Prophylaxis of the laminectomy membrane. An experimental study in dogs

Histopathological Study of the Effects of Dura Adhesive Agents Used in Spinal Surgery Practice on Spinal Epidural Fibrosis in Experimental Animal Model

Objective

Histopathological examination of the effects of Tisseel, Cova, Glubran and Coseal, which are used for sealing purposes in spinal surgery practice, on epidural fibrosis is aimed.

Methods

Forty Sprague Dawley rats were randomly divided into five groups in our study as Group 1 (n=8) control group (Laminectomy); Group 2 (n=8) Cova group (Laminectomy + Cova); Group 3 (n=8) Tissel group (Laminectomy + Tisseel); Group 4 (n=8) Coseal group (Laminectomy + Coseal); and Group 5 Glubrane group (Laminectomy + Glubrane). Control group was only applied laminectomy. After laminectomy to other groups, Cova was applied to the 2nd group, Tissel to the 3rd group, Coseal to the 4th group and Glubran to the 5th group in surgical fields. After the rats were monitored in separate cages for 6 weeks after the operation, the relevant spinal level was extracted and the samples were examined histopathologically and the results were evaluated statistically.

Results

It was found that there was a statistically significant difference in Tisseel and Glubran groups in terms of fibrosis grading compared to the control group, and this had a positive effect on fibrosis. Compared to the control group, there was no statistically significant difference on fibrosis in Cova and Coseal groups.

Conclusion

As dura adhesive agents used in spinal surgery practice did not increase spinal epidural fibrosis statistically significantly, we concluded that these products can be used safely during spinal surgery if necessary.

Effect of topical rifamycin application on epidural fibrosis in rats

Objectives

This study aims to investigate the effects of topical rifamycin SV application on epidural fibrosis formation in a rat model.

Materials and methods

Between March 2015 and April 2015, a total of 20 Wistar rats were equally and randomly divided into laminectomy only group (control group) and laminectomy and rifamycin SV group (treatment group). Laminectomy was performed between L3-L5 in all rats. Surgical field was irrigated with 1 mL rifamycin SV (1 mL). After four weeks, vertebral columns of the rats were removed en bloc between the L1 and L5 levels, and epidural fibrosis and arachnoid involvement were histopathologically evaluated and graded.

Results

Grade 3 epidural fibrosis formation ratio was lower in the treatment group (40%) compared to the control group (80%). However, there was no statistically significant difference between the treatment and control groups in terms of epidural fibrosis (p=0.164) and arachnoid involvement (p=0.303).

Conclusion

Intraoperative rifamycin irrigation tends to reduce epidural fibrosis formation risk, although not statistically significant.

Anti-adhesive effect of poloxamer-based thermo-sensitive sol-gel in rabbit laminectomy model

Poloxamer-based thermo-sensitive sol-gel has been developed to reduce the incidence of postoperative scar formation at the laminectomy site. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the anti-adhesive effect of poloxamer based thermo-sensitive sol-gel compared to hyaluronate based solution after laminectomy, using a rabbit model. A thermo-sensitive anti-adhesive with a property of sol-gel transition was manufactured by a physical mixture of Poloxamer188/407, Chitosan and Gelatin. The viscosity in different temperatures was assessed. 72 adult New Zealand rabbits underwent lumbar laminectomy and were randomly divided into experimental (treated with the newly developed agent), positive (treated with hyaluronate based solution), and negative control groups. Each group was subdivided into 1 and 4-week subgroups. Gross and histological evaluations were performed to assess the extent of epidural adhesion. The experimental group showed significantly higher viscosity compared to the positive control group and showed a significant increase of viscosity as the temperature increased. Gross evaluation showed no statistically significant differences between the 1- and 4-week subgroups. However, histologic evaluation showed significant differences both in 1- and 4-week subgroups. Although the 4-week histologic results of the experimental and the positive control subgroups showed no significant difference, both subgroups revealed higher value compared to the negative control subgroup with regard to the ratio of adhesion less than 50 %. The new poloxamer based thermo-sensitive agent showed superior efficacy over the hyaluronate based agent at 1 week postoperatively. At 4 weeks postoperatively, there were no statistically significant differences between the two agents, although both showed efficacy over the sham group.

Effects of Systemic and Local Interferon Beta-1a on Epidural Fibrosis

Study Design

Level 1 randomized controlled study.

Purpose

To investigate the effects of systemic and local interferon-beta-1a (IFN-β-1a) on prevention of epidural fibrosis using histopathological parameters.

Overview of Literature

Epidural fibrosis involves fibroblastic invasion of nerve roots into the epidural space. Formation of dense fibrous tissue causes lumbar and radicular pain. Many surgical techniques and several materials have been proposed in the literature, but no study has assessed the effect of IFN-β-1a on prevention of epidural fibrosis.

Methods

Forty-eight adult female Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into six groups of eight: sham group, control group, systemic 44 μg IFN-β-1a group and 22 μg IFN-β-1a group (after laminectomy and discectomy, 0.28 mL and 0.14 mL IFN-β-1a applied subcutaneously three times for a week, respectively), local 44 μg IFN-β-1a group (laminectomy and discectomy, followed by 0.28 mL IFN-β-1a on the surgical area), and local 22 μg IFN-β-1a group (laminectomy and discectomy, followed by 0.14 mL IFN-β-1a on the surgical area). All rats were sacrificed after 4 weeks and groups were evaluated histopathologically.

Results

Compared with sham and control groups, significantly less epidural fibrosis, dural adhesion, and fibroblast cell density were observed in the local and systemic 44 μg IFN-β-1a groups. No other differences were evident between the local and systemic groups.

Conclusions

IFN-β-1a is effective in preventing epidural fibrosis with systemic and local application.

Effects of cross-linked high-molecular-weight hyaluronic acid on epidural fibrosis: experimental study

OBJECT

Epidural fibrosis is nonphysiological scar formation, usually at the site of neurosurgical access into the spinal canal, in the intimate vicinity of and around the origin of the radicular sheath. The formation of dense fibrous tissue causes lumbar and radicular pain. In addition to radicular symptoms, the formation of scar tissue may cause problems during reoperation. The authors aimed to investigate the effects of cross-linked high-molecular-weight hyaluronic acid (HA), an HA derivative known as HA gel, on the prevention of epidural fibrosis by using histopathological and biochemical parameters.

METHODS

Fifty-six adult female Sprague-Dawley rats were evaluated. The rats were divided into 4 groups. Rats in the sham group (n = 14) underwent laminectomy and discectomy and received no treatment; rats in the control group (n = 14) underwent laminectomy and discectomy and received 0.9% NaCl treatment in the surgical area; rats in the HA group (n = 14) received HA treatment at the surgical area after laminectomy and discectomy; and rats in the HA gel group (n = 14) underwent laminectomy and discectomy in addition to receiving treatment with cross-linked high-molecular-weight HA in the surgical area. All rats were decapitated after 4 weeks, and the specimens were evaluated histopathologically and biochemically. The results were statistically compared using the Mann-Whitney U-test.

