Intraoperative delivery of cell-killing boost radiation – a review of current and future methods

Prognosis comparison between intraoperative radiotherapy and whole-breast external beam radiotherapy for T1–2 stage breast cancer without lymph node metastasis treated with breast-conserving surgery: A case–control study after propensity score matching

Background

External beam radiotherapy (EBRT), an adjuvant to breast-conserving surgery (BCS), requires a long treatment period, is costly, and is associated with numerous complications. Large sample studies with long follow-up periods are lacking regarding whether intraoperative radiotherapy (IORT), an emerging radiotherapy modality, can replace EBRT for patients with T1–2 early stage breast cancer without lymph node metastasis treated with BCS.

Methods

We identified 270,842 patients with T1-2N0M0 breast cancer from 2000 to 2018 in the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) database. A total of 10,992 patients were matched by propensity score matching (PSM). According to the radiotherapy method, the patients were divided into the IORT and EBRT groups. Overall survival (OS) and breast cancer-specific survival (BCSS) rates were analyzed and compared between the IORT and EBRT groups by Kaplan–Meier analysis. Bilateral P < 0.05 was considered to indicate significance.

Results

After PSM, the survival analysis showed no significant differences in OS or BCSS rates between the IORT and EBRT groups. In the subgroup analysis, the IORT population diagnosed from 2010 to 2013 (HRs = 0.675, 95% CI 0.467–0.976, P = 0.037) or with T2 stage (HRs = 0.449, 95% CI 0.261–0.772, P = 0.004) had better OS rates, but in the overall population, the OS and BCSS rates were better in patients with T1 stage than in patients with T2 stage (P < 0.0001), and the proportion of chemotherapy was significantly higher in T2 stage than in T1 stage. Patients who had EBRT with unknown estrogen receptor had better OS rates (HRs = 3.392, 95% CI 1.368–8.407, P = 0.008). In addition, the IORT group had better BCSS rates for married (HRs = 0.403, 95% CI 0.184–0.881, P = 0.023), grade III (HRs = 0.405, 95% CI 0.173–0.952, P = 0.038), and chemotherapy-receiving (HRs = 0.327, 95% CI 0.116–0.917, P = 0.034) patients with breast cancer compared to the EBRT group.

Conclusion

Intraoperative radiotherapy results of non-inferior OS and BCSS rates, compared to those of EBRT, in patients with early stage breast cancer without lymph node metastasis treated with BCS, and IORT may provide substantial benefits to patients as an effective alternative to standard treatment. This finding provides new insights into radiotherapy strategies for early stage breast cancer.

A new 3D printed applicator with radioactive gel for conformal brachytherapy of superficial skin tumors

Surface brachytherapy is an effective method in the treatment of skin cancer. Current skin brachytherapy techniques are based on the placement of a source of gamma or X-ray photons in a close distance from the skin to irradiate the lesion. Due to the nature of photons, radiation dose in these methods may affect healthy tissue as well as sensitive structures around the target. In order to minimize unwarranted and incidental exposure, we propose a new skin brachytherapy applicator based upon beta particles which have penetration ranges of a few millimeters in tissue. The proposed concept is radioactive gel housed within a pre-designed tumor-specific applicator matching the topology of the skin lesion. The particles mixed with the gel showed a uniform distribution pattern, which is an essential prerequisite in having a uniform dose profile on the skin surface. Based on the dose calculation data from the proposed concept, the dose delivered to the depth of 4500 μm in skin tissue is 10% of the dose delivered to the surface of the tumor, making it suitable is treating thin skin tumors especially when located on top of the bone. Through the innovative combination of radioactive gel and tumor-specific applicator, the radiation entering the skin surface can be personalized while minimizing the adverse effects of undesired exposure to the surrounding healthy tissue.

Radiation therapy techniques in the treatment of skin cancer: an overview of the current status and outlook

Nonmelanoma skin cancer (NMSC) is a major health concern due to its high incidence rate, its negative impact on the quality of life of patients as well as the associated economic burden to the healthcare system. Surgery is currently the primary treatment offered for skin cancer patients but not applicable or available in all cases. Radiation therapy (RT), with its long successful history in the management of cancer, has shown to be an effective alternative or complementary method in cutaneous oncology. Specifically, for dermatology applications, RT is very often the preferred option due to its favorable cosmetic results, besides the excellent control rate of the tumor. During the last 120 years since the introduction of treatments based on ionizing radiation, several techniques in this area have been developed. Radionuclide brachytherapy, electronic brachytherapy, X-ray therapies with kilovolt (kV) to megavolt (MV) photons and electron beam therapy are the established methods that are currently used on skin cancer patients. The purpose of this article is to overview these techniques and discuss the pros and cons of these methods in dermatology practices. Additionally, a new approach of beta RT of superficial skin tumors is discussed, which may offer exciting features in the management of NMSC.

Trans-oral miniature X-ray radiation delivery system with endoscopic optical feedback

Purpose

Surgery, chemo- and/or external radiation therapy are the standard therapy options for the treatment of laryngeal cancer. Trans-oral access for the surgery reduces traumata and hospitalization time. A new trend in treatment is organ-preserving surgery. To avoid regrowth of cancer, this type of surgery can be combined with radiation therapy. Since external radiation includes healthy tissue surrounding the cancerous zone, a local and direct intraoral radiation delivery would be beneficial.

Methods

A general concept for a trans-oral radiation system was designed, based on clinical need identification with a medical user. A miniaturized X-ray tube was used as the radiation source for the intraoperative radiation delivery. To reduce dose distribution on healthy areas, the X-ray source was collimated by a newly designed adjustable shielding system as part of the housing. For direct optical visualization of the radiation zone, a miniature flexible endoscope was integrated into the system. The endoscopic light cone and the field of view were aligned with the zone of the collimated radiation. The intraoperative radiation system was mounted on a semi-automatic medical holder that was combined with a frontal actuator for rotational and translational movement using piezoelectric motors to provide precise placement.

Results

The entire technical set-up was tested in a simulated environment. The shielding of the X-ray source was verified by performing conventional detector-based dose measurements. The delivered dose was estimated by an ionization chamber. The adjustment of the radiation zone was performed by a manual controlling mechanism integrated into the hand piece of the device. An endoscopic fibre was also added to offer visualization and illumination of the radiation zone. The combination of the radiation system with the semi-automatic holder and actuator offered precise and stable positioning of the device in range of micrometres and will allow for future combination with a radiation planning system.

Conclusions

The presented system was designed for radiation therapy of the oral cavity and the larynx. This first set-up tried to cover all clinical aspects that are necessary for a later use in surgery. The miniaturized X-ray tube offers the size and the power for intraoperative radiation therapy. The adjustable shielding system in combination with the holder and actuator provides a precise placement. The visualization of radiation zone allows a targeting and observation of the radiation zone.