Correlation between peripheral blood and bone marrow regarding FLT3-ITD and NPM1 mutational status in patients with acute myeloid leukemia

Similarities and differences of bone marrow and peripheral blood samples from acute myeloid leukemia patients in terms of cellular heterogeneity and ex-vivo drug sensitivity

Background

Bone marrow (BM) evaluation is the de facto standard for diagnosis, molecular analysis, risk stratification, and therapy response assessment in acute myeloid leukemia (AML), but in patients with a high number of circulating blast cells, the peripheral blood (PB) sample could provide similar information as BM. However, there is no large-scale molecular study comparing the two specimens in terms of their gene expression profiles, cellular heterogeneities, and ex-vivo drug sensitivity.

Methodology

We used (i) the BEAT-AML cohort each with detailed molecular data; (ii) cell-type deconvolution to estimate leukemic and immune cell proportions between specimen types; (iii) differential expression (DE) and drug-cell type association analysis; and (iv) logistic regression models to assess the association between induction therapy response, cell-type composition and first-line drug treatment.

Results

Results: We identified 207 patients having BM and 116 patients having PB samples. There was a total of 1271 DE genes (false discovery rate < 0.05) between BM and PB; the top enriched pathways in terms of DE genes belong to the immune system pathways. Aggregated ex-vivo drug response profiles from the two specimens were largely similar, as were the cellular components, except for the GMP-like cell type (17% in BM vs. 5% in PB, p-value = 2 × 10-7). Among the specimen-specific results, the GMP-like subtype was associated with multiple drug resistance in BM and the ProMono-like subtype in PB. Several cell types were associated with the response to induction therapy, but the impact of specimen type on the interaction of cell type and cytarabine-associated induction therapy was not statistically significant for most cell types.

Results

Conclusions: Even though there are molecular and cellular differences between BM and PB samples, they show many similarities in ex-vivo drug response profiles, indicating the clinical utility of the substantially less-invasive PB samples.

The Clinical Utility of FLT3 Mutation Testing in Acute Leukemia: A Canadian Consensus

FMS-like tyrosine kinase 3 (FLT3) mutations are detected in approximately 20-30% of patients with acute myeloid leukemia (AML), with the presence of a FLT3 internal tandem duplication (FLT3-ITD) mutation being associated with an inferior outcome. Assessment of FLT3 mutational status is now essential to define optimal upfront treatment in both newly diagnosed and relapsed AML, to support post-induction allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (alloSCT) decision-making, and to evaluate treatment response via measurable (minimal) residual disease (MRD) evaluation. In view of its importance in AML diagnosis and management, the Canadian Leukemia Study Group/Groupe canadien d'étude sur la leucémie (CLSG/GCEL) undertook the development of a consensus statement on the clinical utility of FLT3 mutation testing, as members reported considerable inter-center variability across Canada with respect to testing availability and timing of use, methodology, and interpretation. The CLSG/GCEL panel identified key clinical and hematopathological questions, including: (1) which patients should be tested for FLT3 mutations, and when?; (2) which is the preferred method for FLT3 mutation testing?; (3) what is the clinical relevance of FLT3-ITD size, insertion site, and number of distinct FLT3-ITDs?; (4) is there a role for FLT3 analysis in MRD assessment?; (5) what is the clinical relevance of the FLT3-ITD allelic burden?; and (6) how should results of FLT3 mutation testing be reported? The panel followed an evidence-based approach, taken together with Canadian clinical and laboratory experience and expertise, to create a consensus document to facilitate a more uniform approach to AML diagnosis and treatment across Canada.

Features of the TCR repertoire associate with patients' clinical and molecular characteristics in acute myeloid leukemia

Background

Allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplant remains the most effective strategy for patients with high-risk acute myeloid leukemia (AML). Leukemia-specific neoantigens presented by the major histocompatibility complexes (MHCs) are recognized by the T cell receptors (TCR) triggering the graft-versus-leukemia effect. A unique TCR signature is generated by a complex V(D)J rearrangement process to form TCR capable of binding to the peptide-MHC. The generated TCR repertoire undergoes dynamic changes with disease progression and treatment.