RESULTS

Compared with the sham and control groups, the HA and HA gel groups showed significantly lower fibroblast cell density and tissue hydroxyproline concentrations (p < 0.05). There was statistically significant lower dural adhesion and foreign-body reaction between the control and HA gel groups (p < 0.05). Granulation tissue and epidural fibrosis were significantly lower in the HA and HA gel groups compared with the sham group (p < 0.05). There were no significant differences in any histopathological parameters or biochemical values between Groups 3 and 4 (p > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Cross-linked high-molecular-weight HA had positive effects on the prevention of epidural fibrosis and the reduction of fibrotic tissue density. The efficacy of this agent should also be verified in further experimental and clinical studies.

Immunomodulatory effectiveness of licofelone in preventing epidural fibrosis in post-laminectomy rat

OBJECTIVE

The object of this study was to investigate the effects of licofelone on the prevention of epidural fibrosis (EF) formation in post-laminectomy rat models.

METHODS

A controlled double-blinded study was conducted in sixty, healthy adult Wistar rats that underwent laminectomy at the L1-L2 vertebrae levels. All the rats were divided randomly into three groups according to the treatment (via oral gavage): (1) licofelone treatment group; (2) vehicle treatment group; (3) sham group (laminectomy without treatment). All rats were euthanized humanely 4 weeks postoperatively. The macroscopic assessment of EF, hydroxyproline content in epidural scar tissue, histological analysis, and the mRNA measurements of interleukin-6 (IL-6) and transforming growth factor-β1 were performed.

RESULTS

The Rydell score, hydroxyproline content, epidural scar density, and inflammatory factors expressions all suggested better results in licofelone group than the other two groups.

CONCLUSION

The application of licofelone could reduce hydroxyproline deposits, inflammatory factors expressions and prevent epidural adhesions in post-laminectomy rats.

The effect of resveratrol on surgery-induced epidural fibrosis in laminectomy rats

Epidural fibrosis (EF) is a common complication for the patients who underwent laminectomy. Recently, EF is thought to cause recurrent postoperative pain after laminectomy. Resveratrol has been shown to exert its anti-inflammatory, antifibrotic, and antiproliferative multifaceted properties. The object of this study was to investigate the effects of resveratrol on the prevention of postlaminectomy EF formation in laminectomy rats. A controlled double-blinded study was performed on 60 healthy adult Sprague-Dawley rats that underwent lumbar laminectomy at the L1-L2 levels. They were divided randomly into 3 groups (1, 2, and 3) of 20 rats each—group 1: resveratrol treatment group; group 2: resveratrol dilution saline treatment group; group 3: sham group (rats underwent laminectomy without treatment). All rats were killed 4 weeks after operation. The Rydell score, hydroxyproline content, vimentin cells density, fibroblasts density, and inflammatory factors expressional levels all suggested better results in resveratrol group than the other two groups. Resveratrol is able to inhibit fibroblasts proliferation, and TGF-β1 and IL-6 expressions and prevent epidural fibrosis in postlaminectomy rat.

All-trans retinoic acid prevents epidural fibrosis through NF-κB signaling pathway in post-laminectomy rats

Laminectomy is a widely accepted treatment for lumbar disorders, and epidural fibrosis (EF) is a common complication. EF is thought to cause post-operative pain recurrence after laminectomy or discectomy. All-trans retinoic acid (ATRA) has shown anti-fibrotic, anti-inflammatory, and anti-proliferative functions. The object of this study was to investigate the effects of ATRA on the prevention of EF in post-laminectomy rats. In vitro, the anti-fibrotic effect of ATRA was demonstrated with cultured fibroblasts count, which comprised of those that were cultured with/without ATRA. In vivo, rats underwent laminectomy at the L1-L2 levels. We first demonstrated the beneficial effects using 0.05% ATRA compared to vehicle (control group). We found that a higher concentration of ATRA (0.1%) achieved dose-dependent results. Hydroxyproline content, Rydell score, vimentin-positive cell density, fibroblast density, inflammatory cell density and inflammatory factor expression levels all suggested better outcomes in the 0.1% ATRA rats compared to the other three groups. Presumably, these effects involved ATRA's ability to suppress transforming growth factor (TGF-β1) and interleukin (IL)-6 which was confirmed with reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). Finally we demonstrated that ATRA down-regulated nuclear factor (NF)-κB by immunohistochemistry and western blotting for p65 and inhibition of κB (IκBα), respectively. Our findings indicate that topical application of ATRA can inhibit fibroblast proliferation, decrease TGF-β1 and IL-6 expression level, and prevent epidural scar adhesion in rats. The highest concentration employed in this study (0.1%) was the most effective. ATRA suppressed EF through down-regulating NF-κB signaling, whose specific mechanism is suppression of IκB phosphorylation and proteolytic degradation.

An Experimental Novel Study: Angelica sinensis Prevents Epidural Fibrosis in Laminectomy Rats via Downregulation of Hydroxyproline, IL-6, and TGF- β 1

With laminectomy being widely accepted as the treatment for lumbar disorders, epidural fibrosis (EF) is a common complication for both the patients and the surgeons alike. Currently, EF is thought to cause recurrent postoperative pain after laminectomy or after discectomy. Angelica sinensis is a traditional Chinese medicine which has shown anti-inflammatory, antifibrotic, and antiproliferative properties. The object of this study was to investigate the effects of Angelica sinensis on the prevention of post-laminectomy EF formation in a rat model. A controlled double-blinded study was conducted in sixty healthy adult Wistar rats that underwent laminectomy at the L1-L2 levels. They were divided randomly into 3 groups according to the treatment method, with 20 in each group: (1) Angelica sinensis treatment group, (2) saline treatment group, and (3) sham group (laminectomy without treatment). All rats were euthanized humanely 4 weeks after laminectomy. The hydroxyproline content, Rydell score, vimentin cells density, fibroblasts density, inflammatory cells density, and inflammatory factors expressions all suggested better results in Angelica sinensis group than the other two groups. Topical application of Angelica sinensis could inhibit fibroblasts proliferation and TGF-β1 and IL-6 expressions and prevent epidural scar adhesion in postlaminectomy rat model.

Prevention of peridural fibrosis using a cyclooxygenase-2 inhibitor (nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug) soaked in absorbable gelatin sponge: an experimental comparative animal model

STUDY DESIGN

Experimental study.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the efficacy and safety of peridural parecoxib-soaked absorbable gelatin sponge, and cellulose membrane on peridural fibrosis prevention in an animal model.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Postoperative peridural fibrosis is one of the causes of failed back surgery syndrome. Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs inhibit the inflammatory response, while an absorbable gelatin sponge or cellulose membrane interposes between the dura and the paraspinal muscle to staunch the surgical bleeding. These mechanisms may prevent peridural fibrosis.

METHODS

Forty L5-L6 laminectomized adult Sprague-Dawley rats were randomly allocated into 4 groups. The high parecoxib group received 6 mg of parecoxib soaked into an absorbable gelatin sponge placed over the dura. The low parecoxib group was given 2 mg of parecoxib soaked into an absorbable gelatin sponge. The dura in the cellulose group was covered with a cellulose membrane, while the control group received normal saline drip before surgical wound closure. All rats were killed at 6 weeks for histopathological assessment. The fibroblast density, inflammatory cell density, fibrous adherence, and adverse events were quantified. The obtained results were analyzed statistically.

