Efficacy of irradiation for incompletely excised acoustic neurilemomas

Outcomes of Near-Total and Subtotal Resection of Sporadic Vestibular Schwannoma: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate tumor control and facial nerve outcomes after gross-total (GTR), near-total (NTR), and subtotal resection (STR) of sporadic vestibular schwannomas (VS).

DATA SOURCES

PubMed, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, Web of Science, and Scopus databases were searched in August 2021 through inception following PRISMA guidelines.

REVIEW METHODS

English language articles reporting tumor control and facial nerve outcomes of adults (≥18 years) with NTR and STR of VS were evaluated. Study characteristics, demographics data, tumor characteristics, type of surgical intervention, and outcome measures on tumor control and facial nerve function were collected. Pooled relative risk (RR) estimates for tumor recurrence and facial nerve outcomes were calculated and stratified by extent of resection.

RESULTS

From an initial search of 2504 articles, 48 studies were included in the analysis. When comparing 1108 patients who underwent NTR to 3349 patients with GTR, the pooled RR of recurrence in the NTR cohort was 2.94 (95% confidence interval [CI] 1.65-5.24, P = .0002). When comparing 1016 patients who underwent STR to 6171 patients with GTR, the pooled RR of recurrence in the STR cohort was 11.50 (95% CI 6.64-19.92, P < .0001). Estimates for risk of tumor regrowth for less-than-complete resection are presented. There was no elevated risk of adverse facial nerve outcome (defined as House-Brackmann grade III and above) in each category of extent of resection compared to GTR.

CONCLUSION

Extent of resection predicts risk of tumor recurrence/regrowth following microsurgical resection. Favorable facial nerve outcome should be weighed against the increased risk of regrowth and the potential need for further treatment.

Delayed Facial Nerve Dysfunction Following CyberKnife® Radiosurgery for Vestibular Schwannoma

OBJECTIVE

The incidence and risk factors for facial nerve dysfunction (FND) following CyberKnife® therapy for vestibular schwannoma (VS) remain poorly understood. This study investigates whether differential radiation doses to vulnerable segments of the facial nerve may be associated with FND outcomes.

METHODS

Patients were identified who underwent CyberKnife® radiosurgery for VS at a single institution. Basic demographics, tumor characteristics, and facial nerve function were collected. Total radiation doses to tumor, internal auditory canal (IAC), and labyrinthine segment of facial nerve (LSFN) were evaluated.

RESULTS

Six out of 64 patients experienced FND following CyberKnife® treatment for VS (9.38%, 6/64). Patients with FND were compared to those without FND (control). Of the 64 patients, complete radiation records were obtained for 30 patients (6 FND vs. 24 control). There were no significant differences in demographic or tumor characteristics between control and FND cohorts. More severe FND (HB ≥ 4) had significantly larger tumors (3.74 vs. 1.27 cm3, p = 0.037) with directionally decreased time to FND (3.50 vs. 33.5 months, p = 0.106) than patients with HB < 4, respectively. There were directionally, nonsignificant differences between maximum radiation doses to the LSFN (2492.4 vs. 2557.0 cGy, p = 0.121) and IAC (2877.3 vs. 2895.5 cGy, p = 0.824) between the control and FND cohorts, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

FND may represent an underrecognized sequelae of CyberKnife® radiosurgery for VS that can occur many months following treatment. Further studies are needed to elucidate the effect of differential radiation exposure to the facial nerve with FND following treatment.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III (Retrospective Cohort Study) Laryngoscope, 2024.

Dosimetric predictive factors for facial nerve paralysis after cyberknife® stereotactic radiotherapy for vestibular schwannomas: A single institution experience of 88 patients

PURPOSE

To identify dosimetric predictive factors of facial nerve paralysis for patients with vestibular schwannomas (VS) treated in a single institution with Cyberknife® (CK) hypofractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Eighty-eight patients were treated from 2010 to 2020. Different treatment schedules were used over that period, some prescribed to the 80% isodose line (4 × 5 Gy, 3 × 7 Gy, 3 × 8 Gy and 5 × 5 Gy) and one to the 70% isodose line (3 × 7.7 Gy). Local control tumor and facial nerve toxicity were recorded, as well as various dosimetric indicators.

RESULTS

Median follow-up 37 months (range, 7-96). Of the 88 stereotactic treatments, 20 patients (23%) developed objectively diagnosed radiation-induced facial nerve paralysis. The 2-year and 5-year local tumor control were respectively 95% and 88%, and the overall 2-year facial nerve preservation was 76%. Prescriptions with a maximum dose point (Dmax) of 33 Gy were at a substantially higher risk of facial paralysis than prescriptions with a Dmax less than or equal to 30 Gy (HR = 4.51, 95% CI = [1.04;19.6], p = 0.045). The 2-years cumulative incidences of facial paralysis were 32% [20%;44%] in the case of a 33 Gy Dmax, against 7% [1%;21%] otherwise. We identified four significative dosimetric predictive factors for radiation-induced facial nerve dysfunction: a GTV minimal dose over 22 Gy (EQD2 = 45.5 Gy, p = 0.019), a GTV mean dose over 29 Gy (EQD2 = 73.5 Gy, HR = 2.84, 95% CI = [1.10;7.36], p = 0.024), a PTV mean dose over 27 Gy (EQD2 = 64.8 Gy, HR = 10.52, 95% CI = [1.39;79.76], p = 0.002) and a PTV maximal dose of 32 Gy (EQD2 = 87.5 Gy,HR = 5.09, 95% CI = [1.17;22.15], p = 0.013).

CONCLUSION

We identified four dosimetric predictive factors for post-treatment facial paralysis. Increasing the doses of hypofractionated stereotactic radiotherapy for vestibular schwannomas leads to higher facial nerve toxicity and may lead to lower local control rates than other published series. Our three-hypofractionated regimens may have also played a role in these results.

Schwannomas of Brain and Spinal Cord

Schwannomas are benign tumors originating from the Schwann cells of cranial or spinal nerves. The most common cranial schwannomas originate from the eight cranial nervevestibular schwannomas (VS). VS account for 6-8% of all intracranial tumors, 25-33% of the tumors localized in the posterior cranial fossa, and 80-94% of the tumors in the cerebellopontine angle (CPA). Schwannomas of other cranial nerves/trigeminal, facial, and schwannomas of the lower cranial nerves/are much less frequent. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), intracranial and intraspinal schwannomas are classified as Grade I. Some VS are found incidentally, but most present with hearing loss (95%), tinnitus (63%), disequilibrium (61%), or headache (32%). The neurological symptoms of VSs are mainly due to compression on the surrounding structures, such as the cranial nerves and vessels, or the brainstem. The gold standard for the imaging diagnosis of VS is MRI scan. The optimal management of VSs remains controversial. There are three main management options-conservative treatment or "watch-and-wait" policy, surgical treatment, and radiotherapy in all its variations. Currently, surgery of VS is not merely a life-saving procedure. The functional outcome of surgery and the quality of life become issues of major importance. The most appropriate surgical approach for each patient should be considered according to some criteria including indications, risk-benefit ratio, and prognosis of each patient. The approaches to the CPA and VS removal are generally divided in posterior and lateral. The retrosigmoid suboccipital approach is a safe and simple approach, and it is favored for VS surgery in most neurosurgical centers. Radiosurgery is becoming more and more available nowadays and is established as one of the main treatment modalities in VS management. Radiosurgery (SRS) is performed with either Gamma knife, Cyber knife, or linear accelerator. Larger tumors are being increasingly frequently managed with combined surgery and radiosurgery. The main goal of VS management is preservation of neurological function - facial nerve function, hearing, etc. The reported recurrence rate after microsurgical tumor removal is 0.5-5%. Postoperative follow-up imaging is essential to diagnose any recurrence.

