Stability of femoral neck fracture. Roentgen stereophotogrammetry of 29 hook-pinned fractures

No effect of hydroxyapatite-coated sliding hip screw threads on screw migration in the femoral head/neck of pertrochanteric fractures: a randomized controlled trial using radiostereometric analysis

INTRODUCTION

Cut-out is the most frequently reported mechanical failure of internal fixation of pertrochanteric fractures. The purpose of this study was to examine if hydroxyapatite-coated screw thread on a sliding hip screw (SHS) could reduce screw migration within the femoral head in patients with stable pertrochanteric fractures.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In a double-blinded randomized controlled study, 37 patients at mean age 78 (range 56-96), with pertrochanteric fracture (Evans I, II, IV) received surgery with a SHS with a hydroxyapatite-coated or a non-coated lag screw thread. Radiostereometry and standard radiographs were obtained 1 day, 6 weeks, 3- and 6 months post-operatively to evaluate screw and fracture migration and fracture reposition. The two groups were combined to describe fracture migration.

RESULTS

There was similar and small screw migration in the femoral head between the two groups at 6 weeks, 3- and 6 months (p > 0.12). Fracture migration occurred predominantly in the first 6 weeks, where fracture impaction was 5.95 mm (CI 95% 2.87 to 9.04) and anterior rotation of the femoral head was -2.94° (CI 95% - 5.22 to - 0.66). Migration of the fracture (total translation) correlated to the post-operative fracture reposition (p = 0.002), but not significantly to screw migration (p = 0.09). Neither screw total translation (rho 0.06, p = 0.79) nor fracture total translation (rho 0.04, p = 0.77) correlated with bone mineral density.

CONCLUSION

There was no clinical benefit of hydroxyapatite coating on lag screw migration in this patient cohort. Migration of the pertrochanteric fractures was higher with poor fracture reposition but fractures generally stabilized after 6 weeks follow-up. The study was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT05677061).

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE II

Patient-blinded prospective randomized study. Trial registration number The study was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT05677061).

Biomechanical evaluation of two modified intramedullary fixation system for treating unstable femoral neck fractures: A finite element analysis

Purpose: The existing implants for fixation of femoral neck fractures have poor biomechanical stability, so the failure rate is high. We designed two modified intramedullary implants for treating unstable femoral neck fractures (UFNFs). We tried to improve the biomechanical stability of fixation by shortening the moment and reducing stress concentration. Each modified intramedullary implant was compared with cannulated screws (CSs) through finite element analysis (FEA). Methods: Five different models were included: three cannulated screws (CSs, Model 1) in an inverted triangle configuration, the dynamic hip screw with an anti-rotation screw (DHS + AS, Model 2), the femoral neck system (FNS, Model 3), the modified intramedullary femoral neck system (IFNS, Model 4), and the modified intramedullary interlocking system (IIS, Model 5). Three-dimensional (3D) models of femur and implants were constructed by using 3D modelling software. Three load cases were simulated to assess the maximal displacement of models and fracture surface. The maximal stress at the bone and implants was also evaluated. Results: FEA data showed that Model 5 had the best performance in terms of maximum displacement while Model 1 had the worst performance for this index under axial load of 2100 N. With respect to Maximum stress, Model 4 had the best performance while Model 2 had the worst performance under axial load. The general trends under bending and torsion load were consistent with that under axial load. Our data demonstrated that the two modified intramedullary implants exhibited the best biomechanical stability, followed by FNS and DHS + AS, and then three cannulated screws in axial, bending, and torsion load cases. Conclusion: The two modified intramedullary designs showed the best biomechanical performance among the five implants included in this study. Therefore, this might provide some new options for trauma surgeons to deal with unstable femoral neck fractures.

Biomechanical comparison of the femoral neck system versus InterTan nail and three cannulated screws for unstable Pauwels type III femoral neck fracture

BACKGROUND

There are a variety of internal fixation methods for unstable femoral neck fractures (FNFs), but the best method is still unclear. Femoral neck system (FNS) is a dynamic angular stabilization system with cross screws, and is a new internal fixation implant designed for minimally invasive fixation of FNFs. In this study, we conducted a biomechanical comparison of FNS, InterTan nail and three cannulated screws for the treatment of Pauwels III FNFs and investigate the biomechanical properties of FNS.