RESULTS

The respective mean fibroblast density in the high parecoxib, low parecoxib, cellulose, and control groups was 217.77 ± 51.76, 317.51 ± 126.92, 321.80 ± 90.94, and 328.48 ± 73.41 cells/mm², while the respective mean inflammatory cell density was 539.65 ± 236.52, 910.17 ± 242.59, 1011.84 ± 239.30, and 1261.78 ± 319.68 cells/mm². The mean fibroblast and inflammatory cell densities of the high parecoxib group were significantly lower than the control. The high parecoxib group also showed statistically less fibrous adherence than low parecoxib, cellulose, and control groups.

CONCLUSION

The high-dose parecoxib-soaked absorbable gelatin sponge can prevent peridural fibrosis without complications. The low-dose parecoxib and cellulose membrane provided no significant benefit vis-à-vis prevention of peridural fibrosis, as adduced from the lack of any statistically significant difference between the test and control rats.

Effects of sodium hyaluronate and methylprednisolone alone or in combination in preventing epidural fibrosis

OBJECTIVE

Epidural fibrosis and leptomeningeal adhesion formation are common causes of failed back surgery syndrome (FBSS). We employed a rat model of lumbar laminectomy to evaluate the histopathological effects of sodium hyaluronate (HA) and methylprednisolone (MP) alone or in combination on post-laminectomy epidural fibrosis.

METHODS

Thirty-two male Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into four groups. All rats underwent three-level lumbar laminectomy. In the treatment groups, HA solution, MP, or a combination of both was applied locally to the epidural spaces of the laminectomy fields. No neurological deficits or pathological wound site changes were observed in any of the groups. At the end of the sixth week, all rats were sacrificed, and the laminectomy vertebral column areas were removed en-bloc. Specimens were evaluated by an expert neuropathologist according to histopathological criteria.

RESULTS

The results of the three treatment groups were separately compared with the control group to assess epidural fibrosis. Minimal reduction in the rate of epidural fibrosis was observed in the groups treated with HA or MP compared with the control group. However, no significant difference in epidural fibrosis was noted between the combined treatment group and the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study showed that MP and HA, given separately, significantly reduce post-laminectomy epidural fibrosis; however, the combination of these drugs is not effective. Further investigation is needed to address the causative drug interactions.

Alpha-lipoic acid reduces peridural fibrosis after laminectomy of lumbar vertebrae in rabbits

BACKGROUND

Peridural fibrosis is an inevitable healing process causing failed back surgery syndrome after lumbar spinal operations. In this study, alpha-lipoic acid (ALA), reported to reduce fibrosis in liver, oral mucosa, and peritoneum, investigated as a potential candidate for prevention of peridural fibrosis.

METHOD

Twelve adult New Zealand white male rabbits were divided into control (n = 5) and ALA groups (n = 7). Laminectomy of lumbar spine was performed and ALA was applied on the exposed dura mater topically in ALA group.

RESULTS

According to histological peridural grading, the ALA group (median grade 1) showed significantly less peridural fibrosis than the control group (median grade 3, p = 0.005).

CONCLUSIONS

ALA is a promising substance in the prevention of peridural fibrosis, especially in early preoperative and postoperative period.

The effectiveness of poloxamer 407-based new anti-adhesive material in a laminectomy model in rats

PURPOSE

In the laminectomy model in rats, to verify anti-adhesive effectiveness of the new material, a mixture composed of poloxamer 407, calcium chloride, and xanthorrhizol, we compared it with that of commercially used solution form anti-adhesive agent GUARDIX-SL, Biorane.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 108 Sprague-Dawley rats (SD rats) were divided equally into three groups: negative control group (NCG), positive control group (PCG), and experimental group (EG). After exposing the dura on L4 level, we closed the wound shortly after hemostasis, after administering the anti-adhesive agent. To evaluate effectiveness, 18 SD rats from each group were killed after 1 week of rearing. Nine were examined by grading of gross adhesion and the other nine, by grading of histological adhesion. The degree of adhesion in the remainder of 18 SD rats in each group was examined with the same method after four weeks of rearing.

RESULTS

Comparing the degree of adhesion after growth for 1 week, the gross and histological adhesion of the EG was lower than that of the NCG. There was no statistical significance in the gross score (P = 0.63), but there was statistical significance in the histological score (P = 0.04). The EG showed similar or improved degrees of adhesion in comparison with the PCG. In comparison after growth for 4 weeks, although gross adhesion of the EG was not significantly lower than the NCG, histological adhesion was remarkably low in the EG (P = 0.01). The EG showed similar or improved degrees of gross and histological adhesion in comparison to that of the PCG. (P = 0.20, 0.07).

CONCLUSION

The new anti-adhesive material showed similar or improved effectiveness with the existing agents for commercial use. This result suggests that the new anti-adhesive material will be a successful candidate as a future product for clinical use.

Preparation and characterization of a new gellan gum and sulphated hyaluronic acid hydrogel designed for epidural scar prevention

Postsurgical adhesions are a common problem in clinical practice, causing nerve compression, pain and discomfort. A new hydrogel based on gellan gum and sulphated hyaluronic acid was synthesized, with the aim to create an effective barrier for epidural scar formation. Physico-chemical properties of the gel were analyzed, and preliminary biocompatibility data (i.e. cytotoxicity) have been collected in view of its potential clinical use. The characterization of the new material demonstrated that the hydrogel, due to its high-viscosity, could effectively act as a barrier with a long in situ residence time. In addition, the hydrogel can be easily extruded from a syringe and its structure exhibits excellent stabilizing properties. Furthermore, biological assays showed that this gel is suitable for further preclinical development.

Mitomycin C, 5-fluorouracil, and cyclosporin A prevent epidural fibrosis in an experimental laminectomy model

This study examined the preventive effects of the local application of mitomycin C (MMC), 5-fluorouracil (5-FU), and cyclosporine A (CsA) in minimizing spinal epidural fibrosis in a rat laminectomy model. Thirty-two 2-year-old male Wistar albino rats, each weighing 400 +/- 50 g, were divided into four equal groups: sham, MMC, 5-FU, and CsA. Each rat underwent laminectomy at the L5-L6 lumbar level. Cotton pads (4 x 4 mm2) soaked with MMC (0.5 mg/ml), 5-FU (5 ml/mg), or CsA (5 mg/ml) were placed on the exposed dura for 5 min. Thirty days after surgery, the rats were killed and the epidural fibrosis, fibroblast density, inflammatory cell density, and arachnoid fibrosis were quantified. The epidural and arachnoid fibroses were reduced significantly in the treatment groups compared to the sham group. Fibroblast cell density and inflammatory cell density were decreased significantly in the MMC and 5-FU groups, but were similar in the sham and CsA groups. The decreased rate of epidural fibrosis was promising. Further studies in humans are needed to determine the short- and long-term complications of the agents used here.

