Temporary vessel occlusion in spontaneously hypertensive and normotensive rats. Effect of single and multiple episodes on tissue metabolism and volume of infarction

RODENT STROKE MODEL GUIDELINES FOR PRECLINICAL STROKE TRIALS (1ST EDITION)

Translational stroke research is a challenging task that needs long term team work of the stroke research community. Highly reproducible stroke models with excellent outcome consistence are essential for obtaining useful data from preclinical stroke trials as well as for improving inter-lab comparability. However, our review of literature shows that the infarct variation coefficient of commonly performed stroke models ranges from 5% to 200%. An overall improvement of the commonly used stroke models will further improve the quality for experimental stroke research as well as inter-lab comparability. Many factors play a significant role in causing outcome variation; however, they have not yet been adequately addressed in the Stroke Therapy Academic Industry Roundtable (STAIR) recommendations and the Good Laboratory Practice (GLP). These critical factors include selection of anesthetics, maintenance of animal physiological environment, stroke outcome observation, and model specific factors that affect success rate and variation. The authors have reviewed these major factors that have been reported to influence stroke model outcome, herewith, provide the first edition of stroke model guidelines so to initiate active discussion on this topic. We hope to reach a general agreement among stroke researchers in the near future with its successive updated versions.

Possible control of intermittent cerebral ischemia by monitoring of direct-current potentials

OBJECT

Neurosurgically induced temporary occlusion of intracranial arteries carries the risk of cerebral ischemic damage. Because negative shifts in the cortical direct-current (DC) potential indicate tissue depolarization and, thus, critical ischemic stress, the authors hypothesized that recordings of these potentials could help to determine the optimal duration and frequency of induced intermittent focal ischemia to prevent brain injury. The investigators related the results of DC recordings both to simultaneously recorded decreases in extracellular Ca++ concentration ([Ca++]o), which reflect Ca++ entry into cells, and to histological outcome.

METHODS

In cats anesthetized with halothane the effects of intermittent brief (10 minutes long, six times [6 x 10-min group]) and prolonged (20 minutes long, three times [3 x 20-min group]) episodes of middle cerebral artery occlusions were compared with those of a single continuous episode (1 x 60-min group). Laser Doppler flow probes and ion-selective microelectrodes were used to measure cerebral blood flow, DC potentials, and [Ca++]o in cortical tissues of ectosylvian gyri. Negative shifts in DC potential were evaluated in the three groups during the entire 60-minute-long period of ischemia and were smallest in the 6 x 10-min group, larger in the 3 x 20-min group, and largest in the 1 x 60-min group. Accordingly, infarct volumes were smallest in the 6 x 10-min group, intermediate in the 3 x 20-min group, and largest in the 1 x 60-min group. Decreases in ischemic [Ca++]o were significantly greater in the 1 x 60-min group than in the two groups in which there were repetitive occlusions, and recovery of [Ca++]o after reperfusion normalized only in the 1 x 60-min group.

CONCLUSIONS

The DC potential may provide a reliable measure to optimize intermittent ischemia and to achieve minimal ischemic brain injury during temporary neurosurgical occlusion of cerebral arteries.

Neuronal damage in gerbils caused by intermittent forebrain ischemia

OBJECT

The purpose of this study was to investigate the possibility of preventing cumulative neuronal damage after repetitive severe ischemia.

METHODS

The authors monitored ischemic depolarization in the gerbil hippocampus, which has recently been shown to be a good experimental model of the effects of brief ischemia on the brain, and evaluated neuronal damage in the CA1 subregion 7 days after the ischemic insult. In a single-ischemia paradigm, the results indicate that induction of ischemia-induced neuronal damage depended on the duration of ischemic depolarization. Neuronal damage can be detected in the CA1 subregion after a period of depolarization lasting 210 seconds. Using a double-ischemia paradigm in which the animals were subjected to two periods of ischemia, there was apparently no accumulation of neuronal damage from the first ischemic episode to the second, provided the duration of the first period of ischemic depolarization did not exceed 90 seconds. Neuronal damage accumulated when the duration of the first ischemia episode exceeded 90 seconds, regardless of the duration of the reperfusion interval between the two ischemic insults. Finally, when the ischemic insult was spread over four separate episodes, each lasting 90 seconds (with a reperfusion interval of 5 minutes), neuronal damage was not found when the total depolarization period was less than 420 seconds.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors conclude that cumulative neuronal damage may be avoided by adopting an intermittent ischemia approach. The implications of these results for human surgery requiring temporary occlusion of the cerebral arteries are discussed.

