Functional treatment of acromegaly by transsphenoidal microsurgery

Acromegaly: surgical results in 548 patients

PURPOSE

The goal of this study was to quantified the results of microsurgery, in all the patients with acromegaly treated by the same endocrinologist and the same surgeon between 1975 and 2015.

METHODS

A series of 548 patients with acromegaly were operated and followed-up from 6 months to 40 years. Patients were selected according to five criteria: (1) Operated by the same surgeon. (2) No previous treatment. (3) Complete endocrinological preoperative studies including GH, OGTT, IGF-I, PRL test and TC/MRI. (4) Complete postoperative endocrinological evaluation for at least one determination of GH, OGTT, PRL test and IGF-I six months after surgery. (5) All the patients were supervised by the same endocrinologist.

RESULTS

Microadenomas were present in 119 patients and 109 (91,5%) achieved remission. Non invasive macroadenomas were present in 200 patients and 164 achieved remission (82%). Results were worse for invasive macroadenomas but even with great invasions some patients achieved clinical remission. Follow-up range from 6 months to 40 years (mean 3.3 ± 2.3) A long term follow-up of 15 years was achieved in 61 patients. Four of them had a recurrence 4, 7, 8, 12 years after surgery (6.5%). There was not mortality and the rate of complications was low.

CONCLUSIONS

Surgery remains the first line of therapy for a majority of acromegalic patients. This series proves to be very valuable in circumscribed adenomas but also in invasive tumours. Levels of GH and IGF-I were decreased in almost all the patients without remission.

Normal growth hormone secretion is rare after microsurgical normalization of growth hormone levels in acromegaly

The effect of microsurgery on growth hormone (GH) secretion was studied in 34 patients with acromegaly. All patients showed enlarged sella volumes according to encephalography and macroadenomas at surgery. Preoperative GH levels were elevated in all 34 patients and 14 had concomitant hyperprolactinemia. There was a correlation between basal GH levels and sella size. Visual field defects, suprasellar extension, long duration of the disease, hyperprolactinemia and aneuploidy were noted in patients with low as well as high levels of GH preoperatively. The average reduction of GH levels in the total series was 71 +/- 21% (mean +/- SD). A notably similar reduction of GH levels was seen regardless of preoperative GH levels, concomitant hyperprolactinemia, visual field defects, size of the adenoma, invasive growth or increasing experience of the surgeon. Therefore, normal GH levels after surgery were reached mainly in patients with moderate GH increments preoperatively. GH levels were normalized by surgery in 15 patients but only four of these showed normal GH response to TRH and iota-dopa tests. Thus, only four patients (12%) fulfilled these criteria for cure of GH homeostasis.

Nasal airway resistance and olfactory acuity following transsphenoidal pituitary surgery

Rhinological problems after a transseptal transsphenoidal approach for pituitary tumors were prospectively investigated in 25 patients with special reference to nasal airway resistance and olfactory acuity. Five patients showed a significant increase in the unilateral and/or total nasal airway resistance. Endoscopic observation of the nasal cavity revealed the presence of crust formation, hypertrophy of the inferior turbinate, or synechiae. Three patients showed a significant deterioration in olfactory acuity. Coronal CT views with good visualization of the olfactory cleft were helpful in evaluating causes of hyposmia postoperatively.

Recovery of visual and endocrine function following transsphenoidal surgery of large nonfunctioning pituitary adenomas