A new material for prevention of epidural fibrosis after laminectomy: oxidized regenerated cellulose (interceed), an absorbable barrier

Epidural fibrosis, which may cause persistent back and leg pain, may develop after laminectomy. Several materials have been used in attempts to minimize epidural fibrosis, with varying results. We evaluated the efficacy of an absorbable cellulose adhesion barrier in preventing epidural fibrosis. In 25 New Zealand white rabbits, laminectomies were performed at L3 and L5 vertebrae. The dura mater was covered by the adhesion barrier (Interceed, TC7, Johnson & Johnson, USA) at L3 laminectomy site (group 1), with L5 laminectomy site serving as an internal control (group 2) in each animal. There was no neurological deficit in any of the animals during the postoperative period. Animals were sacrificed at postoperative day 28. The lumbar spine was removed en bloc and placed in neutral, buffered formalin for 72 h. The specimens were then decalcified and embedded in paraffin. Permanent sections of 5 to 7 microm were stained with hematoxylin and eosin and Masson trichrome dye. Epidural fibrosis was evaluated in a double-blinded manner. The extent of epidural fibrosis was graded as 0, no reaction seen; 1, mild reaction; 2, moderate reaction; 3, extensive reaction, and 4, severe reaction. The histological findings of each group were compared. For the statistical analysis, Wilcoxon signed rank test was used. In group 1, the fibrotic tissue formation was minimal in 19 and moderate in 6 laminectomy sites. In group 2, the fibrotic tissue formation was determined as being extensive in 17 and moderate in 8 laminectomy sites. Statistical analysis showed significant decrease in epidural fibrosis in group 1 (P<0.05). This study showed that Interceed, which is commercially available in the market, especially for abdominal and gynecological surgeries, could be used to prevent epidural fibrosis.

The effect of mitomycin C in reducing epidural fibrosis after lumbar laminectomy in rats

Object

xtensive epidural fibrosis after lumbar spine surgery might be an important underlying cause of failed-back syndrome. Based on previously obtained data, the effect of mitomycin C (MMC) in a concentration of 0.1 mg/ml on spinal epidural fibrosis in a rat laminectomy model was investigated in a large series.

Methods

ighty adult Wistar rats underwent lumbar laminectomy. In 40 rats, MMC in a concentration of 0.1 mg/ml was locally applied to the laminectomy sites. No similar treatment was performed in the other 40 rats. At intervals from one to 12 weeks after laminectomy, both macroscopic and histological evaluations were performed. For radiological investigation, 10 rats underwent magnetic resonance (MR) imaging at 6 weeks postoperatively. Furthermore, the concentration of MMC in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and serum was determined 12 hours postoperatively in seven rats.

Due to ease of absorption, high levels of MMC were rapidly detectable in serum, whereas the values obtained from the CSF were markedly lower. In the majority of MMC-treated laminectomy sites, epidural scarring was significantly reduced and dural adhesions were absent, in comparison with control sites (p < 0.001), as confirmed by MR images. Accordingly, the macroscopic dissection of epidural fibrous tissue to reexpose the dura mater was performed more easily and without severe bleeding in these rats. The healing of skin and the lumbar fascia was not affected, and dural leakage was not observed. All control sites showed dense epidural fibrosis with marked dural adherence.

Conclusions

n this experimental model, it was shown that locally applied MMC in a concentration of 0.1 mg/ml effectively reduces epidural fibrosis and dural adherence without side effects in rats that underwent lumbar laminectomy.

Prevention of epidural scarring after microdiscectomy: a randomized clinical trial comparing gel and expanded polytetrafluoroethylene membrane

A randomized clinical trial compared two materials used to prevent epidural scarring after microdiscectomy. To determine whether ADCON-L Gel (ALG) or Preclude Spinal Membrane (PSM) was more effective in preventing scarring, reducing pain, and improving quality of life postoperatively. Postdiscectomy syndrome may result from epidural scarring. Various materials have been used in attempts to prevent this problem, but none have provided optimal results. Previous laboratory and clinical studies have found ALG and PSM to be effective, but none compared the two materials. Thirty-one patients undergoing primary microdiscectomy were randomly assigned to receive either ALG or PSM. Postoperatively, patients were evaluated by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), with contrast, for volume and rostral-caudal extent of scar tissue and nerve root involvement. Back and leg pain and quality of life were assessed by neurologic examinations and standardized patient surveys. Findings at any reoperations were recorded. Results in the PSM (n = 18) and ALG (n = 13) groups were compared statistically. No operative or postoperative complications occurred. Two patients in each group required reoperation. MRI at 6 months showed no, mild or mild-moderate scarring in most patients, with no significant differences between the ALG and PSM groups in scar volume and extent or nerve root involvement. Neurologic examinations and patient surveys showed substantial reductions in pain over time in both groups but no significant differences between groups. PSM was easy to see and remove at reoperation. PSM and ALG are equally effective in preventing epidural scarring associated with postdiscectomy syndrome.

The effects of free fat graft or cellulose membrane implants on laminectomy membrane formation in dogs

The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of cellulose membrane or free fat grafts (FFG) on laminectomy membrane (LM) formation. Eighteen dogs were randomly divided into three groups of six dogs. All dogs underwent a modified dorsal laminectomy on T(13)-L(1). The laminectomy defect was left uncovered in the control group but either a FFG or a cellulose membrane implant was provided in the other two groups. The dogs were evaluated through neurological examination, myelography, macroscopic roundness index of spinal cord and histological evaluations of epidural fibrosis and spinal cord. The results showed a significant difference between the control and the FFG group, with the FFG causing neurological deficits and spinal cord compression as assessed by the roundness index of the spinal cord. Both FFG and cellulose membrane were partially effective in preventing LM formation. The use of FFG was associated with a high rate of significant neurological complications and spinal cord lesions.

The influence of vertebral instability on peridural circulation and concomitant peridural fibrosis formation

An animal model of vertebral instability was used to analyze the effect of chronic lumbar instability on the peridural vasculature and fibrosis formation. Fifty mature male domestic rabbits were divided into five equal groups. The vertebral instability was performed by excision of supra and interspinous ligaments between L2-L3 and L3-L4, excision of transverse and spinous processes and making bilateral laminectomies and facetectomies in groups I, II, III and IV. In group V only para vertebral muscle dissection was performed without vertebral instability. The simulation of the long term effects of overuse model on unstable spines (chronic instability) were performed with the use of Electrical Neuromuscular Stimulator to simulate cyclic flexion-extension movement in groups I, II. The rabbits in group I and III were sacrified for the histological evaluation at postoperative fifth day. The rabbits in groups I II, IV and V were sacrified at postoperative 21st day. There was no peridural venous endothelial injury or stasis but there was an increased amount of polymorph nuclear leukocytes in both group I (unstable-overuse) and group III (unstable-no overuse) after sacrification at postoperative fifth day. Peridural fibrosis and also vascular changes with different grades were seen in group II, VI and V after sacrification at postoperative 21st day. The grade of the venous changes and the mean amount of peridural scar formation were prominently higher in group II (unstable-overuse) than in group IV (unstable-no overuse) and V (control group). There was no difference between group IV and V for peridural scar formation and vascular changes. In conclusion, the instability of the lumbar spine with overuse could be a cause of peridural venous circulatory impairment, resulting in fibrosis formation.

