Hypoxia-Like Events in UK Typhoon Aircraft from 2008 to 2017

Integrating physiological monitoring systems in military aviation: a brief narrative review of its importance, opportunities, and risks

Military pilots risk their lives during training and operations. Advancements in aerospace engineering, flight profiles, and mission demands may require the pilot to test the safe limits of their physiology. Monitoring pilot physiology (e.g. heart rate, oximetry, and respiration) inflight is in consideration by several nations to inform pilots of reduced performance capacity and guide future developments in aircraft and life-support system design. Numerous challenges, however, prevent the immediate operationalisation of physiological monitoring sensors, particularly their unreliability in the aerospace environment and incompatibility with pilot clothing and protective equipment. Human performance and behaviour are also highly variable and measuring these in controlled laboratory settings do not mirror the real-world conditions pilots must endure. Misleading or erroneous predictive models are unacceptable as these could compromise mission success and lose operator trust. This narrative review provides an overview of considerations for integrating physiological monitoring systems within the military aviation environment.Practitioner summary: Advancements in military technology can conflictingly enhance and compromise pilot safety and performance. We summarise some of the opportunities, limitations, and risks of integrating physiological monitoring systems within military aviation. Our intent is to catalyse further research and technological development.Abbreviations: AGS: anti-gravity suit; AGSM: anti-gravity straining manoeuvre; A-LOC: almost loss of consciousness; CBF: cerebral blood flow; ECG: electrocardiogram; EEG: electroencephalogram; fNIRS: functional near-infrared spectroscopy; G-forces: gravitational forces; G-LOC: gravity-induced loss of consciousness; HR: heart rate; HRV: heart rate variability; LSS: life-support system; NATO: North Atlantic Treaty Organisation; PE: Physiological Episode; PCO2: partial pressure of carbon dioxide; PO2: partial pressure of oxygen; OBOGS: on board oxygen generating systems; SpO2: peripheral blood haemoglobin-oxygen saturation; STANAG: North Atlantic Treaty Organisation Standardisation Agreement; UPE: Unexplained Physiological Episode; WBV: whole body vibration.

Delayed Drowsiness After Normobaric Hypoxia Training in an F/A-18 Hornet Simulator

BACKGROUND: In military aviation, due to high-altitude flight operations, hypoxia training is mandatory and nowadays is mainly done as normobaric hypoxia training in flight simulators. During the last decade, scientific data has been published about delayed recovery after normobaric hypoxia, known as a "hypoxia hangover." Sopite syndrome is a symptom complex that develops as a result of exposure to real or apparent motion, and it is characterized by yawning, excessive drowsiness, lassitude, lethargy, mild depression, and a reduced ability to focus on an assigned task.CASE REPORT: In this study, we present the case of a 49-yr-old pilot who participated in normobaric hypoxia refreshment training in an F/A-18C Hornet simulator and experienced delayed drowsiness, even 3 h after the training.DISCUSSION: This case report demonstrates the danger of deep hypoxia. Hypoxia training instructions should include restrictions related to driving a car immediately after hypoxia training. In addition, hypoxia may lower the brain threshold for sopite syndrome.Varis N, Leinonen A, Perälä J, Leino TK, Husa L, Sovelius R. Delayed drowsiness after normobaric hypoxia training in an F/A-18 Hornet simulator. Aerosp Med Hum Perform. 2023; 94(9):715-718.

Cardiorespiratory Responses to Voluntary Hyperventilation During Normobaric Hypoxia

BACKGROUND: Unexplained physiological events (PE), possibly related to hypoxia and hyperventilation, are a concern for some air forces. Physiological monitoring could aid research into PEs, with measurement of arterial oxygen saturation (S_po₂) often suggested despite potential limitations in its use. Given similar physiological responses to hypoxia and hyperventilation, the present study characterized the cardiovascular and respiratory responses to each.METHODS: Ten healthy subjects were exposed to 55 mins of normobaric hypoxia simulating altitudes of 0, 8000, and 12,000 ft (0, 2438, and 3658 m) while breathing normally and voluntarily hyperventilating (doubling minute ventilation). Respiratory gas analysis and spirometry measured end-tidal gases (P_ETo₂ and P_ETco₂) and minute ventilation. S_po₂ was assessed using finger pulse oximetry. Mean arterial, systolic, and diastolic blood pressure were measured noninvasively. Cognitive impairment was assessed using the Stroop test.RESULTS: Voluntary hyperventilation resulted in a doubling of minute ventilation and lowered P_ETco₂, while altitude had no effect on these. P_ETo₂ and S_po₂ declined with increasing altitude. However, despite a significant drop in P_ETo₂ of 15.2 mmHg from 8000 to 12,000 ft, S_po₂ was similar when hyperventilating (94.7 ± 2.3% vs. 93.4 ± 4.3%, respectively). The only cardiovascular response was an increase in heart rate while hyperventilating. Altitude had no effect on cognitive impairment, but hyperventilation did.DISCUSSION: For many cardiovascular and respiratory variables, there is minimal difference in responses to hypoxia and hyperventilation, making these challenging to differentiate. S_po₂ is not a reliable marker of environmental hypoxia in the presence of hyperventilation and should not be used as such without additional monitoring of minute ventilation and end-tidal gases.Haddon A, Kanhai J, Nako O, Smith TG, Hodkinson PD, Pollock RD. Cardiorespiratory responses to voluntary hyperventilation during normobaric hypoxia. Aerosp Med Hum Perform. 2023; 94(2):59-65.

