Vertical nystagmus in normal subjects: Effects of head position, nicotine and scopolamine

Downbeat nystagmus: a clinical and pathophysiological review

Downbeat nystagmus (DBN) is a neuro-otological finding frequently encountered by clinicians dealing with patients with vertigo. Since DBN is a finding that should be understood because of central vestibular dysfunction, it is necessary to know how to frame it promptly to suggest the correct diagnostic-therapeutic pathway to the patient. As knowledge of its pathophysiology has progressed, the importance of this clinical sign has been increasingly understood. At the same time, clinical diagnostic knowledge has increased, and it has been recognized that this sign may occur sporadically or in association with others within defined clinical syndromes. Thus, in many cases, different therapeutic solutions have become possible. In our work, we have attempted to systematize current knowledge about the origin of this finding, the clinical presentation and current treatment options, to provide an overview that can be used at different levels, from the general practitioner to the specialist neurologist or neurotologist.

The Use of Video-Head Impulse Test in Different Head Positions in Vertical Nystagmus and Ataxia Associated with Probable Thiamine Deficiency

Upward and downward bias of eye movement signals in the semicircular canals (SCC)- and/or otolith-related central pathways have been proposed to explain the occurrence of vertical nystagmus (downbeat nystagmus [DBN] and upbeat nystagmus [UBN]) and its frequent modulation with head position. Video-head impulse test (VHIT), usually performed in upright position, is a recent development for measuring SCC function. We performed longitudinal nystagmus and VHIT assessments in different head positions in a patient with probable thiamine deficiency, in order to explore a possible relationship between the positional behavior of vertical nystagmus and SCC function. Initially, UBN in upright position changed to DBN in prone position and remained relatively unchanged in supine position. This was associated with both anterior and posterior SCC hyperactive responses in upright position, and a relative enhancement of the anterior SCC responses in prone position and the posterior SCC responses in supine position. Over 1 year, in prone position, change from UBN to DBN and the enhancement of anterior SCC responses remained, while in supine position, UBN either decreased or changed to DBN, when compared to upright position. This was associated with a relative enhancement of the anterior SCC responses in supine position, albeit inconsistently, and the presence of posterior SCC hypoactive responses in all positions, including prone. While not contradicting a primary otolithic dysfunction in the genesis of UBN change to DBN with head position, we provide evidence for positional modulation of SCC function in thiamine deficiency and a possible relationship with nystagmus positional behavior.

Conversion of upbeat to downbeat nystagmus in Wernicke encephalopathy

OBJECTIVE

To explain (1) why an initial upbeat nystagmus (UBN) converts to a permanent downbeat nystagmus (DBN) in Wernicke encephalopathy (WE) and (2) why convergence and certain vestibular provocative maneuvers may transiently switch UBN to DBN.

METHODS

Following a literature review and study of our 2 patients, we develop hypotheses for the unusual patterns of vertical nystagmus in WE.

RESULTS

Our overarching hypothesis is that there is a selective vulnerability and a selective recovery from thiamine deficiency of neurons within brainstem gaze-holding networks. Furthermore, since the circuits affected in WE are commonly paraventricular, especially medially, just under the floor of the fourth ventricle where lie structures important for control of vertical gaze, we suggest the patterns of involvement in WE also reflect a breakdown in vulnerable areas of the blood-brain barrier. Many of the initial deficits of our patients improved over time, but their DBN did not. Irreversible changes in paramedian tract neurons, which project to the cerebellar flocculus, may be the cause. Here we suggest that conversion of UBN to permanent DBN points to thiamine deficiency and may argue for a chronic, nonprogressive DBN/truncal ataxia syndrome. Finally, we posit that the transient switch of UBN to DBN reflects abnormal processing of otolith information about linear acceleration, and often points to a diagnosis of WE.

CONCLUSION

Recognizing the unusual patterns of transient switching and then permanent conversion of UBN to DBN in WE is vital since long-term disability from WE may be prevented by timely, parenteral high-dose thiamine.

Central positional nystagmus: Characteristics and model-based explanations

The central vestibular system operates to precisely estimate the rotational velocity and gravity orientation using the inherently ambiguous information from peripheral vestibular system. Therefore, any lesions disrupting this function can generate positional nystagmus. Central positional nystagmus (CPN) can be classified into the paroxysmal (transient) and persistent forms. The paroxysmal CPN has the features suggesting a semicircular canal origin regarding the latency, duration, and direction of nystagmus. Patients with paroxysmal CPN commonly show several different types of nystagmus classified according to the provoking positioning. The persistent form of CPN mostly appears as downbeat nystagmus while prone or supine, or apogeotropic or geotropic horizontal nystagmus when the head is turned to either side while supine. CPN may be ascribed to erroneous neural processing within the velocity-storage circuit that functions in estimating angular head velocity, gravity direction, and inertia. Paroxysmal CPN appears to be post-rotatory rebound nystagmus due to lesions involving the cerebellar nodulus and uvula. In contrast, persistent CPN may arise from erroneous gravity estimation. The overlap of lesion location responsible for both paroxysmal and persistent CPN may account for the frequent coexistence of both forms of nystagmus in a single patient.

