Accounting for strain variations and resistance mutations in the characterization of hepatitis C NS3 protease inhibitors

Hesperidin identified from Citrus extracts potently inhibits HCV genotype 3a NS3 protease

Background

Hepatitis C virus infection is the main cause of liver ailments across the globe. Several HCV genotypes have been identified in different parts of the world. Effective drugs for combating HCV infections are available but not affordable, particularly to infected individuals from resource-limited countries. Hence, cost-effective drugs need to be developed against important HCV drug targets. As Citrus fruits naturally contain bioactive compounds with antiviral activities, the current study was designed to identify antiviral inhibitors from Citrus fruit extracts against an important drug target, NS3 protease, of HCV genotype 3a which is found predominantly in South Asian countries.

Methods

The full-length NS3 protease alone and the NS3 protease domain in fusion with the cognate NS4A cofactor were expressed in Escherichia coli, and purified by chromatographic techniques. Using the purified protein as a drug target, Citrus extracts were evaluated in a FRET assay, and active ingredients, identified using ESI–MS/MS, were docked to observe the interaction with active site residues of NS3. The best interacting compound was further confirmed through the FRET assay as the inhibitor of NS3 protease.

Results

Fusion of the NS3 protease domain to the NS4A cofactor significantly improved the purification yield, and NS3-NS4A was functionally more active than the full-length NS3 alone. The purified protein (NS3-NS4A) was successfully employed in a validated FRET assay to evaluate 14 Citrus fruit extracts, revealing that the mesocarp extract of Citrus paradisi, and whole fruit extracts of C. sinesis, C. aurantinum, and C. reticulata significantly inhibited the protease activity of HCV NS3 protease (IC₅₀ values of 5.79 ± 1.44 µg/mL, 37.19 ± 5.92 µg/mL, 42.62 ± 6.89 µg/mL, and 57.65 ± 3.81 µg/mL, respectively). Subsequent ESI-MSⁿ analysis identified a flavonoid, hesperidin, abundantly present in all the afore-mentioned Citrus extracts. Importantly, docking studies suggested that hesperidin interacts with active site residues, and acts as a potent inhibitor of NS3 protease, exhibiting an IC₅₀ value of 11.34 ± 3.83 µg/mL.

Conclusions

A FRET assay was developed using NS3-NS4A protease, which was successfully utilized for the evaluation of Citrus fruit extracts. Hesperidin, a compound present in the Citrus extracts, was identified as the main flavonoid, which can serve as a cost-effective potent inhibitor of NS3 protease, and could be developed as a drug for antiviral therapy against HCV genotype 3a.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12906-022-03578-1.

The Q41R mutation in the HCV-protease enhances the reactivity towards MAVS by suppressing non-reactive pathways

Recent experimental findings pointed out a new mutation in the HCV protease, Q41R, responsible for a significant enhancement of the enzyme's reactivity towards the mitochondrial antiviral-signaling protein (MAVS). The Q41R mutation is located rather far from the active site, and its involvement in the overall reaction mechanism is thus unclear. We used classical molecular dynamics and QM/MM to study the acylation reaction of HCV NS3/4A protease variants bound to MAVS and the NS4A/4B substrate and uncovered the indirect mechanism by which the Q41R mutation plays a critical role in the efficient cleavage of the substrate. Our simulations reveal that there are two major conformations of the MAVS H1'(p) residue for the wild type protease and only one conformation for the Q41R mutant. The conformational space of H1'(p) is restricted by the Q41R mutation due to a π-π stacking between H1'(p) and R41 as well as a strong hydrogen bond between the backbone of H57 and the side chain of R41. Further QM/MM calculations indicate that the complex with the conformation ruled out by the Q41R substitution is a non-reactive species due to its higher free energy barrier for the acylation reaction. Based on our calculations, we propose a kinetic mechanism that explains experimental data showing an increase of apparent rate constants for MAVS cleavage in Q41R mutants. Our model predicts that the non-reactive conformation of the enzyme-substrate complex modulates reaction kinetics like an uncompetitive inhibitor.

