Outcomes for various dural graft materials after posterior fossa decompression with duraplasty for Chiari malformation type I: a systematic review and meta-analysis

The Use of Synthetic, Nonabsorbable Graft for Middle Fossa Repair in Patients With Spontaneous Cerebrospinal Fluid Leak: A Pilot, Prospective Study

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the efficacy of a nonabsorbable, synthetic graft for the reconstruction of spontaneous middle fossa (sMF) cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leaks.

PATIENTS

Six adult patients (age ≥16 yr) who had sMF CSF leaks surgically repaired within an 18-month period at a single university hospital using synthetic, nonbiological, nonabsorbable graft (Neuro-Patch) and a retrospective control group of five patients undergoing multilayer MF repair with autologous grafts.

INTERVENTIONS

MF repair through a combined transmastoid/MF approach using Neuro-Patch or multilayer autologous grafts.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The incidence of postoperative leak within 6 months postoperatively was the main outcome measure; we also recorded the need for lumbar drain, additional hearing loss, length of inpatient stay, body mass index, previous meningitis, preoperative increased intracranial pressure, and age.

RESULTS

In the Neuro-Patch group, there was no postoperative CSF leak without the need for lumbar drain. We observed no additional hearing loss; patients were monitored for 2 days without any readmissions. Increased intracranial pressure (four of six), previous episodes of meningitis (two of six) or obesity (five of six) did not affect patient outcomes. Demographic and prognostic factors were the same for the control group. However, one patient needed lumbar drain postoperatively because of residual leak; lumbar drain was used in one more case (two of five cases), whereas three of five patients had to stay for longer than 2 days (5 d).

CONCLUSIONS

Our pilot study suggests the use of Neuro-Patch via combined transmastoid/MF approach as an effective technique with minimum, if any morbidity; it could be of particular benefit for patients with larger MF dura defects. A larger number of patients are required to strengthen the evidence.

Dural Reconstruction Materials for the Repairing of Spinal Neoplastic Cerebrospinal Fluid Leaks

Spinal tumors often lead to more complex complications than other bone tumors. Nerve injuries, dura mater defect, and subsequent cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leakage generally appear in spinal tumor surgeries and are followed by serious adverse outcomes such as infections and even death. The use of suitable dura mater replacements to achieve multifunctionality in fluid leakage plugging, preventing adhesions, and dural reconstruction is a promising therapeutic approach. Although there have been innovative endeavors to manage dura mater defects, only a handful of materials have realized the targeted multifunctionality. Here, we review recent advances in dura repair materials and techniques and discuss the relative merits in both preclinical and clinical trials as well as future therapeutic options. With these advances, spinal tumor patients with dura mater defects may be able to benefit from novel treatments.

Surgery for spina bifida occulta: spinal lipoma and tethered spinal cord

The technical evolution of the surgery for spina bifida occulta (SBO) over the course of a half-century was reviewed with special foci placed on the spinal lipoma and tethered spinal cord. Looking back through history, SBO had been included in spina bifida (SB). Since the first surgery for spinal lipoma in the mid-nineteenth century, SBO has come to be recognized as an independent pathology in the early twentieth century. A half-century ago, the only option available for SB diagnosis was the plain X-ray, and pioneers of the time persevered in the field of surgery. The classification of spinal lipoma was first described in the early 1970s, and the concept of tethered spinal cord (TSC) was proposed in 1976. Surgical management of spinal lipoma with partial resection was the most widely practiced approach and was indicated only for symptomatic patients. After understanding TSC and tethered cord syndrome (TCS), more aggressive approaches became preferred. A PubMed search suggested that there was a dramatic increase of publications on the topic beginning around 1980. There have been immense academic achievements and technical evolutions since then. From the authors' viewpoint, landmark achievements in this field are listed as follows: (1) establishment of the concept of TSC and the understanding of TCS; (2) unraveling the process of secondary and junctional neurulation; (3) introduction of modern intraoperative neurophysiological mapping and monitoring (IONM) for surgery of spinal lipomas, especially the introduction of bulbocavernosus reflex (BCR) monitoring; (4) introduction of radical resection as a surgical technique; and (5) proposal of a new classification system of spinal lipomas based on embryonic stage. Understanding the embryonic background seems critical because different embryonic stages bring different clinical features and of course different spinal lipomas. Surgical indications and selection of surgical technique should be judged based on the background embryonic stage of the spinal lipoma. As time flows forward, technology continues to advance. Further accumulation of clinical experience and research will open the new horizon in the management of spinal lipomas and other SBO in the next half-century.

