The Impact of Anosognosia on Clinical and Patient-Reported Assessments of Psychiatric Symptoms in Huntington's Disease

Frequency of depression in Huntington's disease: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Huntington's disease (HD) is a hereditary neurodegenerative disease characterized by a combination of motor, cognitive, and mental health issues, with depression being the most common. Despite its importance, the relationship between depression and disease progression is still debatable.

OBJECTIVE

The primary objective of this study was to examine the frequency of depression across different disease stages in individuals with HD. We also explored the associations between depression and other HD-related factors.

METHODS

This systematic review comprehensively searched MEDLINE, APA PsycINFO, and Embase databases for studies on depression in individuals with HD. Pooled depression frequencies were calculated for premanifest and manifest HD. Depression was analyzed based on HD functional stages and diagnostic tools, alongside reviewing its association with various HD factors.

RESULTS

We assessed 6523 records and included 104 studies. Our meta-analyses revealed that the overall frequency of depression was higher in manifest HD compared to premanifest HD (0.38 vs. 0.23). However, the progression of depression did not follow a consistent pattern, with peaks occurring in earlier rather than later stages. Additionally, the frequency of depression was lower in studies using diagnostic criteria compared to those using clinical scales (0.25 vs. 0.42).

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings showed that the rate of depression is high in HD and varies depending on the disease stage and the criteria used. This emphasizes the necessity for tailored and unified diagnostic criteria for depression in HD.

Apathy and Functional Status in Early-Stage Huntington's Disease

OBJECTIVE

Apathy is common in Huntington's disease (HD) and difficult to treat. Multiple recent calls have been made to increase understanding of apathy across the spectrum of HD severity. Functional status is an important outcome in HD trials; however, no consensus currently exists regarding the impact of apathy on functional status in HD. The authors aimed to identify correlates of apathy and effects on functional status in a primarily early-stage HD sample.

METHODS

This study included secondary analyses of data from a study of neuropsychiatric symptoms in a clinical HD sample. Spearman correlation analyses were used to assess the relationships between apathy (with the Frontal Systems Behavior Scale-Apathy [FrSBe-Apathy] subscore), clinical variables, and patient-reported outcomes. To assess the association of apathy with functional status, two multiple regression analyses were performed, with a different functional status measure (Adult Functional Adaptive Behavior [AFAB] scale or Total Functional Capacity [TFC] scale) as the dependent variable in each analysis.

RESULTS

Statistically significant correlates of apathy included the Quality of Life in Neurological Disorders (Neuro-QoL) Satisfaction With Social Roles and Activities and Neuro-QoL Positive Affect and Well-Being scores (N=70 patients). Univariate correlation analyses also revealed statistically significant associations of FrSBe-Apathy scores with both functional status measures. In the multiple regression analyses, apathy significantly contributed to variability in functional status as measured by both the AFAB (N=49 patients) and TFC (N=56 patients) scales.

CONCLUSIONS

These results underscore the need to address apathy as a target for improving functional status, social satisfaction, and well-being in HD, even for individuals with early-stage HD.

The effect of Huntington's disease on cognitive and physical motivation

Apathy is one of the most common neuropsychiatric features of Huntington's disease. A hallmark of apathy is diminished goal-directed behaviour, which is characterized by a lower motivation to engage in cognitively or physically effortful actions. However, it remains unclear whether this reduction in goal-directed behaviour is driven primarily by a motivational deficit and/or is secondary to the progressive cognitive and physical deficits that accompany more advanced disease. We addressed this question by testing 17 individuals with manifest Huntington's disease and 22 age-matched controls on an effort-based decision-making paradigm. Participants were first trained on separate cognitively and physically effortful tasks and provided explicit feedback about their performance. Next, they chose on separate trials how much effort they were willing to exert in each domain in return for varying reward. At the conclusion of the experiment, participants were asked to rate their subjective perception of task load. In the cognitive task, the Huntington's disease group were more averse to cognitive effort than controls. Although the Huntington's disease group were more impaired than controls on the task itself, their greater aversion to cognitive effort persisted even after controlling for task performance. This suggests that the lower levels of cognitive motivation in the Huntington's disease group relative to controls was most likely driven by a primary motivational deficit. In contrast, both groups expressed a similar preference for physical effort. Importantly, the similar levels of physical motivation across both groups occurred even though participants with Huntington's disease performed objectively worse than controls on the physical effort task, and were aware of their performance through explicit feedback on each trial. This indicates that the seemingly preserved level of physical motivation in Huntington's disease was driven by a willingness to engage in physically effortful actions despite a reduced capacity to do so. Finally, the Huntington's disease group provided higher ratings of subjective task demand than controls for the cognitive (but not physical) effort task and when assessing the mental (but not the physical) load of each task. Together, these results revealed a dissociation in cognitive and physical motivation deficits between Huntington's disease and controls, which were accompanied by differences in how effort was subjectively perceived by the two groups. This highlights that motivation is the final manifestation of a complex set of mechanisms involved in effort processing, which are separable across different domains of behaviour. These findings have important clinical implications for the day-to-day management of apathy in Huntington's disease.

