Investigation of the Interaction Between Lactones and Ketones in a Cheddar Cheese Matrix Using Feller's Additive Model, σ-τ Plots, U-Models, and Aroma Addition Experiments

The objective of this study was to examine the sensory interactions between lactones and ketones in a cheddar simulation matrix through perceptual interaction analysis. The olfactory thresholds of 6 key lactones had values ranging from 8.32 to 58.88 μg/kg, whereas those of the 4 key ketones ranged from 6.61 to 660.69 μg/kg. Both Feller's additive model and σ-τ plots demonstrated complex interactions in 24 binary mixtures composed of the 6 lactones and 4 ketones, including synergy, addition, and masking effects. Specifically, we found that 6 binary mixtures exhibited aroma synergistic effects using both methods. Moreover, the σ-τ plot showed a synergistic effect of aroma in 3 ternary mixtures. The U-model further confirmed the synergistic effects of the 6 groups of binary systems and 3 groups of ternary systems on aroma at actual cheese concentrations. In an aroma addition experiment, the combination of δ-octalactone and diacetyl in binary mixtures had the most pronounced impact on enhancing milk flavor. In ternary mixtures, 2 combinations, namely δ-octalactone/δ-dodecalactone/diacetyl and γ-dodecalactone/δ-dodecalactone/acetoin, significantly enhanced the milky and sweet aroma properties of cheese, while also enhancing the overall acceptability of the cheese aroma.

Development of the gas chromatography/mass spectrometry-based aroma designer capable of modifying volatile chemical compositions in complex odors

Many volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are used to produce various commercial products with aromas mimicking natural products. The VOCs responsible for aromas have been identified from many natural products. The current major strategy is to analyze chemical compositions and aroma qualities of individual VOCs using gas chromatography/mass spectrometry (GC/MS) and GC-olfactometry. However, such analyses cannot determine whether candidate VOCs contribute to the characteristic aroma in mixtures of many VOCs. In this study, we developed a GC/MS-based VOC collection/omission system that can modify the VOC compositions of samples easily and rapidly. The system is composed of GC/MS with a switching unit that can change gas flow routes between MS and a VOC collection device. We first applied this system to prepare gas samples for omission tests, and the aroma qualities of VOC mixtures with and without some VOCs were evaluated by panelists. If aroma qualities were different between the 2 samples, the omitted VOCs were likely key odorants. By collecting VOCs in a gas bag attached to the collection device and transferring some VOCs to MS, specific VOCs could be omitted easily from the VOC mixture. The system could prepare omission samples without chemical identification, preparation of each VOC, and laborious techniques for mixing VOCs, thus overcoming the limitations of previous methods of sample preparation. Finally, the system was used to prepare artificial aromas by replacing VOC compositions between different samples for screening of key odorants. In conclusion, the system developed here can improve aroma research by identifying key odorants from natural products.

In vitro and in vivo acute toxicity of an artificial butter flavoring

Flavorings used in cookies, electronic cigarettes, popcorn, and breads contain approximately 30 chemical compounds, which makes it difficult to determine and correlate signs and symptoms of acute, subacute or chronic toxicity. The aim of this study was to characterize a butter flavoring chemically and subsequently examine the in vitro and in vivo toxicological profile using cellular techniques, invertebrates, and lab mammals. For the first time, the ethyl butanoate was found as the main compound of a butter flavoring (97.75%) and 24 h-toxicity assay employing Artemia salina larvae revealed a linear effect and LC₅₀ value of 14.7 (13.7-15.7) mg/ml (R² = 0.9448). Previous reports about higher oral doses of ethyl butanoate were not found. Observational screening with doses between 150-1000 mg/kg by gavage displayed increased amount of defecation, palpebral ptosis, and grip strength reduction, predominantly at higher doses. The flavoring also produced clinical signs of toxicity and diazepam-like behavioral changes in mice, including loss of motor coordination, muscle relaxation, increase of locomotor activity and intestinal motility, and induction of diarrhea, with deaths occurring after 48 h exposure. This substance fits into category 3 of the Globally Harmonized System. Data demonstrated that butter flavoring altered the emotional state in Swiss mice and disrupted intestinal motility, which may be a result of neurochemical changes or direct lesions in the central/peripheral nervous systems.

