Should poor risk patients with Hodgkin's disease be sorted out for intensive treatments?

Treatment results in advanced stage Hodgkin's lymphoma: a retrospective study

BACKGROUND

Hodgkin's lymphoma displays distinct epidemiological attributes in Asian population thus making it relevant to study whether there are any differences in treatment outcomes too when treated with current standard of care.

AIM

To evaluate the treatment outcomes of de-novo advanced stage HL in adults.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This retrospective study included de-novo advanced stage HL patients (≥15 years) registered at our center from January 2004 to December 2007. Treatment outcomes were measured in terms of response rates, overall survival (OS) and progression-free survival (PFS). Overall and PFS were calculated with Kaplan-Meier methodology and Cox-proportional hazards model was used for multivariate analysis to identify prognostic factors.

RESULTS

There were 125 patients (males 77%) who received minimum one cycle of chemotherapy with median age of 32 years (Range 15-65 years). Stage IV disease was seen in (46 patients) 37%; 75% (94 patients) patients had B symptoms. International prognostic score (IPS) ≤4 was seen in 95/112 (85%) patients. ABVD (adriamycin, bleomycin, vinblastine, dacarbazine) chemotherapy was given to 94%. Radiation to residual/bulky sites was given to 36% (45 patients). Response data was available for 112 patients; complete response in 76%; partial response in 10 % and progressive disease in 3 patients. Nineteen deaths (progressive disease-7, toxicity-8, unrelated cause-4) were observed. At median follow-up of 28 months, estimated 5-year OS and PFS were 60% and 58%, respectively. On multivariate analysis, IPS and response to treatment were significant factors for both OS and PFS.

CONCLUSIONS

The treatment outcomes in this study are comparable with the published literature with limited follow-up data.

Vinblastine, bleomycin, and methotrexate chemotherapy plus irradiation for patients with early-stage, favorable Hodgkin lymphoma

BACKGROUND

The acknowledged effectiveness of vinblastine, bleomycin, and methotrexate (VBM) chemotherapy in patients with early-stage Hodgkin lymphoma has been associated with conflicting toxicity reports.

METHODS

One hundred forty-three patients were evaluated clinically and had favorable Stage IA or IIA Hodgkin lymphoma. Ninety-three patients were treated with the standard VBM schedule combined with extended-field radiotherapy (EF-RT), leaving the choice of the therapeutic sequence free. Fifty subsequent patients were treated with a slightly modified VBM schedule (VbMp) combined with RT limited to involved fields (IF-RT) and delivered only after the end of chemotherapy. In the VbMp schedule, intervals between cycles were 21 days instead of 28 days, bleomycin doses were reduced, small doses of prednisone were given orally, and the interval before RT was prolonged.

RESULTS

Clinical response was complete in 96% of patients who were treated with VBM plus EF-RT and in 94% of patients who were treated with VbMp plus IF-RT. Recurrence rates were nearly identical (12% and 11%, respectively) over necessarily different follow-up (91 months and 33 months, respectively). Hematologic toxicity was tolerable in both trials, and pulmonary side effects were moderate in the first trial and negligible in the second. On the whole, treatment was tolerated better when RT followed chemotherapy.

CONCLUSIONS

The VBM regimen was confirmed to be effective in patients with early-stage Hodgkin lymphoma. Administration of all cycles before RT improved tolerance; pulmonary toxicity probably is mitigated further by reduced bleomycin doses, mild prednisone therapy, and a more prolonged resting interval before RT. A slightly higher recurrence rate was expectable in the VBM plus IF-RT trial despite the actual intensification of vinblastine and methotrexate.

Comparison of prognostic models in patients with advanced Hodgkin disease. Promising results from integration of the best three systems

BACKGROUND

Several prognostic systems have been elaborated for patients with Hodgkin disease (HD) over the last 12 years, but early identification of a reasonably large group of both low and high risk, advanced stage patients remains unsatisfactory.

METHODS

Seven well known models were applied to 516 patients with advanced HD, with 315 patients used for the study sample and 201 patients used for the test sample. Individual performances as well as joint performances were analyzed univariately and multivariately in relation to overall survival, recurrence free survival, and time to treatment failure by means of a proportional hazards model.