Influence of anosognosia on patient-reported outcomes for psychiatric symptoms and quality of life in Huntington's disease

INTRODUCTION

Anosognosia, defined as reduced awareness of one's deficit or symptom, is common in Huntington's disease (HD) and detectable at each disease stage. The impact of anosognosia on self-reporting in HD populations is critical to understand given growing use of patient-reported outcomes in HD clinical care and research. We aimed to determine the influence of anosognosia on patient-reported outcome measures assessing psychiatric symptoms and quality of life in HD.

METHODS

We enrolled HD patients to complete a battery of patient-reported and rater-administered measures, including the Anosognosia Scale, at baseline and 6 months later. Patient-reported outcome measures included NeuroQoL short forms for depression, anxiety, satisfaction with social roles and activities, and positive affect and well-being and Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System short forms for emotional distress-anger and sleep-related impairment. Anosognosia Scale-Difference Score indexed patient-clinician agreement on patient motor, cognitive, and behavioral abilities. We conducted multivariable linear regression analyses to quantify the association of baseline anosognosia with 6-month patient-reported outcomes.

RESULTS

Of 79 patients with complete Anosognosia Scale data at baseline, 25 (31.6 %) met the scale's criterion for anosognosia. In the regression analyses, baseline Difference Score improved prediction of 6-month patient-reported outcomes for depression, anxiety, anger, and positive affect and well-being (χ2(1) value range for likelihood ratio tests contrasting models with and without Difference Score: 13.1-20.9, p-values <0.001). Patients with more anosognosia self-reported less severe psychiatric symptoms and more positive affect and well-being.

CONCLUSION

Study results suggest that anosognosia influences patient-reported outcomes for psychiatric symptoms and quality of life in HD populations.

"I don't have Huntington's disease": the boundaries between acceptance and understanding

Huntington's disease (HD) is an inherited disease that leads to an inexorable progression of motor, cognitive and psychiatric disturbances. In the initial stages, the symptoms are not clearly disabling, and the patient may present a lack of awareness about the symptoms themselves, which we call anosognosia. However, anosognosia might not justify all passivity of the HD patient in face of the diagnosis. Patients may also experience the denial of illness, as a stage of grief, expected to happen in the face of the diagnosis of any neurodegenerative disorder. In addition, people with HD tend to be more apathetic, and more silent, in regular consultations. In the present article, the authors express a point of view, discussing the behavior of the HD patient, in which there is a multifactorial passivity, in the face of the diagnosis and of the disease itself. Having the proper knowledge of this situation may prepare the neurologist to better understand the patient and the evolution of the disease.

Safety and efficacy of valbenazine for the treatment of chorea associated with Huntington's disease (KINECT-HD): a phase 3, randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial

BACKGROUND

Valbenazine is a highly selective vesicular monoamine transporter 2 (VMAT2) inhibitor approved for treatment of tardive dyskinesia. To address the ongoing need for improved symptomatic treatments for individuals with Huntington's disease, valbenazine was evaluated for the treatment of chorea associated with Huntington's disease.

