Primary trabeculectomy versus primary glaucoma eye drops for newly diagnosed advanced glaucoma: TAGS RCT

Systematic methodological review of health state values in glaucoma cost-utility analyses

IMPORTANCE

Describing the characteristics and sources of health state utility values and reporting practice in the literature of cost-utility analyses facilitates an understanding of the level of the transparency, validity, and generalizability of cost-utility analyses. Improving the quality of reporting will support investigators in describing the incremental value of emerging glaucoma interventions.

OBJECTIVE

To describe the state of practice among published glaucoma cost-utility analysis studies, focusing on valuation of health and the quality of reporting.

EVIDENCE REVIEW

We searched several databases including Medline, CINHAL, Embase, Web of Science, Scopus, Biosis previews, the Health Economic Evaluations Database, and the NHS Economic Evaluation Database (NHS EED). We included full-text, English, published cost-utility analyses of glaucoma interventions with quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) as the primary outcome measure to calculate incremental cost-utility ratios. Excluded studies were non-English language, reviews, editorials, protocols, or other types of economic studies (cost-benefit, cost-minimization, cost-effectiveness). Study characteristics, operational definitions of glaucoma health states and health state utilities were extracted. The original source of the health utility was reviewed to determine the scale of measurement and the source of preference weighting. Items from the Systematic Review of Utilities for Cost-Effectiveness (SpRUCE checklist) were used to assess the reporting and quality of health utilities in glaucoma CUA.

FINDINGS

43 CUAs were included, with 11 unique sources of health utilities. A wide range of health utilities for the same Hodapp-Parrish-Anderson glaucoma health states were reported; ocular hypertension (0.84-0.95), mild (0.68-0.94), moderate (0.57-0.92), advanced (0.58-0.88), severe/blind (0.46-0.76), and bilateral blindness (0.26-0.5). Most studies reported the basis for using health utilities (34, 79%) and any assumptions or adjustments applied to the health utilities (22, 51%). Few studies reported a framework for assessing the relevance of health utilities to a decision context (8, 19%). Even fewer (3, 7%) applied a systematic search strategy to identify health utilities and used a structured assessment of quality for inclusion. Overall, reporting has not improved over time.

CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE

This review describes that few CUAs describe important rationale for using health state utility values. Including additional details on the search, appraisal, selection, and inclusion process of health utility values improves transparency, generalizability and supports the assessment of the validity of study conclusions. Future investigations should aim to use health utilities on the same scale of measurement across health states and consider the source and relevance to the decision context/purpose of conducting that cost-utility study.

Evaluating Primary Treatment for People with Advanced Glaucoma: Five-Year Results of the Treatment of Advanced Glaucoma Study

PURPOSE

To determine whether primary trabeculectomy or medical treatment produces better outcomes in terms of quality of life (QoL), clinical effectiveness, and safety in patients with advanced glaucoma.

DESIGN

Multicenter randomized controlled trial.

PARTICIPANTS

Between June 3, 2014, and May 31, 2017, 453 adults with newly diagnosed advanced open-angle glaucoma in at least 1 eye (Hodapp classification) were recruited from 27 secondary care glaucoma departments in the United Kingdom. Two hundred twenty-seven were allocated to trabeculectomy, and 226 were allocated medical management.

METHODS

Participants were randomized on a 1:1 basis to have either mitomycin C-augmented trabeculectomy or escalating medical management with intraocular pressure (IOP)-reducing drops as the primary intervention and were followed up for 5 years.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary outcome was vision-specific QoL measured with the 25-item Visual Function Questionnaire (VFQ-25) at 5 years. Secondary outcomes were general health status, glaucoma-related QoL, clinical effectiveness (IOP, visual field, and visual acuity), and safety.