METHODS

A total of 18 left artificial femurs were selected and randomly divide into Group A (fixation with FNS), Group B (fixation with InterTan nail) and Group C (fixation with three cannulated screws), with 6 specimens in each group. After creating Pauwels type III FNF models, the specimens in each were tested with non-destructive quasi-static tests, including torsion, A-P bending and axial compression tests. The average slope of the linear load-deformation curve obtained from quasi-static tests defines the initial torsional stiffness, A-P bending stiffness, and axial compression stiffness. After cyclic loading test was applied, the overall deformation of models and local deformation of implant holes in each group were assessed. The overall deformation was estimated as the displacement recorded by the software of the mechanical testing apparatus. Local deformation was defined as interfragmental displacement. Data were analyzed by one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by Bonferroni post hoc test using the SPSS software (version 24.0, IBM, New York, NY, USA). Correlation analysis was performed using Pearson's correlation analysis.

RESULTS

Group B exhibited significantly higher axial stiffness and A-P bending stiffness than the other two groups (P < 0.01), while Group A had significantly higher axial stiffness and A-P bending stiffness than Group C (P < 0.01). Groups A and B exhibited significantly higher torsional stiffness than Group C (P < 0.01), no statistical significance was observed between Groups A and B (P > 0.05). Group B exhibited significantly lower overall and local deformations than the other two groups (P < 0.01), while Group A had significantly lower overall and local deformations than Group C (P < 0.01). Correlation analysis revealed positive correlation between axial stiffness and A-P bending stiffness (r = 0.925, P < 0.01), torsional stiffness (r = 0.727, P < 0.01), between torsional stiffness and A-P bending stiffness; negative correlation between overall, local deformations and axial stiffness (r = - 0.889, - 0.901, respectively, both P < 0.01), and positive correlation between the two deformations (r = - 0.978, P < 0.01).

CONCLUSION

For fixation of unstable FNFs, InterTan nail showed the highest axial stiffness and A-P bending stiffness, followed by FNS, and then three cannulated screws. Torsional stiffness of FNS was comparable to that of the InterTan nail. FNS, as a novel minimally invasive implant, can create good mechanical environment for the healing of unstable FNFs. Clinical studies are needed to confirm the potential advantages of FNS observed in this biomechanical study.

Intermediate Dynamic Compression and Decreased Posterior Tilt With Interlocked Pins in Femoral Neck Fixation in Synthetic Bone

Fixation failure with resulting non-union is the key complication after femoral neck fixation. It can be avoided by permitting dynamic compression and reducing rotation and posterior tilt of the femoral head. To achieve this, a novel implant that features an interlocking plate with three hook-pins (The Hansson Pinloc® System) was developed from the original two hook-pins. Only an enhanced torsional fixation by the implant modification is reported. The purpose was to compare the biomechanical compressive and bending stability of the original and modified implant in femoral neck fixation. To analyze the contribution of both modified components, three individual pins were included, although not in regular use. Forty-eight synthetic femurs with mid-cervical wedge osteotomies were fixated by two pins or identical triangular pin patterns with or without the plate. Eight specimens of each group were loaded cyclically in compression with an inferior wedge to simulate stance and anteroposterior bending with a posterior wedge to imitate sitting down. The clinically relevant stability measurements were stiffness and deformation. Fissure formation defined failure. The novel implant improved bending stability by 30% increased stiffness, 44% reduced deformation, and less frequent posterior neck fissure formation (p < 0.001) while increased compressive stability was only evident with 25% reduced deformation and less frequent inferior neck fissures (p < 0.001). These impacts were mainly mediated by the third pin, while the plate prevented a lateral fissure in compression (p < 0.001). The clinical stability was improved by dynamic compression and decreased posterior tilt by implant modification.

Increased stability by a novel femoral neck interlocking plate compared to conventional fixation methods. A biomechanical study in synthetic bone

BACKGROUND

Stable fixation promotes union in the common femoral neck fractures, but high non-union rates due to fixation failure remain with traditional fixations. To enhance stability, a plate interlocking pins, but without further fixation to femur has been developed. To our knowledge, no comparison to other conventional fixation methods has been performed. We tested the hypothesis that the novel implant biomechanically leads to a more stable femoral neck fixation.