Reproducibility of cerebral cortical infarction in the wistar rat after middle cerebral artery occlusion

Although middle cerebral artery (MCA) occlusion in the rat is often used to study focal cerebral ischemia, the model of ischemia affects the size and reproducibility of infarction. The purpose of this experiment was to methodically examine different preparations to determine the optimum focal cerebral ischemia model to produce a reproducible severe ischemic injury. Eighty-two Wistar rats underwent either 1 hour, 3 hour, or permanent MCA occlusion combined with no, unilateral, or bilateral common carotid artery artery (CCA) occlusion. Three days after ischemia, the animals were prepared for tetrazolium chloride assessment of infarction size. One-hour MCA occlusion produced a coefficient of variation (CV) of 200% with an infarction volume of 20.3+/-10.5 mm(3). Adding unilateral or bilateral CCA occlusion resulted in a CV of 134% and 101%, respectively. Three-hour MCA occlusion combined with bilateral CCA occlusion decreased the CV to 58% with a cortical infarction volume of 82.6+/-12.1 mm(3), P<05, compared with 1-hour MCA occlusion with or without CCA occlusion. Permanent MCA occlusion combined with 3 hours of bilateral CCA occlusion resulted in a CV of 47% with a cortical infarction volume of 89.6+/-16.0 mm(3). These results indicate that 3-hour MCA occlusion combined with bilateral CCA occlusion provide consistently a large infarction volume after temporary focal cerebral ischemia.

Temporary occlusion of the middle cerebral artery in intracranial aneurysm surgery: time limitation and advantage of brain protection

The risk of focal infarction secondary to the induced reversible arrest of local arterial flow during microsurgical dissection of middle cerebral artery (MCA) aneurysms was evaluated further to define the optimal approach to temporary arterial occlusion. To compare the effectiveness of potential brain-protection anesthetics, a group of patients treated with the intravenous agents propofol, etomidate, and pentobarbital, administered individually or in combination, was compared to a group treated with the inhalational agent isoflurane. Forty-nine consecutive MCA aneurysm surgeries involving the temporary clipping of the parent vessel were retrospectively reviewed. Thirty-eight patients received intravenous brain-protection (IVBP) anesthesia. Groups of patients with and without infarctions, and receiving and not receiving IVBP anesthesia, were compared based on the duration and nature of temporary arterial occlusion. Postoperative radiographic evidence of new infarction was used as the threshold for failure of occlusion tolerance. The overall infarction rate was 22.4% (11 of 49 patients), including 15.8% (six of 38 patients) in the IVBP group versus 45.5% (five of 11 patients) in the group that did not receive brain protection (NBP). In the NBP group, the mean duration of temporary occlusion was 3.9 +/- 2.2 minutes for patients without infarction versus 12.2 +/- 4.3 minutes for patients with focal infarction (p < 0.01). In contrast, the mean duration was 13.6 +/- 10.6 minutes for patients without infarction and 18.5 +/- 9.9 minutes for patients with infarction in the IVBP group. All patients (four of four) in the NBP group who underwent occlusion lasting 10 minutes or longer suffered an infarction versus five of 23 patients in the IVBP group (p < 0.0001). Patients with multiple aneurysms were found to be at increased risk of developing focal infarction, whereas those treated with intermittent temporary clip application were at decreased risk. It is concluded that patients in whom focal iatrogenic ischemia is induced during MCA aneurysm clip ligation have a significant advantage compared with those receiving isoflurane when they are given pentobarbital as the primary neuroprotective agent or when they receive propofol or etomidate titrated to achieve electroencephalographic burst suppression, particularly if more than 10 minutes of occlusion time is required. It is also concluded that 10 minutes is a general guideline for safe, temporary occlusion of the MCA. The use of intermittent temporary arterial occlusion and its use in patients with multiple aneurysms need further evaluation before specific recommendations can be made.

