Pediatric Emergencies-Worsening Care Bottlenecks as Exemplified in a Major German City

[Does the nursing shortage in neonatal intensive care units (NICU) threaten the warranty of healthcare for newborns? : The "Mary and Joseph" project]

BACKGROUND

Germany has been experiencing a dramatic shortage of nursing staff for years that particularly affects neonatal intensive care units (NICUs). It is assumed that this situation leads to reductions in bed capacities, resulting in negative effects on the healthcare of newborns. These were investigated through a retrospective observational study using the example of three NICUs at the University Hospital of Munich (LMU).

METHODS

For the four-year observation period from August 2017 to May 2021, time series data from the "Quality Assurance Guideline for Premature and Mature Infants" (QFR-RL) of the Federal Joint Committee, bed resource analysis, planned personnel statistics, clinical logout data, and rescue service data were mutually examined using descriptive statistics and regression analysis.

RESULTS

During the observation period, around 21% of the necessary nursing staff positions were vacant, although the quality of nursing care for newborns seemed to have been guaranteed. However, to ensure quality, given the staff shortage, several available beds had to be blocked. In this context, both an increase in the number of hours the wards were logged off from population care and an increase in the relative risk of neonatal intensive care transfer were observed, resulting in a transfer every three days on average.

DISCUSSION

A shortage of nursing staff reduces the neonatal hospital bed capacity, since neonatal nursing care quality is regulated by strict legally binding guidelines, the QFR-RL. This is why the consequences for the security of care for the population through hospital cancellations and a risk of transfer must be accepted on a regular basis.

[Childhood emergencies-worsening healthcare bottlenecks for children in a systematic long-term analysis of the EMS system in a German metropolis]

BACKGROUND

Children have the right to the best possible medical care. The lack of treatment capacity is rising steadily and increasingly leads to forced centralized allocation of patients by the emergency medical services (EMS) to pediatric emergency departments that are, officially, temporarily "closed".

AIM

The aim of this study is to present trends in allocation of pediatric emergency patients in greater Munich.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Retrospective analysis of hospital admissions of children < 18 years of age collected from 01 January 2015 to 31 December 2019 by means of the web-based IT system IVENA eHealth (manis IT, Frankfurt) used by the emergency medical services. The focus of the evaluation is on patients in category II, who are likely to require inpatient admission.

RESULTS

During the 5‑year observation period, a total of 44,549 pediatric patients < 18 years of age (90.6% of total admissions) were admitted to a children's hospital by the ambulance service as category II (SKII) in the Munich metropolitan area. These patients showed an increase in the relative frequency of forced allocations from 1.7% (2015) to 9.4% (2019). Parallel to this, there is an increasing frequency of time intervals over the years in which all children's hospitals were temporarily closed due to lack of treatment availability, especially in the winter half-year.

CONCLUSION

In the examined period from 2015 to 2019, there has been a relevant increase in the number of forced allocations to children's hospitals by the emergency medical services in the Munich area. This observed trend is likely to persist over the coming years, in view of current staff shortages and diminishing hospital capacities.