RESULTS

None of the models identified a group containing > 10% of patients from the total population who had a failure risk of either < or = 10% or > or = 50%. The systems of the International Database on Hodgkin Disease, the Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, and the International Prognostic Factor Project showed the best prognostic power; only these three, when analyzed together, predicted clinical outcome with a statistically significant fit to the clinical data. Integration of the three systems in a linear model dramatically improved their individual discriminatory capacity by identifying patients with 10% and 50% failure risks, respectively, in 23% and 24% of the study patient population and in 19% and 25% of the test population, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

As powerful and simple new prognostic factors are awaited that may improve our predictive ability, this integrated index is probably the best way to exploit the significance of those presently available. The program required for the calculations can be downloaded from the Internet at the web site http://www.unimo.it/gisl/default.htm.

Image-aided estimate of tumor burden in Hodgkin's disease: evidence of its primary prognostic importance

PURPOSE

To explore a more direct method for evaluating tumor burden (TB) in Hodgkin's disease (HD) and to verify its prognostic importance.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The volume of TB at diagnosis was directly and retrospectively measured in 121 HD patients through images of the lesions recorded by computed tomographic (CT) scan of the thorax, abdomen, and pelvis for all deep sites of involvement and many superficial ones, and by ultrasonography (US) for the remaining superficial lesions.

RESULTS

The TB, which was obtained from the sum of the volumes of all the lesions measured on CT scans and US and normalized to body-surface area (relative TB [rTB]), showed a median value of 102.6 cm(3)/m(2) (range, 2.2 to 582.8). At multivariate analysis for prognostic value, rTB was the parameter that statistically correlated best with time to treatment failure (P = 2.2 x 10(-6)), followed by erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) (P =.0003), and serum fibrinogen (P =.0112). The prognostic discrimination allowed by rTB alone proved to be clearly superior to that obtained with the score of the International Prognostic Factor Project. The rTB was found to be correlated with many clinical staging parameters (bulky disease, number of involved lymph node regions, serum lactate dehydrogenase, ESR, hemoglobin, Karnofsky index), but its predictability from these variables was low (R(2) =.668).

CONCLUSION

Relative TB is emerging as a strong prognostic factor in HD, more powerful than and largely independent of those hitherto known and used. Further studies are needed to confirm these results and exploit their clinical value, particularly the relationship among rTB, drug doses, and response.

Childhood stage IV Hodgkin disease: therapeutic results of the Polish pediatric leukemia/lymphoma study group

BACKGROUND

The therapeutic management in patients with stage IV Hodgkin disease is still controversial.

PROCEDURE

Among 783 children with Hodgkin disease treated from 1971 to 1996, 56 patients (7.3%) were diagnosed with stage IV. The treatment consisted of MVPP or MVPP/B-DOPA chemotherapy combined with involved-field radiotherapy in 50 children.

RESULTS

The results of treatment of stage IV patients were compared in the three sequential time periods, during which the therapy was modified. In these periods, the first complete remission was obtained in 67%, 86%, and 90% of children, respectively, and the 10-year event-free survival was 42%, 64%, and 85%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Alternate multidrug chemotherapy combined with low-dose involved-field radiotherapy is at present a satisfactory therapeutic method in children with stage IV Hodgkin disease.

Retrospective assessment of quality of life and treatment outcome in patients with Hodgkin's disease from 1969 to 1994