Effect of sagittal plane deformity of the lumbar spine on epidural fibrosis formation after laminectomy: an experimental study in the rat

STUDY DESIGN

An animal model of postlaminectomy lumbar column sagittal plane deformity was designed in rats.

OBJECTIVES

To analyze the effect of lumbar column deformity (lordosis and kyphosis) on postlaminectomy epidural fibrosis formation.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Incidence of peridural fibrosis formation after lumbar spinal surgery is considerably high. Instability and sagittal plane deformity of the lumbar spine has been implicated (not proven) as the factors for the development of epidural fibrosis. The effect of traction (kyphosis) or relaxation (lordosis) of the lumbar spine on epidural fibrosis formation is not known.

METHODS

L4 laminectomies were performed in 30 rats. Three equal groups were formed. In the control group (group I), only laminectomy was performed. In other groups after laminectomy, lumbar lordosis (group II) and kyphosis (group III) was maintained with steel implants. The scar formation was evaluated both histologically and histomorphometrically on the 12th postoperative week.

RESULTS

Kyphosis developed in group I. The mean amount of peridural scar tissue was significantly more evident in groups I and III than the lordosis group. The extent of adherence to the dura mater and the nerve roots was most apparent in group III.

CONCLUSIONS

Kyphosis and consequent traction of the lumbar spine is one of the causes for increased epidural fibrosis formation after laminectomy. On the contrary, establishment of lordosis and relaxation of the lumbar spine decreased the scar tissue formation in rats.

Seprafilm superior to Gore-Tex in the prevention of peridural fibrosis

OBJECT

This is an investigation into the effects of two barrier membranes in the prevention of peridural fibrosis in an animal model.

METHODS

Seprafilm or Gore-Tex was applied to a laminectomy defect overlying the dura mater in rats separated into treatment groups. A third group of rats underwent laminectomy only and served as controls. Two months postoperatively a histological study was performed to compare the amount of scar tissue in each group. The gross dissection demonstrated that both membranes created a controlled dissection plane, facilitated access to the epidural space, and provided a reduction in the amount of tissue adhering to the dura mater. Statistically, Seprafilm was superior to Gore-Tex in preventing peridural fibrosis (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Seprafilm can prevent peridural fibrosis better than Gore-Tex and can be used in humans in spinal surgery.

Mitomycin C in preventing spinal epidural fibrosis in a laminectomy model in rats

Object. Extensive epidural fibrosis after lumbar surgery may be the underlying cause in most cases of failed—back surgery syndrome. Various materials have been used to prevent epidural fibrosis, but only moderate success has been shown.

Mitomycin C, an alkylosing antibiotic substance isolated from Streptomyces caespitosus, potentially supresses fibroblast proliferation after surgery. In this study, the authors investigated the effect of mitomycin C by local application on spinal epidural fibrosis in a rat laminectomy model.

Methods. Five Wistar rats underwent laminectomy at cervical, thoracic, and lumbar levels. Based on data obtained from ophthalmological studies, mitomycin C was applied to the laminectomy sites in various concentrations (0.01, 0.05, and 0.1 mg/ml). One laminectomy site in each rat was left untreated and thus served as a control. Evoked potentials were measured pre- and postoperatively, and all rats underwent clinical evaluation. Mobility status and evidence of neurological deficit were recorded. Twelve weeks later, the rats were killed, and the spinal column, including surrounding muscle tissue, was removed en bloc, decalcified, and fixed in formaldehyde. Epidural fibrosis was evaluated histologically.

In all mitomycin C—treated laminectomy sites, epidural scarring was significantly reduced compared with control sites. Remarkably, dural adhesions were absent in laminectomy defects treated with mitomycin C concentrations of 0.05 and 0.1 mg/ml. Moderate to marked epidural fibrosis with adhesion to the dura mater was noted at sites receiving 0.01 mg/ml of mitomycin C. All control sites showed dense epidural fibrosis with marked dura adherence.

Conclusions. In this experimental model, mitomycin C applied locally at a concentration of 0.1 mg/ml effectively reduced epidural fibrosis, completely avoided dural adherence, and induced no side effects.

The Effect of Low-dose External Beam Radiation on Extraneural Scarring after Peripheral Nerve Surgery in Rats

OBJECTIVE

Scar tissue is an inevitable result of peripheral nerve surgery. A variety of substances have been used to prevent epineurial scarring. In this study, the effect of low-dose radiation therapy on epineurial scarring was investigated.

METHODS

Seventy-eight male Sprague-Dawley rats were studied. A total of 60 rats were subjected to one of three types of surgical procedure on the sciatic nerve, as follows: Procedure 1, external neurolysis (n = 20); Procedure 2, abrasive injury (n = 20); and Procedure 3, anastomosis (n = 20). On the left sciatic nerves, 700 cGy external beam radiation was administered 24 hours after surgery, and the right sciatic nerves served as a control group (surgery only). Eighteen animals without surgical intervention were used to establish the fibrotic effect of radiotherapy on normal nerves. A neurological examination was performed weekly. Six weeks after surgery, the extent of extraneural scarring was examined by gross microdissection by means of a numerical grading scheme and histological analysis. Cellular density and surface measurements of scar tissue were also evaluated.

RESULTS

The dissection around the nerve was easier in rats treated with low-dose radiation compared with the control group. Furthermore, grading scores in both nerve adherence and nerve separability were significantly lower in treated nerves than in the control group (P < or = 0.05). Low-dose radiotherapy decreased the scores of cellular density and surface measurement of scar tissue (P < or = 0.05). In normal nerves, radiotherapy did not produce any fibrotic effects and the density of fibroblasts/fibrocytes was also very low.

CONCLUSION

In the case of surgery or local trauma to peripheral nerve, the use of low-dose radiation therapy may be a safe method of limiting postoperative epineurial scar formation.

Prevention of postlaminectomy epidural fibrosis using bioelastic materials

STUDY DESIGN

The use of elastic protein-based polymers for the prevention of epidural fibrosis following lumbar spine laminectomy was investigated in a rabbit model.

OBJECTIVES

To determine the safety and efficacy of two bioelastic polymers in matrix and gel forms as interpositional materials in preventing postlaminectomy epidural fibrosis.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Postlaminectomy epidural fibrosis complicates revision spine surgery and is implicated in cases of "failed back syndrome." Materials employed as mechanical barriers to limit tethering of neural elements by the fibrosis tissue have met with little success. A recent family of protein-based polymers, previously reported to prevent postoperative scarring and adhesions, may hold promise in treating this condition.

METHODS

Sixteen female New Zealand White rabbits underwent laminectomy at L4 and L6. Two polymer compositions, each in membrane and gel forms, were implanted at a randomly assigned level in four rabbits each, with the remaining level serving as an internal control. The animals were killed at 8 weeks, and qualitative and quantitative histology and gross pathologic examination were performed for both the control and the experimental sites to assess the polymers' efficacy in preventing dorsal epidural fibrosis.