Identification of the key off-flavor odorants for undesirable spoiled odor in thermally sterilized fermented soymilk

Spoiled odors are a problem in thermally sterilized fermented soymilk. This study aims to clarify production conditions and key odorants of spoiled odors. The sensory evaluation showed that thermal sterilization caused a decrease in the sensory intensity of yogurt and fruity odors while significantly increasing undesirable aromas including beany, acidic, cooked-beans and spoiled odors. The spoiled odors increased with increasing acidity and heating temperatures. The strongest spoiled odor was observed in fermented soymilk at titratable acidity of 5.4 g/kg, sterilized at 90 °C. Apart from common volatiles that were inherent in soymilk and generated from lactic fermentation, 2-methyltetrahydrothiophen-3-one was found for the first time in soybean foods and was found to cause the spoiled odor. 44 volatiles found in thermally sterilized fermented soymilk were jointly formed its flavor wheel. This study provides important theoretical support for solving the problem of spoiled odor restricting the popularization of plant-based fermented soymilk.

Relationship between the dynamics of volatile aroma compounds and microbial succession during the ripening of raw ewe milk-derived Idiazabal cheese

Cheese microbiota contributes to various biochemical processes that lead to the formation of volatile compounds and the development of flavour during ripening. Nonetheless, the role of these microorganisms in volatile aroma compounds production is little understood. This work reports for the first time the dynamics and odour impact of volatile compounds, and their relationship to microbial shifts during the ripening of a raw ewe milk-derived cheese (Idiazabal). By means of SPME-GC-MS, 81 volatile compounds were identified, among which acids predominated, followed by esters, ketones and alcohols. The ripening time influenced the abundance of most volatile compounds, thus the moments of greatest abundance were determined (such as 30-60 days for acids). Through Odour Impact Ratio (OIR) values, esters and acids were reported as the predominant odour-active chemical families, while individually, ethyl hexanoate, ethyl 3-methyl butanoate, ethyl butanoate, butanoic acid or 3-methyl butanal were notable odorants, which would provide fruity, rancid, cheesy or malt odour notes. Using a bidirectional orthogonal partial least squares (O2PLS) approach with Spearman's correlations, 12 bacterial genera were reported as key bacteria for the volatile and aromatic composition of Idiazabal cheese, namely Psychrobacter, Enterococcus, Brevibacterium, Streptococcus, Leuconostoc, Chromohalobacter, Chryseobacterium, Carnobacterium, Lactococcus, Obesumbacterium, Stenotrophomonas and Flavobacterium. Non-starter lactic acid bacteria (NSLAB) were highly related to the formation of certain acids, esters and alcohols, such as 3-hexenoic acid, ethyl butanoate or 1-butanol. On the other hand, the starter LAB (SLAB) was related to particular ketones production, specifically 3-hydroxy-2-butanone; and environmental and/or non-desirable bacteria to certain ketones, hydrocarbons and sulphur compounds formation, such as 2-propanone, t-3-octene and dimethyl sulphone. Additionally, the SLAB Lactococcus and Psychrobacter, Brevibacterium and Chromohalobacter were described as having a negative effect on aroma development caused by NSLAB and vice versa. These results provide novel knowledge to help understand the aroma formation in a raw ewe milk-derived cheese.

Changes in Key Aroma Compounds and Esterase Activity of Monascus-Fermented Cheese across a 30-Day Ripening Period

Monascus-fermented cheese (MC) is a new type of mold-ripened cheese that combines a traditional Chinese fermentation fungus, Monascus purpureus M1, with Western cheese fermentation techniques. In this study, the compositions of the volatile aroma compounds in MC were analyzed during a 30-day ripening period using SPME-Arrow and GC-O-MS. The activity of esterase in MC, which is a key enzyme catalyzing esterification reaction, was determined and compared with the control group (CC). Next, sensory analysis was conducted via quantitative descriptive analysis followed by Pearson correlation analysis between esterase activity and the key flavor compounds. A total of 76 compounds were detected. Thirty-three of these compounds could be smelled at the sniffing port and were identified as the key aroma compounds. The esterase activity in MC was found to be 1.24~1.33 times that of the CC. Moreover, the key odor features of ripened MC were alcohol and fruity flavors, considerably deviating from the sour and cheesy features found for the ripened CC. Furthermore, correlation analysis showed that esterase activity was strongly correlated (|r|> 0.75, p < 0.05) with various acids such as pentanoic and nonanoic acids and several aromatic esters, namely, octanoic acid ethyl ester and decanoic acid ethyl ester, revealing the key role that esterases play in developing the typical aroma of ripened MC.

