRS and operates as a tRNA-interacting factor (tIF) in trans of these two synthetases. In plant MetRS, the EMAPII-like domain is fused to the catalytic core of the synthetase and acts as a cis-acting tIF for aminoacylation. We observed that the catalytic core of plant MetRS expressed from a centromeric plasmid cannot complement a yeast arc1(-) mes1(-) strain. Overexpression of the mutant enzyme from a high-copy number plasmid restored cell growth, suggesting that deletion of its C-terminal tIF domain was responsible for the poor aminoacylation efficiency of that enzyme in vivo. Accordingly, expression of full-size plant MetRS from a centromeric plasmid, but also of fusion proteins between its catalytic core and the EMAPII-like domains of yeast Arc1p or of human p43 restored cell viability. These data showed that homologous tIF domains from different origins are interchangeable and may act indifferently in trans or in cis of the catalytic domain of a synthetase. Unexpectedly, co-expression of Arc1p with the catalytic core of plant MetRS restored cell viability as well, even though Arc1p did not associate with plant MetRS. Because Arc1p also interacts with yeast GluRS, restoration of cell growth could be due at least in part to its role of cofactor for that enzyme. However, co-expression of human p43, a tIF that did not associate with plant MetRS or with yeast GluRS and MetRS, also restored cell viability of a yeast strain that expressed the catalytic core of plant MetRS. These results show that p43 and Arc1p are able to facilitate tRNA aminoacylation in vivo even if they do not interact physically with the synthetases. We propose that p43/Arc1p may be involved in sequestering tRNAs in the cytoplasm of eukaryotic cells, thereby increasing their availability for protein synthesis.

An aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase paralog with a catalytic role in histidine biosynthesis

In addition to their essential catalytic role in protein biosynthesis, aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases participate in numerous other functions, including regulation of gene expression and amino acid biosynthesis via transamidation pathways. Herein, we describe a class of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase-like (HisZ) proteins based on the catalytic core of the contemporary class II histidyl-tRNA synthetase whose members lack aminoacylation activity but are instead essential components of the first enzyme in histidine biosynthesis ATP phosphoribosyltransferase (HisG). Prediction of the function of HisZ in Lactococcus lactis was assisted by comparative genomics, a technique that revealed a link between the presence or the absence of HisZ and a systematic variation in the length of the HisG polypeptide. HisZ is required for histidine prototrophy, and three other lines of evidence support the direct involvement of HisZ in the transferase function. (i) Genetic experiments demonstrate that complementation of an in-frame deletion of HisG from Escherichia coli (which does not possess HisZ) requires both HisG and HisZ from L. lactis. (ii) Coelution of HisG and HisZ during affinity chromatography provides evidence of direct physical interaction. (iii) Both HisG and HisZ are required for catalysis of the ATP phosphoribosyltransferase reaction. This observation of a common protein domain linking amino acid biosynthesis and protein synthesis implies an early connection between the biosynthesis of amino acids and proteins.

Histidyl-tRNA synthetase

Histidyl-tRNA synthetase (HisRS) is responsible for the synthesis of histidyl-transfer RNA, which is essential for the incorporation of histidine into proteins. This amino acid has uniquely moderate basic properties and is an important group in many catalytic functions of enzymes. A compilation of currently known primary structures of HisRS shows that the subunits of these homo-dimeric enzymes consist of 420-550 amino acid residues. This represents a relatively short chain length among aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRS), whose peptide chain sizes range from about 300 to 1100 amino acid residues. The crystal structures of HisRS from two organisms and their complexes with histidine, histidyl-adenylate and histidinol with ATP have been solved. HisRS from Escherichia coli and Thermus thermophilus are very similar dimeric enzymes consisting of three domains: the N-terminal catalytic domain containing the six-stranded antiparallel beta-sheet and the three motifs characteristic of class II aaRS, a HisRS-specific helical domain inserted between motifs 2 and 3 that may contact the acceptor stem of the tRNA, and a C-terminal alpha/beta domain that may be involved in the recognition of the anticodon stem and loop of tRNA(His). The aminoacylation reaction follows the standard two-step mechanism. HisRS also belongs to the group of aaRS that can rapidly synthesize diadenosine tetraphosphate, a compound that is suspected to be involved in several regulatory mechanisms of cell metabolism. Many analogs of histidine have been tested for their properties as substrates or inhibitors of HisRS, leading to the elucidation of structure-activity relationships concerning configuration, importance of the carboxy and amino group, and the nature of the side chain. HisRS has been found to act as a particularly important antigen in autoimmune diseases such as rheumatic arthritis or myositis. Successful attempts have been made to identify epitopes responsible for the complexation with such auto-antibodies.