A series of 35 patients with non-functioning pituitary adenomas undergoing transsphenoidal surgery is presented. In most cases, the presenting symptoms were related to the mass effect of the tumor. There was no operative mortality. Before surgery, visual field defects were documented in 21 patients (60%). After surgery, excluding 3 patients with preoperative blindness, 28% regained normal vision and 67% showed variable improvement. Preoperatively, 24 patients (69%) had abnormal pituitary function, 24 (69%) had hypogonadism, 7 (20%) adrenal insufficiency, 8 (23%) hypothyroidism and 2 (6%) panhypopituitarism. After pituitary surgery, all but one patient with normal preoperative function retained it. Of the patients with hypopituitarism, 11 (46%) had variable improvement and 13 (54%) had persistent deficits. After surgery, 4 patients (57%) with adrenal insufficiency recovered normal adrenal function, 7 patients (29%) with hypogonadism recovered gonadal function and 1 patient (13%) with hypothyroidism recovered thyroid function. Prior to surgery, the presence of a normal or slightly elevated PRL and a rise in TSH after TRH and in LH after GnRH stimulation were of value in predicting possible recovery of pituitary function after surgery. These observations suggest the presence of viable pituitary tissue in these cases and point out that, in some instances, the mechanism of hypopituitarism may be compression of the portal circulation, rather than destruction of the normal pituitary gland.

Results of transsphenoidal microsurgery for growth hormone-secreting pituitary adenoma in a series of 214 patients

Of 214 patients with acromegaly who underwent transsphenoidal microsurgical resection of a pituitary adenoma, 54% had growth hormone (GH) levels below 5 ng/ml and 74% had levels less than 10 ng/ml immediately after surgery. Among the 174 patients who could be contacted for long-term follow-up review (average duration 76 months), most recent GH determinations were available for 165. Of these 165 patients, 131 (79.4%) have a GH level less than 5 ng/ml and 153 (92.7%) have a level below 10 ng/ml; these represent 75.3% and 87.9%, respectively, of the total 174 patients reviewed. Fifty-two patients received postoperative radiation therapy. Nine patients underwent reoperation. There were five cases of tumor recurrence following an apparent surgical cure (4.3%), nine new instances of anterior pituitary hypofunction (5%), and five failures of multimodality therapy (2.3%). There were no perioperative deaths, five cases of cerebrospinal fluid leak requiring surgical repair (2.2%), and four cases of postoperative meningitis (1.8%). Permanent diabetes insipidus did not occur. Two of 52 patients who were irradiated postoperatively had severe complications; 23 (54.8%) of 42 patients who were available for follow-up evaluation had developed panhypopituitarism; and eight (19%) of 42 had normal pituitary function an average of 44 months postirradiation.

Investigation of the criteria for assessing the outcome of treatment in acromegaly

The outcome of treatment in acromegaly is usually assessed by measuring plasma concentrations of growth hormone (GH)--either basal spontaneous levels or during hyperglycaemia. There is no consensus on how cure should be defined. Many studies have considered basal plasma growth hormone concentrations below 20 mU/l (10 ng/ml) as proof of cure, although some recent studies have applied lower values. At present a limit of 10 mU/l (5 ng/ml) seems to be accepted as evidence of cure. We have studied 28 acromegalic patients after transsphenoidal adenomectomy. Plasma GH concentrations (basal and during hyperglycaemia) as well as plasma somatomedin C (SMC) concentrations were measured and compared to the clinical symptoms. There was a close correlation between plasma GH and SMC concentrations (except when plasma GH levels were low) and between the clinical assessment and SMC concentrations. Very low plasma GH levels (less than 1 mU/l or 0.5 ng/ml) were associated with normal SMC values and clinical cure, high GH levels (greater than 10 mU/l or 5 ng/ml) with elevated SMC levels and persisting acromegaly. Moderately elevated plasma GH concentrations (1.9-9.6 mU/l) did not allow any conclusions on the outcome of treatment as assessed from SMC determinations and clinical evaluation. It is concluded that the usual criteria for cure in acromegaly may not be sufficiently strict.