RESULTS

The use of the polymers caused no adverse effects. Compared to the control sites, both polymers in either gel or membrane form significantly reduced the formation of epidural fibrosis and its area of contact with the dura postlaminectomy. However, no significant difference in efficacy was detected between either the polymers or their respective forms in preventing epidural fibrosis.

CONCLUSIONS

The selected compositions of biosynthetic, bioelastic polymers were safe and effective in the limiting the direct contact and consequent tethering of the underlying neural elements by the postlaminectomy epidural fibrosis in rabbits.

Topical mitomycin C-induced inhibition of postlaminectomy peridural fibrosis in rabbits

OBJECT

The authors conducted a study to determine the effectiveness of mitomycin C in preventing postlaminectomy peridural fibrosis in rabbits.

METHODS

Laminectomies were performed at L-4 in 12 rabbits. Color-coded cotton pads soaked either with 0.02% mitomycin C or saline were applied in a blinded fashion to the operative sites, with saline-treated laminectomy sites serving as controls. The rabbits were killed 30 days after surgery. The extent of peridural fibrosis was evaluated by histological analysis. The mitomycin C-treated sites showed significantly decreased peridural fibrosis.

CONCLUSIONS

Peridural fibrosis can be a devastating condition that develops after laminectomy. Topical application of mitomycin C may be a successful method of preventing postlaminectomy peridural fibrosis.

Use of polylactide resorbable film as an adhesion barrier

OBJECT

The present investigation evaluates two thicknesses of a resorbable polylactic acid (PLA) barrier film as an adhesion barrier to posterior spinal scar formation.

METHODS

A readily contourable, thin film was placed directly over the dura. The thick film was placed above the lamina defect to act as a physical barrier inhibiting the prolapse of soft tissue into the epidural space. Through a combination of gross dissection with and without scar scores, quantitative analysis of collagen adjacent to the scar site, and histological evaluation, the resorbable adhesion barrier membranes were found to be effective treatment for reduction of posterior adhesions.

CONCLUSIONS

The gross dissection demonstrated that both thicknesses of resorbable PLA barrier films created a controlled dissection plane, facilitated access to the epidural space, and provided a reduction in the tissue adherent to the dura.

Use of polylactide resorbable film as an adhesion barrier

The present investigation evaluates two thicknesses of a resorbable polylactide barrier film as an adhesion barrier to posterior spine scar formation. A readily contourable, thin film was placed directly over the dura. The thick film was placed above the lamina defect to act as a physical barrier inhibiting the prolapse of soft tissue into the epidural space. Through a combination of gross dissection with and without scar scores, quantitative analysis of collagen adjacent to the scar site, and histologic evaluation, the resorbable adhesion barrier membranes were found to be effective treatment for reduction of posterior adhesions. The gross dissection demonstrated that both thicknesses of resorbable polymer barrier films created a controlled dissection plane, facilitated access to the epidural space, and provided a reduction in the tissue adhered to the dura.

A collagen-based sealant to prevent in vivo reformation of epidural scar adhesions in an adult rat laminectomy model

OBJECT

The authors investigated the effect of a collagen-based sealant, Gel Amidon Oxydé (GAO), in preventing the reformation of epidural scar adhesions in an adult rat model of laminectomy.

METHODS

Thirty-two adult Sprague-Dawley rats underwent a complete L5-6 laminectomy, after which the dura mater was exposed and the left adjacent L-4 and L-5 nerve roots were exposed. The surgical wound was then closed; 1 month later it was reopened. The epidural scar adhesions that developed were observed and carefully removed, leaving clean dura and nerve roots reexposed. In 16 experimental rats, GAO was placed onto the reexposed dura and around the nerve roots before it polymerized. No treatment was performed in 16 control rats. Postoperatively, all rats were healthy and without neurological deficit. The incisions healed within 1 week regardless of the treatment with the GAO. Three months after reoperation, magnetic resonance imaging revealed that important epidural adhesions were present in the control rats but not in the experimental rats. These findings were then confirmed by gross anatomical examination in which a white tissue layer was found over the dura without adhesions in the experimental animals, whereas significant epidural scar adhesions were demonstrated in the controls. Histological evaluation of the laminectomy site also showed that the peridural space in the experimental rats was larger than that in the controls.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors found that GAO may be a safe and effective antiscarring adhesion biomaterial in vivo. When placed into the laminectomy site, GAO may prove beneficial in preventing the formation and reformation of epidural scar adhesions in humans.

The fate of autogenous free-fat grafts after posterior lumbar surgery: part 1. A postoperative serial magnetic resonance imaging study

STUDY DESIGN

Time-related changes in free-grafted fat were investigated by postoperative serial magnetic resonance imaging in 22 patients with degenerative spinal disease who underwent posterior lumbar decompressive surgery.

OBJECTIVES

To analyze the size and quality of the grafted fat on magnetic resonance imaging after posterior lumbar surgery.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Epidural fat grafts have been used to prevent epidural and perineural fibroses. Evaluations of changes in grafted fat have been reported, as observed on computed tomography scans. However, there are no published reports of clinical serial magnetic resonance imaging observations of grafted fat after posterior lumbar surgery.

METHODS

Axial T1- and T2-weighted magnetic resonance imaging was performed at 3, 7, 21, and 42 days as well as 1 year after surgery. The signal intensity of the fat was classified on the T1-weighted image as Grade 1 (almost equal to subcutaneous fat tissue), Grade 2 (low-signal intensity as compared with subcutaneous fat tissue), Grade 3 (speckled intensity), or Grade 4 (signal void, suggesting the change to scar tissue. The time-related, cross-sectional area of the subarachnoidal space was measured from the T2-weighted image.

RESULTS

The size of the grafted fat was reduced to approximately 57% after 42 days, and to about 33% after more than 1 year, as compared with the condition 3 days after surgery. In time, the shape of the grafted fat was changed along the shape of the dura mater. During the early stage (within 6 weeks after surgery), the signal intensity of the grafted fat was lower than that of normal subcutaneous fat tissue (Grades 2-4: 40.9-59.1%). However, the intensity had recovered to normal status (Grade 1) by 1 year after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

The total amount of grafted fat used in posterior lumbar surgery is reduced. However, as observed on magnetic resonance imaging, it is alive and remodeled along the shape of the dura mater in relation to its shrinkage and reexpansion. This remodeling of the grafted fat is meaningful and effective in protecting the spinal nerve. This report clarifies the fate of the grafted fat from the findings of postoperative serial magnetic resonance imaging after lumbar decompressive surgery.

Use of a collagen-based sealant to prevent in vivo epidural adhesions in an adult rat laminectomy model

OBJECT

The authors investigated the effect of a collagen-based sealant, Gel Amidon Oxydé (GAO), in the prevention of epidural scar adhesions in an adult rat model of laminectomy.