Gamma Knife Radiosurgery for Large Vestibular Schwannoma More Than 10 cm3: A Single-Center Indian Study

Introduction Gamma Knife radiosurgery (GKRS) is an effective treatment for benign vestibular schwannomas (VSs). The established cutoffs have recently been challenged, as recent literature expanded the horizon of GKRS to larger tumors. Even though microsurgery remains the primary option for large VS, GKRS can provide reasonable tumor control and is more likely to avoid cranial neuropathies associated with open surgery.

Methods We analyzed patients with VS with volume exceeding 10 cm3 who underwent GKRS at our center from January 2006 to December 2016. Clinicoradiological and radiosurgical data were collected from medical records for statistical analysis. Follow-up was performed every 6 months with a clinical assessment along with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brain and audiometric evaluation in patients with serviceable hearing.

Results The study included 34 patients (18 males and 16 females) with an average age of 45.5 years. The mean tumor volume was 10.9 cm3 (standard deviation [SD], ± 0.83), with a median tumor dose of 12 Gy (interquartile range, 11.5–12) and a mean follow-up of 34.7 months (SD, ± 23.8). Tumor response was graded as regression in 50%, stable in 44.1%, and increase or GKRS failure in 2 cases (5.8%). Treatment failure was noted in five cases (14.7%), requiring microsurgical excision and a ventriculoperitoneal shunt post-GKRS. The tumor control rate for the cohort is 85.3%, with a facial preservation rate of 96% (24/25) and hearing loss in all (5/5), while three patients developed new-onset hypoesthesia. We noted that gait ataxia and involvement of cranial nerve V or VII at initial presentation were associated with GKRS failure in univariate analysis.

Conclusion Microsurgery should remain the first-choice treatment option for large VSs. GKRS is a viable alternative with good tumor control and improved or stabilized cranial neuropathies with a low complication rate.

Stereotactic radiosurgery for recurrent vestibular schwannoma after previous resection

OBJECTIVE

The goal of this retrospective cohort study was to assess long-term outcomes in patients with vestibular schwannoma (VS) who underwent stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) after initial microsurgical resection.

METHODS

From the authors' database of 1770 patients with VS, the authors retrospectively analyzed data from 173 Gamma Knife SRS procedures for VS after 1 (128 procedures) or multiple (45 procedures) microsurgical resections. The median length of the interval between the last resection and SRS was 42 months (range 2–329 months). The median length of clinical follow-up was 74 months (range 6–285 months). Progression-free survival after SRS was determined with Kaplan-Meier analysis.

RESULTS

At the time of SRS, the hearing of 161 patients (93%) was Gardner-Robertson Class V, and 81 patients (47%) had facial neuropathy (i.e., facial function with House-Brackmann [HB] grades of III–VI), 87 (50%) had trigeminal neuropathy, and 71 (41%) reported imbalance or disequilibrium disorders. The median tumor volume was 2.7 cm3 (range 0.2–21.6 cm3), and the median dose to the tumor margin was 13 Gy (range 11–20 Gy). Radiosurgery controlled growth of 163 (94%) tumors. Progression-free survival after SRS was 97% at 3 years, 95% at 5 years, and 90% at 10 years. Four patients with delayed tumor progression underwent repeat SRS at a median of 35 months (range 23–64 months) after the first SRS. Four patients (2.3%) with tumor progression underwent repeat resection at a median of 25 months (range 19–33 months). Among the patients with any facial dysfunction (indicated by HB grades of II–VI), 19% had improvement in this condition after SRS, and 5.5% with some facial function (indicated by HB grades of I–V) developed more facial weakness. Among patients with trigeminal neuropathy, 20% had improvement in this condition, and 5.8% developed or had worsened trigeminal neuropathy after SRS.

CONCLUSIONS

Stereotactic radiosurgery offered a safe and effective long-term management strategy for VS patients whose tumors remained or recurred after initial microsurgery.

Radiotherapy for vestibular schwannoma: Review of recent literature results

BACKGROUND

The management of vestibular schwannoma is still a quite controversial issue and can include wait and see policy, surgery and radiotherapy, mainly with stereotactic technique. The purpose of this study is to review the results of recent clinical series treated by radiotherapy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Literature search was performed by Pubmed and Scopus by using the words "vestibular schwannoma, acoustic neuroma, radiotherapy, radiosurgery".

RESULTS

Management options of VS include wait and see, surgery and radiotherapy. In case of small lesions, literature data report local control rates higher than 90% after radiosurgery (SRS) similar those of surgical techniques. Recent literature reviews show favourable functional outcome by using SRS. Several literature data support the use of fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (FSRT) in case of large inoperable lesions.

CONCLUSION

Radiotherapy plays a relevant role in the treatment of VS. In small-size lesions, SRS can guarantee similar local control and potentially better function outcome compared to surgery. In case of large and irregularly shaped lesions, FSRT can be the used when surgery is not feasible.

Photon Radiosurgery: A Clinical Review

The term radiosurgery has been used to describe a variety of radiotherapy techniques which deliver high doses of radiation to small, stereotactically defined intracranial targets in such a way that the dose fall-off outside the targeted volume is very sharp. Proton, charged particle, gamma unit, and linear accelerator-based techniques appear to be equivalent from the standpoint of accuracy, dose distributions, and clinical results. However, capital and operating costs associated with the use of linear accelerators in general clinical use are much lower. Radiosurgery has an established role in the treatment of arteriovenous malformations and acoustic neurinomas. Interest in these techniques is increasing in neurosurgical and radiation oncological communities, as radiosurgery is rapidly assuming a place in the management of several other conditions, including craniopharyngiomas, meningiomas, and selected malignant lesions.

Gamma Knife surgery for large vestibular schwannomas: a single-center retrospective case-matched comparison assessing the effect of lesion size

Object

Gamma Knife surgery (GKS) is a safe and effective treatment for patients with small to moderately sized vestibular schwannomas (VSs). Reports of stereotactic radiosurgery for large VSs have demonstrated worse tumor control and preservation of neurological function. The authors endeavored to assess the effect of size of VSs treated using GKS.

Methods

This study was a retrospective comparison of 24 patients with large VSs (> 3 cm in maximum diameter) treated with GKS compared with 49 small VSs (≤ 3 cm) matched for age, sex, radiosurgical margin and maximal doses, length of follow-up, and indication.

Results

Actuarial tumor progression-free survival (PFS) for the large VS cohort was 95.2% and 81.8% at 3 and 5 years, respectively, compared with 97% and 90% for small VSs (p = 0.009). Overall clinical outcome was better in small VSs compared with large VSs (p < 0.001). Patients with small VSs presenting with House-Brackmann Grade I (good facial function) had better neurological outcomes compared with patients with large VSs (p = 0.003). Treatment failure occurred in 6 patients with large VSs; 3 each were treated with resection or repeat GKS. Treatment failure did not occur in the small VS group. Two patients in the large VS group required ventriculoperitoneal shunt placement. Univariate analysis did not identify any predictors of treatment failure among the large VS cohort.

Conclusions

Patients with large VSs treated using GKS had shorter PFS and worse clinical outcomes compared with age-, sex-, and indication-matched patients with small VSs. Nevertheless, GKS has efficacy for some patients with large VSs and represents a reasonable treatment option for selected patients.