METHODS

Fifty synthetic femurs with a cervical wedge osteotomy were allocated to intervention with three hook-pins interlocked in a plate (Hansson Pinloc® System) or standard fixations with a two-hole Dynamic Hip Screw® plate with an anti-rotational screw, three cannulated screws (ASNIS® III) or two screws (Olmed® or Cannulated Hip Screws®). Quasi-static non-destructive torsion around the neck, anteroposterior bending and vertical compression were tested to detect stiffness. The specimen's deformation was evaluated after cyclic compression simulating weight-bearing. Local deformation of implant channels was measured. Fixation failure was defined by fissure formation.

FINDINGS

Compared to the conventional implants all together, the interlocked pins enhanced mean stiffness 130% in torsion and 33% in bending (P < 0.001), while compressive stability was increased by a reduced deformation of 62% in average of the global test specimen and 95% decreased local implant channel deformation after cycling (P < 0.001). In comparisons with each of the standard fixations the interlocking pins revealed no signs of adverse effects.

INTERPRETATION

The novel femoral neck interlocking plate allowed dynamic compression and improved multi-directional stability compared to the traditional fixations.

Radiostereometric analysis of the initial stability of internally fixed femoral neck fractures under differential loading

We examined the feasibility of radiostereometric analysis (RSA) in the assessment of the initial stability of internally fixed femoral neck fractures. The study included 16 patients (mean age 73 years). During surgery, multiple RSA-beads were inserted on both sides of the fracture. Radiographs for RSA were taken in the supine position within the first 3 days and 6, 12, 24, and 52 weeks after surgery. To detect any inducible motion at the fracture-site, radiographs for RSA were taken with the patient resting or applying a load through the fracture. Fracture loading was achieved by the patient pressing the ipsilateral foot as much as tolerated on a force plate while providing a counterforce through both hands. Micromotion exceeding the precision values of RSA (≥0.3 mm for the translation vector and/or ≥1.2 degrees for the rotation vector) was considered significant. Permanent three-dimensional fracture-site displacement was also recorded. Voluntary loading induced fracture-site micromotion, which exhibited a dichotomous distribution. In patients with uncomplicated fracture union, inducible micromotion was detectable only at baseline-if at all. Conversely, fractures that developed a nonunion were characterized by the continuation of inducible micromotion beyond baseline. Permanent fracture-site displacement was, on average, nearly an order of magnitude greater than the inducible micromotion. Fracture unions were characterized by the cessation of permanent fracture-site displacement by 12 weeks. Nonunions presented as outliers in permanent fracture-site displacement. Large-scale studies are warranted to evaluate whether the detection of inducible micromotion beyond baseline could serve as an indicator of insufficient fixation stability. © 2018 The Authors. Journal of Orthopaedic Research® Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. on behalf of the Orthopaedic Research Society.

Increased torsional stability by a novel femoral neck locking plate. The role of plate design and pin configuration in a synthetic bone block model

BACKGROUND

In undisplaced femoral neck fractures, internal fixation remains the main treatment, with mechanical failure as a frequent complication. As torsional stable fixation promotes femoral neck fracture healing, the Hansson Pinloc® System with a plate interlocking pins, was developed from the original hook pins. Since its effect on torsional stability is undocumented, the novel implant was compared with the original configurations.

METHODS

Forty-two proximal femur models custom made of two blocks of polyurethane foam were tested. The medial block simulated the cancellous head, while the lateral was laminated with a glass fiber filled epoxy sheet simulating trochanteric cortical bone. Two hollow metal cylinders with a circumferential ball bearing in between mimicked the neck, with a perpendicular fracture in the middle. Fractures were fixated by two or three independent pins or by five configurations involving the interlocking plate (two pins with an optional peg in a small plate, or three pins in a small, medium or large plate). Six torsional tests were performed on each configuration to calculate torsional stiffness, torque at failure and failure energy.

FINDINGS

The novel configurations improved parameters up to an average of 12.0 (stiffness), 19.3 (torque) and 19.9 (energy) times higher than the original two pins (P < 0.001). The plate, its size and its triangular configuration improved all parameters (P = 0.03), the plate being most effective, also preventing permanent failure (P < 0.001).

INTERPRETATION

The novel plate design with its pin configuration enhanced torsional stability. To reveal clinical relevance a clinical study is planned.