We determined the current quality of life (QoL) of patients with Hodgkin's disease treated at the Innsbruck University Hospital between 1969 and 1994 at a mean time of 9.1 +/- 7.0 years after their initial treatment. Further aims of our study were to assess potential differences in objective treatment outcome and QoL between patients treated with chemo-, radio- or combined modality therapy and those enrolled in randomised clinical trials or treated according to standard procedures. The QLQ-C30, a health-related and validated self-report questionnaire developed by the Study Group on Quality of Life of the European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer (EORTC) was mailed to a cohort of 194 survivors out of a total of 225 patients with Hodgkin's disease; 126 of them (64.9%) returned the completed questionnaire. The 5- and 10-year overall survival rates for the total group of 225 patients were 94.3% and 84.9%, respectively. Irrespective of stage, higher relapse-free survival rates were observed in patients receiving combined modality treatment (P = 0.025). Five-year relapse-free survival rates were 96.6% for patients enrolled in clinical trials and 82.8% for patients treated outside of randomised studies (P = 0.037 in univariate and P = 0.064 in multivariate analysis). Patients treated with combined modality regimens had reduced QoL scores in comparison with those treated with either radiation or chemotherapy alone, but QoL parameters did not differ between patients enrolled in clinical trials and those treated according to standard procedures. Patients with Hodgkin's disease had an excellent long-term prognosis and very high QoL scores a mean of 9.1 years after treatment of their disease. The improved relapse-free survival rates achieved by combined modality regimens must be carefully weighed against the accompanying reduced QoL, since lower relapse rates did not translate into a survival advantage.

A prognostic score for advanced Hodgkin's disease. International Prognostic Factors Project on Advanced Hodgkin's Disease

BACKGROUND

Two thirds of patients with advanced Hodgkin's disease are cured with current approaches to treatment. Prediction of the outcome is important to avoid overtreating some patients and to identify others in whom standard treatment is likely to fail.

METHODS

Data were collected from 25 centers and study groups on a total of 5141 patients treated with combination chemotherapy for advanced Hodgkin's disease, with or without radiotherapy. The data included the outcome and 19 demographic and clinical characteristics at diagnosis. The end point was freedom from progression of disease. Complete data were available for 1618 patients; the final Cox model was fitted to these data. Data from an additional 2643 patients were used for partial validation.

RESULTS

The prognostic score was defined as the number of adverse prognostic factors present at diagnosis. Seven factors had similar independent prognostic effects: a serum albumin level of less than 4 g per deciliter, a hemoglobin level of less than 10.5 g per deciliter, male sex, an age of 45 years or older, stage IV disease (according to the Ann Arbor classification), leukocytosis (a white-cell count of at least 15,000 per cubic millimeter), and lymphocytopenia (a lymphocyte count of less than 600 per cubic millimeter, a count that was less than 8 percent of the white-cell count, or both). The score predicted the rate of freedom from progression of disease as follows: 0, or no factors (7 percent of the patients), 84 percent; 1 (22 percent of the patients), 77 percent; 2 (29 percent of the patients), 67 percent; 3 (23 percent of the patients), 60 percent; 4 (12 percent of the patients), 51 percent; and 5 or higher (7 percent of the patients), 42 percent.

CONCLUSIONS

The prognostic score we developed may be useful in designing clinical trials for the treatment of advanced Hodgkin's disease and in making individual therapeutic decisions, but a distinct group of patients at very high risk could not be identified on the basis of routinely documented demographic and clinical characteristics.

Twelve years experience with high-dose therapy and autologous stem cell transplantation for high-risk Hodgkin's disease patients in first remission after MOPP/ABVD chemotherapy

High-dose therapy followed by autografting can cure patients with aggressive Hodgkin's disease (HD) refractory or with early relapse to first-line combination chemotherapy. On the other hand, the eradication of the disease is rarely achieved in heavily pretreated patients. It has been suggested that patients with HD with very high risk characteristics at diagnosis, often relapse despite appropriate therapy with 7-8 drugs combination. Thus it seems to us that such patients are potential candidates for early autografting during first remission. Twelve years ago, we initiated a pilot study to investigate whether patients with very high risk characteristics, would benefit from early autografting. The application of early autografting was compared with our historical group of patients in complete remission after receiving MOPP/ABVD, who had the same negative prognostic characteristics, refused autografting and who did not receive other treatment after achieving complete remission. Among the 22 consecutive patients entered into the pilot study and autografted, 18 are alive and 17 (77%) remain alive in unmaintained remission at a median of 86 months. One patient (4%) died of interstitial pneumonitis in the transplantation group. Only 8/24 (33%) patients, who did not receive an autograft, are currently alive and disease free at a median of 89 months. In conclusion, the early application of autografting appears to improve the outcome in patients with very high risk HD who achieved remission with MOPP/ABVD.