Jugular foramen schwannomas: surgical approaches and outcome of treatment

Twelve cases of schwannomas of the jugular foramen that involved surgery in our department between 1983 and 1997 are described. Eight were women and 4 were men (mean age, 40 years), and the duration of their symptoms, the most predominant of which were hearing loss and tinnitus, ranged from 1 month to 20 years (median, 8.5 months). Depending on their radiological and surgical features, tumors were classified as type A, a tumor primarily at the cerebellopontine angle with minimal enlargement of the jugular foramen (n = 5); type B, a tumor primarily at the jugular foramen with or without intracranial extension (n = 4); type C, a primarily extracranial tumor with extension into the jugular foramen (n = 0); or type D, a dumbbell tumor with both intracranial and extracranial components (n = 3). A retrosigmoid suboccipital craniectomy (RSSOC) was performed for type A tumors; for types B and D, the RSSOC or staged infratemporal fossa approach (ITFA)/RSSOC was used. Total removal was achieved in 6 cases, near total removal in 3, and subtotal removal in 3. The most common complication was lower cranial nerve dysfunction (n = 5). The follow-up period ranged from 6 to 173 (mean, 48) months, and there was no recurrence. Two patients showed regrowth of the tumor after subtotal resection, however. In 1 of these, the residual tumor had progressed within 12 months of initial surgery, it was again resected and linac radiosurgery was successful. In the other, the residual mass had progressed within 8 months of initial surgery, and the pathological report indicated malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumor. Conclusively, type A tumors could be totally resected with the retrosigmoid approach alone. For type B and D tumors, however, combined ITFA and retrosigmoid approach showed the better results. In spite of our limited data, cases showing adhesion to critical structures can be managed by subtotal or near total resection followed by radiosurgery to reduce postoperative complications.

Guiding patients through the choices for treating vestibular schwannomas: balancing options and ensuring informed consent. 2007

Counseling patients who are diagnosed with vestibular schwannomas, formerly known as acoustic neuromas, can be challenging. The health care provider has the responsibility to explain, in understandable language, to the patient or legal representative the proposed treatment options, risks and complications associated with each form of treatment, and alternatives to treatment, including no therapy. Patients should be encouraged to gather information before making a treatment decision. For the physicians managing these patients, information should be delivered in a balanced way to ensure patient understanding of their options leading to adequate informed consent.

THE APPLICATION OF STEREOTACTIC RADIOSURGERY TO DISORDERS OF THE BRAIN

STEREOTACTIC RADIOSURGERY IS the first widely used “biological surgery.” The opportunity for surgeons working with radiation oncologists and medical physicists to affect cell structures with both direct and indirect vascular effects has transformed neurosurgery. As a minimal access surgical approach, it fits well into the patient goals of functional preservation, risk reduction, and cost-effectiveness. Longer-term results have been published for many indications. For many disorders, it may be better to “leave the tumor in rather than take it out.” Radiosurgery has had an impact on the management of patients with vascular malformations, all forms of cerebral neoplasia, and selected functional disorders such as trigeminal neuralgia and tremor. It can be performed alone when lesion volume is not excessive or as part of a multimodality strategy with resection or endovascular surgery. Epilepsy, behavioral disorders, and other novel indications are the topics of current investigation. The combination of high-resolution imaging, high-speed computer workstations, robotics, patient fixation techniques, and radiobiological research has put radiosurgery into the practice of almost all neurosurgeons.

Fractionated Conformal Radiotherapy in Vestibular Schwannoma: Early Results from a Single Centre

AIMS

To assess the local control and cranial nerve toxicity in vestibular schwannoma patients treated with fractionated conformal radiotherapy delivered using a linear accelerator.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ninety-five patients were referred for consultation to the Oncology Department in Addenbrookes Hospital between 1996 and 2005. The 42 cases who received fractionated conformal radiotherapy are the subject of this analysis. All patients had radiological or symptomatic progression. Conformal radiotherapy was prescribed at 50Gy in 30 fractions over 6 weeks, delivered using a linear accelerator. Patients were immobilised using either a beam direction shell or a Gill Thomas Cosman relocatable stereotactic head frame.

RESULTS

The median age was 63 years (range 28-81) with 57% men. The average tumour size was 21.5mm on magnetic resonance imaging. Before treatment, 20 (48%) patients were deemed to have useful hearing on the affected side. The median follow-up was 18.6 months (range 0.3-6.5 years) and the actuarial local control rate at 2.5 years was 96.9% (one patient progressed after treatment). In previously hearing patients, the actuarial rate of useful hearing preservation was 100%, and the rate of mild hearing loss was 20% at 1 year and 26.7% at 2.5 years of follow-up. There were five neurofibromatosis type 2 patients treated, two of whom had useful hearing before radiotherapy. In one patient this was affected, with a 20dB loss, although he still has useful hearing. In those with normal facial nerve function before radiotherapy (n=40), this was preserved in 96.8% at 2.5 years. Trigeminal nerve function was preserved in all patients (n=38) who had normal nerve function before radiotherapy.

CONCLUSION

Although follow-up was relatively short in this single institution series, fractionated linear accelerator radiotherapy gave excellent local control, useful hearing preservation and retained cranial nerve function in vestibular schwannoma.

Guiding patients through the choices for treating vestibular schwannomas: balancing options and ensuring informed consent

Counseling patients who are diagnosed with vestibular schwannomas, formerly known as acoustic neuromas, can be challenging. The health care provider has the responsibility to explain, in understandable language, to the patient or legal representative the proposed treatment options, risks and complications associated with each form of treatment, and alternatives to treatment, including no therapy. Patients should be encouraged to gather information before making a treatment decision. For the physicians managing these patients, information should be delivered in a balanced way to ensure patient understanding of their options leading to adequate informed consent.

Twenty years' experience in the treatment of acoustic neuromas with fractionated radiotherapy: a review of 45 cases

PURPOSE

To evaluate very long-term results of fractionated radiotherapy (FRT) of acoustic neuromas (AN).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From January 1986 to January 2004, FRT was performed in 45 consecutive patients (46 AN). Indications were as follows: poor general condition contraindicating surgery, hearing preservation in bilateral neuromas, partial resection, nonsurgical recurrence. A 3-field to 5-field technique with static beams was used. A mean total dose of 51 Gy was given (1.80 Gy/fraction). The median tumor diameter was 31 mm (range, 11-55 mm). The median follow-up from FRT was 80 months (range, 4-227 months).

RESULTS

The particularity of our series consists of a very long-term follow-up of FRT given to selected patients. Nineteen patients died, two with progressive disease, and 17 from non-AN causes. A serviceable level of hearing was preserved in 7/9 hearing patients. No patient had facial or trigeminal neuropathy. Tumor shrinkage was observed in 27 (59%) and stable disease in 16 (35%). Tumor progression occurred in three patients, 12 to 15 months after FRT. Two additional tumors recurred after shrinkage 20 and 216 months after treatment and were operated on. Actuarial local tumor control rates at 5 and 15 years were 86%. For the patient who had a tumor recurrence at 216 months, histologic examination documented transformation to a low-grade malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumor.

CONCLUSION

Very long-term efficacy of FRT is well documented in this series. However, our results suggest that malignant transformation can occur many years after FRT so we advocate caution when using this treatment for young patients.

Basic Principles of Radiobiology Applied to Radiotherapy of Benign Intracranial Tumors

The use of ionizing radiation in the treatment of benign intracranial tumors may involve one of several types of ionizing radiation given as single-fraction radiosurgery or fractionated radiotherapy. An understanding of the biophysical and radiobiologic principles involved in these treatments is essential to the design and delivery of safe and efficacious treatment. This article discusses the basic radiobiologic principles applicable to radiotherapy of benign brain tumors.

Long-term outcome of stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) in patients with acoustic neuromas

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effectiveness and long-term outcome of stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) for acoustic neuromas (AN).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between 1990 and 2001, we treated 26 patients with 27 AN with SRS. Two patients suffered from neurofibromatosis type 2. Before SRS, a subtotal or total resection had been performed in 3 and in 5 patients, respectively. For SRS, a median single dose of 13 Gy/80% isodose was applied.

RESULTS

The overall actuarial 5-year and 10-year tumor control probability in all patients was 91%. Two patients developed tumor progression after SRS at 36 and 48 months. Nineteen patients (73%) were at risk of treatment-related facial nerve toxicity; of these, 1 patient developed a complete facial nerve palsy after SRS (5%). A total of 93% of the lesions treated were at risk of radiation-induced trigeminal neuralgia. Two patients (8%) developed mild dysesthesia of the trigeminal nerve after SRS. The hearing preservation rate in patients with useful hearing before SRS was 55% at 9 years.

CONCLUSION

Stereotactic radiosurgery results in good local control rates of AN and the risk of cranial nerve toxicities is acceptable. As toxicity is lower with fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy, SRS should be reserved for smaller lesions.