Aroma classification and characterization of Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus fermented milk

•

The aroma types of fermented milk produced by L. bulgaricus were divided into milky-type, cheesy-type, fermented-type and miscellaneous-type.

•

The flavor fingerprints of different aroma types were established by GC-IMS.

•

Acetaldehyde, 2,3-butanedione, acetic acid, butanoic acid, hexanoic acid and δ-decalactone of different aroma types were determined by Flavoromics.

The aroma of the fermented milk produced by twenty-eight Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus strains was evaluated via quantitative descriptive analysis. According to the sensory analysis results, the fermented milks were grouped into milky-type, cheesy-type, fermented-type and miscellaneous-type. The representative samples of cheese-type and fermented-type were analyzed by headspace-gas chromatography-ion mobility spectrometry (HS-GC-IMS) and flavoromics. A total of 95 volatile compounds were identified and particularly, 12 aroma-active compounds were detected by using gas chromatography-olfactometry-mass spectrometry (GC-O-MS). Among the different aroma types, 2,3-butanedione, δ-decalactone, acetaldehyde, butanoic acid, acetic acid and hexanoic acid were finally screened out as the key aroma-active compounds by quantitative and odor activity value (OAV) analysis combined with aroma recombination, omission and addition experiments. These findings were valuable in developing specific fermented milk products with different aroma profiles.

Red Beetroot Fermentation with Different Microbial Consortia to Develop Foods with Improved Aromatic Features

The European culinary culture relies on a wide range of fermented products of plant origin, produced mostly through spontaneous fermentation. Unfortunately, this kind of fermentations is difficult to standardize. Therefore, the use of commercial starter cultures is becoming common to achieve more stable, reproducible, and predictable results. Among plant-based fermentation processes, that of the red beet (Beta vulgaris L. var. conditiva) is scarcely described in the scientific literature. In this work, we compared different types of fermentation methods of beetroot and evaluated the processes' micro-biological, physico-chemical, structural, and volatilome features. A multi-variate analysis was used to match the production of specific VOCs to each starter and to define the correlations between the process variables and volatilome. Overall, the results showed a successful lactic acid fermentation. The analysis of the volatilome clearly discriminated the metabolic profiles of the different fermentations. Among them, the sample fermented with the mixture was the one with the most complex and diversified volatilome. Furthermore, samples did not appear softened after fermentation. Although this work had its weaknesses, such as the limited number of samples and variety, it may pave the way for the standardization of artisanal fermentation procedures of red beetroot in order to improve the quality and safety of the derived food products.

Characterization of key aroma compounds in low-salt fermented sour fish by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, odor activity values, aroma recombination and omission experiments

In this study, key aroma compounds of low-salt fermented sour fish were characterized using headspace solid-phase micro extraction (HS-SPME) coupled with gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS), odor activity values (OAV) and aroma recombination and omission experiments. Eighty-eight volatile compounds, including esters, aldehydes, alcohols, acids, furans and pyrazines, were identified by HS-SPME-GC-MS. Eighteen aroma-active compounds were quantified by employing calculation of OAV greater than 1. A recombination aroma model prepared using aroma-active compounds based on the odorless fish matrix sensorially matched the aroma of fermented sour fish with a score of 4.5 out of 5. The omission experiment showed that 7 out of 18 compounds had a significant contribution to the overall aroma (P < 0.05). The key aroma compounds of fermented sour fish were concluded to be ethyl acetate (OAV = 189), ethyl hexanoate (OAV = 66), isoamyl acetate (OAV = 424), ethyl butyrate (OAV = 26), hexanal (OAV = 49), 1-hexadecanal (OAV = 14) and 2-pentylfuran (OAV = 13).

Characterization of Six Lactones in Cheddar Cheese and Their Sensory Interactions Studied by Odor Activity Values and Feller's Additive Model

To evaluate the perceptual interactions among important lactone compounds in cheddar cheese, a molecular-level flavoromic approach, in combination with perceptual interaction analysis, was applied. Six aroma-active lactones with flavor dilution factors ranging from 4 to 128 were identified in three cheddar samples by gas chromatography-olfactometry-mass spectrometry. Odor thresholds of these six aroma-active lactones were determined with values from 7.16 to 30.03 μg/kg using a deodorized cheddar matrix. The odor activity value approach demonstrated complicated interactions among the 15 binary mixtures of six important lactones, including additive, synergistic, or masking effects. Based on partial differential odor intensities, each lactone with similar degrees of perceptual interactions in binary mixtures tends to present synergistic or masking effects. Owing to the difference in the chemical structure and mixture composition, δ-dodecalactone and γ-dodecalactone caused promotive and inhibitory effects on the expression of lactone fruity aroma, respectively.