tRNA recognition and evolution of determinants in seryl-tRNA synthesis

We have analyzed the evolution of recognition of tRNAsSerby seryl-tRNA synthetases, and compared it to other type 2 tRNAs, which contain a long extra arm. In Eubacteria and chloroplasts this type of tRNA is restricted to three families: tRNALeu, tRNASer and tRNATyr. tRNALeuand tRNASer also carry a long extra arm in Archaea, Eukarya and all organelles with the exception of animal mitochondria. In contrast, the long extra arm of tRNATyr is far less conserved: it was drastically shortened after the separation of Archaea and Eukarya from Eubacteria, and it is also truncated in animal mitochondria. The high degree of phylo-genetic divergence in the length of tRNA variable arms, which are recognized by both class I and class II aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, makes type 2 tRNA recognition an ideal system with which to study how tRNA discrimination may have evolved in tandem with the evolution of other components of the translation machinery.

Human tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase shares amino acid sequence homology with a putative cytokine

To test the hypothesis that tRNATyr recognition differs between bacterial and human tyrosyl-tRNA synthetases, we sequenced several clones identified as human tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase cDNAs by the Human Genome Project. We found that human tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase is composed of three domains: 1) an amino-terminal Rossmann fold domain that is responsible for formation of the activated E.Tyr-AMP intermediate and is conserved among bacteria, archeae, and eukaryotes; 2) a tRNA anticodon recognition domain that has not been conserved between bacteria and eukaryotes; and 3) a carboxyl-terminal domain that is unique to the human tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase and whose primary structure is 49% identical to the putative human cytokine endothelial monocyte-activating protein II, 50% identical to the carboxyl-terminal domain of methionyl-tRNA synthetase from Caenorhabditis elegans, and 43% identical to the carboxyl-terminal domain of Arc1p from Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The first two domains of the human tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase are 52, 36, and 16% identical to tyrosyl-tRNA synthetases from S. cerevisiae, Methanococcus jannaschii, and Bacillus stearothermophilus, respectively. Nine of fifteen amino acids known to be involved in the formation of the tyrosyl-adenylate complex in B. stearothermophilus are conserved across all of the organisms, whereas amino acids involved in the recognition of tRNATyr are not conserved. Kinetic analyses of recombinant human and B. stearothermophilus tyrosyl-tRNA synthetases expressed in Escherichia coli indicate that human tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase aminoacylates human but not B. stearothermophilus tRNATyr, and vice versa, supporting the original hypothesis. It is proposed that like endothelial monocyte-activating protein II and the carboxyl-terminal domain of Arc1p, the carboxyl-terminal domain of human tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase evolved from gene duplication of the carboxyl-terminal domain of methionyl-tRNA synthetase and may direct tRNA to the active site of the enzyme.

Affinity coelectrophoresis for dissecting protein-RNA domain-domain interactions in a tRNA synthetase system

The class I methionyl tRNA synthetase has a conserved N-terminal nucleotide binding fold which contains the active site, and a largely non-conserved C-terminal anticodon binding domain. At the C-terminal end of the anticodon binding domain is a peptide which curls back into the N-terminal nucleotide binding fold near the active site. We showed that a mutation in this peptide disrupts aminoacylation and binding of a 7 base pair microhelix substrate based on the acceptor stem of tRNA(fMet). The novel technique of affinity coelectrophoresis was applied to this system for the first time to determine dissociation constants of wild-type and mutant MetRS for small RNA substrates. A description and evaluation of this technique for measuring weak protein-nucleic acid interactions is presented here, in the context of the methionyl tRNA synthetase system.