Stereotactic Radiotherapy for Vestibular Schwannomas: Favorable Outcome with Minimal Toxicity

OBJECTIVE:

To determine the outcome and toxicity in patients with vestibular schwannomas treated with conventionally fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) and to identify prognostic factors that are predictive of outcome.

METHODS:

Between 1992 and 2001, 70 patients with vestibular schwannomas were treated with linear accelerator-based SRT in our institutions. Eleven patients had neurofibromatosis Type II (NF2). The median age was 53 years (range, 17–82 yrs). The median tumor volume was 2.4 cm3 (range, 0.05–21.1 cm3). The indications for SRT were distributed as follows: 47% newly diagnosed, 31% progressive tumors after watchful waiting, 3% adjuvant postoperative radiation, and 19% recurrent tumors after surgical resection. The median dose was 54 Gy in 1.8 Gy per fraction, prescribed to 95% of the isodose line. Relocatable stereotactic frames were used for daily treatments. The median follow-up was 45.3 months.

RESULTS:

Tumor recurrence was defined as progressive enlargement of tumor on follow-up magnetic resonance imaging studies. One patient had a tumor recurrence at 38 months after SRT. The actuarial tumor control rates were 100 and 98% at 3 and 5 years, respectively. Three patients with a median tumor volume of 16.2 cm3 required surgical resection for persistent or increasing symptoms at a median of 37 months. The actuarial freedom from resection rates were 98 and 92% at 3 and 5 years, respectively. In multivariate analysis, tumor volume at time of treatment was predictive for neurosurgical intervention (surgical resection or shunt placement) after SRT (P = 0.001). The 3- and 5-year actuarial rates of freedom from any neurosurgical intervention were 100 and 97% for patients with tumor volume less than 8 cm3 and 74 and 47% respectively for patients with tumor of at least 8 cm3 (P &lt; 0.0001). The 3-year actuarial rates of facial and trigeminal nerve preservation were 99 and 96%, respectively. Surgery before SRT was predictive of posttreatment trigeminal neuropathy. The 3-year actuarial rates of freedom from trigeminal neuropathy were 86 and 98% for patients with and without previous resection, respectively (P = 0.04). There was no difference in tumor control and cranial nerve function preservation rates seen in NF2 patients compared with non-NF2 patients. No second primary cancer or malignant transformation was observed.

CONCLUSION:

SRT in the conventionally fractionated approach results in a very favorable outcome with minimal toxicity, with results comparable to those of the best of the radiosurgery series. Patients with large tumors are more likely to undergo neurosurgical interventions after SRT. Patients who have undergone previous surgery are at increased risk of developing trigeminal neuropathy.

Management of acoustic schwannoma

PURPOSE

To discuss the optimal management for patients with acoustic schwannoma.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Review of the pertinent literature.

RESULTS

Microsurgery, stereotactic radiosurgery, and fractionated radiotherapy result in cure rates that approximate 90% at 5 years. Depending on tumor extent and surgical approach, the morbidity of microsurgery may exceed that of stereotactic radiosurgery and fractionated radiotherapy. Patients with useful hearing before treatment may have a higher likelihood of hearing preservation after radiotherapy compared with radiosurgery.

CONCLUSION

Both microsurgery and radiosurgery are good options for patients with tumors less than 3 cm. Depending on tumor extent and the surgical approach, the morbidity of microsurgery may exceed that of radiosurgery. Patients with useful hearing may have a higher likelihood of hearing preservation after radiotherapy. Microsurgery is preferred for patients in whom the disease progresses after initial irradiation and in patients with tumors larger than 3 cm.

Management of vestibular schwannoma by fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy and associated cerebrospinal fluid malabsorption

OBJECT

The goal of this study was to investigate outcomes in patients with vestibular schwannoma (VS) who were treated with fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT).

METHODS

One hundred one patients with VS were treated with fractionated SRT at a radiation level of 40 to 50 Gy administered in 20 to 25 fractions over a 5- to 6-week period. The median tumor size in these patients was 19 mm (range 3-40 mm), and 27 tumors were larger than 25 mm. Patients were consistently followed up using magnetic resonance imaging every 6 months for 5 years in principle. The median follow-up period was 45 months. The actuarial 5-year rate of tumor control (no growth > 2 mm and no requirement for salvage surgery) was 91.4% (95% confidence interval 85.2-97.6%). Three patients with progressive tumors underwent salvage tumor resection. The actuarial 5-year rate of useful hearing preservation (Gardner-Robertson Class I or II) was 71%. The observed complications of fractionated SRT included transient facial nerve palsy (4% of patients), trigeminal neuropathy (14% of patients), and balance disturbance (17% of patients). No new permanent facial weakness occurred after fractionated SRT. Eleven patients (11%) who had progressive communicating hydrocephalus (cerebrospinal fluid malabsorption) and no evidence of tumor growth after fractionated SRT required a shunt. The symptoms of this type of hydrocephalus were similar to those of normal-pressure hydrocephalus and occurred 4 to 20 months (median 12 months) after fractionated SRT. The mean size (+/- standard deviation) of tumors causing symptomatic hydrocephalus (25.5 +/- 7.8 mm) was significantly larger than that of other tumors (18.2 +/- 8.7 mm) (p = 0.011). Only four of the 72 patients with tumors smaller than 25 mm in maximum diameter received a shunt.

CONCLUSIONS

Fractionated SRT resulted in an excellent tumor control rate, even for relatively large tumors, and produced a high rate of hearing preservation that was comparable to the best results of single-fraction radiosurgery. The progression of communicating hydrocephalus should be monitored closely, particularly in patients harboring a large VS.

Proton beam radiosurgery for vestibular schwannoma: tumor control and cranial nerve toxicity

OBJECTIVE

We sought to determine the tumor control rate and cranial nerve function outcomes in patients with vestibular schwannomas who were treated with proton beam stereotactic radiosurgery.

METHODS

Between November 1992 and August 2000, 88 patients with vestibular schwannomas were treated at the Harvard Cyclotron Laboratory with proton beam stereotactic radiosurgery in which two to four convergent fixed beams of 160-MeV protons were applied. The median transverse diameter was 16 mm (range, 2.5-35 mm), and the median tumor volume was 1.4 cm(3) (range, 0.1-15.9 cm(3)). Surgical resection had been performed previously in 15 patients (17%). Facial nerve function (House-Brackmann Grade 1) and trigeminal nerve function were normal in 79 patients (89.8%). Eight patients (9%) had good or excellent hearing (Gardner-Robertson [GR] Grade 1), and 13 patients (15%) had serviceable hearing (GR Grade 2). A median dose of 12 cobalt Gray equivalents (range, 10-18 cobalt Gray equivalents) was prescribed to the 70 to 108% isodose lines (median, 70%). The median follow-up period was 38.7 months (range, 12-102.6 mo).

RESULTS

The actuarial 2- and 5-year tumor control rates were 95.3% (95% confidence interval [CI], 90.9-99.9%) and 93.6% (95% CI, 88.3-99.3%). Salvage radiosurgery was performed in one patient 32.5 months after treatment, and a craniotomy was required 19.1 months after treatment in another patient with hemorrhage in the vicinity of a stable tumor. Three patients (3.4%) underwent shunting for hydrocephalus, and a subsequent partial resection was performed in one of these patients. The actuarial 5-year cumulative radiological reduction rate was 94.7% (95% CI, 81.2-98.3%). Of the 21 patients (24%) with functional hearing (GR Grade 1 or 2), 7 (33.3%) retained serviceable hearing ability (GR Grade 2). Actuarial 5-year normal facial and trigeminal nerve function preservation rates were 91.1% (95% CI, 85-97.6%) and 89.4% (95% CI, 82-96.7%). Univariate analysis revealed that prescribed dose (P = 0.005), maximum dose (P = 0.006), and the inhomogeneity coefficient (P = 0.03) were associated with a significant risk of long-term facial neuropathy. No other cranial nerve deficits or cancer relapses were observed.

