Cross-reactivity of sperm-binding proteins from chicken, turkey, and duck oocytes

Modification and Clinical Application of the Inner Perivitelline Membrane Test in Different Avian Species

The aim of this study was to adapt an inner perivitelline membrane (IPVM) test as an interspecies penetration assay for avian spermatozoa. The IPVM of different bird species was evaluated to test the penetrating ability of avian spermatozoa in an intra- and interspecies design. Isolation of the IPVM via acid hydrolysis was tested in pre-incubated chicken eggs and in six other avian species. The separation protocol was modified (time, acid concentration) to facilitate practicability. Separated membranes were evaluated with dark field microscopy for the presence of holes produced by penetrating spermatozoa. In chicken eggs, the influence of different membrane storage conditions was tested. In the penetration assay, the IPVM of chicken eggs was used as a model for fresh and frozen-thawed rooster sperm and for fresh spermatozoa of cockatiels and falcons. Results demonstrated that the time of egg-incubation had a significantly negative influence on the isolation ability of the IPVM (p < 0.0001). IPVM-separation was successful for a maximum of two days after preincubation. In the experiments with eggs from other avian species, results were heterogenous: there was no isolation in geese and cockatiels, 20% in the European kestrel, and 40% in pheasant, quail, and duck. In the penetration assay, holes were found in 100% of the IPVM of chicken eggs after incubation with native and frozen-thawed rooster semen and in 10% with fresh cockatiel semen. Falcon spermatozoa failed to produce visible holes. In conclusion, the IPVM of chicken eggs seems to be unsuitable to establish a functional sperm assay in other species tested but is suitable for quality evaluation of cryopreserved rooster sperm.

Reproductive isolation in birds: postcopulatory prezygotic barriers

Reproductive isolation is an important part of the speciation process. Recent studies of birds have highlighted not only the significance of postcopulatory postzygotic barriers, but also the almost complete absence of information about postcopulatory prezygotic barriers. Here, we draw attention to studies that provide an opportunity to test whether prezygotic barriers to heterospecific sperm exist in birds. We show that, compared with other taxa, such barriers in birds are relatively inefficient, possibly because, similar to postcopulatory postzygotic barriers, they take a long time to evolve. These data also raise questions about the mechanisms of sperm-female and sperm-egg recognition in birds. Future research will serve the dual purpose of providing more detail of the mechanisms of both heterospecific and conspecific prezygotic processes.

Species specificity in avian sperm:perivitelline interaction

The interaction of chicken spermatozoa with the inner perivitelline layer from different avian species in vitro during a 5 min co-incubation was measured as the number of points of hydrolysis produced per unit area of inner perivitelline layer. The average degree of interaction, as a proportion of that between chicken spermatozoa and their homologous inner perivitelline layer, was: equal to or greater than 100% within Galliformes (chicken, turkey, quail, pheasant, peafowl and guineafowl); 44% within Anseriformes (goose, duck); and less than 30% in Passeriformes (Zebra Finch) and Columbiformes (collared-dove). The homologue of the putative chicken sperm-binding proteins, chicken ZP1 and ZP3, were identified by Western blotting with anti-chicken ZP1/ZP3 antibody in the perivitelline layers of all species. The functional cross-reactivity between chicken spermatozoa and heterologous inner perivitelline layer appeared to be linked to known phylogenetic distance between the species, although it was not related to the relative affinity of the different ZP3 homologues for anti-chicken ZP3. This work demonstrates that sperm interaction with the egg investment does not represent such a stringent species-specific barrier in birds as it does in mammals and marine invertebrates. This may be a factor in the frequency of hybrid production in birds.

Common egg envelope antigens are limited to the animal class

The antigens of the egg envelope (zona pellucida) in mammals are of special interest because of their possible involvement in immunoinfertility and as candidate targets for immunocontraception. Conserved zona epitopes from divergent species may present a suitable source and an animal model for investigation of the above factors. We compared egg envelope antigens from 6 species of vertebrates belonging to 3 different classes in order to demonstrate the existence of shared antigens. Egg envelopes from the trout, carp, turtle, hen, duck and quail were isolated and heat-solubilized. They were tested with rabbit polyclonal antisera against carp, trout and duck egg envelopes by the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The results showed significant cross-reactions among egg envelopes of fish and birds. The examined solubilized preparations did not show cross-reactivity with egg envelopes from any other class, suggesting that divergent species did not share common egg envelope antigens, and that their use may not be appropriate in the investigation of immunoinfertility and immunocontraception in humans.