Method

Here we applied two different computational tools (TRUST4 and MIXCR) to extract the TCR sequences from RNA-seq data from The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) and examine the association between features of the TCR repertoire in adult patients with AML and their clinical and molecular characteristics.

Results

We found that only ~30% of identified TCR CDR3s were shared by the two computational tools. Yet, patterns of TCR associations with patients' clinical and molecular characteristics based on data obtained from either tool were similar. The numbers of unique TCR clones were highly correlated with patients' white blood cell counts, bone marrow blast percentage, and peripheral blood blast percentage. Multivariable regressions of TCRA and TCRB median normalized number of unique clones with mutational status of AML patients using TRUST4 showed significant association of TCRA or TCRB with WT1 mutations, WBC count, %BM blast, and sex (adjusted in TCRB model). We observed a correlation between TCRA/B number of unique clones and the expression of T cells inhibitory signal genes (TIGIT, LAG3, CTLA-4) and foxp3, but not IL2RA, CD69 and TNFRSF9 suggestive of exhausted T cell phenotypes in AML.

Conclusion

Benchmarking of computational tools is needed to increase the accuracy of the identified clones. The utilization of RNA-seq data enables identification of highly abundant TCRs and correlating these clones with patients' clinical and molecular characteristics. This study further supports the value of high-resolution TCR-Seq analyses to characterize the TCR repertoire in patients.

Prognostic impact of FLT3-ITD, NPM1 mutation and CEBPA bZIP domain mutation in cytogenetically normal acute myeloid leukemia: a Hokkaido Leukemia Net study

Mutation status of FLT3, NPM1, and CEBPA is used to classify the prognosis of acute myeloid leukemia, but its significance in patients with cytogenetically normal (CN) AML is unclear. We prospectively analyzed these genes in 295 patients with CN-AML and identified 76 (25.8%) FLT3-ITD, 113 (38.3%) NPM1 mutations, and 30 (10.2%) CEBPA biallelic mutations. We found that patients with FLT3-ITD had a poor prognosis at any age, while patients with CEBPA biallelic mutation were younger and had a better prognosis. FLT3-ITD and NPM1 mutations were correlated, and the favorable prognostic impact of being FLT3-ITD negative and NPM1 mutation positive was evident only in patients aged 65 years or more. For CEBPA, 86.7% of the patients with biallelic mutation and 9.1% of patients with the single allele mutation had in-frame mutations in the bZIP domain, which were strongly associated with a favorable prognosis. Multivariate analysis showed that age < 65 years, FLT3-ITD and CEBPA bZIP in-frame mutation were independent prognostic factors. The results suggest that analyzing these gene mutations at diagnosis can inform selection of the optimal intensity of therapy for patients with CN-AML.

Human circulating small non-coding RNA signature as a non-invasive biomarker in clinical diagnosis of acute myeloid leukaemia

Background: Acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) is the most common acute leukaemia in adults; AML is highly heterogeneous and involves abnormalities at multiple omics levels. Small non-coding RNAs (sncRNAs) present in body fluids are important regulatory molecules and considered promising non-invasive clinical diagnostic biomarkers for disease. However, the signature of sncRNA profile alteration in AML patient serum and bone marrow supernatant is still under exploration. Methods: We examined data for blood and bone marrow samples from 80 consecutive, newly-diagnosed patients with AML and 12 healthy controls for high throughput small RNA-sequencing. Differentially expressed sncRNAs were analysed to reveal distinct patterns between AML patients and controls. Machine learning methods were used to evaluate the efficiency of specific sncRNAs in discriminating individuals with AML from controls. The altered expression level of individual sncRNAs was evaluated by RT-PCR, Q-PCR, and northern blot. Correlation analysis was employed to assess sncRNA patterns between serum and bone marrow supernatant. Results: We identified over 20 types of sncRNA categories beyond miRNAs in both serum and bone marrow supernatant, with highly coordinated expression patterns between them. Non-classical sncRNAs, including rsRNA (62.86%), ysRNA (14.97%), and tsRNA (4.22%), dominated among serum sncRNAs and showed sensitive alteration patterns in AML patients. According to machine learning-based algorithms, the tsRNA-based signature robustly discriminated subjects with AML from controls and was more reliable than that comprising miRNAs. Our data also showed that serum tsRNAs to be closely associated with AML prognosis, suggesting the potential application of serum tsRNAs as biomarkers to assist in AML diagnosis. Conclusions: We comprehensively characterized the expression pattern of circulating sncRNAs in blood and bone marrow and their alteration signature between healthy controls and AML patients. This study enriches research of sncRNAs in the regulation of AML, and provides insights into the role of sncRNAs in AML.

