Conditions for excellence in teaching in medical education: The Frankfurt Model to ensure quality in teaching and learning

Differences in clerkship development between public and private Brazilian medical schools: an overview

BACKGROUND

Around the world, it is very expensive to become a physician. Although public medical schools are less expensive than private medical schools, tuition fees are charged at public medical schools in the majority of countries. In Brazil, public medical schools, with the exception of municipal schools, are free. There has been little investigation of any differences in conditions offered by paid or free medical schools or what occurs in public and private clerkships in Brazil. We investigated the clerkship conditions offered to the students in both public and private Brazilian medical schools by gathering the opinions of clerkship coordinators and others responsible for clerkships.

METHODS

A cross-sectional, descriptive, analytical study using an electronic questionnaire was answered by clerkship coordinators to compare the clerkships of 30 public and 38 private Brazilian medical schools from all regions of the country. The questionnaires covered various aspects of the clinical environments, student supervision, faculty development, student assessments, rotation evaluations and extracurricular activities developed by students.

RESULTS

We observed significant differences between public and private medical schools in several aspects investigated. Based on the opinions of the clerkship coordinators, with the exception of access to university hospitals, which was predominantly offered by public medical schools, private medical schools offer better clerkship conditions. The main differences were related to the number of positions, infrastructure, clinical learning environments, faculty development, student assessments, rotation evaluations and students' extracurricular activities.

CONCLUSION

This is the first study comparing Brazilian medical clerkships in private and public medical schools and provides a general vision of these programmes. It is necessary to further investigate clerkship development in the Brazilian medical school system and to study the differences between private and public medical schools globally.

How curricular changes influence medical students' perceptions of basic science: A pilot study

Theory

The perceived value of study material may have implications on learning and long-term retention. This study compares the perceived value of basic science of medical students from schools with a traditional “2+2” curriculum and the USMLE Step 1 placed before core clerkships to those from medical schools that have undergone curricular revisions, resulting in shortened pre-clerkship curricula and administration of the USMLE Step 1 after core clerkships.

Hypothesis

We hypothesize that differences in curricula, particularly duration of pre-clerkship curriculum and timing of the USMLE Step 1, affect medical students’ perceived value of basic science.

Methods

A twenty item anonymous questionnaire using a 5-point Likert scale was developed to assess medical students’ perceptions of basic science. The questionnaire was distributed to third-year medical students across four medical schools. Generalized linear models and p-values were calculated comparing the perceived value and use of basic science between medical schools with the USMLE Step 1 before clerkships and 2-years of basic science (BC) and medical schools with the USMLE Step 1 after core clerkships and 1.5-years of basic science (AC).

Results

The questionnaire was distributed to 695 eligible students and completed by 287 students. Students at BC schools tended to view basic science as more essential for clinical practice than students at AC schools across both outcomes (rating independence of basic science and clinical practice, AC school mean = 2.97, BC school mean = 2.73, p = 0.0017; rating importance of basic science to clinical practice, AC school mean = 3.30, BC schools mean = 3.50, p = 0.0135).

Conclusions

Our study suggests that students who have a longer basic science curriculum tend to value basic science greater than students with a shorter basic science curriculum. The timing of the USMLE Step 1 may also influence this relationship. Curricular decisions, such as reductions in pre-clerkship curricula and administration of the USMLE Step 1 after clerkships, may impact medical students’ perceptions of the value of basic science to clinical practice. This can have implications on their future engagement with basic science and should be considered when modifying curriculum.

Concept and contents of a voluntary course for medical students' achievement of a basic qualification in patient safety during the practical year of medical studies

Objective: Regarding the urgent need of qualification in the field of patient safety, the respective education and training were completed by a voluntary course for 10-15 students in their practical year (PY) provided in cooperation of the private University Hospital of Marburg and the Medical Faculty of the Philipps-University of Marburg. At the same time, this course was intended to develop important knowledge for implementing improvements of the current PY teaching as well as revising the curriculum of Marburg in the medium term. Project description: The PY course on patient safety is offered every six months since 2016 and comprises about 80 lessons. It is based on the principles of shifting simple knowledge transfer to autonomous preparation by the students themselves, of revising already experienced situations of the professional routine, of working with real data of current patients of the PY students, of fostering teamwork, and of applying very deliberately a large combination of methods with numerous interactive types of teaching. The topics of those 13 course units include the majority of the most important problem categories of patient safety as reported in the literature such as communication, drug safety, diagnostic errors, and handovers as well as methods for systematic identification and analysis of errors. In the context of a project task, the students evaluate by means of the global trigger tool and 10 patient files of their current wards each if harm has occurred in the treatment of these patients. Afterwards, the students elaborate in teams of 2 a fishbone diagram for one case where an avoidable harm had emerged. In this graph, the deficient process, the factors contributing to its development, the safety measures that are already applied in the department as well as suggested improvements of the students are visualized. In the final lesson of the course, the students explain and describe their diagram to a member of the managing board of the university hospital. Successful participation is confirmed by an official certificate issued by the Medical Center for Quality in Medicine (Ärztliches Zentrum für Qualität in der Medizin) stating that the course meets the level II requirements ("Basic qualification") of the training concept on "patient safety" of the Germany medical staff. Results: After meanwhile 5 episodes of this course, the whole curriculum obtained a mean score of "very good" based on the standard questionnaire of the Medical Faculty of the University of Marburg. The students perceive an enormous increase in competence regarding the implementation of specific projects to improve patient safety. Furthermore, the intensive cooperation with the PY students led to conceiving and establishing further 7 PY courses for the benefit of patient safety and consolidation of entrustable professional activities. In combination with experiences gained elsewhere from courses on patient safety, the collected knowledge could be used for a first draft of teaching and education of patient safety during the entire clinical studies that takes into account the local conditions. Conclusion: In the process of anchoring the topic of patient safety in the Marburg curriculum of medical studies, the introduction of an extensive voluntary course in the second four months of the clinical internship (practical year) turned out to have a very positive effect. Supported by the management board of the hospital and the medical faculty, we consider it useful to permanently provide such an extensive course for a group of students who want to early and intensively deal with the topic of patient safety.