Temporary vessel occlusion during intracranial aneurysm repair

Any method that decreases the risk of intraoperative rupture should improve outcome if complications associated with its use do not negate positive effect. If application time is limited and a form of cerebral protection and appropriate monitoring of cerebral function are used, temporary clip application may meet these requirements. The efficacy of temporary occlusion as an adjunct to aneurysm clipping may be limited by technical considerations with respect to regional anatomy, aneurysm size, and aneurysm consistency. In areas of limited access, positioning proximal clips may not be feasible. The use of endovascular techniques of balloon occlusion may provide proximal control in these situations (9, 106). The decision to use total circulatory arrest and profound hypothermia, as opposed to temporary clip application, remains largely a matter of the surgeon's judgment. The role of proximal parent vessel ligation must also be considered in the decision-making process regarding the treatment of giant or technically difficult aneurysms (114). Further refinements in cerebral monitoring that can accurately reflect intracellular processes in all territories affected by the application of temporary clips or balloon occlusion and development of more effective forms of cerebral protection may permit safer use of this technique. An adequately controlled clinical trial of temporary occlusion with or without putative "cerebral protection" is needed to confirm the efficacy of this technique.

Cerebral protection by intermittent reperfusion during temporary focal ischemia in the rat

Temporary arterial occlusion has been routinely used as an adjunct in intracranial aneurysm surgery. This has commonly been performed using a protocol of multiple short periods of occlusion alternating with periods of restoration of normal circulation. Recently, the logical basis of this method has come under scrutiny. There is extensive experimental evidence to suggest that repetitive, brief periods of global ischemia may cause more severe cerebral injury than an equivalent single period of global ischemia. Only recently has this issue begun to be addressed with regard to focal ischemia. Hence, despite the common use of temporary clipping, little experimental data are available regarding the ischemic consequences of temporary arterial occlusion with periods of reperfusion versus uninterrupted temporary occlusion. To investigate this issue, a protocol of occlusion/reperfusion that simulates the temporal profile that occurs during surgery was performed in a rat model of focal ischemia. Sixteen anesthetized Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into two groups. The animals in Group I underwent 60 minutes of uninterrupted middle cerebral artery occlusion and the animals in Group II were subjected to six separate 10-minute occlusion periods with 5 minutes of reperfusion between occlusions. Histopathological analysis was performed 72 hours postischemia. Group I had significantly increased mean infarction volumes (50.0 +/- 12.1 mm3) compared to Group II (8.7 +/- 3.1 mm3) (p = 0.008). Injuries in Group I occurred in both the cortex and striatum, whereas Group II showed only striatal injuries. Furthermore, the extent of the injuries in Group II was less severe, characterized by ischemic neuronal injury rather than frank infarction. The results indicate that intermittent reperfusion is neuroprotective during temporary focal ischemia and support the hypothesis that intermittent reperfusion is beneficial if temporary clipping is required during aneurysm repair.

Interrupted arterial occlusion reduces ischemic damage in a focal cerebral ischemia model of rats