HCV resistance-associated substitutions following direct-acting antiviral therapy failure - Real-life data from Poland

BACKGROUND

This study analysed the NS3 and NS5A mutation frequencies, persistence and drug susceptibility in a cohort of real-life patients, with failed hepatitis C virus (HCV) therapy following directly acting antiviral (DAA) treatment.

METHODS

NS3/NS5A Sanger sequences from 105 patients infected with HCV genotype (G) 1a (6,5.7%), G1b (94,89.5%), G3a (4,3.8%), and G4 (1,1.0%) post DAA treatment failure were analysed. NS3 and NS5A resistance-associated substitutions (RASs) were identified using the geno2pheno algorithm and associated with clinical variables. Time trends were examined using logistic regression.

RESULTS

NS5A RAS were found in 87.9% of sequences derived from patients exposed to this class of agents, whereas NS3 RAS was found in 59.1% of HCV protease-exposed subjects. The frequency of the NS3 RAS increased with fibrosis stage, from 40.0% among F0/F1 individuals to 81.8% among patients with liver cirrhosis (F4, p = 0.094). NS5A mutation frequencies were 7.6% for 28A/V/M, 10.6% for 30 K/Q/R, 42.4% for 31I/F/M/V, and 75.8% for 93H. For NS3, the most common RASs were 56F-23.7%, 168A/E/I/Y/T/V-14.0%, and 117H-5.4%. Susceptibility to glecaprevir/pibrentasvir, velpatasvir/voxlaprevir, and elbasvir/grazoprevir was retained in 92.9%, 43.4%, and, 25.3% of patients, respectively. The frequency of NS3 RAS decreased with time elapsed from failure to sampling (p = 0.034 for trend). NS5A RAS frequency remained stable over the 24-months.

CONCLUSIONS

Following DAA treatment failure, NS5A and NS3 RASs were common with increasing frequency among patients with advanced liver disease. In most cases, despite the presence of RASs, susceptibility to DAA combinations with higher genetic barrier was retained.

Screening and identification of bioactive compounds from citrus against non-structural protein 3 protease of hepatitis C virus genotype 3a by fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay and mass spectrometry

BACKGROUND

Hepatitis C virus genotype 3a (HCV G3a) is highly prevalent in Pakistan. Due to the elevated cost of available Food and Drug Administration-approved drugs against HCV, medicinal natural products of potent antiviral activity should be screened for the cost-effective treatment of the disease. Furthermore, from natural products, active compounds against vital HCV proteins like non-structural protein 3 (NS3) protease could be identified to prevent viral proliferation in the host.

AIM

To develop cost-effective HCV genotype 3a NS3 protease inhibitors from citrus fruit extracts.

METHODS

Full-length NS3 without co-factor non-structural protein 4A (NS4A) and codon optimized NS3 protease in fusion with NS4A were expressed in Escherichia coli. The expressed protein was purified by metal ion affinity chromatography and gel filtration. Citrus fruit extracts were screened using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) assay against the protease and polyphenols were identified as potential inhibitors using electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry (MS)/MS technique. Among different polyphenols, highly potent compounds were screened using molecular modeling approaches and consequently the most active compound was further evaluated against HCV NS4A-NS3 protease domain using FRET assay.

RESULTS

NS4A fused with NS3 protease domain gene was overexpressed and the purified protein yield was high in comparison to the lower yield of the full-length NS3 protein. Furthermore, in enzyme kinetic studies, NS4A fused with NS3 protease proved to be functionally active compared to full-length NS3. So it was concluded that co-factor NS4A fusion is essential for the purification of functionally active protease. FRET assay was developed and validated by the half maximal inhibitory concentration (IC₅₀) values of commercially available inhibitors. Screening of citrus fruit extracts against the native purified fused NS4A-NS3 protease domain showed that the grapefruit mesocarp extract exhibits the highest percentage inhibition 91% of protease activity. Among the compounds identified by LCMS analysis, hesperidin showed strong binding affinity with the protease catalytic triad having S-score value of -10.98.

CONCLUSION

Fused NS4A-NS3 protease is functionally more active, which is effectively inhibited by hesperidin from the grapefruit mesocarp extract with an IC₅₀ value of 23.32 µmol/L.