RESULTS

At 5 years, the mean ± standard deviation VFQ-25 scores in the trabeculectomy and medication arms were 83.3 ± 15.5 and 81.3 ± 17.5, respectively, and the mean difference was 1.01 (95% confidence interval [CI], -1.99 to 4.00; P = 0.51). The mean IOPs were 12.07 ± 5.18 mmHg and 14.76 ± 4.14 mmHg, respectively, and the mean difference was -2.56 (95% CI, -3.80 to -1.32; P < 0.001). Glaucoma severity measured with visual field mean deviation were -14.30 ± 7.14 dB and -16.74 ± 6.78 dB, respectively, with a mean difference of 1.87 (95% CI, 0.87-2.87 dB; P < 0.001). Safety events occurred in 115 (52.2%) of patients in the trabeculectomy arm and 124 (57.9%) of patients in the medication arm (relative risk, 0.92; 95% CI, 0.72-1.19; P = 0.54). Serious adverse events were rare.

CONCLUSIONS

At 5 years, the Treatment of Advanced Glaucoma Study demonstrated that primary trabeculectomy surgery is more effective in lowering IOP and preventing disease progression than primary medical treatment in patients with advanced disease and has a similar safety profile.

FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S)

Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found in the Footnotes and Disclosures at the end of this article.

Antioxidant effect of gallic acid on retinal ganglion cells in glaucoma model

To evaluate the protective effect of gallic acid on the optic nerve by studying the inhibitory effect of gallic acid on oxidative stress in retinal ganglion cells. 100 male SD rats were randomly divided into four groups: normal control group, simple high IOP group, 0.5% gallic acid experimental group, and 1% gallic acid experimental group. HE staining, immunofluorescence, DHE staining, Western blot, and q-PCR were used to observe the antioxidant effect of gallic acid on the retina of acute ocular hypertension rats. HE staining of the retina of SD rats confirmed that the nucleus of RGCs was clear, the thickness of the RNFL was regular in the normal control group, and the nucleus of RGCs was ruptured and lysed in the simple high intraocular pressure (IOP) group and the gallic acid group, and the thickness of the RNFL was significantly thickened, but the thickness of the RNFL in the gallic acid group was significantly reduced compared with that in the simple high IOP group (p < 0.05). DHE staining showed that ROS content in the simple high IOP group was significantly increased compared with the normal control group, and ROS content was significantly decreased after the application of gallic acid (p < 0.05). Immunofluorescence staining with Brn-3a antibody confirmed that the number of RGCs was significantly reduced in the simple high IOP group compared with the normal control group, whereas after application of gallic acid, the number of RGCs was significantly more in the gallic acid group than in the simple high IOP group (p < 0.05). Western Blot and q-PCR confirmed that hypoxia-inducing factor 1α (HIF-1α) protein content and transcription level were significantly increased in the retinal tissue of the simple high IOP group, and gallic acid could inhibit HIF-1α protein content (p < 0.05) and reduce transcription factor level (p < 0.05). Gallic acid exerts a protective effect on RGC by inhibiting oxidative stress in rats with acute IOP elevation.

Longitudinal evaluation of advanced glaucoma: ten year follow-up cohort study

This study focused on patients with advanced open-angle glaucoma (OAG) and aimed to identify key factors for monitoring them. We included 127 such patients who were followed for seven years or more, undergoing annual ophthalmic examinations. Glaucoma progression was defined as a deterioration in either structure or function. The progression rates and risk factors were evaluated. The patients were divided into upper- and lower-half subgroups based on the reduction in intraocular pressure (IOP) from the baseline. Over an 11-year period, glaucoma progression was detected in 59 eyes (46.5%). The rate of change in mean deviation (MD) was - 0.43 dB/year for the entire population; - 0.67 dB/year for progressors; and - 0.20 dB/year for non-progressors. Hypertension and disc hemorrhage (DH) were more common in progressors compared to non-progressors (45.8 vs. 23.5%, 11.9 vs. 1.5%; P = 0.008 and P = 0.016). Multivariate Cox's proportional hazard model revealed that the presence of DH and a better baseline MD were associated with glaucoma progression. Additionally, patients with a higher percentage reduction in IOP (> 20.94%) had a lower risk of progression compared to those with less reduction. Inadequate IOP reduction, better baseline MD, presence of DH, and lower central corneal thickness were identified as risk factors for progression in advanced OAG patients.