Stability of Internally Fixed Femoral Neck Fractures Augmented with Resorbable Cement

Background and Aims:

Internal fixation of displaced femoral neck fractures is associated with a high risk for complications such as non-union or avascular necrosis. A stable fracture fixation can improve prognosis although stability is often counteracted by weak osteoporotic bone. The aim with this study was to evaluate whether augmentation with resorbable calcium-phosphate cement could improve fracture stability during the early period after surgery as shown in biomechanical studies.

Material and Methods:

40 ambulatory patients with a displaced femoral neck fracture were randomized to treatment with cannulated screws alone (controls) or screws combined with calcium-phosphate cement for augmentation (augmented). All patients were allowed unrestricted weight bearing after surgery. Fracture movement was measured with radiostereometry (RSA) at 1 and 6 weeks.

Results:

At 1 week the augmented fractures had moved on average 1.9±1.0 mm while movement in the controls was 5.5±3.4 mm (p < 0.0001). The average total movement at weeks was 6.9±2.9 mm and 10.9±5.1 mm, respectively (p < 0.005). Varus angulation and distal migration of the femoral head were the most common movements for both groups although augmented fractures had moved significantly less at both 1 and 6 weeks. There were no significant differences in angulation between groups around the longitudinal and transversal axes or in migration along the transverse or sagittal axes.

Conclusion:

Augmentation with calcium-phosphate cement improved the stability of internally fixed femoral neck fractures during the first six weeks after surgery, with improvement being less pronounced at six weeks compared with at one week.

The stability of fixation of proximal femoral fractures

The aim of this study was to quantify the stability of fracture-implant complex in fractures after fixation. A total of 15 patients with an undisplaced fracture of the femoral neck, treated with either a dynamic hip screw or three cannulated hip screws, and 16 patients with an AO31-A2 trochanteric fracture treated with a dynamic hip screw or a Gamma Nail, were included. Radiostereometric analysis was used at six weeks, four months and 12 months post-operatively to evaluate shortening and rotation.

Migration could be assessed in ten patients with a fracture of the femoral neck and seven with a trochanteric fracture. By four months post-operatively, a mean shortening of 5.4 mm (-0.04 to 16.1) had occurred in the fracture of the femoral neck group and 5.0 mm (-0.13 to 12.9) in the trochanteric fracture group. A wide range of rotation occurred in both types of fracture. Right-sided trochanteric fractures seem more rotationally stable than left-sided fractures.

This prospective study shows that migration at the fracture site occurs continuously during the first four post-operative months, after which stabilisation occurs. This information may allow the early recognition of patients at risk of failure of fixation.

Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2015;97-B:391–7.

Good stability but high periprosthetic bone mineral loss and late-occurring periprosthetic fractures with use of uncemented tapered femoral stems in patients with a femoral neck fracture

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

We previously evaluated a new uncemented femoral stem designed for elderly patients with a femoral neck fracture and found stable implant fixation and good clinical results up to 2 years postoperatively, despite substantial periprosthetic bone mineral loss. We now present the medium-term follow-up results from this study.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In this observational prospective cohort study, we included 50 patients (mean age 81 (70-92) years) with a femoral neck fracture. All patients underwent surgery with a cemented cup and an uncemented stem specifically designed for fracture treatment. Outcome variables were migration of the stem measured with radiostereometry (RSA) and periprosthetic change in bone mineral density (BMD), measured with dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA). Hip function and health-related quality of life were assessed using the Harris hip score (HHS) and the EuroQol-5D (EQ-5D). DXA and RSA data were collected at regular intervals up to 4 years, and data concerning reoperations and hip-related complications were collected during a mean follow-up time of 5 (0.2-7.5) years.

RESULTS

At 5 years, 19 patients had either passed away or were unavailable for further participation and 31 could be followed up. Of the original 50 patients, 6 patients had suffered a periprosthetic fracture, all of them sustained after the 2-year follow-up. In 19 patients, we obtained complete RSA and DXA data and no component had migrated after the 2-year follow-up. We also found a continuous total periprosthetic bone loss amounting to a median of -19% (-39 to 2). No changes in HHS or EQ-5D were observed during the follow-up period.

INTERPRETATION

In this medium-term follow-up, the stem remained firmly fixed in bone despite considerable periprosthetic bone mineral loss. However, this bone loss might explain the high number of late-occurring periprosthetic fractures. Based on these results, we would not recommend uncemented femoral stems for the treatment of femoral neck fractures in the elderly.