Transsphenoidal surgery following unsuccessful prior therapy. An assessment of benefits and risks in 158 patients

The authors report the results of a retrospective study conducted in an effort to define the results and risks of transsphenoidal surgery for patients whose prior therapy had failed. In a series of 1210 patients undergoing transsphenoidal surgery during a 10-year period, 158 had received prior therapy: 127 for pituitary adenoma, 20 for craniopharyngioma, and 11 for other lesions. Prior therapy was considered "direct" when it consisted of craniotomy or transsphenoidal surgery (either open or stereotaxic), and "indirect" when it consisted of radiation therapy, adrenalectomy, or bromocriptine therapy. The current transsphenoidal operation was performed for persistent hyperfunctioning endocrinopathy in 63 patients, for visual loss in 72 patients, and for cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) rhinorrhea in 21 patients. Success rates were as follows: normalization of endocrinopathy was achieved in 35% of cases; improvement or stabilization of vision in 59%; and successful repair of CSF rhinorrhea in 74%. The risks associated with repeat transsphenoidal surgery are significantly greater than the same procedure in a previously untreated patient.

Long-term results of transsphenoidal pituitary microsurgery in 60 acromegalic patients

Sixty patients with clinically and biochemically active acromegaly were treated by transsphenoidal surgery. All patients underwent a full assessment of pituitary function both preoperatively and postoperatively; these studies were repeated 6 months after surgery and every year, when possible. The mean follow-up period was 3.3 years (range 0.5-7 years). The GH level normalized in 62% of patients after surgery. A paradoxical reaction of GH to TRH was present in 35 patients before surgery and had normalized in 17 after surgery. Large tumours were associated with higher GH levels than smaller tumours. A prognostic factor in terms of normalization of both the GH level and an eventual paradoxical reaction to TRH or a glucose challenge was a low preoperative GH level. Three out of seven patients with either a positive postoperative TRH test but a normal GH level, or a slightly elevated GH level suffered a biochemical and clinical recurrence and two of them underwent reoperation. In contrast, when the TRH test had normalized (always in association with normal GH levels) no recurrence was found. The impact of surgery on the other pituitary functions was generally slight and the numbers of patients with preoperative and postoperative impairment were about equal. Postsurgical radiation therapy was administered to patients with an elevated GH level, a non-normalized TRH test irrespective of whether the GH level had normalized, or local invasion of the tumour. In 11 out of 17 patients with elevated GH levels after surgery, normalization was achieved by radiation therapy after a mean period of 2.7 years. The incidence of pituitary failure after irradiation appeared to be high; gonadal function in men and the GH reserve function were especially vulnerable. From this study we conclude that in many cases the adenoma can be removed effectively, without compromising the other pituitary functions. However, a substantial number of the patients require additional radiation therapy, leading to an inevitable loss of other pituitary functions.

A decade of pituitary microsurgery. The Herbert Olivecrona lecture

The author reviews his experience with surgical treatment of 1000 pituitary tumors, the majority of which were endocrine-active. The criteria of grading, the microsurgical technique used, and the postoperative results are presented. The mortality rate was 0.2% overall, with no deaths in the group of 774 patients with endocrine-active adenomas.

Clinical use of pre- and postsurgical evaluation of abnormal GH responses in acromegaly

The criteria by which acromegalic patients are considered "cured" after surgical therapy are still controversial. Since the abnormal growth hormone (GH) increase after the administration of some agents has been demonstrated to be characteristic of the tumoral somatotrophs, its disappearance after surgery may be taken as an index of the complete removal of the tumor. Serum GH increases after thyrotropin-releasing hormone (TRH, 200 micrograms intravenously), gonadotropin-releasing hormone (Gn-RH, 100 micrograms intravenously), and sulpiride (100 mg intramuscularly) injected during dopamine infusion (DA-Slp test), were evaluated in 68 acromegalic patients before and after transnasosphenoidal adenomectomy, and every 12 to 18 months during a follow-up period of 6 months to 11 years (average 42 months). Forty-two patients had abnormal responses to at least one test before surgery: 32 out of 68 (47%) to TRH, six out of 40 (15%) to Gn-RH, and 20 out of 28 (71%) to the DA-Slp test. Of 18 patients who underwent all three tests, 78% had abnormal responses to at least one of them. Twenty-three patients became unresponsive after surgery, and none of them had a recurrence or became abnormally responsive again during the follow-up period. Three out of six patients with postoperative serum GH levels between 5.1 and 10 ng/ml and three out of six patients with postoperative serum GH levels between 2.1 and 5 ng/ml remained abnormally responsive: one of them relapsed 1 year after the operation. The abnormal responses were lost in all 11 patients whose postoperative serum GH levels were below 2 ng/ml, and abnormal responses were maintained in all the patients in whom surgery was considered unsuccessful because postoperative serum GH levels were higher than 10 ng/ml. The TRH, Gn-RH, and DA-Slp tests should thus be considered useful tools in verifying the total removal of an adenoma. The reappearance of active acromegaly in the patient with low postoperative GH levels, who was still responsive to TRH, should be regarded as a reactivation and not a true recurrence of the disease.