Predictive potential of optical coherence tomography parameters for the prognosis of decreased visual acuity after trabeculectomy in open-angle glaucoma patients with good vision

BACKGROUND

Trabeculectomy (trab) is the most effective surgical procedure for lowering IOP and preventing glaucoma progression. However, decline in best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) is one of the most serious postoperative complications of trab. Here, we investigated methods to predict decreased BCVA after trab in glaucoma patients with good preoperative BCVA.

METHODS

This study included 35 eyes of 35 open-angle glaucoma (OAG) patients (male / female: 21 / 14, age: 64.0 ± 9.7 years old, preoperative intraocular pressure: 15.9 ± 5.4 mmHg, mean deviation: -18.1 ± 5.6 dB) with preoperative BCVA of 0.7 or better who underwent trab and were observed for more than 12 months. As a preoperative analysis, we measured temporal quadrant circumpapillary retinal nerve fiber layer thickness (cpRNFLT) and ganglion cell complex thickness in a central strip between the disc and fovea (csGCCT), an area that corresponds to the location of the papillomacular bundle (PMB) in swept-source optical coherence tomography (OCT). We defined BCVA decline as a loss of more than 3 lines of BCVA after 12 months. Measurement parameters were compared between the BCVA-decline group and the non-BCVA-decline group.

RESULTS

BCVA decline was detected in 11 cases (31.4%) 12 months after trab. There was a statistically significant difference in axial length (P = 0.049). A single logistic analysis showed that the BCVA-decline group had significantly lower cpRNFLT than the non-BCVA-decline group (27.7 ± 8.0 μm vs. 45.1 ± 5.3 μm, P < 0.001, cut-off value: 33.4 μm), as well as lower csGCCT (72.4 ± 7.7 μm vs. 87.5 ± 5.1 μm, P = 0.002, cut-off value: 82.3 μm). Multivariable logistic analysis showed that the BCVA-decline group had significantly lower temporal quadrant cpRNFLT (P < 0.001) and lower middle csGCCT (P < 0.001) compared to the non-BCVA-decline group.

CONCLUSIONS

Lower temporal quadrant cpRNFLT and middle csGCCT, OCT scan areas that correspond to the location of the PMB, might be biomarkers that predict BCVA decline after trab in OAG patients with good vision.

Clinical Outcomes and Cost Analysis of PreserFlo versus Trabeculectomy for Glaucoma Management in the United Kingdom

PURPOSE

Clinical evaluation and cost analysis of mitomycin-C-augmented PreserFlo MicroShunt versus trabeculectomy.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study across 3 teaching hospitals.

PARTICIPANTS

A total of 134 consecutive eyes of 129 patients (70 undergoing MicroShunt, 64 trabeculectomy).

METHODS

Primary and secondary glaucoma cases with uncontrolled intraocular pressure (IOP) were included. Neovascular glaucoma and surgery combined with cataract extraction were excluded. The cost analysis used results from the clinical study to estimate operative costs (equipment and staff costs) and postoperative costs (follow-up visits, nonglaucoma medications, and postoperative procedures) per eye for PreserFlo and trabeculectomy.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary clinical outcome measure was surgical failure (defined as IOP > 21 mmHg or < 20% reduction from baseline, IOP ≤ 5 mmHg, reoperation, or loss of light perception) or qualified and complete success (with or without medication) at 18 months. Secondary measures were IOP, glaucoma medications, visual acuity, mean deviation, time to cessation of steroid drops, complications, surgical time, follow-up visits, postoperative interventions, and reoperations. The cost analysis evaluated costs of PreserFlo compared with trabeculectomy.