A new uncemented hydroxyapatite-coated femoral component for the treatment of femoral neck fractures

Our aim in this pilot study was to evaluate the fixation of, the bone remodelling around, and the clinical outcome after surgery of a new, uncemented, fully hydroxyapatite-coated, collared and tapered femoral component, designed specifically for elderly patients with a fracture of the femoral neck.

We enrolled 50 patients, of at least 70 years of age, with an acute displaced fracture of the femoral neck in this prospective single-series study. They received a total hip replacement using the new component and were followed up regularly for two years.

Fixation was evaluated by radiostereometric analysis and bone remodelling by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry. Hip function and the health-related quality of life were assessed using the Harris hip score and the EuroQol-5D.

Up to six weeks post-operatively there was a mean subsidence of 0.2 mm (−2.1 to +0.5) and a retroversion of a mean of 1.2° (−8.2° to +1.5°). No component migrated after three months. The patients had a continuous loss of peri-prosthetic bone which amounted to a mean of 16% (−49% to +10%) at two years. The mean Harris hip score was 82 (51 to 100) after two years.

The two-year results from this pilot study indicate that this new, uncemented femoral component can be used for elderly patients with osteoporotic fractures of the femoral neck.

Differentially loaded radiostereometric analysis to monitor fracture stiffness: a feasibility study

Inability to accurately and objectively assess the mechanical properties of healing fractures in vivo hampers clinical fracture management and research. We describe a method to monitor fracture stiffness during healing in a clinical research setting by detecting changes in fracture displacement using radiostereometric analysis and simultaneously measuring applied axial loads. A method was developed for load application, positioning of the patient, and radiographic setup to establish the technique of differentially loaded radiostereometric analysis (DLRSA). A DLRSA examination consists of radiostereometric analysis radiographs taken without load (preload), under different increments of load, and without load (postload). Six patients with distal femur fractures had DLRSA examinations at 6, 12, 18, and 26 weeks postoperatively. The DLRSA method was feasible in a clinical setting. The method provides objective and quantifiable data for internally fixed fractures and may be used in clinical research as a tool to monitor the in vivo stiffness of healing femoral fractures managed with nonrigid internal fixation.

Biomechanical comparison of two side plate fixation techniques in an unstable intertrochanteric osteotomy model: Sliding Hip Screw and Percutaneous Compression Plate

BACKGROUND

Our objective was to determine the biomechanical primary stability of two different side plate fixation devices in an unstable intertrochanteric cadaver model: the Sliding Hip Screw with an additional derotation screw was compared with the Percutaneous Compression Plate.

METHODS

Eight pairs of human cadaver femurs were tested for comparison of the primary stability of the two implants in two modes: (a) cyclic loading up to 200 N, 400 N, 600 N, 800 N, and 1000 N, respectively. In vitro combined axial and bending loads were applied. Angular displacements of the proximal head fragment during loading were recorded in rotational, varus-valgus, and anterior-posterior directions. (b) The load to failure was determined.

FINDINGS

Specimens fixed with the Percutaneous Compression Plate showed higher displacements in the varus during loading up to 200 N (P=0.033), and 400 N (P=0.001), compared to the Sliding Hip Screw. A similar tendency was observed for higher loads. The Percutaneous Compression Plate allowed more external rotation of the proximal fragment only at loads up to 800 N (P=0.019). No statistical difference could be found for the slight migrations in the posterior direction. Load to failure also revealed no statistical difference between the two implants.

INTERPRETATION

The Percutaneous Compression Plate as a double-axis fixation device with a sliding capability allows higher displacements in the varus direction and also in external rotation at 800 N loading compared to the Sliding Hip Screw as a single-axis fixation device combined with an additional derotation screw. While both implants are successful used in clinical practice, this should be considered in treatment of unstable intertrochanteric fractures with inferior comminution in osteoporotic patients.