AML risk stratification models utilizing ELN-2017 guidelines and additional prognostic factors: a SWOG report

Background

The recently updated European LeukemiaNet risk stratification guidelines combine cytogenetic abnormalities and genetic mutations to provide the means to triage patients with acute myeloid leukemia for optimal therapies. Despite the identification of many prognostic factors, relatively few have made their way into clinical practice.

Methods

In order to assess and improve the performance of the European LeukemiaNet guidelines, we developed novel prognostic models using the biomarkers from the guidelines, age, performance status and select transcript biomarkers. The models were developed separately for mononuclear cells and viable leukemic blasts from previously untreated acute myeloid leukemia patients (discovery cohort, N = 185) who received intensive chemotherapy. Models were validated in an independent set of similarly treated patients (validation cohort, N = 166).

Results

Models using European LeukemiaNet guidelines were significantly associated with clinical outcomes and, therefore, utilized as a baseline for comparisons. Models incorporating age and expression of select transcripts with biomarkers from European LeukemiaNet guidelines demonstrated higher area under the curve and C-statistics but did not show a substantial improvement in performance in the validation cohort. Subset analyses demonstrated that models using only the European LeukemiaNet guidelines were a better fit for younger patients (age < 55) than for older patients. Models integrating age and European LeukemiaNet guidelines visually showed more separation between risk groups in older patients. Models excluding results for ASXL1, CEBPA, RUNX1 and TP53, demonstrated that these mutations provide a limited overall contribution to risk stratification across the entire population, given the low frequency of mutations and confounding risk factors.

Conclusions

While European LeukemiaNet guidelines remain a critical tool for triaging patients with acute myeloid leukemia, the findings illustrate the need for additional prognostic factors, including age, to improve risk stratification.

Detection and Quantification of FLT3 Internal Tandem Duplication Mutations Do Not Vary Significantly Between Whole Blood and Blast-Enriched Samples

OBJECTIVES

Many commonly used FLT3 mutational assay protocols require a tedious blast enrichment step. We investigated whether elimination of this step would still give equivalent results and compared the accuracy of variant allele fraction (VAF) between polymerase chain reaction/capillary electrophoresis (PCR/CE) vs next-generation sequencing (NGS) methods.

METHODS

Total leukocyte vs blast-enriched whole-blood aliquots were tested for FLT3 internal tandem duplication (ITD) and tyrosine kinase domain mutations by PCR/CE. VAF of the ITD mutations was also compared with NGS VAF.

RESULTS

Blast-enriched vs total leukocyte specimens showed 100% concordance in the 25 positive specimens. VAF was consistently lower by NGS, with poorer fidelity to PCR/CE VAF as the ITD size increased.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study supports elimination of the blast enrichment step without compromising results or sensitivity. In addition, since NGS shows a loose correlation with PCR/CE quantitative results, NGS VAF should not be reported for FLT3 ITDs.