Flavoromic determination of lactones in cheddar cheese by GC-MS-olfactometry, aroma extract dilution analysis, aroma recombination and omission analysis

To systematically identify and quantify the γ- and δ-lactones in Cheddar cheeses, 20 samples from three sources (Ireland, the UK and the USA) were analysed by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS), gas chromatography-olfactometry (GC-O), aroma extract dilution analysis, aroma recombination analysis, and aroma addition/omission analysis. Nine lactones were detected in these samples, and one of these lactones, γ-undecalactone, was identified in Cheddar cheese for the first time. The quantitative results showed that the concentration of lactones in these cheeses usually increased as the length of their maturity period increased. γ-Octalactone, γ-undecalactone, γ-dodecalactone, δ-octalactone, δ-decalactone and δ-dodecalactone were identified as aroma-active substances based on their odour activity values and aroma extract dilution analysis, with flavour dilution factors ranging from 2 to 128. Aroma recombination and omission experiments based on a newly developed deodorised Cheddar matrix further validated the important contributions of these lactones to the overall aroma of Cheddar cheeses. The addition of each lactone to aroma recombination models reduced the aroma intensity of sour and rancid properties to various extents and improved the acceptability of the overall flavour.

The key aroma compounds and sensory characteristics of commercial Cheddar cheeses

To study the key aroma components and flavor profile differences of Cheddar cheese with different maturity and from different countries, the flavor components of 25 imported commercial Cheddar cheese samples in the China market were determined by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. The quality and quantity of 40 flavor compounds were analyzed by gas chromatography-olfactometry among 71 aroma compounds determined by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. Combined with odor activity value calculation, principal component analysis (PCA) was conducted to analyze the relationship among 26 flavor compounds with odor activity values >1 and the maturity of Cheddar cheese. The PCA results showed significant differences between the group of mild Cheddar cheese and the groups of medium Cheddar cheese and mature Cheddar cheese, and no significant differences were observed between medium Cheddar cheese and mature Cheddar cheese. According to the results of PCA and consumers' preference test, representative Cheddar cheese samples with different ripening times were selected for the flavor profile analysis. Partial least squares regression analysis was conducted to obtain the relationship between sensory properties and flavor compounds of different Cheddar cheeses. Based on partial least squares regression analysis, 1-octen-3-one, hexanal, acetic acid, 3-methylindole, and acetoin were positively correlated with milky, sour, and yogurt of mild Cheddar cheese. Dimethyl trisulfide, phenylacetaldehyde, ethyl caproate, octanoic acid, and furaneol and other compounds were positively correlated with fruity, caramel, rancid, and nutty notes of the medium and mature Cheddar cheeses.

Evaluation of the synergistic olfactory effects of diacetyl, acetaldehyde, and acetoin in a yogurt matrix using odor threshold, aroma intensity, and electronic nose analyses

Despite intensive analyses of yogurt flavor, the synergistic effects of the key aroma compounds on sensory responses and their optimum concentration ranges remain less well-documented. This study investigated the odor thresholds, optimum concentration ranges, and perceptual actions of diacetyl, acetaldehyde, and acetoin in a yogurt matrix. Our results show that the odor thresholds of diacetyl, acetaldehyde, and acetoin in the yogurt matrix were 5.43, 15.4, and 29.0 mg/L, respectively, which were significantly higher than the corresponding values in water. The optimum diacetyl, acetaldehyde, and acetoin concentration ranges were found to be 6.65 to 9.12, 25.9 to 35.5, and 37.3 to 49.9 mg/L, respectively. In Feller's additive model, the addition of each compound led to a significant reduction in their odor threshold in the yogurt matrix, thus demonstrating the synergistic effects of the compounds. In the σ-τ plot, various concentrations of compounds were associated with various degrees of additive behavior with respect to the aroma intensity of the yogurt matrix, thus demonstrating the synergism among these compounds in increasing the overall aroma intensity. The optimal simultaneous concentration ratio of diacetyl:acetaldehyde:acetoin was determined to be 4.00:16.0:32.0 mg/L. The specific synergistic effects were also confirmed by an electronic nose analysis and aroma profile comparison. In summary, these 3 aroma compounds exhibited synergistic effects in a yogurt matrix, thus providing a theoretical basis for the enhancement of flavors in dairy products.