Neutron interstitial brachytherapy for malignant gliomas: a pilot study

Neutron brachytherapy in the modern era: Indications and evidence

Hadrontherapy is a form of radiation therapy (RT) that relies on heavy particles, such as proton, heavy ions, or neutrons, to enhance anti-tumoral efficacy based on their specific dosimetric and radio-biological properties. Neutrons are characterized by specific radiobiological properties that might deserve greater consideration, including the high linear energy transfer and the low oxygen enhancement ratio. Neutron brachytherapy, relying on interstitial or intracavitary neutron sources, has been developed since the 1950s using Californium-252 (252Cf) as a mixed emitter of fission fast neutrons and γ-photos. However, the place of NBT in the era of modern radiation therapy is yet to be precisely defined. In this systematic review, we aim to provide an up-to-date analysis of current experience and clinical evidence of NBT in the XXI ^th century, by answering the following clinical questions: How is NBT currently delivered? What are the current efficacy data and tolerance profiles of NBT?

Surgery for malignant gliomas: mechanistic reasoning and slippery statistics

Current surgical treatment of malignant gliomas largely depends on mechanistic reasoning and data collected in non-randomised studies. Technological advance has enabled more accurate resection of tumours and preservation of eloquent brain areas but ethical considerations have restricted randomised trials on the efficacy of surgery to one small trial that found a 3 month survival advantage for patients over age 65 years who received surgery and interim analysis of a larger trial. There is an argument for surgery as a palliative measure in patients with symptoms caused by mechanisms that are surgically remediable. Whether there is any survival advantage from surgery in patients other than those with immediately life-threatening, surgically remediable complications, such as raised intracranial pressure, is unclear. The available data show that if such an advantage does exist, it is modest at best. Adjuvant treatments given surgically are being studied. Chemotherapy wafers are the most prominent of the adjuvant treatments but the evidence available is insufficient to recommend their use in routine practice. In this review we examine the prevailing mechanistic model and observational data; we assess how these are applied and the priorities they indicate for future research.

Accelerator-based neutron brachytherapy

The development and evaluation of a new approach to neutron brachytherapy is described. This approach, accelerator-based fast neutron brachytherapy, involves the interstitial or intracavity insertion of a narrow, evacuated accelerator beam tube such that its tip, containing the neutron-producing target, is placed in or near the tumor. Tumor irradiation via brachytherapy should result in a reduction in the healthy tissue complication rate observed when poorly collimated and/or low energy external neutron beam are used for treatment. Use of a variable energy accelerator provides an advantage over isotope sources for neutron brachytherapy in that the neutron beam can be turned on and off and the neutron energy spectrum varied for different treatment applications. A prototype accelerator-based fast neutron brachytherapy device, 10 cm long and 6 mm outer diameter, has been constructed and evaluated in terms of its dosimetric output, treatment time, and practical feasibility. The prototype device is a tube-in-tube design with cooling water running between the inner and outer tubes to cool a beryllium target located at the tip of the inner tube. Cooling experiments were performed and coupled with Monte Carlo simulations to determine treatment times as a function of heat load for various neutron-producing reactions. Using the 9Be(d,n) 10B reaction at Ed= 1.5 MeV, 66 RBE-Gy (12 Gy physical dose) can be delivered to the boundary of a 4.5-cm-diam treatment volume in 8 min at a heat load of 130 W. Other reactions offer similar treatment times at somewhat higher bombarding energies and also show higher potential for dose enhancement with the boron-10 neutron capture reaction due to their softer neutron spectra. Dose distributions in a water phantom were measured with the prototype brachytherapy tube using the dual-ion chamber technique for the 9Be(d,n) 10B reaction at Ed = 1.5 MeV. The measurements and simulations agree within uncertainties and demonstrate that fast neutrons contribute more than 90% of the dose to the target volume.

A phase I trial of neutron brachytherapy for the treatment of malignant gliomas

We performed a phase I trial to test the feasibility of neutron brachytherapy using californium-252 (252Cf) as the sole source of radiation, and to determine the maximum tolerable dose (MTD), for the treatment of malignant gliomas. Previous studies using external beam neutron radiation have shown that neutrons are capable of totally eradicating malignant gliomas. However, in most cases, fatal widespread radiation necrosis resulted. Radioactive implants are a logical method of increasing the dose to the tumour and decreasing the dose to normal brain. 252Cf is a relatively stable neutron-emitting isotope suitable for implant therapy. The study was an open ended dose-escalation study. All radiation was delivered by using only 252Cf implants, without external beam therapy of any type. The first dose step was 900 neutron cGy (ncGy); each subsequent step was increased by 100 ncGy. Three patients with newly diagnosed malignant gliomas were entered at each dose step, and the number was increased to six patients in dose steps at which necrosis of brain occurred. The study ended when two patients at any dose step developed radiation necrosis of brain outside the prescribed radiation field. 33 patients were entered into the study. 10 patients developed scalp necrosis associated with scalp doses above 900 ncGy. The study ended when two patients at the 1300 ncGy dose step developed radiation necrosis of brain. We conclude: (1) neutron brachytherapy using 252Cf as the sole source of radiation is a feasible treatment for malignant gliomas; (2) the scalp tolerates less neutron radiation than the brain; (3) the MTD (and the recommended dose for a phase II trial) of interstitial neutron brachytherapy is 1200 ncGy.