CONCLUSION

Proton beam stereotactic radiosurgery has been shown to be an effective means of tumor control. A high radiological response rate was observed. Excellent facial and trigeminal nerve function preservation rates were achieved. A reduced prescribed dose is associated with a significant decrease in facial neuropathy.

[Cerebellopontine angle surgery. Part 2: Specific remarks]

OBJECTIVES

Cerebellopontine angle tumors are uncommon lesions that can potentially be cured by microsurgical removal. The primary objective of the surgical treatment differs between vestibular schwannoma and meningioma. This feature may be influenced by the site of tumor origin and displacement of neurovascular structures as well as by their different tumor biology.

METHODS

A review of the current literature was conducted.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Relevant cranial nerves and vascular involvement as well as anatomical location with respect to the cerebellopontine angle are discussed for vestibular schwannoma and meningioma. The main factors influencing the surgical outcome are outlined with special reference to facial and cochlear nerve function and cerebrospinal fluid leakage. The retrosigmoid approach offers a comparable success rate for hearing conservation and probably a superior outcome in terms of facial nerve function when compared with the middle fossa approach. The intrameatal limitations of the retrosigmoid approach can be excluded by the intraoperative assistance of an endoscope. The advantages of endoscope-assisted surgery may include improved visualization of relevant structures, more complete tumor removal, and a lowered risk of cerebrospinal fluid leakage.

Recovery of audition after favorable resection of vagal schwannoma

Two patients with vagal schwannoma manifesting as deafness with no lower cranial nerve paresis were treated surgically. A 42-year-old male underwent partial resection of the tumor, which was tightly adhered to the cranial nerves, to prevent lower cranial nerve paresis. A 29-year-old female underwent total removal of the tumor without complications. The patients recovered useful audition with no postoperative deficit.

Proton beam stereotactic radiosurgery of vestibular schwannomas

PURPOSE

The proton beam's Bragg peak permits highly conformal radiation of skull base tumors. This study, prompted by reports of transient (30% each) and permanent (10% each) facial and trigeminal neuropathy after stereotactic radiosurgery of vestibular schwannomas with marginal doses of 16-20 Gy, assessed whether proton beam radiosurgery using a marginal dose of only 12 Gy could control vestibular schwannomas while causing less neuropathy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Sixty-eight patients (mean age 67 years) were treated between 1992 and 1998. The mean tumor volume was 2.49 cm(3). The dose to the tumor margin (70% isodose line) was 12 Gy. The prospectively specified follow-up consisted of neurologic evaluation and MRI at 6, 12, 24, and 36 months.

RESULTS

After a mean clinical follow-up of 44 months and imaging follow-up of 34 months in 64 patients, 35 tumors (54.7%) were smaller and 25 (39.1%) were unchanged (tumor control rate 94%; actuarial control rate 94% at 2 years and 84% at 5 years). Three tumors enlarged: one shrank after repeated radiosurgery, one remained enlarged at the time of unrelated death, and one had not been imaged for 4 years in a patient who remained asymptomatic at last follow-up. Intratumoral hemorrhage into one stable tumor required craniotomy that proved successful. Thus, 97% of tumors required no additional treatment. Three patients (4.7%) underwent shunting for hydrocephalus evident as increased ataxia. Of 6 patients with functional hearing ipsilaterally, 1 improved, 1 was unchanged, and 4 progressively lost hearing. Cranial neuropathies were infrequent: persistent facial hypesthesia (2 new, 1 exacerbated; 4.7%); intermittent facial paresthesias (5 new, 1 exacerbated; 9.4%); persistent facial weakness (2 new, 1 exacerbated; 4.7%) requiring oculoplasty; transient partial facial weakness (5 new, 1 exacerbated; 9.4%), and synkinesis (5 new, 1 exacerbated; 9.4%).

CONCLUSION

Proton beam stereotactic radiosurgery of vestibular schwannomas at the doses used in this study controls tumor growth with relatively few complications.

Fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy for the treatment of vestibular schwannomas: combined experience of the Toronto-Sunnybrook Regional Cancer Centre and the Princess Margaret Hospital

PURPOSE

To evaluate the efficacy and toxicity of fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (FSRT) for vestibular schwannomas in patients treated at two university-affiliated hospitals.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Thirty-nine patients were treated between April 1996 and September 2000. The median age was 56 years (range: 29-80), and median maximal tumor diameter was 20 mm (range: 9-40). A total of 11 patients had fifth and/or seventh cranial nerve dysfunction before irradiation; 2 patients had only facial weakness, 5 patients had only facial numbness, and 4 patients had both facial weakness and numbness. Thirty-three patients were treated with primary FSRT, and 6 patients were treated for recurrent or persistent disease after previous surgery. All patients were treated with 6-MV photons using a stereotactic system with a relocatable frame. The 39 patients received 50 Gy in 25 fractions over 5 weeks. Median follow-up was 21.8 months (range: 4.4-49.6).

RESULTS

Local control was achieved in 37 patients (95%). Two patients experienced deterioration of their symptoms at 3 and 20 months as a result of clinical progression in one case and tumor progression in the other and underwent surgery post FSRT. A total of 19/28 (67.9%) patients preserved serviceable hearing after FSRT. Deterioration of the facial and trigeminal nerves was observed in only 2 patients who were treated with surgery post FSRT.

CONCLUSION

FSRT provided excellent tumor control with minimal morbidity and good hearing preservation in this cohort of patients. Longer follow-up is required to confirm long-term control rates.

Radiotherapy and radiosurgery for skull base tumors

Tumors arising in the vicinity of the skull base are relatively uncommon; however, lesions that may be successfully treated by radiotherapy and radiosurgery include temporal bone chemodectomas, schwannomas, juvenile angiofibromas, pituitary adenomas, and meningiomas. This article reviews treatment techniques and results and discusses the pertinent literature.

Reduced-dose radiosurgery for vestibular schwannomas

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate tumor control and complications associated with low-dose radiosurgery for vestibular schwannomas.

METHODS

Between December 1993 and January 2000, 47 patients with vestibular schwannomas were treated at our center with gamma knife radiosurgery. The marginal tumor doses ranged from 7.5 to 14.0 Gy (median, 12.0 Gy) for patients treated after microsurgery and from 10.0 to 15.0 Gy (median, 12.0 Gy) for patients in whom radiosurgery was the primary treatment. The median maximum tumor diameter was 18 mm (range, 3-50 mm). Evaluation included audiometry, neurological examination, and serial imaging tests. A survey was conducted at the time of analysis.

RESULTS

Follow-up data were available for 45 patients and ranged from 1 to 7 years (median, 3.6 yr). In 43 patients (96%), tumor control (no radiographic progression or surgical resection) was observed. All 33 previously untreated patients had tumor control. Transient facial weakness, experienced in two patients (4%), had resolved completely within 6 months. No patient developed trigeminal neuropathy. Hearing was diminished from baseline in 12% of patients with useful hearing (Gardner-Robertson Class III). However, all patients with pretreatment hearing Gardner-Robertson Class I or II maintained testable hearing (Class I to III) at the most recent examination.

CONCLUSION

Low-dose radiosurgery in this series provided comparable local control and decreased incidences of complications in relation to other reports. Additional follow-up will allow more definitive conclusions to be reached regarding the ultimate rates of tumor control and hearing preservation. Nevertheless, the current dose used for vestibular schwannomas at the University of Maryland Medical Center is 12.0 Gy to the tumor periphery.

Analysis of risk factors associated with radiosurgery for vestibular schwannoma

OBJECT

The aim of this study was to identify factors associated with delayed cranial neuropathy following radiosurgery for vestibular schwannoma (VS or acoustic neuroma) and to determine how such factors may be manipulated to minimize the incidence of radiosurgical complications while maintaining high rates of tumor control.