METHODS

KINECT-HD (NCT04102579) was a phase 3, randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial, performed in 46 Huntington Study Group sites in the USA and Canada. The study included adults with genetically confirmed Huntington's disease and chorea (Unified Huntington's Disease Rating Scale [UHDRS] Total Maximal Chorea [TMC] score of 8 or higher) who were randomly assigned (1:1) via an interactive web response system (with no stratification or minimisation) to oral placebo or valbenazine (≤80 mg, as tolerated) for 12 weeks of double-blinded treatment. The primary endpoint was a least-squares mean change in UHDRS TMC score from the screening and baseline period (based on the average of screening and baseline values for each participant) to the maintenance period (based on the average of week 10 and 12 values for each participant) in the full-analysis set using a mixed-effects model for repeated measures. Safety assessments included treatment-emergent adverse events, vital signs, electrocardiograms, laboratory tests, clinical tests for parkinsonism, and psychiatric assessments. The double-blind placebo-controlled period of KINECT-HD has been completed, and an open-label extension period is ongoing.

FINDINGS

KINECT-HD was performed from Nov 13, 2019, to Oct 26, 2021. Of 128 randomly assigned participants, 125 were included in the full-analysis set (64 assigned to valbenazine, 61 assigned to placebo) and 127 were included in the safety-analysis set (64 assigned to valbenazine, 63 assigned to placebo). The full-analysis set included 68 women and 57 men. Least-squares mean changes from the screening and baseline period to the maintenance period in the UHDRS TMC score were -4·6 for valbenazine and -1·4 for placebo (least-squares mean difference -3·2, 95% CI -4·4 to -2·0; p<0·0001). The most commonly reported treatment-emergent adverse event was somnolence (ten [16%] with valbenazine, two [3%] with placebo). Serious treatment-emergent adverse events were reported in two participants in the placebo group (colon cancer and psychosis) and one participant in the valbenazine group (angioedema because of allergic reaction to shellfish). No clinically important ch anges in vital signs, electrocardiograms, or laboratory tests were found. No suicidal behaviour or worsening of suicidal ideation was reported in participants treated with valbenazine.

INTERPRETATION

In individuals with Huntington's disease, valbenazine resulted in improvement in chorea compared with placebo and was well tolerated. Continued research is needed to confirm the long-term safety and effectiveness of this medication throughout the disease course in individuals with Huntington's disease-related chorea.

FUNDING

Neurocrine Biosciences.

Anosognosia in HD: Comparison of self-report and caregiver ratings with objective performance measures

INTRODUCTION

Individuals with Huntington's disease (HD) commonly experience anosognosia, a lack of awareness of deficits. Thus, it is important to examine the accuracy of patient vs caregiver ratings on the basis of objective performance-based measures.

METHODS

The Anosognosia Scale (AS) was given to 33 patients with manifest HD and their caregivers. The AS consists of 8 items in which individuals rate their global abilities relative to same-aged peers. Scores range from very impaired to excellent. Caregiver and patient ratings were then correlated with objective measures.

RESULTS

Caregivers' evaluations of patients' cognitive and motoric abilities were more highly correlated with objective measures than patients' ratings. Specifically, caregivers' AS item scores were highly correlated with objective measures of walking (Unified Huntington Disease Rating Scale (UHDRS) tandem walking score [r = 0.57, p = .001] vs. patient [r = 0.39, p = .031]); dexterity (UHDRS pronation supination score [r = 0.55, p = .011] vs. patient [r = 0.18, p = .393]); speech (UHDRS dysarthria score [r = 0.55, p = .004] vs. patient [r = 0.03, p = .854]); memory (MoCA score [r = -.45, p = .048] vs. patient [r = -.11, p = .963]); attention (Trails Making Test A score [r = 0.58, p = .004] vs. patient [r = 0.08, p = .686]); and word retrieval (category fluency ([r = -.58, p = .004] vs. patient [r = -.02, p = 1.00]). Moreover, both the UHDRS total motor score (TMS) (F(1,29) = 7.50, p = .010) and the Mini Mental Status Exam (MMSE) (F(1,31) = 5.40, p = .027) were significant predictors of patient levels of anosognosia.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings indicate that caregivers may be better able to rate HD patients' cognitive and motor abilities than patients themselves. Both cognitive and motor severity are significant predictors of levels of anosognosia in HD.

Frequency and Pathophysiology of Apathy in Huntington Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

OBJECTIVE

Apathy is a common behavioral symptom of Huntington disease (HD). This systematic review describes current evidence on the pathophysiology, assessment, and frequency of apathy in HD.