METHODS

Seventy-two adult Sprague-Dawley rats underwent an L5-6 laminectomy, after which the dura mater and the left L-4 and L-5 nerve roots were exposed. In the 36 animals that received GAO, the sealant was applied over the dura and around the nerve roots, and it was used to fill the laminectomy cavity before it polymerized. In 36 control animals, the same surgical treatment was performed, but the rats did not receive GAO. During the early postoperative period, a significant decrease in the occurrence of epidural hematoma was found in the GAO-treated rats. In contrast to findings in control rats, a thin white connective tissue layer was found between the dura and surrounding muscles after GAO had degraded and been absorbed. One month posttreatment, no epidural scar adhesion was found between the tissue layer and the dura in the GAO-treated animals. Three months postoperatively, both gross inspection and histological examination further confirmed that formation of epidural adhesions was significantly inhibited in the rats treated with GAO. No special inflammatory reaction was observed, and the healing of skin and muscle lesions was not affected by either treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

The data obtained in this study suggest that the GAO collagen-based sealant may be an effective biomaterial to prevent epidural adhesions in vivo after laminectomy.

Increase in spinal canal area after inverse laminoplasty: an anatomical study

STUDY DESIGN

In vitro measurement of the area of the spinal canal in the rostral and caudal portions of lumbar vertebrae before and after application of a new technique called "inverse laminoplasty."

OBJECTIVES

To quantify the normal area of the spinal canal in the rostral and caudal portions of lumbar vertebrae and the amount of enlargement gained after inverse laminoplasty.

SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND DATA

Other types of laminoplasty have been proven to increase the area of the spinal canal. Inverse laminoplasty has been performed in 10 patients but has not been evaluated in vitro.

METHODS

The transverse and anteroposterior diameter of the spinal canal was measured in 34 vertebrae from seven cadavers using digital calipers. In each vertebra, the laminae and spinous process were removed en bloc using a high-speed drill. The removed piece was inverted and reattached with titanium mini-plates. The area of the spinal canal was again measured and compared with the prelaminoplasty measurements using paired Student's t tests.

RESULTS

The anteroposterior diameter and area of the spinal canal were significantly smaller before surgery in the rostral than in the caudal part of the vertebrae (P <10(-3)). The rostral and caudal areas of the spinal canal increased by 61% and 17%, respectively, after the laminae were inverted (P <10(-3)).

CONCLUSION

Because inverse laminoplasty is simple and increases the area of the spinal canal, it may prove to be a useful surgical technique for the treatment of lumbar spinal stenosis. Further studies are needed to determine whether the technique is biomechanically sound and whether it helps prevent perineural scarring.

Surgical treatment of degenerative lumbosacral stenosis in dogs

OBJECTIVE

To study the epidemiology, clinical findings, and long-term outcome of surgical treatment of degenerative lumbosacral stenosis (DLSS) in dogs.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective study.

SAMPLE POPULATION

131 client-owned dogs with DLSS.

METHODS

The medical records of dogs with DLSS treated by dorsal laminectomy and dorsal fenestration were reviewed. The clinical diagnosis had been verified by diskography, epidurography or myelography, or a combination thereof.

RESULTS

The German shepherd breed was over-represented (56.5%), and males were more often affected than females (2:1). Historically, reluctance or pain when jumping, rising from a prone position, or climbing stairs (92.4%) and signs of pain or stiffness during extensive physical activity (85.5%) were the most frequent concerns. The most common physical and neurologic examination findings were pain in the lumbosacral area during hyperextension (97.7%) and on direct digital palpation (84.7%). A total of 93.2% of the dogs were improved clinically within the follow-up period (mean 26 +/- 17 months). Recurrence of clinical signs resembling DLSS was reported by the owner or diagnosed by clinical examination in 17.6% of the dogs with a mean onset of signs at 18 +/- 13 months postoperatively.

CONCLUSIONS

Surgical treatment of DLSS with dorsal laminectomy and fenestration generally resulted in good to excellent clinical outcome.

Reduction of peridural fibrosis after lumbar laminotomy and discectomy in dogs by a resorbable gel (ADCON-L)

STUDY DESIGN

A canine lumbar laminotomy and discectomy model was used to evaluate the effects of a resorbable gel, ADCON-L (Gliatech Inc., Cleveland, OH), in reducing peridural scar formation and to assess the healing progress of immediately adjacent normal structures.

OBJECTIVES

To compare peridural scar formation and anulus fibrosis healing with and without the use of ADCON-L in an animal model that closely replicates the common human surgical procedure.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

ADCON-L has been shown to reduce the development of peridural scars in rat, rabbit, and canine laminectomy models in previous investigations; discectomies were not performed in these previous studies, however, and thus anular healing could not be assessed.

METHODS

Seven adult mongrel dogs underwent a three-level unilateral lumbar hemilaminotomy and anular fenestration. In each dog, the ADCON-L was applied to two randomly assigned sites around the discectomy, the nerve roots, and the hemilaminotomy. The third site underwent surgery, but was left untreated (sham surgery only). The canines were killed 8 weeks after surgery, and a gross anatomic assessment of scar formation was done using microdissection by an observer blinded to treatment. A numerical rating system was developed to assess the relative amount and tenacity of the anterior scarring (discectomy site) and posterior scarring (hemilaminotomy site). The healing of the anular defect was assessed histologically.

RESULTS

ADCON-L significantly reduced peridural fibrosis in this lumbar discectomy model compared with the sham treated sites (p < 0.05). Further, the superficial layers, the posterior longitudinal ligament, and the anulus fibrosus healed well in the ADCON-L treated sites.

CONCLUSIONS

ADCON-L reduced local peridural fibrosis after lumbar laminotomy and discectomy without impacting the healing of the surrounding tissues.

Duraplasty with biosynthetic cellulose: an experimental study

In the search for a new synthetic substitute for the dura mater, the authors conducted a research study using 32 mongrel dogs divided into three groups. Group I animals (21 dogs) underwent a right-sided parietooccipital craniotomy and substitution of two 1-cm pieces of dura mater by two different grafts: one piece of biosynthetic cellulose (50 mu thick) and one fragment of temporal fascia. The animals were observed for 30, 90, or 180 days. Group II animals (five dogs) underwent a somewhat larger craniotomy, removal of a 2-cm piece of dura mater, and lesioning of the cortex made by a thin sharp forceps, which caused bleeding that was controlled by application of a thin film of cellulose (10 mu thick). Duraplasty was performed using a 50-mu-thick cellulose membrane to complete the procedure and the animals were observed over a period of 270 days. Group III animals (six dogs) underwent smaller (1-cm diameter) bilateral parietal craniectomy, which included additional covering of the dura on the left side with 50-mu-thick cellulose and a suture of temporalis muscle. This group was observed for 40, 60, 80, or 120 days. Transient mild clinical symptoms were observed during the early postoperative period. At autopsy, macroscopic examination demonstrated good acceptance of the grafts with few and moderate extradural fibrosis, which caused adherence of the implants to the bone fragment. No adherence to the cortex was observed. Microscopic examination demonstrated absence of graft adherence to the cortical surface even when the cortex was injured. The cellulose was enveloped by two layers of connective tissue, the external layer being thicker than the internal one. Cellulose fibers increased in thickness over time until 30 days and then decreased in thickness until 270 days. This decrease in thickness between 30 to 270 days was statistically significant (p < 0.05). The physical properties of biosynthetic cellulose and the low cellular reaction to its implantation qualify this material as a dural substitute. Additional long-term studies must be undertaken to complete this report.