[Radiotherapy of glioblastoma]

Glioblastoma cells appear to be inherently radioresistant and to present a significant fraction of hypoxic cells. The most significant prognostic factors to compare results achieved in several series of patients are the age, performance status and quality of surgical resection. Several randomized trials have provided evidence supporting the efficacy of radiation therapy in the treatment of glioblastoma. Prescription of a 60-Gy dose delivered according to a conventional dose-fractionation scheme (single daily fractions of 1.7 to 2 Gy five times per week) in a target volume with a 2-3 cm margin of tissue surrounding the perimeter of the contrast enhancing lesion on computerized tomography and magnetic resonance imaging is derived from observations made in several retrospective and prospective studies. Evidence of improvement in survival was observed neither in patients receiving hyperfractioned and accelerated radiotherapy, nor in patients for whom radiation sensitizers such as nitroimidazole compounds or halogenated pyrimidine analogs were associated to radiation therapy. The addition of nitrosourea to radiotherapy increases the 2-year survival rate by about 10%. Combination of full-dose external beam radiotherapy and brachytherapy or radiosurgery boost in selected patients with glioblastoma leads to an increase in the median survival, while external beam radiation alone in patients with similar prognosis does not.

Interstitial brachytherapy procedures for brain tumors

Promising results have been obtained using brachytherapy in the treatment of brain tumors. Very low-dose rate brachytherapy (60-100 Gy given at 0.05-0.10 Gy/h) has been used for low-grade gliomas, resulting in 5- and 10-year survival probabilities of 85% and 83% for pilocytic astrocytomas and 61% and 51% for grade II astrocytomas. Only 2.6% of patients had symptomatic radiation necrosis. For faster-growing high-grade gliomas, temporary implants delivering about 60 Gy at 0.40-0.60 Gy/h are generally used. The largest series have reported median survival times of 12-13 months after brachytherapy for recurrent malignant gliomas and 18-19 months after diagnosis of primary glioblastomas treated with external beam radiotherapy and brachytherapy boost. A recent prospective, randomized trial demonstrated significantly improved survival for high-grade glioma patients who had brachytherapy boost. However, over 50% of patients who undergo brachytherapy for malignant gliomas require reoperation for tumor progression and/or radiation necrosis. Strategies are under development to improve local control without increasing radiation toxicity.

Brachytherapy for recurrent malignant astrocytoma

PURPOSE

To assess the efficacy of interstitial brachytherapy in the treatment of patients with recurrent malignant astrocytoma.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Forty-six patients with recurrent malignant astrocytoma were treated with stereotactic high-activity temporary iodine-125 implants between September, 1986 and October, 1992. All patients had been initially treated for malignant astrocytoma (44) or low-grade astrocytoma (2) with surgery and external fractionated radiation. The median time between initial diagnosis and recurrence treated with brachytherapy was 12.5 months. Twenty-five patients received chemotherapy prior to brachytherapy.

RESULTS

All but four patients have died; median survival time following brachytherapy is 46 weeks. Twelve patients underwent reoperation for radiation necrosis at a median interval of 6.5 months after treatment (26%). Five patients incurred complications directly due to brachytherapy (11%). Forty-four patients are evaluable regarding pattern of failure following brachytherapy. Six of these 44 patients (13.6%) recurred at a distance from the treatment volume (4 in brain and 2 in spinal subarachnoid space).

CONCLUSION

Brachytherapy confers modest but meaningful prolongation of survival in selected patients with recurrent malignant astrocytoma, but complications are significant, reoperation frequently required, and recurrence outside the treatment volume common.

Long term results of stereotactic brachytherapy used in the initial treatment of patients with glioblastomas

BACKGROUND

Despite optimal therapy with surgery and radiotherapy, the prognosis of patients with glioblastomas remains poor. Stereotactic brachytherapy involves the accurate placement of radioactive isotopes within brain tumors, significantly increasing the dose of radiation that can be delivered to the tumor bed without substantial risk to surrounding normal tissue, potentially improving local tumor control and patient survival.

METHODS

Between February 1987 and July 1993, the authors treated 56 patients with glioblastomas with stereotactic brachytherapy as part of their initial therapy. Patients underwent surgery, limited field external beam radiotherapy, and brachytherapy with temporary high-activity iodine 125 sources, giving an additional 50 Gy to the tumor bed.