Characterization of interactions between hepatitis C virus NS5B polymerase, annexin A2 and RNA - effects on NS5B catalysis and allosteric inhibition

Background

Direct acting antivirals (DAAs) provide efficient hepatitis C virus (HCV) therapy and clearance for a majority of patients, but are not available or effective for all patients. They risk developing HCV-induced hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), for which the mechanism remains obscure and therapy is missing. Annexin A2 (AnxA2) has been reported to co-precipitate with the non-structural (NS) HCV proteins NS5B and NS3/NS4A, indicating a role in HCC tumorigenesis and effect on DAA therapy.

Methods

Surface plasmon resonance biosensor technology was used to characterize direct interactions between AnxA2 and HCV NS5B, NS3/NS4 and RNA, and the subsequent effects on catalysis and inhibition.

Results

No direct interaction between AnxA2 and NS3/NS4A was detected, while AnxA2 formed a slowly dissociating, high affinity (K_D = 30 nM), complex with NS5B, decreasing its catalytic activity and affinity for the allosteric inhibitor filibuvir. The RNA binding of the two proteins was independent and AnxA2 and NS5B interacted with different RNAs in ternary complexes of AnxA2:NS5B:RNA, indicating specific preferences.

Conclusions

The complex interplay revealed between NS5B, AnxA2, RNA and filibuvir, suggests that AnxA2 may have an important role for the progression and treatment of HCV infections and the development of HCC, which should be considered also when designing new allosteric inhibitors.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s12985-017-0904-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Biophysical Mode-of-Action and Selectivity Analysis of Allosteric Inhibitors of Hepatitis C Virus (HCV) Polymerase

Allosteric inhibitors of hepatitis C virus (HCV) non-structural protein 5B (NS5B) polymerase are effective for treatment of genotype 1, although their mode of action and potential to inhibit other isolates and genotypes are not well established. We have used biophysical techniques and a novel biosensor-based real-time polymerase assay to investigate the mode-of-action and selectivity of four inhibitors against enzyme from genotypes 1b (BK and Con1) and 3a. Two thumb inhibitors (lomibuvir and filibuvir) interacted with all three NS5B variants, although the affinities for the 3a enzyme were low. Of the two tested palm inhibitors (dasabuvir and nesbuvir), only dasabuvir interacted with the 1b variant, and nesbuvir interacted with NS5B 3a. Lomibuvir, filibuvir and dasabuvir stabilized the structure of the two 1b variants, but not the 3a enzyme. The thumb compounds interfered with the interaction between the enzyme and RNA and blocked the transition from initiation to elongation. The two allosteric inhibitor types have different inhibition mechanisms. Sequence and structure analysis revealed differences in the binding sites for 1b and 3a variants, explaining the poor effect against genotype 3a NS5B. The indirect mode-of-action needs to be considered when designing allosteric compounds. The current approach provides an efficient strategy for identifying and optimizing allosteric inhibitors targeting HCV genotype 3a.

Identification of weak points of hepatitis C virus NS3 protease inhibitors using surface plasmon resonance biosensor-based interaction kinetic analysis and genetic variants

To aid the design of next generation hepatitis C virus (HCV) drugs, the kinetics of the interactions between NS3 protease inhibitors and enzyme from genotypes 1a, 1b, and 3a have been characterized. The linear mechanism-based inhibitors VX-950 (telaprevir) and SCH 503034 (boceprevir) benefited from covalent adduct formation. However, the apparent affinities were rather weak (VX-950, K(D)* of 340, 8.5, and 1000 nM for genotypes 1a, 1b and 3a, respectively; SCH 503034, K(D)* of 90 and 3.9 nM for 1b and 3a, respectively). The non-mechanism-based macrocyclic inhibitors BILN-2016 (ciluprevir) and ITMN-191 (danoprevir) had faster association and slower dissociation kinetics, indicating that rigidification is kinetically favorable. ITMN-191 had nanomolar affinities for all genotypes (K(D)* of 0.13, 1.6, and 0.52 nM), suggesting that a broad spectrum drug is conceivable. The data show that macrocyclic scaffolds and mechanism-based inhibition are advantageous but that there is considerable room for improvement of the kinetics of HCV protease targeted drugs.