A New Method for Combined Hyperventilation and Hypoxia Training in a Tactical Fighter Simulator

INTRODUCTION: Physiological episodes are an issue in military aviation. Some non-pressure-related in-flight symptoms are proved to be due to hyperventilation rather than hypoxia. The aim of this study was to validate a new training method provoking hyperventilation during normobaric hypoxia (NH) training in an F/A-18 Hornet simulator.METHODS: In a double-blind setting, 26 fighter pilots from the Finnish Air Force performed 2 setups in a WTSAT simulator in randomized order with full flight gear. Without the pilot's knowledge, 6% O2 in nitrogen or 6% O2 + 4% CO2 in nitrogen was turned on. Ventilation (VE) was measured before, during, and after hypoxia. Spo2 and ECG were monitored and symptoms documented. The subjects performed a tactical identification flight until they recognized symptoms of hypoxia. Thereafter, they performed hypoxia emergency procedures with 100% O2 and returned to the base with a GPS malfunction and executed an instrument landing system (ILS) approach with the waterline HUD mode evaluated by the flight instructor on a scale of 1 to 5.RESULTS: Ventilation increased during normobaric hypoxia (NH) from 12 L · min−1 to 19 L · min−1 at Spo2 75% with 6% O2, and from 12 L · min−1 to 26 L · min−1 at Spo2 77% with 6% O2 + 4% CO2. ILS flight performance was similar 10 min after combined hyperventilation and hypoxia (3.1 with 6% O2 + 4% CO2 and 3.2 with 6% O2). No adverse effects were reported during the 24-h follow-up.DISCUSSION: Hyperventilation-provoking normobaric hypoxia training is a new and well-tolerated method to meet NATO Standardization Agreement hypoxia training requirements.Leinonen AM, Varis NO, Kokki HJ, Leino TK. A new method for combined hyperventilation and hypoxia training in a tactical fighter simulator. Aerosp Med Hum Perform. 2022; 93(9):681–687.

Hyperventilation and Hypoxia Hangover During Normobaric Hypoxia Training in Hawk Simulator

Introduction: In military aviation during high-altitude operations, an oxygen or cabin pressure emergency can impair brain function and performance. There are variations in individuals’ physiological responses to low partial pressure of oxygen and hypoxia symptoms can vary from one exposure to another. The aim of this study was to evaluate how normobaric hypoxia (NH) affects pilots’ minute ventilation and 10 min afterwards on Instrument Landing System (ILS) flight performance in Hawk simulator during a tactical flight sortie.

Methods: Fifteen volunteer fighter pilots from the Finnish Air Force participated in this double blinded, placebo controlled and randomized study. The subjects performed three flights in a tactical Hawk simulator in a randomized order with full flight gear, regulators and masks on. In the middle of the flight without the subjects’ knowledge, 21% (control), 8% or 6% oxygen in nitrogen was turned on. Minute ventilation (VE) was measured before, during NH and after NH. Forehead peripheral oxygen saturation (SpO₂), wireless ECG and subjective symptoms were documented. The flights were conducted so that both subjects and flight instructors were blinded to the gas mixture. The pilots performed tactical maneuvers at simulated altitude of 20,000 ft or 26,000 ft until they recognized the symptoms of hypoxia. Thereafter they performed hypoxia emergency procedures with 100% oxygen and returned to base (RTB). During the ILS approach, flight performance was evaluated.

Results: The mean VE increased during NH from 12.9 L/min (21% O2 on the control flight) to 17.8 L/min with 8% oxygen (p < 0.01), and to 21.0 L/min with 6% oxygen (p < 0.01). Ten minutes after combined hyperventilation and hypoxia, the ILS flight performance decreased from 4.4 (control flight) to 4.0 with 8% oxygen (p = 0.16) and to 3.2 with 6% oxygen (p < 0.01). A significant correlation (r = -0.472) was found between the subjects’ VE during 6% oxygen exposure and the ILS flight performance.

Discussion: Hyperventilation during NH has a long-lasting and dose-dependent effect on the pilot’s ILS flight performance, even though the hypoxia emergency procedures are executed 10 min earlier. Hyperventilation leads to body loss of carbon dioxide and hypocapnia which may even worsen the hypoxia hangover.