Letter to the Editor. The craniopharyngioma-hypothalamus relationship

Strictly third ventricle craniopharyngiomas: pathological verification, anatomo-clinical characterization and surgical results from a comprehensive overview of 245 cases

The strictly third ventricle craniopharyngioma topography (strictly 3V CP) defines the subgroup of lesions developed above an anatomically intact third ventricle floor (3VF). The true existence of this exceedingly rare topographical category is highly controversial owing to the presumed embryological CP origin from Rathke's pouch, a structure developmentally situated outside the neural tube. This study thoroughly analyzes the largest series of strictly 3V CPs ever collected. From 5346 CP reports published between 1887 and 2021, we selected 245 cases with reliable pathological, surgical, and/or neuroradiological verification of an intact 3VF beneath the tumor. This specific topography occurs predominantly in adult (92.6%), male (64.4%) patients presenting with headache (69.2%), and psychiatric disturbances (59.2%). Neuroradiological features defining strictly 3V CPs are a tumor-free chiasmatic cistern (95.9%), an entirely visible pituitary stalk (86.4%), and the hypothalamus positioned around the tumor's lower pole (92.6%). Most are squamous papillary (82%), showing low-risk severity adhesions to the hypothalamus (74.2%). The adamantinomatous variant, however, associates a higher risk of severe hypothalamic adhesion (p < .001). High-risk attachments are also associated with psychiatric symptoms (p = .013), which represented the major predictor for unfavorable prognoses (83.3% correctly predicted) among cases operated from 2006 onwards. CP recurrence is associated with infundibulo-tuberal symptoms (p = .036) and incomplete surgical removal (p = .02). The exclusive demographic, clinico-pathological and neuroradiological characteristics of strictly 3V CPs make them a separate, unique topographical category. Accurately distinguishing strictly 3V CPs preoperatively from those tumors replacing the infundibulum and/or tuber cinereum (infundibulo-tuberal or not strictly 3V CPs) is critical for proper, judicious surgical planning.

Craniopharyngioma treatment: an updated summary of important clinicopathological concepts

INTRODUCTION

Craniopharyngiomas (CPs) are benign histological tumors that may develop at different positions along the hypothalamic-pituitary axis. Their close, heterogenous relationship to the hypothalamus makes surgical removal challenging even though this remains the primary treatment strategy.

AREAS COVERED

This article presents a critical overview of the pathological and clinical concepts regarding CPs that should be considered when planning treatment. Thus, we have performed a comprehensive review of detailed CP reports published between 1839 and 2020.

EXPERT OPINION

CP surgery should pursue maximal tumor resection while minimizing the risk of injuring the hypothalamus. Therefore, surgical strategies should be individualized for each patient. Accurate assessment of presenting symptoms and preoperative MRI has proven useful to predict the type of CP-hypothalamus relationship that will be found during surgery. CPs with dense and extensive adhesions to the hypothalamus should be highly suspected when MRI shows the hypothalamus positioned around the mid-third of the tumor and an amputated upper portion of the pituitary stalk. Symptoms related to functional impairment of the infundibulo-tuberal area of the third ventricle floor, such as obesity/hyperphagia, Fröhlich's syndrome, diabetes insipidus, and/or somnolence, also indicate risky CP-hypothalamic adhesions. In these cases, limited tumor removal is strongly advocated followed by radiation therapy.