C-terminal zinc-containing peptide required for RNA recognition by a class I tRNA synthetase

Escherichia coli isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase is one of five closely related class I tRNA synthetases. The active site of the 939 amino acid polypeptide is in an N-terminal domain which contains an insertion believed essential for interactions with the tRNA acceptor helix. The enzyme was shown previously to contain an essential (for function in vivo) zinc bound to a Cys4 cluster at the C-terminal end of the polypeptide. The specific function of this zinc has been unknown. We show here that aminoacylation activity can be reconstituted in vitro by combining a 53 amino acid zinc-containing C-terminal peptide with a protein consisting of the remaining 886 amino acids. Reconstitution of aminoacylation is zinc-dependent. In contrast, the zinc-containing peptide is dispensable for synthesis of isoleucyl adenylate. Affinity coelectrophoresis showed that the 53 amino acid C-terminal peptide is required specifically for tRNA binding. We propose that the zinc-containing peptide curls back to the active site to make contact with the acceptor helix of bound tRNA, but not with isoleucine or ATP. It is the first example of a zinc-containing peptide in a class I tRNA synthetase that is essential for tRNA binding interactions. The design of this enzyme may be part of a more general scheme for class I tRNA synthetases to acquire acceptor helix binding elements during the development of the genetic code.

Human alanyl-tRNA synthetase: conservation in evolution of catalytic core and microhelix recognition

The class II Escherichia coli and human alanyl-tRNA synthetases cross-acylate their respective tRNAs and require, for aminoacylation, an acceptor helix G3:U70 base pair that is conserved in evolution. We report here the primary structure and expression in the yeast Pichia of an active human alanyl-tRNA synthetase. The N-terminal 498 amino acids of the 968-residue polypeptide have substantial (41%) identity with the E. coli protein. A closely related region encompasses the class-defining domain of the E. coli enzyme and includes the part needed for recognition of the acceptor helix. As a result, previously reported mutagenesis, modeling, domain organization, and biochemical characterization on the E. coli protein appear valid as a template for the human protein. In particular, we show that both the E. coli enzyme and the human enzyme purified from Pichia aminoacylate 9-base pair RNA duplexes whose sequences are based on the acceptor stems of either E. coli or human alanine tRNAs. In contrast, the sequences of the two enzymes completely diverge in an internal portion of the C-terminal half that is essential for tetramer formation by the E. coli enzyme, but that is dispensable for microhelix aminoacylation. This divergence correlates with the expressed human enzyme behaving as a monomer. Thus, the region of close sequence similarity may be a consequence of strong selective pressure to conserve the acceptor helix G3:U70 base pair as an RNA signal for alanine.

Molecular evolution of transfer RNA from two precursor hairpins: implications for the origin of protein synthesis

In this paper we are going to present a model for the coevolution of major components of the protein synthesis machinery in a primordial RNA world. We propose that the essential prerequisites for RNA-based protein synthesis, i.e., tRNA-like molecules, ribozymic charging catalysts, small-subunit(SSU) rRNA, and large-subunit(LSU) rRNA, evolved from the same ancestral RNA molecule. Several arguments are considered which suggest that tRNA-like molecules were derived by tandem joining of template-flanking hairpin structures involved in replication control. It is further argued that the ancestors of contemporary group I tRNA introns catalyzed such hairpin joining reactions, themselves also giving rise to the ribosomal RNAs. Our model includes a general stereochemical principle for the interaction between ribozymes and hairpin-derived recognition structures, which can be applied to such seemingly different processes as RNA polymerization, aminoacylation, tRNA decoding, and peptidyl transfer, implicating a common origin for these fundamental functions. These and other considerations suggest that generation and evolution of tRNA were coupled to the evolution of synthetases, ribosomal RNAs, and introns from the beginning and have been a consequence arising from the original function of tRNA precursor hairpins as replication and recombination control elements.

Operational RNA code for amino acids: species-specific aminoacylation of minihelices switched by a single nucleotide

The genetic code is based on aminoacylation reactions where specific amino acids are attached to tRNAs bearing anticodon trinucleotides. However, the anticodon-independent specific aminoacylation of RNA minihelix substrates by bacterial and yeast tRNA synthetases suggested an operational RNA code for amino acids whereby specific RNA sequences/structures in tRNA acceptor stems correspond to specific amino acids. Because of the possible significance of the operational RNA code for the development of the genetic code, we investigated aminoacylation of synthetic RNA minihelices with a human enzyme to understand the sequences needed for that aminoacylation compared with those needed for a microbial system. We show here that the species-specific aminoacylation of glycine tRNAs is recapitulated by a species-specific aminoacylation of minihelices. Although the mammalian and Escherichia coli minihelices differ at 6 of 12 base pairs, two of the three nucleotides essential for aminoacylation by the E. coli enzyme are conserved in the mammalian minihelix. The two conserved nucleotides were shown to be also important for aminoacylation of the mammalian minihelix by the human enzyme. A simple interchange of the differing nucleotide enabled the human enzyme to now charge the bacterial substrate and not the mammalian minihelix. Conversely, this interchange made the bacterial enzyme specific for the mammalian substrate. Thus, the positional locations (if not the actual nucleotides) for the operational RNA code for glycine appear conserved from bacteria to mammals.

