Pregnancy outcomes after failed cervical ripening with prostaglandin E2 followed by Foley balloon catheter

Maternal and perinatal outcomes of failed prostaglandin induction of labour: A retrospective cohort study

Background

Induction of labor is performed in up to 25% of pregnant women. When the cervix is unfavorable, cervical ripening may be safely and effectively performed using slow-release vaginal inserts of prostaglandin E2. However, the risk factors, management, and outcome of patients who fail to respond remain unclear.

Objective

To evaluate the outcomes of women who fail to respond to cervical ripening with prostaglandins.

Methods

A retrospective cohort analysis (2013-2019) was conducted. Women with a singleton gestation who underwent induction of labor due to post-date pregnancy using a slow-release prostaglandin E2 vaginal insert for cervical ripening were included. Data on clinical and outcome factors were derived from the medical files, and findings were compared between patients who achieved ripening within 24 h of treatment onset and those who did not. The primary outcome measure was the vaginal delivery rate following the ripening process. Secondary outcome measures were adverse composite maternal and neonatal outcomes. A model combining maternal characteristics and response rates to ripening was constructed.

Results

The final cohort included 1285 women: 1202 responded to cervical ripening (93.54%) and 83 (6.46%) did not. Compared to non-responders, responders had higher rates of vaginal delivery (96.51% vs. 66.27%, P < 0.001); lower rates of adverse maternal composite outcome (12.81% vs. 24.10%, P = 0.031) and adverse neonatal composite respiratory outcome (1.33% vs. 6.02%, P = 0.009). Responders were younger than non-responders (mean 30.03 years vs 31.73 years, P = 0.005) and had a lower nulliparity rate (50.99% vs 76.92%, P < 0.001). On multivariate analysis, failure to achieve cervical ripening was an independent risk factor for intrapartum cesarean delivery due to prolonged labor (aOR 11.90, 95% CI 6.13-23.25).

Conclusion

Women who achieve cervical ripening with prostaglandin E2 vaginal inserts are younger and more often multiparous than women who fail to respond. Good response to the cervical ripening process is associated with lower rates of intrapartum cesarean delivery and of adverse outcomes.

The efficacy and safety of second dinoprostone pessary or balloon catheter after unsuccessful primary ripening with dinoprostone pessary

We investigated which treatment should be applied if primary cervical ripening with a dinoprostone pessary is unsuccessful. We included 281 women who experienced unsuccessful cervical ripening with a dinoprostone pessary and continued on induction of labour (IOL). Of the 281 women recruited, 177 were given a second dose of dinoprostone; 104 women received a balloon catheter. The second dinoprostone pessary was successful in achieving vaginal delivery in 88 of the 177 (48.6%) women, while the balloon catheter was successful in 42 of the 104 women (40.4%); there was no significant difference between the two treatments with regards to successful vaginal delivery. However, of the women who experienced successful vaginal delivery, the delivery rate in the dinoprostone group was significantly higher than that in the balloon catheter group 12, 24, 36, or 48 h after insertion (p = .0094, .0005, .0258, .0483, respectively). The neonatal outcomes, the proportion of maternal infection and postpartum haemorrhage were similar between the two groups.IMPACT STATEMENTWhat is already known on this subject? Labour induction is a common procedure in obstetrics in a bid to achieve vaginal delivery in China, because vaginal delivery is more beneficial and associated with a better quality of life as compared to a Caesarean delivery. There is consensus relating to the preferred method of IOL after unsuccessful IOL with a dinoprostone pessary.What do the results of this study add? This is the first study in a Chinese population to compare the dinoprostone pessary and balloon catheter for women with no response to dinoprostone for cervical ripening with a sample size greater than 100. We found that a second dose of dinoprostone can reduce the time from the re-initiation of IOL to vaginal delivery compared with the balloon catheter. Our data also indicated that all other outcomes relating to the mother and infant were similar.What are the implications of these findings for clinical practice and/or future research? A second dose of dinoprostone is a superior choice for women who experience unsuccessful IOL with dinoprostone to further accelerate vaginal delivery.

Comparison of two management options for labor induction following unsuccessful prostaglandin E2 ripening