METHODS

This systematic review was conducted in accordance with PRISMA guidelines. Using a comprehensive search strategy, the investigators searched the MEDLINE, Embase, and PsycINFO databases. All studies that evaluated apathy in HD patients with a valid scale and reported apathy frequency or scores were included. Apathy scores were analyzed by mean or standardized mean differences in accordance with Cochrane guidelines.

RESULTS

A total of 1,085 records were screened and 80 studies were ultimately included. The Problem Behaviors Assessment-Short was the most frequently used apathy assessment tool. Apathy frequency generally ranged from 10%-33% in premanifest HD to 24%-76% in manifest HD. A meta-analysis of 5,311 records of patients with premanifest HD showed significantly higher apathy scores, with a standardized mean difference of 0.41 (CI=0.29-0.52; p<0.001). A comparison of 1,247 patients showed significantly higher apathy scores in manifest than premanifest HD, with a mean difference of 1.87 (CI=1.48-2.26; p<0.001). There was evidence of involvement of various cortical and subcortical brain regions in HD patients with apathy.

CONCLUSIONS

Apathy was more frequent among individuals with premanifest HD compared with those in a control group and among individuals with manifest HD compared with those with premanifest HD. Considering the complexity and unique pattern of development in neurodegenerative disease, further studies are required to explore the pathophysiology of apathy in HD.

Anosognosia and Memory Encoding in Huntington Disease

BACKGROUND

Anosognosia can manifest as an unawareness of neurobehavioral symptoms in individuals with Huntington disease (HD). Measurement of anosognosia is challenging, but the Anosognosia Scale (AS) represents a brief option with promising findings in small samples.

OBJECTIVE

To replicate application of the AS in a larger HD sample than previous studies in order to assess psychometrics and demographic correlates and to investigate the genetic, motor, and neuropsychological correlates of the AS in individuals with HD.

METHOD

We retrospectively reviewed the AS ratings of 74 genetically confirmed Huntington gene carriers, nearly all early motor manifest, who had been referred for clinical neuropsychological assessment. Concurrent clinical neurologic examination and neuropsychometric assessment data were compiled, where available (ns = 35-74). The severity of the anosognosia per AS ratings was characterized for the HD sample.

RESULTS

The AS ratings did not correlate with demographic variables, genetic markers, or motor dysfunction severity. Correlation analyses revealed that higher AS ratings correlated with worse recognition-discrimination memory performance (r = 0.38, P < 0.05) but not cognitive control on executive functioning performance or on collateral-reported frontal-behavioral symptoms. Higher AS ratings also correlated with fewer patient-reported depressive symptoms (r = -0.38, P < 0.01) and diurnal hypersomnia symptoms (r = -0.44, P < 0.01).

CONCLUSION

Anosognosia (per AS) is associated with recognition-discrimination deficits and fewer self-reported neuropsychiatric symptoms in individuals with pre-to-early manifest HD, though not with HD severity per genetic or motor markers, nor to executive dysfunction or collateral-reported frontal-behavioral symptoms.

Perceived Effects of Neuropsychiatric Symptoms on Functional Status in Early-stage Huntington Disease

Neuropsychiatric symptoms in Huntington disease (HD) are commonly encountered, but their effects on functional status are poorly understood. In this qualitative study guided by the Theory of Unpleasant Symptoms, 15 HD patients and caregivers completed semi-structured interviews regarding perceived effects of neuropsychiatric symptoms on functional status. Physical, cognitive, and social functional effects were reported, with negative effects on daily activities and social withdrawal being reported by the greatest number of subjects. Participants also reported improved function with intervention for neuropsychiatric symptoms. This study provides a novel description of the lived experiences of HD patients with neuropsychiatric symptoms.

Understanding the Burdens Associated with Huntington’s Disease in Manifest Patients and Care Partners–Comparing to Parkinson’s Disease and the General Population