An operational RNA code for amino acids and variations in critical nucleotide sequences in evolution

An operational RNA code relates specific amino acids to sequences/structures in RNA hairpin helices which reconstruct the seven-base-pair acceptor stems of transfer RNAs. These RNA oligonucleotides are aminoacylated by aminoacyl tRNA synthetases. The specificity and efficiency of aminoacylation are generally determined by three or four nucleotides which are near the site of amino acid attachment. These specificity-determining nucleotides include the so-called "discriminator base" and one or two base pairs within the first four base pairs of the helix. With three examples considered here, nucleotide sequence variations between the eubacterial E. coli tRNA acceptor stems and their human cytoplasmic and mitochondrial counterparts are shown to include changes of some of the nucleotides known to be essential for aminoacylation by the cognate E. coli enzymes. If the general locations of the specificity-determining nucleotides are the same in E. coli and human RNAs, these RNA sequence variations imply a similar covariation in sequences/structures of the E. coli and human tRNA synthetases. These covariations would reflect the integral relationship between the operational RNA code and the design and evolution of tRNA synthetases.

Possible role of aminoacyl-RNA complexes in noncoded peptide synthesis and origin of coded synthesis

Images

Region of a conserved sequence motif in a class II tRNA synthetase needed for transfer of an activated amino acid to an RNA substrate

The class II Escherichia coli alanine tRNA synthetase aminoacylates RNA miniduplexes, which reconstruct the acceptor end of alanine tRNA with the critical G3:U70 base pair. A benzophenone photoaffinity label attached adjacent to G3:U70 in a miniduplex substrate was previously cross-linked to a long enzyme peptide that begins at Gly161 between the class-defining motifs 2 and 3 [Musier-Forsyth, K., & Schimmel, P. (1994) Biochemistry 33, 773-779]. To identify side chains in this peptide that potentially contribute hydrogen bonding or catalytic determinants for the RNA-dependent step of the aminoacylation reaction, peptide functional side chains that are conserved among sequenced alanine enzymes (Asp, Asn, Arg, Glu, Gln, and Tyr) were individually replaced. Of the 21 mutant proteins so generated, one was identified that was not viable even though it accumulated in vivo. This Asp235-->Ala mutant enzyme is defective in the rate of transfer of the activated amino acid to the 3'-end of the RNA substrate. The conserved Asp235 is at the beginning of motif 3. By comparison with the crystal structure of the related class II yeast aspartate tRNA synthetase complexed with tRNA(Asp) (Cavarelli et al., 1993), we suggest that D235 is not in direct contact with acceptor helix base pairs such as G3:U70. Instead, we propose that D235 contributes to transfer-step interactions at the 3'-end of alanine tRNA. Because D235 in alanine tRNA synthetase is at the beginning of one of the conserved motifs that define class II tRNA synthetases, this region of the structure may in general be important for the transfer step.

Mammalian tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetases

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases of higher organisms are far less studied compared to their prokaryotic and unicellular eukaryotic counterparts. However, many aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases from multi-cellular organisms exhibit certain features not yet described for the same enzymes of bacteria or yeast. Tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetases (TrpRS) are among the most thoroughly studied mammalian enzymes of this group. TrpRS are Zn(2+)-dependent, dimeric, class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases with known amino acid sequence for four different mammalian orders. TrpRS is not associated in a stable multi-synthetase complex, although it exhibits a long N-terminal extension absent from bacterial TrpRS. The human gene encoding TrpRS belongs to the interferon-responsive gene family and TrpRS activity drastically increases after interferon gamma induction. For unknown reasons TrpRS is overproduced in pancreas of Ruminantia. Other data on TrpRS available so far are summarized and briefly discussed here.