Objective: We sought to compare the likelihood of a vaginal delivery (VD) using oxytocin, with and without a cervical ripening balloon, in nulliparous women who did not respond to initial ripening with prostaglandin E2 (PGE2).Methods: We a performed a retrospective cohort study of nulliparous women with a singleton pregnancy at term who underwent cervical ripening with vaginal PGE2 between October 2015 and March 2019. Patients who did not respond to PGE2 ripening (bishop score (BS) of 6 or less with cervical dilation less than 3 cm) were stratified into two groups based on management: sequential ripening with a cervical ripening balloon in addition to oxytocin versus oxytocin alone. Patients who had PGE2 for less than 6 h, a BS greater than 6 after ripening, rupture of membranes or missing data were excluded. The primary outcome was VD. Secondary outcomes included VD within 24 h of induction, time from induction to delivery, rates of chorioamnionitis and postpartum hemorrhage, presence of meconium, neonatal birthweight, NICU admission, 5 min apgar < 5, and umbilical cord pH < 7. Statistical analysis included Chi-squared, Fisher's exact and Mann-Whitney U tests, as well as logistic regression. Odds ratios (ORs) were calculated and adjusted for significant confounders using backwards-stepwise logistic regression. For time to delivery, a Cox proportional hazard regression was used to determine the hazard ratio (HR) and adjusted HR.Results: 840 patients underwent cervical ripening with PGE2 during the study period. After the exclusion criteria were applied, 272 cases comprised the study cohort. Of those, 123 (45%) continued labor induction with a cervical ripening balloon and oxytocin and 149 (55%) continued labor induction with oxytocin alone. Baseline characteristics such as age, BMI, ethnicity, gestational age at induction and number of women undergoing elective induction were similar between both groups. There was no statistically significant difference in the likelihood of VD (oxytocin and cervical ripening balloon: 62.6% vs. oxytocin alone: 50.3%; a OR 1.61, p = .07) or rate of secondary outcomes between the two groups. Patients in the oxytocin alone group had a higher BS after PGE2 ripening, although both were very low (3 vs. 2, p < .0001).". Additionally, there were significantly more patients undergoing full PGE2 ripening for 12 h in the cervical ripening balloon and oxytocin group compared to oxytocin alone (65.9% vs. 49.7%, p = .02).Conclusion: Our data did not show a difference in VD rate in nulliparous women unresponsive to PGE2 ripening who underwent continued induction with oxytocin and cervical ripening balloon compared to oxytocin alone. Larger studies investigating the utility of sequential ripening and determining the optimal induction method following unsuccessful ripening are needed.

Double-balloon catheter for induction of labor in 362 women with and without prior cesarean section

Objective

Balloon catheter is the preferred method for induction of labor in women with prior cesarean section. We sought to evaluate the rate of vaginal delivery, induction-delivery time and outcome predictors after induction with double-balloon catheter.

Study design

We conducted a retrospective cohort study including women with prior cesarean section undergoing induction of labor with a double-balloon catheter during the period January 2007–June 2014 at a large, tertiary Danish university hospital. For comparison, we included women with no prior cesarean section undergoing induction with double-balloon catheter after failed medical induction. Inclusion criteria were singleton pregnancy, an unfavorable cervix, intact membranes, cephalic presentation and either previous cesarean section or failed medical induction of labor. Exclusion criteria included contraindications for vaginal delivery, severe fetal malformation and stillbirth. Study subjects were identified in a local computerized system and data extracted from the medical records.

Results

Women with prior cesarean section (n = 304) induced with double-balloon catheter had a vaginal delivery rate of 50.3% (95% CI 44.7–55.9) compared to 51.7% (95% CI 39.2–64.1) in women with no prior cesarean section but preceding failed medical induction of labor (n = 58) (p = 0.85). BMI≥30 was associated with increased frequency of cesarean section. Median time from induction to vaginal delivery was 27.1(20.4–31.1) hours and 28.4(25.5–36.1) hours, respectively (p = 0.05). The rate of complete uterine rupture was 1.0%.

Conclusions

Similar success rates of approximately 50% for vaginal delivery were observed after induction of labor with a double-balloon catheter in women with and without prior caesarean section. A BMI ≥ 30 was associated with an increased frequency of caesarean section.

Predictors of cesarean delivery in cervical ripening and labor induction with Foley catheter

Purpose: The aim of this paper is to identify predictors of cesarean delivery (CD) in patients with an unfavorable cervix undergoing cervical ripening and labor induction with Foley catheter.Materials and methods: A retrospective cohort study of singleton pregnancies induced using Foley catheter was performed to evaluate whether factors in the maternal history and during the process of labor induction are useful in predicting the risk of CD.Results: During the study period there were 2221 births in the Chair and Department of Obstetrics and Perinatology, Medical University of Lublin, Poland. From a cohort of 402 women with Foley catheter induction (FCI), 327 met inclusion criteria. There were 236 vaginal labors (72.2%) and 91 CDs (27.8%). Nulliparity (OR 2.344), Bishop score of 1-2 points (OR 1.473), and meconium-stained amniotic fluid (OR 1.980) are linked to the risk of CD. In nulliparous patients, factors associated with an increased risk of CD included maternal age greater than 30 years (OR 3.200), meconium-stained amniotic fluid (OR 2.505), and birthweight ≥3400 g (OR 1.803). Among multiparous women none of the evaluated factors was significantly connected to CD.Conclusions: Nulliparity, low Bishop score, and meconium-stained amniotic fluid are important risk factors of CD after FCI.