RESULTS

Baseline characteristics were similar, except for more non-White patients in the trabeculectomy group (51% Black and Asian vs. 32% MicroShunt, P = 0.02) and more cases with prior ab externo glaucoma surgery in the MicroShunt group (19% vs. 3% in the trabeculectomy group, P = 0.004). Overall, 59% of eyes had primary open-angle glaucoma. Mean follow-up was 19.9 months for both groups. At 18 months, surgical failure was 25% for MicroShunt compared with 35% for trabeculectomy (P = 0.18). Failure in MicroShunt cases was due to inadequate IOP reduction (84%) or reoperation for glaucoma (16%). Failure in trabeculectomy cases was due to inadequate IOP reduction (58%), persistent hypotony (29%), or reoperation for glaucoma (13%). Combined blebitis and endophthalmitis rate was 1.4% for MicroShunt and 3.1% for trabeculectomy. Cost analysis showed a savings of £245 to £566 per eye in the MicroShunt group, driven mostly by reduced postoperative procedures and follow-up visits. This is in contrast to prior randomized controlled trial data reporting the incremental cost of $2058 of PreserFlo over trabeculectomy.

CONCLUSIONS

Our experience of introducing PreserFlo MicroShunt surgery showed it was safer than trabeculectomy and is a cost-saving and effective option that offers potential to free up highly limited National Health Service resources.

FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S)

Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found after the references.

Two-Year Visual Field Outcomes of the Treatment of Advanced Glaucoma Study (TAGS)

PURPOSE

to compare visual field (VF) progression between the 2 arms of the Treatment of Advanced Glaucoma Study (TAGS).

DESIGN

Post hoc analysis of VF data from a 2-arm, multicenter, randomized controlled clinical trial.

METHODS

A total of 453 patients with newly diagnosed advanced open-angle glaucoma in at least 1 eye from 27 centers in the United Kingdom were randomized to either trabeculectomy (n = 227) or medication in their index eye (n = 226) and followed-up for 2 years with 2 24-2 VF tests at baseline, 4, 12, and 24 months. Data were analyzed for participants with a reliable VF (false positive rate < 15%) at baseline and at least 2 other time points. Average difference in rate of progression (RoP) was analyzed using a hierarchical Bayesian model. Time for each eye to progress from baseline beyond specific cut-offs (0.5, 1, 1.5, and 2 dB) was compared using survival analysis.

RESULTS

This study analyzed 211 eyes in the trabeculectomy first arm and 203 eyes in the medication first arm. The average RoP (estimate [95% credible intervals]) was -0.59 [-0.88, -0.31] dB/year in the medication first arm and -0.40 [-0.67, -0.13] dB/year in the trabeculectomy first arm. The difference was not significant (Bayesian P-value = .353). More eyes progressed in the medication first arm, but this difference was not significant.

CONCLUSIONS

There was no significant difference in the average RoP at 2 years.

Follow-up of primary melanoma patients with high risk of recurrence: recommendations based on evidence and consensus

In spite of the good prognosis of patients with early-stage melanoma, there is a substantial proportion of them that develop local or distant relapses. With the introduction of targeted and immune therapies for advanced melanoma, including at the adjuvant setting, early detection of recurrent melanoma and/or second primary lesions is crucial to improve clinical outcomes. However, there is a lack of universal guidelines regarding both frequency of surveillance visits and diagnostic imaging and/or laboratory evaluations. In this article, a multidisciplinary expert panel recommends, after careful review of relevant data in the field, a consensus- and experience-based follow-up strategy for melanoma patients, taking into account prognostic factors and biomarkers and the high-risk periods and patterns of recurrence in each (sub) stage of the disease. Apart from the surveillance intensity, healthcare professionals should focus on patients' education to perform regular self-examinations of the skin and palpation of lymph nodes.