METHODS

From July 1988 to June 1998, 149 cases of VS were treated using linear accelerator radiosurgery at the University of Florida. In each of these cases, the patient's tumor and brainstem were contoured in 1-mm slices on the original radiosurgical targeting images. Resulting tumor and brainstem volumes were coupled with the original radiosurgery plans to generate dose-volume histograms. Various tumor dimensions were also measured to estimate the length of cranial nerve that would be irradiated. Patient follow-up data, including evidence of cranial neuropathy and radiographic tumor control, were obtained from a prospectively maintained, computerized database. The authors performed statistical analyses to compare the incidence of posttreatment cranial neuropathies or tumor growth between patient strata defined by risk factors of interest. One hundred thirty-nine of the 149 patients were included in the analysis of complications. The median duration of clinical follow up for this group was 36 months (range 18-94 months). The tumor control analysis included 133 patients. The median duration of radiological follow up in this group was 34 months (range 6-94 months). The overall 2-year actuarial incidences of facial and trigeminal neuropathies were 11.8% and 9.5%, respectively. In 41 patients treated before 1994, the incidences of facial and trigeminal neuropathies were both 29%, but in the 108 patients treated since January 1994, these rates declined to 5% and 2%, respectively. An evaluation of multiple risk factor models showed that maximum radiation dose to the brainstem, treatment era (pre-1994 compared with 1994 or later), and prior surgical resection were all simultaneously informative predictors of cranial neuropathy risk. The radiation dose prescribed to the tumor margin could be substituted for the maximum dose to the brainstem with a small loss in predictive strength. The pons-petrous tumor diameter was an additional statistically significant simultaneous predictor of trigeminal neuropathy risk, whereas the distance from the brainstem to the end of the tumor in the petrous bone was an additional marginally significant simultaneous predictor of facial neuropathy risk. The overall radiological tumor control rate was 93% (59% tumors regressed, 34% remained stable, and 7.5% enlarged), and the 5-year actuarial tumor control rate was 87% (95% confidence interval [CI] 76-98%). Analysis revealed that a radiation dose cutpoint of 10 Gy compared with more than 10 Gy prescribed to the tumor margin yielded the greatest relative difference in tumor growth risk (relative risk 2.4, 95% CI 0.6-9.3), although this difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.207).

CONCLUSIONS

Five points must be noted. 1) Radiosurgery is a safe, effective treatment for small VSs. 2) Reduction in the radiation dose has played the most important role in reducing the complications associated with VS radiosurgery. 3) The dose to the brainstem is a more informative predictor of postradiosurgical cranial neuropathy than the length of the nerve that is irradiated. 4) Prior resection increases the risk of late cranial neuropathies after radiosurgery. 5) A prescription dose of 12.5 Gy to the tumor margin resulted in the best combination of maximum tumor control and minimum complications in this series.

Stereotactic radiosurgery versus stereotactic radiotherapy for patients with vestibular schwannoma: a Leksell Gamma Knife Society 2000 debate

✓ By definition, the term “radiosurgery” refers to the delivery of a therapeutic radiation dose in a single fraction, not simply the use of stereotaxy. Multiple-fraction delivery is better termed “stereotactic radiotherapy.” There are compelling radiobiological principles supporting the biological superiority of single-fraction radiation for achieving an optimal therapeutic response for the slowly proliferating, late-responding, tissue of a schwannoma. It is axiomatic that complication avoidance requires precise three-dimensional conformality between treatment and tumor volumes. This degree of conformality can only be achieved through complex multiisocenter planning. Alternative radiosurgery devices are generally limited to delivering one to four isocenters in a single treatment session. Although they can reproduce dose plans similar in conformality to early gamma knife dose plans by using a similar number of isocenters, they cannot reproduce the conformality of modern gamma knife plans based on magnetic resonance image—targeted localization and five to 30 isocenters.

A disturbing trend is developing in which institutions without nongamma knife radiosurgery (GKS) centers are championing and/or shifting to hypofractionated stereotactic radiotherapy for vestibular schwannomas. This trend appears to be driven by a desire to reduce complication rates to compete with modern GKS results by using complex multiisocenter planning. Aggressive advertising and marketing from some of these centers even paradoxically suggests biological superiority of hypofractionation approaches over single-dose radiosurgery for vestibular schwannomas. At the same time these centers continue to use the term radiosurgery to describe their hypofractionated radiotherapy approach in an apparent effort to benefit from a GKS “halo effect.” It must be reemphasized that as neurosurgeons our primary duty is to achieve permanent tumor control for our patients and not to eliminate complications at the expense of potential late recurrence. The answer to minimizing complications while maintaining maximum tumor control is improved conformality of radiosurgery dose planning and not resorting to homeopathic radiosurgery doses or hypofractionation radiotherapy schemes.

Fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy for vestibular schwannoma (VS): comparison between cystic-type and solid-type VS

PURPOSE

To compare the effectiveness and complications of fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) for cystic-type vestibular schwannoma (VS) with those of solid-type VS.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

In 65 patients treated with fractionated SRT between 1991 and 1999, 20 were diagnosed with cystic VS, in which at least one-third of the tumor volume was a cystic component on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), and 45 were diagnosed with solid VS. Thirty-six Gy to 50 Gy in 20-25 fractions was administered to the isocenter and approximately 80% of the periphery of the tumor. All cystic and solid components were included in the gross tumor volume. The mean follow-up period was 37 months, ranging from 6 to 97 months.

RESULTS

The actuarial 3-year rate of no episode of enlargement greater than 2.0 mm was 55% for cystic-type and 75% for solid-type VS; the difference was statistically significant (p = 0.023). The actuarial 3-year tumor-reduction (reduction in tumor size greater than 2.0 mm) rates were 93% and 31%, respectively (p = 0.0006). The overall actuarial tumor control rate (no tumor growth greater than 2. 0 mm after 2 years or no requirement of salvage surgery) was 92% at 5 years in 44 patients with a follow-up period of 2 or more years. There was no difference in the class hearing preservation rate between cystic VS and solid VS. No permanent trigeminal or facial nerve palsy was observed in either group.

CONCLUSION

Transient tumor enlargement occurs in cystic VS more frequently than in solid-type VS, but the subsequent tumor-reduction rate in cystic VS is better.

Results of linear accelerator-based stereotactic radiosurgery for recurrent and newly diagnosed acoustic neuromas

Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) is used to treat acoustic neuromas, but additional information is needed to firmly establish its safety and efficacy. We review our experience over 7 years treating 29 consecutive patients with a modified linear accelerator (linac) SRS system. Between August 1989 and October 1995, 29 patients with a median age of 67 years (range 26 to 83) underwent linac SRS treatment. Twenty-five patients had unilateral acoustic neuromas, and four patients with neurofibromatosis type II had bilateral vestibular schwannoma. Eligibility criteria for SRS were recurrent tumors (n = 9), age >65 (n = 16), or patient preference (n = 6). Follow-up magnetic resonance imaging scans were performed on all patients. The most common presenting symptoms were hearing impairment (18 patients) and gait difficulties (17 patients). Ten patients were deaf in the affected ear prior to treatment. Doses to the periphery of the tumor ranged from 800 to 2,400 cGy (median 1, 600 cGy) prescribed to the 50% to 80% isodose line (median 80%). After a median radiographic follow-up of 49 months (range 4 to 110 months), 11 tumors were smaller, 17 were stable, and one had evidence of progression (at 41 months). The 5-year local disease control rate (Kaplan-Meier estimate) was 94%. Acute complications were minimal, with only two patients experiencing nausea and vomiting after the procedure. Long-term complications included new or progressive trigeminal and facial nerve deficits with estimated 5-year incidences of 15% and 32%, respectively. Subjective hearing reduction or loss occurred in 14 (74%) of the 19 patients who had useful hearing prior to treatment. Five patients died from unrelated causes. These results suggest that linac SRS provides excellent short-term tumor control rates. Since there was a high risk of cranial nerve neuropathy, we do not recommend using only computed tomography-based planning and high prescription doses. Int. J. Cancer (Radiat. Oncol. Invest.) 90, 145-151 (2000).