Background: The study provides real-world data on the impact of Huntington’s disease (HD) from the perspective of individuals with HD (IHD) and care partners (HD-CP) and contextualizes these results relative to Parkinson’s disease (PD) and the general population (GP). Methods: Cross-sectional survey of IHD and HD-CP in the US (July 2019–August 2019) conducted using the Rare Patient Voice panel. Data for individuals with Parkinson’s Disease (IPD), the general population (GP), and respective care partners (PD-CP; GP-CP) came from the 2018 US National Health and Wellness Survey. Outcomes included demographics, mental health, clinical characteristics, and health-related quality of life (HRQoL). Results: IHD had greater comorbid anxiety (IHD = 51.2%, IPD = 28.8%, GP = 2.0%), and HD-CP had greater comorbid anxiety (HD-CP = 52.5%, PD-CP = 28.6%, GP-CP = 19.6%) and depression (HD-CP = 65.0%, PD-CP = 29.9%, GP-CP = 19.6%), relative to other cohorts (p < 0.05). Respective of their GP cohorts, IHD exhibited lower HRQoL (EQ-5D: 0.66 ± 0.21 vs. 0.81 ± 0.17) and greater depression (PHQ-9: 11.59 ± 7.20 vs. 5.85 ± 6.71), whereas HD-CP exhibited greater depression only (PHQ-9: 6.84 ± 6.38 vs. 4.15 ± 5.58) (p < 0.001). No differences were observed between HD/HD-CP and PD/PD-CP cohorts on PHQ-9 or HRQoL. Conclusions: HD has a significant burden on patients and care partners, which is higher than GP. Notably, anxiety and depression were greater among HD vs. PD, despite similar HRQoL.

Social Withdrawal in Huntington's Disease: A Scoping Review

BACKGROUND

Huntington's disease (HD) commonly presents with impaired social functioning. Specifically, many patients exhibit social withdrawal, or decreased engagement in social activities. Despite the frequency of social withdrawal in HD, no review has been previously published on this subject.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to conduct a scoping review of social withdrawal in HD.

METHODS

Two searches were conducted to identify relevant literature. The articles were screened by title and abstract, followed by full text review for all remaining articles. Consistent with scoping review methodology, data extraction focused on identification of broad themes and knowledge gaps.

RESULTS

Eight articles were identified that described social withdrawal in HD. Social withdrawal was exhibited by individuals with varying disease severity, and it occurred both within and outside of the home. Social withdrawal was associated with increased caregiver burden, behavioral issues, and psychiatric, cognitive, and physiological changes. Only one case study described an intervention that increased social participation in a previously withdrawn patient.

CONCLUSION

Although social withdrawal is commonly encountered in clinical settings, this review highlights the need for prospective studies to systematically evaluate social withdrawal in HD. These studies should be designed to consider disease stage and associated HD features as well as caregiver burden and potential interventions. Additionally, objective measures of social withdrawal should be used when possible, as existing instruments measure perceptions of participation levels rather than actual withdrawal behavior. Such studies will lay the groundwork to improve social functioning and quality of life for people with HD.

The Relationship Between Plasma Oxytocin and Executive Functioning in Huntington's Disease: A Pilot Study

The role of oxytocin (OT) in social cognition of patients with Huntington's disease (HD) has been studied, but its impact on executive functioning has not been explored yet. Healthy controls, premanifest HD, and manifest HD participants underwent executive functioning assessment and OT plasma measurement. There were no significant group differences in plasma OT levels. Higher OT levels were associated with better executive functioning in premanifest HD participants. Our findings revealed an association between OT levels and depressive symptoms in premanifest and manifest HD participants. The potential role of OT in HD deserves further investigation.

State-of-the-art pharmacological approaches to reduce chorea in Huntington's disease

Introduction Chorea is a common motor manifestation of Huntington's disease (HD). Two vesicular monoamine transporter type 2 (VMAT-2) inhibitors have been approved by the FDA for treatment of HD chorea, and a third is currently being assessed in a phase 3 trial. Antipsychotic therapies are used off-label for treatment of chorea and can treat comorbid psychiatric symptoms. There is considerable clinical equipoise regarding the safe and effective treatment of chorea and comorbid symptoms in HD.Areas covered: The authors review existing medications used to treat HD chorea in the United States of America (USA). Implications for common comorbid symptoms (e.g. psychiatric, metabolic) are also discussed. Available therapies vary widely in cost, dosing frequency, and off -target effects, both beneficial or negative.Expert opinion: Treatment considerations for chorea should account for patient comorbidities. The authors recommend prospective, observational clinical effectiveness studies which can evaluate the long-term comparative effectiveness and safety of VMAT-2 inhibitors and antipsychotics in HD. Data regarding safety of dual therapy is another critical need. This is especially timely given the changing landscape of HD therapies which may increase cost burden and possibly extend both asymptomatic and symptomatic years for HD patients.