Perception of Affordance during Short-Term Exposure to Weightlessness in Parabolic Flight

We investigated the role of the visual eye-height (VEH) in the perception of affordance during short-term exposure to weightlessness. Sixteen participants were tested during parabolic flight (0g) and on the ground (1g). Participants looked at a laptop showing a room in which a doorway-like aperture was presented. They were asked to adjust the opening of the virtual doorway until it was perceived to be just wide enough to pass through (i.e., the critical aperture). We manipulated VEH by raising the level of the floor in the visual room by 25 cm. The results showed effects of VEH and of gravity on the perceived critical aperture. When VEH was reduced (i.e., when the floor was raised), the critical aperture diminished, suggesting that widths relative to the body were perceived to be larger. The critical aperture was also lower in 0g, for a given VEH, suggesting that participants perceived apertures to be wider or themselves to be smaller in weightlessness, as compared to normal gravity. However, weightlessness also had an effect on the subjective level of the eyes projected into the visual scene. Thus, setting the critical aperture as a fixed percentage of the subjective visual eye-height remains a viable hypothesis to explain how human observers judge visual scenes in terms of potential for action or “affordances”.

Paraneoplastic disorders of eye movements

Paraneoplastic syndromes affecting the brainstem and cerebellum are reported to cause a variety of abnormalities of eye movements. Recent studies have begun to account for the mechanisms underlying several syndromes, characterized by opsoclonus, slow, or dysmetric saccades, as well as downbeat nystagmus. We provide evidence that upbeat nystagmus in a female patient with pancreatic cancer reflected a cerebellar-induced imbalance of otolithic pathways: she showed marked retropulsion, and her nystagmus was dependent on head position, being absent when supine, and suppressed with convergence. In addition to anti-Hu antibodies, we demonstrated antibodies to a novel neuronal cell surface antigen. Taken with other recent studies, our findings suggest that paraneoplastic syndromes arise due to antibodies against surface neuronal antigens, including receptors and channels. Abnormal eye movements in paraneoplastic syndromes offer insights into the pathogenesis of these disorders and the opportunity to test potential therapies, such as new drugs with effects on neuronal channels.

Nystagmus and saccadic intrusions

We review current concepts of nystagmus and saccadic oscillations, applying a pathophysiological approach. We begin by discussing how nystagmus may arise when the mechanisms that normally hold gaze steady are impaired. We then describe the clinical and laboratory evaluation of patients with ocular oscillations. Next, we systematically review the features of nystagmus arising from peripheral and central vestibular disorders, nystagmus due to an abnormal gaze-holding mechanism (neural integrator), and nystagmus occurring when vision is compromised. We then discuss forms of nystagmus for which the pathogenesis is not well understood, including acquired pendular nystagmus and congenital forms of nystagmus. We then summarize the spectrum of saccadic disorders that disrupt steady gaze, from intrusions to flutter and opsoclonus. Finally, we review current treatment options for nystagmus and saccadic oscillations, including drugs, surgery, and optical methods. Examples of each type of nystagmus are provided in the form of figures.

Effect of gravity on vertical eye position

There is growing evidence that gravity markedly influences vertical eye position and movements. A new model for the organization of brainstem upgaze pathways is presented in this review. The crossing ventral tegmental tract (CVTT) could be the efferent tract of an "antigravitational" pathway terminating at the elevator muscle motoneurons in the third nerve nuclei and comprising, upstream, the superior vestibular nucleus and y-group, the flocculus, and the otoliths. This pathway functions in parallel to the medial longitudinal fasciculus pathways, which control vertical eye movements made to compensate for all vertical head movements and may also comprise the "gravitational" vestibular pathways, involved in the central reflection of the gravity effect. The CVTT could provide the upgaze system with the supplement of tonic activity required to counteract the gravity effect expressed in the gravitational pathway, being permanently modulated according to the static positions of the head (i.e., the instantaneous gravity vector) between a maximal activity in the upright position and a minimal activity in horizontal positions. Different types of arguments support this new model. The permanent influence of gravity on vertical eye position is strongly suggested by the vertical slow phases and nystagmus observed after rapid changes in hypo- or hypergravity. The chin-beating nystagmus, existing in normal subjects with their head in the upside-down position, suggests that gravity is not compensated for in the downgaze system. Upbeat nystagmus due to brainstem lesions, most likely affecting the CVTT circuitry, is improved when the head is in the horizontal position, suggesting that this circuitry is involved in the counteraction of gravity between the upright and horizontal positions of the head. In downbeat nystagmus due to floccular damage, in which a permanent hyperexcitation of the CVTT could exist, a marked influence of static positions of the head is also observed. Finally, the strongest argument supporting a marked role of gravity in vertical eye position is that the eye movement alterations observed in the main, typical physiological and pathological conditions are precisely those that would be expected from a direct effect of gravity on the eyeballs, with, moreover, no single alternative interpretation existing so far that could account for all these different types of findings.

A neurobiological approach to acquired nystagmus

The development of animal and mathematical models for several forms of acquired nystagmus has led to more comprehensive knowledge of these disorders. In the best understood forms, such as periodic alternating nystagmus, our range of knowledge includes an animal model, the neurotransmitters involved, and effective treatment. For some other forms, such as downbeat nystagmus, we have an animal model, but reliable treatment is lacking. In other cases, exemplified by acquired pendular nystagmus, we have only a provisional hypothesis for pathogenesis to account for the oscillations, without an animal model, but effective treatment is possible in some patients. The present trend of studying all aspects of the neurobiology of nystagmus, from molecules to behavior, seems to be the best approach to extend our knowledge and to identify new treatments, but much remains to be done.