Transient meningism in children after non-autologous duraplasty for Chiari Malformation surgery: A case series

BACKGROUND

Increasing the posterior fossa volume is the mainstay of treatment for Chiari type 1 Malformation (C1M) and type 1.5 (C1.5M). Different options to restore CSF flow have been described but no consensus has been reached yet. Bony decompression of posterior cranial fossa with dural opening provides good results but at the price of complications such as pseudomeningocele and aseptic meningitis. A single center retrospective analysis was conducted to find any relationships between outcome and perioperative factors. As a second goal a specific analysis was conducted on the complications and their hypothetical causes.

METHODS

All the pediatric patients who underwent to posterior fossa bony decompression and dural opening for C1M or C1.5M in the period 2008-2020 were included in the study. A minimum period of three-months follow-up was considered among the inclusion criteria.

RESULTS

A population of fifty-three consecutive patients was collected. Pseudomeningocele and a mild meningeal irritation resulted the most frequent complications. Considering preoperative and intraoperative factors, the type of dural graft showed a relatively strong correlation (P<.01) with pseudomeningocele appearance and the development of meningism. In the latter case, a short course of steroids was the only treatment required to control symptoms.

CONCLUSIONS

Different factors could influence the outcome in Chiari Malformation surgery and eventually the development of complications. An adequate dural graft selection is of paramount importance when a dural opening for posterior fossa augmentation is planned. In case of mild meningeal irritation, a trial with short course steroids could avoid revision surgery.

Foramen Magnum Decompression for Chiari Malformation Type 1: Is There a Superior Surgical Technique?

BACKGROUND

Foramen magnum decompression is a common operation used to treat Chiari malformation. There are different surgical techniques; however, some are anecdotally more effective than others. Our aim was to determine whether there is a superior technique in relation to revision rates, presence of persistent postoperative headache and nausea, and syrinx reduction.

METHODS

This was a retrospective analysis of foramen magnum decompressions performed between 2012 and 2017 for Chiari 1 in a single institution. Three types of operations were performed: 1) bony decompression alone; 2) bony decompression with durotomy and dura left open; 3) bony decompression with opening of dura and duraplasty. We compared postoperative symptoms and revision rates between these 3 operations.

RESULTS

In 168 patients, 185 foramen magnum decompressions were performed. Among the 168 primary operations, in 66 the dura was not opened, in 86 the dura was opened without a duraplasty, and in 16 a duraplasty was performed. Of 185 operations, 17 were revision surgery. For primary procedures, the revision rates were 12 (18%) where the dura was not opened, 4 (5%) where the dura was left open, and 1 (6%) when duraplasty was performed. Severe postoperative headache and nausea occurred in 2 (3%) patients where the dura was not opened, 4 (25%) patients after primary duraplasty, and 64 (74%) patients after primary durotomy.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, rate of revision surgery was highest in patients who had bony decompression without dural opening. Rate of postoperative headache and nausea was highest in the durotomy group. Overall duraplasty had the best results.

Evaluation of Adult and Pediatric Chiari Type 1 Malformation Patients: Do Consensus Documents Fit Everyday Practice?

The management of Chiari 1 malformation (CM1) and Syringomyelia (Syr) has shown many changes in surgical indications and techniques over time. The dedicated neurosurgical and neurological community recently planned to analyze the state of the art and find conduct uniformity. This led to international consensus documents on diagnostic criteria and therapeutic strategies. We aimed to evaluate, in a large, monocentric surgical series of adult and children CM1 patients, if the daily clinical practice reflects the consensus documents. Our series comprises 190 pediatric and 220 adult Chiari patients submitted to surgery from 2000 to 2021. The main indications for the treatment were the presence of Syr and symptoms related to CM1. While there is great correspondence with the statements derived from the consensus documents about what to do for Syr and symptomatic CM1, the accordance is less evident in CM1 associated with craniosynostosis or hydrocephalus, especially when considering the early part of the series. However, we think that performing such studies could increase the homogeneity of surgical series, find a common way to evaluate long-term outcomes, and reinforce the comparability of different strategies adopted in different referral centers.