It is generally thought by neurosurgeons that when temporary clipping of a major cerebral vessel is necessary during aneurysm surgery, repeated short periods of cerebral ischemia are safer for the brain than a single long episode. This study was performed to investigate whether repetitive short episodes of cerebral ischemia would alter the resulting brain injury as compared with a single long period of ischemia in a rat model for focal cerebral ischemia. Middle cerebral artery occlusion and reperfusion were performed by the intraluminal thread technique. The experimental design consisted of a single 90-minute occlusion period in the continuous ischemia group versus three 30-minute occlusion periods with 15-minute reperfusion periods in the repetitive group. Local cerebral blood flow was measured by the hydrogen clearance technique. During the ischemic period, local cerebral blood flow values significantly decreased in both the continuous and the repetitive groups. Cerebral blood flow restoration was demonstrated after each episode of reperfusion in both groups. The neurological status scores 2 hours after surgery in the rats subjected to repetitive insults were significantly better compared with those in the rats of the continuous ischemia group. However, the scores on Days 1, 3, and 7 did not show a significantly better difference. The animals were killed 7 days after the induction of ischemia for the measurement of the infarction area under the microscope. The total area of infarction was significantly reduced (4.05 +/- 4.56 versus 47.2 +/- 37.3 mm2, P < 0.001) by interruption of the ischemic time period.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effect of intermittent reperfusion and nitric oxide synthase inhibition on infarct volume during reversible focal cerebral ischemia

The authors examined the effects of both intermittent reperfusion and nitric oxide synthase (NOS) inhibition, caused by NG-nitro-L-arginine methyl ester (L-NAME) during episodes of focal cerebral ischemia induced to simulate the neurosurgical setting. Seventy-eight Wistar rats underwent single (60 minutes of ischemia) or repetitive (four 15-minute periods of ischemia separated by 5 minutes of reperfusion) episodes of middle cerebral artery occlusion while under anesthesia (1.0% halothane). Twenty-four hours after the procedure, the animals were given neurological examinations and then sacrificed for histological preparation and examination. The intermittent reperfusion groups tended to have smaller mean cortical infarctions. There was also a trend showing a decrease in infarction size in groups given L-NAME. The combination of intermittent reperfusion and preischemic administration of L-NAME (10 mg/kg) resulted in a 65% reduction in infarction size (p < 0.05) when compared to that caused by 60 minutes of single occlusion without L-NAME. The use of NOS inhibition combined with intermittent reperfusion may be a technique to provide intraoperative cerebral protection during neurovascular procedures that require temporary vascular occlusion.

Effects of intermittent reperfusion on brain pHi, rCBF, and NADH during rabbit focal cerebral ischemia

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The use of intermittent reperfusion versus straight occlusion during neurovascular procedures is controversial. This experiment studied the effects of intermittent reperfusion and single occlusion on intracellular brain pH (pHi), regional cerebral or cortical blood flow, and nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) fluorescence during temporary focal ischemia.

METHODS

Twenty fasted rabbits under 1.0% halothane anesthesia were divided into four groups: (1) nonischemic controls, (2) 60 minutes of uninterrupted focal ischemia, (3) 2 x 30-minute periods of focal ischemia separated by a 5-minute reperfusion, and (4) 4 x 15-minute periods of focal ischemia separated by three 5-minute reperfusion periods. Focal ischemia was produced by occlusion of both the middle cerebral and ipsilateral anterior cerebral arteries. After the final occlusion, there was a 3-hour reperfusion period in all groups. Regional cerebral and cortical blood flow, brain pHi, and NADH fluorescence were measured with in vivo panoramic fluorescence imaging.

RESULTS

During occlusion, regional cerebral and cortical blood flows and NADH fluorescence values were not different among the groups. Brain pHi was significantly lower in the 4 x 15-minute group compared with the 1 x 60-minute group (6.57 +/- 0.02 versus 6.73 +/- 0.06; P < .03) but not significant when compared with the 2 x 30-minute group. During the short reperfusion periods, all parameters returned to normal except for NADH fluorescence levels, which remained elevated. During the postischemic final reperfusion period, there was a mild brain alkalosis of approximately 7.1 in all groups. There were no significant differences in NADH fluorescence among groups during the final reperfusion. Regional cerebral and cortical blood flow returned to near normal values in all groups.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that intermittent reperfusion during temporary focal ischemia has different effects on the intracytoplasmic and the intramitochondrial compartments: worsening of brain cytoplasmic pHi but no significant differences in the oxidation/reduction level of mitochondrial NADH.