RESULTS

Median survival for patients undergoing brachytherapy was 18 months compared with 11 months for a matched brachytherapy control group with similar clinical and radiologic features (P < 0.0007). Survival rates at 1, 2, and 3 years after diagnosis of 83%, 34%, and 27%, respectively, for patients receiving brachytherapy were significantly increased compared with survival rates of 40%, 12.5%, and 9%, respectively, for control subjects. Thirty-six patients (64%) underwent reoperation for symptomatic radiation necrosis from 3 to 42 months (median, 11 months) after brachytherapy. The median survival of patients undergoing reoperation was 22 months compared with 13 months for those who did not have further surgery (P < 0.02). Thirty-five percent of patients relapsed locally within the brachytherapy target volume, whereas 65% had marginal or distant relapses.

CONCLUSIONS

Brachytherapy may improve local tumor control and prolong survival when used in the initial treatment of selected patients with glioblastomas.

High activity iodine-125 interstitial implant for gliomas

A total of 307 adult patients with glioma were treated with high-activity removable iodine-125 interstitial brain implants at the University of California at San Francisco from December 1979 to June 1990. Recurrent gliomas underwent brain implant alone whereas previously untreated (primary) tumors underwent brain implant boost after external beam radiotherapy. Of these patients, 106 had primary glioblastoma multiforme, 68 had primary non-glioblastoma glioma, 66 had recurrent glioblastoma multiforme and 67 had recurrent nonglioblastoma glioma. Median follow-up for living patients was 143 weeks. Median survival from diagnosis for primary glioblastoma multiforme and high and low grade nonglioblastoma glioma was 88 weeks, 142 weeks, and 226 weeks, respectively. Median survival measured from the date of implant for recurrent glioblastoma multiforme and high and low grade nonglioblastoma glioma was 49 weeks, 52 weeks, and 81 weeks, respectively. Ninety-two percent of patients had no toxicity or transient acute side effects. Severe acute toxicity was seen in 6% of patients, life threatening acute toxicity in 1% of patients, and fatal toxicity in less than 1% of patients. Forty percent of patients with malignant glioma underwent reoperation at a median of 33 weeks after brain implant, with tumor found in 95% of specimens at reoperation. This large experience demonstrates that interstitial implant is well-tolerated and prolongs survival in patients with primary and recurrent glioblastoma multiforme, as evidenced by the 3-year survival rates of 22% and 15%, respectively.

The effects of local and systemic interferon beta (Fiblaferon) on supratentorial malignant cerebral glioma--a phase II study

In contrast to the highly promising and, with rates up to 40%, surprisingly high response rates of malignant supratentorial brain gliomas to post-operative adjuvant IFN beta therapy, we were unable to demonstrate any definite anti-proliferative, anti-tumor or immunomodulatory effects of interferon in a phase II study in 13 patients. We used high doses of an IFN beta, Fiblaferon, whose potency was repeatedly confirmed by pharmacokinetic investigations, for local and systemic administration, and the times of administration were those used in the Japanese comparative studies. The side effects observed proved to be related to the amount of IFN beta administered and its duration in our patients as well. In this context, the neurotoxic disturbances require particular attention. These resolved completely after discontinuation of IFN treatment, as do the haematological and liver enzyme disturbances after suspension of medication. We did not observe any improvement in the post-operative quality of life, nor, above all, any improvement in long-term prognosis resulting from a prolonged tumor-free remission period and prolongation of the actual post-operative survival time.

A controlled study of efficacy of interstitial or external irradiation in a virus-induced brain-tumor model in rats

In a controlled study of interstitial radiotherapy in the avian sarcoma virus (ASV)-induced glioma model in rats, prolongation of survival was demonstrated (p = 0.08 in Experiment 1 and p = 0.03 in Experiment 2) following mean dosages of 7582 to 9902 cGy 125I, when compared to nontreatment or to control studies with implantation of nonradioactive seeds. More significant (p = 0.02) prolongation of survival was demonstrated following external beam whole-head radiotherapy with nine fractions of 333 cGy, three times weekly over 3 weeks (total dose 3000 cGy). Survival was more prolonged when whole-head radiotherapy was begun 35 days following virus inoculation rather than at 71 days, probably reflecting a greater efficacy with smaller tumor targets.

Neutron brachytherapy for the treatment of malignant neoplasia

In the 1930's both neutrons and the cyclotron were discovered, developed and used almost immediately for neutron beam therapy. Cf-252 was discovered in 1950 but its potential for cancer therapy was not postulated until 1965. Early sporadic clinical trials were used to treat only a few patients. The recognition of its curative properties and usefulness for bulky localized and radioresistant cancer therapy was not made until recently. In 1985, the Lexington Workshop led to a sharing of independent experiences from the USA, Japan, and the USSR; early trial experiences were related to neutron beam results. Localized neutron therapy using brachytherapy methods was found effective against radioresistance and bulky tumors. However, it needed to be used properly and with full appreciation of clinical oncology and the role of photon adjuvant therapy.