Gamma surgery for vestibular schwannoma

OBJECT

The goal of this study was to assess the results of gamma surgery (GS) for vestibular schwannoma (VS) in 200 cases treated over the last 10 years and to review the role of this neurosurgical procedure in the management of VS.

METHODS

Follow-up reviews ranging from 1 to 10 years were available in 153 of these patients. Follow-up images in these cases were analyzed using computer software that we developed to obtain volume measurements for the tumors, and the clinical condition of the patients was assessed using questionnaires. Gamma surgery was the primary treatment modality in 96 cases and followed microsurgery in 57 cases. Tumors ranged in volume from 0.02 to 18.3 cm(3). In the group in which GS was the primary treatment, a decrease in volume was observed in 78 cases (81%), no change in 12 (12%), and an increase in volume in six cases (6%). The decrease was more than 75% in seven cases. In the group treated following microsurgery, a decrease in volume was observed in 37 cases (65%), no change in 14 (25%), and an increase in volume in six (11%). The decrease was more than 75% in eight cases. Five patients experienced trigeminal dysfunction; in three cases this was transient and in the other two it was persistent, although there has been improvement. Three patients had facial paresis (in one case this was transient, lasting 6 weeks; in one case there was 80% recovery at 18 months posttreatment; and in one case surgery was performed after the onset of facial paresis for presumed increase in tumor size). Over a 6-year period, hearing deteriorated in 60% of the patients. Three patients showed an improvement in hearing. No hearing deterioration was observed during the first 2 years of follow-up review.

CONCLUSIONS

Gamma surgery should be used to treat postoperative residual tumors as well as tumors in patients with medical conditions that preclude surgery. Microsurgery should be performed whenever a surgeon is confident of extirpating the tumor with a risk-benefit ratio superior to that presented in this study.

Fractionated stereotactic radiation therapy and single high-dose radiosurgery for acoustic neuroma: early results of a prospective clinical study

PURPOSE

To prospectively assess the local control and toxicity rate in acoustic neuroma patients treated with linear accelerator-based radiosurgery and fractionated stereotactic radiation therapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

We evaluated 37 consecutive patients treated with stereotactic radiation therapy for acoustic neuroma. All patients had progressive tumors, progressive symptoms, or both. Mean tumor diameter was 2.3 cm (range 0.8-3.3) on magnetic resonance (MR) scan. Dentate patients were given a dose of 5x4 Gy or 5x5 Gy and edentate patients were given a dose of 1x10 Gy or 1x12.50 Gy prescribed to the 80% isodose. All patients were treated with a single isocenter.

RESULTS

With a mean follow-up period of 25 months (range 12-61), the actuarial local control rate at 5 years was 91% (only 1 patient failed). The actuarial rate of hearing preservation at 5 years was 66% in previously-hearing patients. The actuarial rate of freedom from trigeminal nerve toxicity was 97% at 5 years. No patient developed facial nerve toxicity or other complications.

CONCLUSION

In this unselected series, fractionated stereotactic radiation therapy and linear accelerator-based radiosurgery give excellent local control in acoustic neuroma. It combines a high rate of preservation of hearing with a very low rate of other toxicity, although follow-up is relatively short.

Improved trigeminal and facial nerve tolerance following fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy for large acoustic neuromas

The purpose of this study was to demonstrate improved cranial nerve tolerance following fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy for large acoustic neuromas, defined as tumours with pons-petrous distance (A) > 1 cm and midporous transverse diameter (A + Y) > 2 cm. Of 28 patients with acoustic neuromas treated with fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy, 19 had large tumours at high risk for radiosurgery-induced cranial neuropathy. Six patients received 36 Gy in six, weekly, fractions and 13 patients received 30 Gy in six, weekly, fractions. 15 patients had evaluable trigeminal nerve function and 16 had evaluable facial nerve function. At a median follow-up of 4.5 years, tumour shrinkage was seen in 10 patients and tumour size was stable in nine. None of the patients developed any evidence of transient, or permanent, trigeminal or facial neuropathy at any time during their follow-up period. Fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy may offer a superior therapeutic ratio to single fraction stereotactic radiosurgery in the management of large acoustic neuromas, as evidenced by the absence of post-treatment trigeminal and facial neuropathy.

[Fractionated irradiation of cerebellopontine angle neurinoma: 12 years' experience of the Bordeaux University Hospital Center]

PURPOSE

To evaluate retrospectively the long-term results of fractionated radiation therapy (RT) in cerebello-pontine angle neurinomas (CPA).

METHODS AND MATERIAL

From January 1986 to October 1995, 29 patients with stage III and IV neurinomas were treated with external fractionated RT. One patient was irradiated on both sides and indications for RT were as follows: (1) general contraindications for surgery (16 patients); (2) hearing preservation in bilateral neurinomas after controlateral tumor exeresis (six patients); (3) partial tumor removal (five patients); and, (4) non-surgical recurrence (three patients). A three to four fields technique with coplanar static beams and conformal cerobend blocks was used; doses were calculated on a 95 to 98% isodoses and were given five days a week for a median total dose of 51 Gy (1.8 Gy/fraction). Most patients were irradiated with 6 to 10 MV photons).

RESULTS

Median follow-up was 66 months (seven to 120 months). Seven patients died, two with progressive disease, five from non-tumoral causes. Tumor shrinkage was observed in 13 patients (43.3%), stable disease in 14 (46.6%), and tumor progression in three. Two patients underwent total tumor removal after RT (one stable and one growing tumor). Hearing was preserved in four out of six patients. No patient experienced facial or trigeminal neuropathy.

CONCLUSION

Fractionated RT is a well tolerated and efficacious treatment of large non-surgical CPA neurinomas.

Comparison between observation policy and fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) as an initial management for vestibular schwannoma

PURPOSE

To compare the use of an observation policy with that of stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) for treatment of vestibular schwannoma.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The study group consisted of 27 patients who underwent observation as an initial treatment (observation group) and 50 who received SRT (SRT group). The mean follow-up period was 35 months and 31 months, respectively. Stereotactic radiotherapy consisted of small-field fractionated radiotherapy (36-44 Gy in 20-22 fractions over 6 weeks) with or without a subsequent 4-Gy single irradiation boost.

RESULTS

Actuarial tumor control rate of the SRT group was significantly better than that of the observation group (p < 0.0001). The mean growth was 3.87 mm/year in the observation group and -0.75 mm/year in the SRT group (p < 0.0001). Eleven patients (41 %) in the observation group and 1 (2 %) in the SRT group received salvage therapy (p < 0.001). There was no difference in the actuarial Gardner and Robertson's class preservation curves for 5 years after the initial presentation.

CONCLUSION

Stereotactic radiotherapy using a fractionated schedule provides a better tumor control rate and a similar rate of deterioration for hearing levels compared to an observation policy. Initial SRT may be a reasonable alternative to a wait-and-see policy.

Radiation therapy for benign central nervous system disease

The most common indication for the use of radiation therapy in the treatment of benign central nervous system disease is for the treatment of benign brain tumors, such as meningioma, pituitary adenoma, acoustic neuroma, arteriovenous malformation, and craniopharyngioma. Other less common benign intracranial tumors treated with radiation include chordoma, pilocytic astrocytoma, pineocytoma, choroid-plexus papilloma, hemangioblastoma, and temporal bone chemodectomas. Benign conditions, such as histiocytosis X, trigeminal neuralgia, and epilepsy, are also amenable to radiation treatment. There have also been reports of radiosurgery being used for the treatment of movement disorders and psychiatric disturbances, such as obsessive-compulsive and anxiety disorders. For benign brain tumors, radiation therapy as either primary or adjuvant therapy plays an integral role in improving local control. In the treatment of trigeminal neuralgia, epilepsy, tremor, and some psychiatric disturbances, radiosurgery may help ameliorate or eliminate some symptoms. Patients with benign central nervous system disease are expected to live a long time. As such, treatment should be highly conformal and based on three-dimensional planning using magnetic resonance imaging, computed tomography, or both. It is critical that damage to normal brain be minimized.