Chiari Type 1 Malformation and Syringomyelia in Children: Classification and Treatment Options

Chiari type 1 malformation (CIM) is defined as tonsillar ectopia of >5 mm, while syringomyelia (SM) is defined as a cerebrospinal fluid (CSF)-filled cavity larger than 3 mm dissecting the spinal cord. Over the last decades, our understanding of these pathologies has grown; however, many controversies still exist almost in every aspect of CIM and SM, including etiology, indication for treatment, timing of treatment, surgical technique, follow-up regime, and outcome. This chapter provides a comprehensive overview on different aspects of CIM and SM and on the still existing controversies, based on the evidence presently available. Future directions for clinical research concerning CIM and SM treatment and outcome are elaborated and discussed as well.

Foramen magnum decompression for Chiari malformation type I - UK surgical practice

Background: Symptomatic Chiari 1 malformation (CM1) is a common condition in Neurosurgery. Surgery involves hindbrain decompression and restoration of CSF flow through different surgical approaches. No Class 1 evidence exists to suggest the superiority of any of the surgical techniques.Aims: To investigate current surgical practice for symptomatic CM1 patients in the United Kingdom (UK) and determine the willingness to participate in a randomised controlled trial (RCT) comparing different surgical techniques.Methods: An electronic survey was sent to consultant members of the Society of British Neurological Surgeons and the British Chiari-Syringomyelia Group. The questions covered pre-operative and intra-operative management, presence of equipoise/uncertainty in optimal technique and willingness to participate in an RCT.Results: 98 responses were received. 67% operate on adults. 30% on adult and paediatric patients. There is variation in routine pre-operative use of: ICP monitoring (18%), flexion/extension x-rays (16%), venography (20%) and ophthalmology assessment (26%). 18% of neurosurgeons would not offer foramen magnum decompression when the presenting symptom is only refractory cough/sneeze headache. 15% routinely perform bony decompression alone in adults vs 8% in children. In 68% of adult cases, durotomy is performed routinely (46% of them leave the dura open, 54% perform a type of duroplasty) and 16% routinely resect the cerebellar tonsils. Only 17% leave the dura open in children. The most common indicators for durotomy are syringomyelia and intra-operative ultrasound findings. 61% believe there is equipoise/uncertainty in the optimal strategy for decompression and would be willing to participate in an RCT. Comments also mention the heterogeneity of CM1 and that treatment should be tailored to each patient.Conclusion: There is wide variation in pre- and intra-operative management of CM1 patients in the UK and the majority of neurosurgeons would be willing to participate in an RCT comparing bony decompression alone vs dural opening with/without duroplasty.

Syringomyelia intermittens: highlighting the complex pathophysiology of syringomyelia. Illustrative case

BACKGROUND

Chiari Type I malformation (CM1) is a disorder recognized by caudal displacement of the cerebellar tonsils through the foramen magnum and into the cervical canal. Syringomyelia is frequently found in patients with CM1, but the pathophysiology of syringomyelia remains an enigma. As a general consensus, symptomatic patients should be treated and asymptomatic patients without a syrinx should not be treated. Mildly symptomatic patients or asymptomatic patients with a syrinx, on the other hand, pose a more challenging dilemma, as the natural evolution is uncertain. For many surgeons, the presence of a syrinx is an indication to offer surgery even if the patient is asymptomatic or mildly symptomatic.

OBSERVATIONS

The authors describe an illustrative case of a 31-year-old female with an incidental finding of a CM1 malformation and cervical syrinx in 2013. Conservative management was advocated as the patient was asymptomatic. Monitoring of the syrinx over a course of 8 years showed resolution, followed by reappearance and finally a complete resolution in 2021. A review of the literature and the possible pathophysiology is discussed.

LESSONS

The unusual course of this patient highlights the importance of guiding treatment by clinical symptoms, not radiological findings. Furthermore it reflects the complexity of the pathophysiology and the uncertain natural history of syringomyelia.