Complication of epidural fat graft in lumbar spine disc surgery: case report

A left-sided L5-S1 lumbar disc herniation operation was performed on a 36-year-old woman in 1987. After a 6-year period, the same patient came back to the clinic with the problem of severe sciatic pain on the same side as before. Upon diagnosis, it was seen that the left S1 radix was compressed with a piece of free autofat graft in the foramen, which was used in the first operation. As far as the writers are informed, this is the first report about a later complication of epidural autofat graft in lumbar spine disc surgery.

Epidural scar tissue formation after spinal surgery: an experimental study

Extensive epidural scar formation is a well-known complication after spine surgery. Fibrous adhesions around nerve roots are a major reason for recurrent neurological symptoms following lumbar discectomy. A large variety of materials, implanted onto the dura, have been used to prevent or reduce laminectomy membrane, with conflicting results. We therefore carried out an experimental study in dogs to compare those materials that seemed to be most suitable. In each of 30 adult beagles, three lumbar laminectomies were performed. Each level was covered with a different material--free autologous fat graft, cellulose mesh, Gelfoam or triamcinolone suspension. In a control group nothing was implanted. After 7 days or 1, 3 or 6 months the animals were killed. The lumbar vertebral columns were harvested and prepared for further histological examination. To compare the results, we designed a new classification scheme (scar index). The data were obtained without knowledge of implanted material or time since operation. We found that free autologous fat grafts are able to reduce epidural scar formation in a high proportion of cases, especially after 3 and 6 months; cellulose mesh showed the worst results. We conclude that free autologous fat grafts are superior to other materials because of simple operative handling, good compatibility and effective prevention of laminectomy membrane.

[The scar tissue protective effect of free autologous fatty tissue transplants. An animal experiment on spinal surgery]

All spinal operations can be followed by the formation of extensive epidural scar tissue. The development of fibrous adhesions around the nerve roots is known to be the main cause of recurrent symptoms after lumbar discectomy. In the past many materials have been used to prevent or to reduce postlaminectomy membrane, with very different results. They have to be implanted onto the dura at the end of the operation. Therefore, we carried out the following controlled experimental study in dogs to compare the materials that seemed to be most suitable. In 30 adult beagles three lumbar laminectomies were performed. For each level a different material was used--free autologous fat graft, cellulose mesh, gel foam, triamcinolone suspension. Animals were sacrificed after 7 days and 1, 3, and 6 months. The lumbar vertebral columns were prepared for further histological examination. We found that free autologous fat grafts reduce epidural scarring in a high percentage, especially after 3 and 6 months. Only in this group good or excellent results were found at all lumbar levels (n = 18). To compare the results with each other we used a newly developed classification scheme (I-IV). The consistency and extent of scar tissue, the kind of cellular infiltrations, and adhesions to the surrounding structures were estimated separately. Cellulose mesh yielded the worst results. We conclude that free autologous fat is superior to other materials, because of: (1) simple and uncomplicated operative handling, (2) good compatibility and (3) effective prevention of postlaminectomy membrane.

Prevention of adhesions after laminectomy: an experimental study in dogs

An experimental study was designed to compare the efficacy of Vicryl mesh and autogenous fat in minimizing postoperative epidural scar formation. Three-level noncontiguous laminectomies were performed on ten adult dogs. Exposed dura at the three levels was covered with (1) nothing (control group), (2) fat, and (3) Vicryl mesh. Animals were sacrificed 6 and 12 weeks postoperatively and the specimens were examined histologically. Compared with the use of free fat grafts after laminectomy in dogs, Vicryl mesh produced slightly more scarring, but consistently less than observed in controls. Although no surgical zone treated with Vicryl mesh exhibited evidence of neural compression, one of the ten fat-grafted zones showed gross evidence of neural compression. These findings indicate that the use of Vicryl mesh at laminectomy sites may be an alternative method of minimizing postoperative epidural scar formation.

Effect of fibrin glue on postlaminectomy scar formation

An experimental study in rats has been carried out with the aim of studying the scar formation over the spinal dura in the presence of fibrin glue. Although the main action of fibrin glue is the enhancement of wound healing by increasing the fibrous tissue, our present data suggest that this re-absorbable biomaterial diminishes the epidural scar formation, at least the first two weeks after laminectomy. This finding leads us to consider the use of fibrin glue over spinal duramater when it is likely that reoperation may become necessary in a short period of time after a laminectomy.

Silicon prevents post laminectomy epidural root adhesions. An experimental study in rats

An experimental study was designed to test the efficacy of a silicon barrier around a nerve root in order to prevent post operative epidural root scar adhesions. In 32 Sprague-Dawley rats a lumbar nerve root was microsurgically exposed bilaterally. In 16 animals a silicon tube, prepared with a longitudinal cut along half of its wall, was placed around one nerve root, while the contralateral side served as control. In another group of 12 animals, an autologous subcutaneous fat graft was placed on the exposed root. A group of 4 animals served as the control group which had not been operated upon. No post operative neurological deficit was observed in any of the animals. All animals were sacrificed 60 days after the operation and a block of tissue including the nerve roots were resected bilaterally without removal of the silicon or fat graft. Longitudinal and transverse cuts of the roots were stained with Haematoxilin and Eosin and with Masson's trichrome collagen stain. The roots in the "unoperated" control group were clean of any scar tissue. In 13 out of 16 animals, silicon prevented scar formation around the root as opposed to scar adhesions around control root on the contralateral side and as compared to unoperated roots. In the silicon group, adhesions penetrated only through the longitudinal narrow cut edge of the tube. Fat did not prevent adhesions in 11 out of 12 animals. We conclude that a silicon barrier is an effective method preventing post operative epidural root scarring in rats.

The reduction of postlaminectomy peridural fibrosis in rabbits by a carbohydrate polymer

Spinal peridural fibrosis following total laminectomy in New Zealand White rabbits was significantly decreased by the intraoperative application of GT1587, a semi-synthetic carbohydrate polymer. The application of a similar polymer, GT1043, or phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) was not as effective. Laminectomies were performed at L-2 and L-4 in 25 rabbits. Absorbable gelatin sponge soaked with GT1043, GT1587, or PBS was applied in a blinded fashion to the operative sites, with untreated (sham) laminectomy sites serving as controls. Animals were sacrificed after 2 or 4 weeks. The extent of peridural fibrosis was evaluated by gross microdissection and histological analysis. Dense scar formation and dural adhesions were evident at both time intervals in the sham- and PBS-treated laminectomy sites. The sites treated with GT1587 showed significantly decreased peridural scar formation and dural adhesions, whereas GT1043 treatment caused modest reduction of scar formation at only the 2-week examination. The healing of skin and lumbosacral fascia was not affected by treatment of the laminectomy site with GT1587. These results suggest that GT1587 may prove beneficial in preventing postlaminectomy dural adhesions and peridural fibrosis in humans.