Molecular Measurable Residual Disease Testing of Blood During AML Cytotoxic Therapy for Early Prediction of Clinical Response

Measurable residual disease (MRD) testing after initial chemotherapy treatment can predict relapse and survival in acute myeloid leukemia (AML). However, it has not been established if repeat molecular or genetic testing during chemotherapy can offer information regarding the chemotherapy sensitivity of the leukemic clone. Blood from 45 adult AML patients at day 1 and 4 of induction (n = 35) or salvage (n = 10) cytotoxic chemotherapy was collected for both quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) assessment (WT1) and next generation sequencing (>500 × depth) of 49 gene regions recurrently mutated in MDS/AML. The median age of subjects was 62 (23–78); 42% achieved a complete response. WT1 was overexpressed in most patients tested but was uninformative for very early MRD assessment. A median of 4 non-synonymous variants (range 0–7) were detected by DNA sequencing of blood on day 1 of therapy [median variant allele frequency (VAF): 29%]. Only two patients had no variants detectable. All mutations remained detectable in blood on day 4 of intensive chemotherapy and remarkably the ratio of mutated to wild-type sequence was often maintained. This phenomenon was not limited to variants in DNMT3A, TET2, and ASXL1. The kinetics of NPM1 and TP53 variant burden early during chemotherapy appeared to be exceptions and exhibited consistent trends in this cohort. In summary, molecular testing of blood on day 4 of chemotherapy is not predictive of clinical response to cytotoxic induction therapy in AML. The observed stability in variant allele frequency suggests that cytotoxic therapy may have a limited therapeutic index for clones circulating in blood containing these mutations. Further validation is required to confirm the utility of monitoring NPM1 and TP53 kinetics in blood during cytotoxic therapy.

Bone marrow evaluation for diagnosis and monitoring of acute myeloid leukemia

The diagnosis of acute myeloid leukemia (AML) can be made based on peripheral blood or bone marrow blasts. In this review, we will discuss the role of bone marrow evaluation and peripheral blood monitoring in the diagnosis, management, and follow up of AML patients. For patients with circulating blasts, it is reasonable to perform the necessary studies needed for diagnosis and risk stratification, including multiparametric flow cytometry, cytogenetics, and molecular analysis, on a peripheral blood specimen. The day 14 marrow is used to document hypocellularity in response to induction chemotherapy, but it is unclear if that assessment is necessary as it often does not affect immediate management. Currently, response assessments performed at count recovery for evaluation of remission and measurable residual disease rely on bone marrow sampling. For monitoring of relapse, peripheral blood evaluation may be adequate, but the sensitivity of bone marrow testing is in some cases superior. While bone marrow evaluation can certainly be avoided in particular situations, this cumbersome and uncomfortable procedure currently remains the de facto standard for response assessment.

NPM1 Mutation Detection in Acute Myeloid Leukemia: A Method Comparison Study

BACKGROUND

Mutations in the nucleophosmin (NPM1) gene have been used as molecular biomarkers for prognostication of patients with adult acute myeloid leukemia (AML).

METHODS

We designed a rapid and sensitive method using the allele-specific-refractory mutation system-polymerase chain reaction (ARMS-PCR) to detect the most common mutations of NPM1 gene, which are mostly four base pair insertions and compared its efficacy with direct sequencing and capillary electrophoresis which served as the gold standards.

RESULTS

The incidence of mutation was 22% (33% of patients with normal karyotypes had mutation compared with 16% of patients with abnormal karyotypes) based on the results obtained with capillary electrophoresis analysis and direct sequencing. All of the specimens determined to be mutation-positive by the gold standard tests were also positive by the ARMS-PCR method. Significantly, the ARMS-PCR test also helped determine the mutation status of an extra set of patients who had low call rates on capillary electrophoresis and appeared normal on direct sequencing.

DISCUSSION

The low mutation rate in some patients hindered its detection in the gold standard assays because of the interference of the mutation signal by high background noise. The low sensitivity of the gold standard assays for detecting low copy number mutations rates thus increase their risk of producing false negative results that adversely affects prognostication and therapy. Our results suggest that the mutation detection rate of the ARMS-PCR assay is better than existing tests. This is most probably because of the fact that in an ARMS-PCR-based method, the mutated variant is specifically amplified, based on a mutation-specific primer.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that the high sensitivity of the ARMS-based method together with its rapidity and low expense should make it a suitable choice for clinical laboratories.