Guidelines for standardization of radiostereometry (RSA) of implants

There is a need for standardization of radiostereometric (RSA) investigations to facilitate comparison of outcome reported from different research groups. In this document, 6 research centers have agreed upon standards for terminology, description and use of RSA arrangement including radiographic set-up and techniques. Consensus regarding minimum requirements for marker stability and scatter, choice of coordinate systems, and preferred way of describing prosthetic micromotion is of special interest. Some notes on data interpretation are also presented. Validation of RSA should be standardized by preparation of protocols for assessment of accuracy and precision. Practical issues related to loading of the joint by weight bearing or other conditions, follow-up intervals, length of follow-up, radiation dose, and the exclusion of patients due to technical errors are considered. Finally, we present a checklist of standardized output that should be included in any clinical RSA paper.This document will form the basis of a detailed standardization protocol under supervision of ISO and the European Standards Working Group on Joint Replacement Implants (CEN/TC 285/WG4). This protocol will facilitate inclusion of RSA in a standard protocol for implant testing before it is released for general use. Such a protocol-also including other recognized clinical outcome parameters-will reduce the risk of implanting potentially inferior prostheses on a large scale.

Quality of life related to fracture displacement among elderly patients with femoral neck fractures treated with internal fixation

OBJECTIVE

To determine differences in outcome between undisplaced (Garden I and II) and displaced (Garden III and IV) femoral neck fractures in elderly patients treated with internal fixation.

SETTING

University hospital.

DESIGN

Prospective clinical study.

PATIENTS

Ninety patients with an acute femoral neck fracture after a fall. The inclusion criteria were age older than sixty-five years, absence of severe cognitive dysfunction, independent living, and unhindered walking capability preoperatively. The mean follow-up was twenty-six months.

INTERVENTION

The patients were treated with closed reduction and percutaneous internal fixation with two cannulated screws.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS

Fracture healing complications, pain (visual analogue scale), walking capability, activities of daily living, and quality of life according to EuroQol.

RESULTS

The rate of fracture healing complications in displaced femoral neck fractures in patients available at the final follow-up was 36 percent compared with 7 percent in patients with undisplaced fractures. The quality of life, according to EuroQol, of patients with uneventfully healed fractures was significantly lower in patients with primarily displaced fractures (0.51) than in patients with undisplaced ones (0.76).

CONCLUSION

There was a major difference in outcome on comparing undisplaced and displaced femoral neck fractures in elderly patients treated with internal fixation. The rate of fracture healing complications in patients with undisplaced fractures was low, and patients with healed fractures regained their prefracture quality of life level. The rate of fracture healing complications and reoperations in patients with displaced fractures was high, and even in patients with uneventfully healed fractures, there was a substantial decrease in the quality of life.

Predicting the mechanical outcome of femoral neck fractures fixed with cancellous screws: an in vivo study

OBJECTIVE

The goal of this project was to determine, by using a retrospective cohort analysis, the relative importance of fracture geometry, bone density, and quality of fracture reduction in predicting redisplacement of femoral neck fractures fixed with multiple cancellous screws in a patient population.

DESIGN

A retrospective analysis of quantitative geometric and bone density data from forty-seven patients with femoral neck fractures fixed with cancellous screws was performed.

SETTING

Radiographs retrieved after analysis of a statewide hospital database were digitized and analyzed quantitatively.

INTERVENTION

Quantitative data from radiographs included estimates of femoral neck bone density, fracture surface orientation and location, degree of comminution, prefixation displacement, initial reduction position of the fractured component, and final displacement of the fracture after fixation.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS

Angular rotation and inferior displacement of the fracture component after fixation.

RESULTS

Femoral neck bone density can be correlated to femoral cortical thickness and can be used as a measure of bone density from plain x-rays. Significant relative risk of redisplacement of a femoral neck fracture is correlated with initial inferior offset of the fracture component and varus angulation. Relative risks of other variables, including valgus reduction, Garden Stage 3 and 4 position of the femoral head, low bone density, presence of inferior comminution, a more vertical fracture surface angle, and fracture position, were not significant.

CONCLUSIONS

When compared with other geometric and mechanical variables, nonanatomic reduction of a femoral neck fracture, with either inferior offset or varus angulation, is the strongest predictor of postfixation redisplacement of the fracture.

Biomechanical comparison of internal fixation techniques for the treatment of unstable basicervical femoral neck fractures

OBJECTIVES

The optimal method of internal fixation of basicervical femoral neck fractures is controversial. This area represents a transition zone between the intracapsular femoral neck fracture, usually fixed with multiple cancellous screws, and the extracapsular interochanteric fracture, fixed with a sliding screw device [sliding hip screw (SHS)] and derotation screw (DRS) device. The authors' specific aim was to biomechanically compare these two methods of fixation in a cadaveric model of a basicervical femoral neck fracture with posteromedial comminution.