Small-field fractionated radiotherapy with or without stereotactic boost for vestibular schwannoma

PURPOSE

To assess the efficacy and toxicity of small-field fractionated radiotherapy with or without stereotactic boost (SB) for vestibular schwannomas.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Thirty-nine patients with vestibular schwannoma were treated with irradiation between March 1991 and February 1996. Extra-meatal tumor diameters were under 30 mm. Thirty-three patients received small-field fractionated radiotherapy followed by SB. Basic dose schedule was 44 Gy in 22 fractions over 5 1/2 weeks plus 4 Gy in one session. Six patients received small-field fractionated radiotherapy only (40-44 Gy in 20-22 fractions over 5-5 1/2 weeks or 36 Gy in 20 fractions over 5 weeks).dash;p >

RESULTS

Follow-up ranged from 6 to 69 months (median, 24 months). Tumors decreased in size in 13 cases (33%), were unchanged in 25 (64%), and increased in one (3%). The actuarial 2-year tumor control rate was 97%. Fifteen patients had useful hearing (Gardner-Robertson class 1-2) and 25 patients had testable hearing (class 1-4) before irradiation. The 2-year actuarial rates of useful hearing preservation (free of deterioration from class 1-2 to class 3-5) were 78%. The 2-year actuarial rates of any testable hearing preservation (free of deterioration from class 1-4 to class 5) were 96%. No permanent facial and trigeminal neuropathy developed after irradiation. The 2-year actuarial incidences of facial and trigeminal neuropathies were 8% and 16%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Small-field fractionated radiotherapy with or without SB provides excellent short-term local control and a relatively low incidence of complications for vestibular schwannoma, although further follow-up is necessary to evaluate the long-term results.

Linear accelerator radiosurgery for nonacoustic schwannomas

PURPOSE

To analyze the results of nonacoustic schwannomas treated with linear accelerator stereotactic radiosurgery.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between August 1989 and October 1997, 18 patients with nonacoustic schwannomas underwent stereotactic radiosurgery at the University of Florida. Nine patients had schwannomas located in the jugular foramen region, seven in the trigeminal nerve, and two in the facial nerve. Nine patients had initial subtotal resections and nine did not undergo surgical intervention. One of the 9 patients with subtotal resection was treated with radiosurgery for a recurrent tumor. Tumor volumes ranged from 0.7 to 15.4 cm3 with a mean volume of 5.5 cm3. Minimal tumor doses ranged from 10.0 to 15.0 Gy with a mean dose of 13.1 Gy. Treatment dose was specified to the 80% isodose shell in 11 patients (58%) and to the 70% isodose shell in the remaining patients. Ten patients (56%) were treated with a single isocenter, 6 patients (33%) with 2-4 isocenters, and 2 patients (11%) with greater than 5 isocenters. Follow-up ranged from 5 to75 months and the mean follow-up was 32 months. Ten patients (56%) had follow-up beyond 2 years and none were lost to follow-up. Local control was defined as clinically stable neurological status and/or stable or decreased tumor size on yearly follow-up MR imaging.

RESULTS

Eighteen evaluable patients (100%) had local control after treatment. All were alive and progression-free at last follow-up. Six of 10 patients with follow-up MRI 2 years or more after treatment had tumor regression and 4 patients had stable disease. Three additional patients with an MRI at 1 year showed no tumor change. Four complications in 3 patients included one worsening of a preexisting VII nerve palsy, 2 patients with new onset of hearing loss, and one with ataxia. No surgical intervention or prolonged steroid use was necessary for any patient with complications. Five patients had improvement in preexisting neurologic deficits.

CONCLUSIONS

Excellent preliminary tumor control rates and a favorable toxicity profile support the effectiveness of linear accelerator stereotactic radiosurgery for patients with nonacoustic schwannomas.

[Stereotactic one-time irradiation (radiosurgery). The methods, indications and results]

BACKGROUND

Stereotaxy is a method to determine a point in the patient's body by an external coordinate system which is attached to the patient. Radiosurgery uses this method for precise delivery of a high single radiation dose to the patient. The aim is to destroy the tissue in the target and to spare surrounding unaffected normal tissue by a steep dose gradient.

METHODS

Three techniques of percutaneous radiosurgery are available: radiosurgery with ion beams with a cyclotron, spherical arrangement of cobalt-60 sources, the so-called gamma knife, and an adapted linear accelerator. The availability and the good clinical experience lead to a wide spread use of linear accelerator for radiosurgery in recent years. A subsequent development is fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy which combines the precision of radiosurgery with the radiobiological advantage of fractionation.

RESULTS

Only a few indications for radiosurgery are proven by statistically valid studies. One of these is the treatment of small arteriovenous malformation, where obliteration rates of 80% to 100% are reported with only minor toxicity. However, the obliteration rate is reduced significantly in large arteriovenous malformations. A local control rate of 90% is obtained after radiosurgery of brain metastases which is comparable to the results of microsurgical resection followed by adjuvant whole brain radiotherapy. An ongoing EORTC study evaluates the role of adjuvant whole brain radiotherapy after radiosurgery. The survival of the patients with brain metastases is limited by the existence of progressive extracerebral disease. The role of radiosurgery in the treatment of benign tumors is currently evaluated in clinical studies which include: vestibular schwannomas, meningiomas, chordomas and chondrosarcomas and pituitary adenomas. Most of the published studies include only small tumors because radiosurgery is limited by the risk of radionecrosis of adjacent normal tissue, which shows a steep dose volume response relationship. Recent developments of stereotactic radiotherapy include the use of mini-multileaf-collimators and clinical studies on stereotactic radiotherapy of extracranial targets.

CONCLUSIONS

Stereotactic irradiation is a well established treatment technique for intracranial tumors and arteriovenous malformations. Methods are available that allow optimization of dose distributions to irregularly shaped tumors for single dose as well as fractionated stereotactic irradiations by linear accelerator. Therefore the therapeutic potential of this technique has increased and enables also the extracerebral application in controlled clinical studies.

Vestibular schwannoma management in the next century: a radiosurgical perspective

PURPOSE

To discuss how the evolution of vestibular schwannoma radiosurgery, changes in health care delivery, and patient accessibility to medical information will affect the management of vestibular schwannomas in the future.

CONCEPT

In comparison with microsurgical resection of vestibular schwannomas, radiosurgery has a lower morbidity rate, a similar risk of requiring further surgery, and higher patient satisfaction. As this information becomes more widely available to patients and third-party payors, radiosurgery may replace surgical resection as the preferred management strategy for patients with small to medium sized vestibular schwannomas in the United States.

RATIONALE

It is estimated that 2500 patients are diagnosed with vestibular schwannomas each year in the United States. Assuming that 80% undergo surgery, 2000 operations are performed annually for newly diagnosed vestibular schwannomas. Data available since 1987 regarding the number of cases for which gamma knife radiosurgery was performed were used to predict the number of patients who will undergo vestibular schwannoma radiosurgery in the future. If the current trend continues, an equal number of patients will undergo surgical resection and radiosurgery to treat their vestibular schwannomas (approximately 1000/yr) sometime between 2005 and 2010. Moreover, it is predicted that by 2020, two-thirds of the patients who are newly diagnosed with vestibular schwannomas will undergo radiosurgery, with surgical resection being reserved for patients with large tumors associated with symptomatic brain stem compression.

DISCUSSION

Early data regarding vestibular schwannoma radiosurgery predicted an exponential growth curve. Although it is premature to assume that the current trend will continue, it is likely that an ever increasing percentage of patients will undergo radiosurgery as accessibility to this alternative increases, and more data are published regarding long-term tumor growth control rates. If the mathematical model proves to be accurate, then stereotactic radiosurgery will replace surgical resection as the preferred management strategy for the majority of patients with vestibular schwannomas.