Transsphenoidal microsurgical removal of growth hormone-secreting pituitary adenomas. A review of 137 cases

A series of 137 patients with growth hormone (GH)-secreting pituitary adenomas were treated by transsphenoidal surgery during a 10-year period. Group A comprised patients for whom this surgery was the first therapeutic interventions, and Group B included those who underwent the surgery after previous therapeutic intervention. The results were analyzed considering preoperative and postoperative endocrinological, neurological, ophthalmological, and neuroradiological data. Remission was defined as clinical response and a normal postoperative GH level, and partial remission at clinical response and postoperative reduction of the GH level by more than 50%. Any other result was considered failure. The mean follow-up period was 37.1 months; follow-up review was achieved in all the patients. Among the 102 patients in Group A, remission was achieved in 80 (78%) patients with transsphenoidal surgery alone, and in an additional 16 (16%) after postoperative irradiation (combined response rate, 94%). All failures and patients with partial remission had preoperative GH levels of more than 50 ng/ml and suprasellar extension of the tumor. There were no deaths; 8% of patients had minor surgical morbidity; 5% had new hypopituitarism postoperatively. Of patients subsequently irradiated, 71% developed hypopituitarism. Among the 35 patients in Group B, remission was achieved in 26 (74%), partial remission was obtained in two (6%), and seven (20%) were considered treatment failures. There were no deaths, and the morbidity rate was 14%; 66% of patients had hypopituitarism postoperatively. Of the eight patients who had received prior irradiation only, seven (88%) went into remission. All failures and partial responders had preoperative GH levels greater than 40 ng/ml; 56% had suprasellar extension. These results confirm the efficacy of the transsphenoidal approach for the treatment of GH-secreting pituitary adenomas.

Pituitary surgery for endocrine disorders

The use of pituitary surgery for patients with over-production of growth hormone, corticotrophin and prolactin is reviewed. The value of specialized neuroradiological techniques is discussed including computerized tomography, air-encephalography and cavernous sinus venography. The indications for transcranial as opposed to trans-sphenoidal surgery are considered. The place of trans-sphenoid surgery in the treatment of acromegaly is emphasized and the indications for surgical treatment are reviewed. The two syndromes due to over-production of ACTH are considered--Cushing's disease and Nelson's syndrome. The increasing use of pituitary surgery for the treatment of Cushing's syndrome due to increased ACTH production is noted, but a warning is given about the small ACTH-secreting pulmonary carcinoid tumour that may closely mimic Cushing's disease. The difficulties encountered in trying to treat patients with Nelson's syndrome are stressed. It is recommended that in the rate case where total adrenalectomy is required in Cushing's disease, pituitary irradiation should be given before or shortly after adrenalectomy. The present position relating to the surgical treatment of the small prolactin-secreting pituitary tumour is reviewed. Published data and personal experience suggests that for many of these patients, treatment with bromocriptine is preferable to trans-sphenoidal surgery. Large prolactinomas usually need transfrontal surgery and X-ray therapy, sometimes followed by bromocriptine treatment. The need for steroid cover for pituitary surgery is discussed and it is suggested that a glucocorticoid with less salt-retaining action than cortisol should be used. The importance of post-operative endocrine assessment is emphasized and a convenient method suggested. The incidence of complications after transsphenoidal surgery is low, although panhypopituitarism occurred in 14% of the cases reported.