Immunization of chickens with quail and turkey perivitelline membrane proteins: production of antibodies and their effects on fertility

The cross-reactivity of antibodies developed against zona pellucida proteins and their subsequent deleterious effect on fertility in heterologous species is well documented. However, similar investigations have not been undertaken in avian species. In Experiment 1, White Leghorn hens were immunized with intact germinal discs (GD) of quail and chickens. Chicken GD proteins did not elicit an immune response in chicken hens, whereas quail GD proteins were highly immunogenic. Anti-quail GD antibodies did not bind with chicken inner perivitelline membrane (IPM) proteins as determined by immunoblot analysis. To examine the fertility of immunized hens, artificial insemination was performed at weekly intervals for 4 wk following the booster immunization. No significant differences were detected in fertility or hatchability of immunized hens when compared with unimmunized control hens. In Experiment 2, White Leghorn hens were immunized with intact turkey GD, solubilized turkey perivitelline membrane (PM) modified with dinitrophenol (DNP), and solubilized chicken IPM modified with DNP. High titers of antibodies were detected against the turkey GD and the DNP-modified turkey PM proteins. A weak immune response was observed in hens immunized with modified chicken IPM proteins. The fertility and hatchability of eggs laid by immunized hens, however, were not significantly different from those of unimmunized hens. Antibodies from immunized hens were further analyzed using an in vitro assay that assesses sperm penetration of intact IPM. Sperm penetration of intact IPM was inhibited to the same extent when IPM was preincubated with preimmune as well as anti-PM immunoglobulins. Collectively, these results suggested that the antibodies developed in these hens did not cross-react with the chicken IPM proteins involved in sperm-egg interaction and thus did not influence the fertility.

Quantification of a sperm-egg interaction for estimating the mating efficiency of broiler breeder flocks

1. The frequency distribution of points of sperm hydrolysis (or holes) produced per unit area of the inner perivitelline layer was examined in samples of approximately 60 laid eggs, taken on the same day from each of 19 flocks of broiler breeder hens. 2. The holes counted in samples of perivitelline layer from eggs varied from 0 to greater than 100; lower numbers being found in eggs from flocks with lower fertility. 3. The median frequency of holes in the inner perivitelline layer was strongly correlated (r = 0.92) with the median frequency of spermatozoa found trapped in the corresponding outer perivitelline layer. 4. The median frequency of holes in the inner perivitelline layer and of spermatozoa in the outer perivitelline layer were both strongly correlated (r = 0.80 and 0.77, respectively) with flock fertility. 5. It is suggested that counting 'holes' in the inner perivitelline layer of laid eggs is a more convenient method for assessing breeding efficiency and predicting flock fertility than counting spermatozoa trapped in the outer perivitelline layer.

Quantitative determination of spermatozoa penetration of the perivitelline layer of the hen's ovum as assessed on oviposited eggs

A technique was developed to assess the number of cock spermatozoa penetrating the perivitelline layer (PL) in oviposited eggs in vivo. Two trials were conducted to test this technique and to establish correlation values between fertility and sperm penetration (SP). First, three Athens Canadian Randombred males, previously tested as having high fertility (100%), were each housed with seven hens. Sperm penetration was determined from eggs laid over a 3-d period (n = 41) with the mean number of spermatozoa penetrating the PL overlying the germinal disc (GD; 1.35 mm2 area) and nongerminal disc (NGD) areas being 162.8 and 8.4, respectively. Following removal of the males, SP was monitored to establish its duration with an average of 4.6 eggs analyzed per male per day. Mean sperm penetration during this period declined from 167.0 to .2 and from 9.2 to 0 for the GD and NGD regions, respectively. The mean duration of SP was 15.7 and 11.3 d for the GD and NGD PL, respectively. The duration of fertility was also established to be 14.0 d. There was a positive correlation between sperm penetration of the GD PL and fertility from eggs laid by naturally mated hens (r = .89, P < .001). In the second trial, three groups (1, 2, or 3) of 16 hens (35 wk of age) each were artificially inseminated weekly for 4 consecutive wk with either 100, 50, or 25 million sperm/50 microL, respectively. Inseminations were repeated weekly for 12 consecutive wk. Mean values were obtained from each of three 4-wk periods and used as replicates. Mean SP values from the GD PL for Groups 1, 2, and 3 were 402, 19.5, and 14.1, with fertility values of 95.8, 92.4, and 83.3%, respectively. Each replicate mean was obtained from approximately 24 eggs per group per day postinsemination. A significant correlation between SP of the GD PL and fertility (r = .90, P < .001) was established using artificial insemination of hens.