DESIGN

The authors compared the average peak force during cyclic loading and the maximum axial force sustained by matched pairs of specimens stabilized with either fixation and subjected to axial and torsional loading while flexing and extending the hip. The average peak force was defined as the mean of the peak force values measured in each loading cycle with the maximum displacement of the materials tester actuator the same for each cycle (displacement control) as opposed to the maximum force being held constant (load control).

RESULTS

The cancellous screw group maintained a significantly lower average peak force, 470 Newtons (SD = 145 Newtons), compared with 868 Newtons (SD = 186 Newtons) for the SHS and DRS composite group (p < 0.01). Similarly, the cancellous screw group demonstrated a lower ultimate load to failure, 1,863 Newtons (SD = 475 Newtons) compared with 3,557 Newtons (SD = 215 Newtons) for the SHS and DRS composite group (p < 0.01).

CONCLUSION

The results support the use of an SHS and DHS composite compared with three cancellous screws in the treatment of unstable basicervical femoral neck fractures.

Relationship of mechanical factors to the strength of proximal femur fractures fixed with cancellous screws

The decision of whether to attempt screw fixation of a femoral neck fracture is based partly on the estimated strength of the fixed bone/implant construct in relation to the loads it will be required to bear. The goal of this study was to determine in vitro the relation of the following biomechanical factors to the strength of internally fixed femoral neck fractures subjected to cyclic and failure loading: (a) square of the density of cancellous bone in the femoral head, (b) percent comminution of the inferior fracture surface, (c) moment arm of the joint force, or distance from the axis of the joint force to the fracture surface, and (d) orientation angle of the fracture surface in the medial/lateral plane relative to the axis of the femoral shaft. Femoral neck fractures were created in each of 38 fresh cadaveric proximal femora using a dropweight or with a materials testing machine. After sustaining a displaced fracture, fixation was achieved using three cannulated cancellous bone screws. The fixed femur was then subjected to 10,000 cycles of a sinusoidially varying load acting on the femoral head, parallel to the femoral shaft, with an initial peak magnitude of 2.2 times body weight, while the hip was flexed, extended, and rotated to mimic some motions of gait. Muscle loading was not simulated. The magnitude of the peak load decreased as the femoral head displaced during cycling. The mean of the peak load for each cycle over the duration of the test was defined as the average load. Following cycling, the bone/screw construct was loaded to failure in the same direction, and this measurement was termed the maximum load. Average and maximum load were then correlated to the four biomechanical factors using a multiple regression analysis. These factors correlated to a high degree with average force (R2 = 0.771; p < 0.0001) and to a lesser but still significant degree with maximum force (R2 = 0.458; p = 0.012), demonstrating that they can be used to estimate the strength of fixation under these loading conditions. The strongest correlation for average force was with fracture angle (p = 0.005) and for failure force was with moment arm length (p = 0.072).

The accuracy of measurements of femoral neck fractures. Conventional radiography versus roentgen stereophotogrammetric analysis

Postoperative displacement of the femoral head center was measured in 60 intracapsular hip fractures at repeated conventional radiographic (CR) and roentgen stereophotogrammetric (RSA) examinations. The measurements of the conventional radiographs (405 pairs) were done on a digitizing table. Totally, 105 pairs of these radiographs (AP and lateral, CR) were measured by 2 observers. Manual measurements were also made on 176 pairs of the conventional radiographs. Conventional radiographs tended to overestimate or underestimate the average displacements up to about 2 mm. Two standard deviations of the differences (RSA-CR) varied from 5.8 to 9.6 mm depending on the direction of the movements. The accuracy of the measurements on conventional radiographs did not differ between the 2 examiners. The digitizing table was found to be more accurate than the manual measurements. The accuracy of conventional radiography can most likely be improved by using a strictly standardized examination technique.

Posterior angulation in trochanteric fractures detected with roentgen stereophotogrammetry

Roentgen stereophotogrammetric analysis has been carried out in 8 patients with trochanteric fracture after fixation with a sliding screw-plate. In 6 of the 8 cases the proximal fragment angulated posteriorly after the operation. Posterior angulation may be an important mode of failure of trochanteric fractures.