Oxygen Reduction Reaction at Penta-Coordinated Co Phthalocyanines

Ligand Isomerization Driven Electrocatalytic Switching

The prevailing view about molecular catalysts is that the central metal ion is responsible for the reaction mechanism and selectivity, whereas the ligands mainly affect the reaction kinetics. Here, we question this paradigm and show that ligands have a dramatic influence on the selectivity of the product. We show how even a seemingly small change in ligand isomerization sharply alters the selectivity of the well-researched oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) Co phthalocyanine catalyst from an indirect 2e- to a direct 4e- pathway. Detailed analysis reveals that intramolecular hydrogen-bond interactions in the ligand activate the catalytic Co, directing the oxygen binding and thus deciding the final product. The resulting catalyst is the first example of a Co-based molecular catalyst catalyzing a direct 4e- ORR via ligand isomerization, for which it shows an activity close to the benchmark Pt in an actual H2-O2 fuel cell. The effect of the ligand isomerism is demonstrated with different central metal ions, thus highlighting the generalizability of the findings and their potential to open new possibilities in the design of molecular catalysts.

A theoretical study on the ORR electrocatalytic activity of axial ligand modified cobalt polyphthalocyanine

In this work, the catalytic activity in the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) of cobalt polyphthalocyanine whose central Co atom is coordinated at the axial position by ligands (L = -F, -OH, -OCH3, -N3, -Cl, -Br, -I, -SCN, and -CN) (CoPPc-L) was investigated using theoretical calculations in alkaline medium. Among all CoPPc-L, CoPPc-N3 exhibited the lowest ORR overpotential of 0.23 V vs. a standard hydrogen electrode, which is significantly lower than those of CoPPc (0.48 V) and Pt(111) (0.43 V). There is a good linear relationship between ΔG*OOH and the electronegativity of ligating atoms in axial ligands of CoPPc-L. The greater the electronegativity, the stronger the adsorption of the catalyst to the intermediate. Additionally, the adsorption strength of CoPPc to the intermediate is modified by the axial ligands, which adjust the distribution of anti-bonding electronic states of dz2, dxz, and dyz orbitals near the Fermi level, Ef. A larger Mayer bond order of the Co-L bond resulted in a smaller bond order of the Co-O bond. CoPPc-N3 exhibited a moderate Co-O bond order of 0.737, corresponding to moderate adsorption energy to the OOH intermediate. This study demonstrates that the interaction strength between CoPPc and ORR intermediates can be adjusted by selecting appropriate axial ligands, which can modulate the ORR catalytic activity.

Advances on Axial Coordination Design of Single-Atom Catalysts for Energy Electrocatalysis: A Review

Single-atom catalysts (SACs) have garnered increasingly growing attention in renewable energy scenarios, especially in electrocatalysis due to their unique high efficiency of atom utilization and flexible electronic structure adjustability. The intensive efforts towards the rational design and synthesis of SACs with versatile local configurations have significantly accelerated the development of efficient and sustainable electrocatalysts for a wide range of electrochemical applications. As an emergent coordination avenue, intentionally breaking the planar symmetry of SACs by adding ligands in the axial direction of metal single atoms offers a novel approach for the tuning of both geometric and electronic structures, thereby enhancing electrocatalytic performance at active sites. In this review, we briefly outline the burgeoning research topic of axially coordinated SACs and provide a comprehensive summary of the recent advances in their synthetic strategies and electrocatalytic applications. Besides, the challenges and outlooks in this research field have also been emphasized. The present review provides an in-depth and comprehensive understanding of the axial coordination design of SACs, which could bring new perspectives and solutions for fine regulation of the electronic structures of SACs catering to high-performing energy electrocatalysis.

Kinetic and mechanistic investigations of dioxygen reduction by a molecular Cu(II) catalyst bearing a pentadentate amidate ligand

A pentadentate Cu(II) complex, [CuII(dpaq)](ClO4) (1), featuring a redox active ligand, H-dpaq (H-dpaq = 2-[bis(pyridine-2-ylmethyl)]amino-N-quinolin-8-yl-acetamidate), catalyses four-electron reduction of dioxygen by decamethylferrocene (Fc*) in the presence of trifluoroacetic acid (CF3COOH) in acetone at 298 K. No catalytic oxygen reduction was observed in the presence of stronger Brønsted acids than CF3COOH, such as perchloric acid (HClO4) or trifluoromethanesulphonic acid (HOTf). In contrast, facile catalytic reduction of O2 occurs by Fc* with 1 and HClO4 or HOTf in dimethylformamide (DMF). The use of CF3COOH as the proton source in DMF results in the suppression of O2 reduction under otherwise identical reaction conditions. While the O2 reduction reactions in DMF are linearly dependent on the pKa of Brønsted acids, the acid dependence on catalytic O2-reduction reactivity by 1 in acetone showed complete reversal. Cyclic voltammetry studies using p-chloranil as the probe substrates in the presence of acids in the solvents reveal that the strengths of the protonic acids increase significantly in acetone compared to that in DMF. The amidate-N in [CuII(dpaq)](ClO4) (1) undergoes protonation in the presence of HClO4 or HOTf in DMF to form [CuII(H-dpaq)]2+ (1-H+), but not in the presence of CF3COOH. Enhanced acid strength of CF3COOH in acetone, however, effectively protonates 1 and triggers O2 reduction. Protonation of 1 with HClO4 or HOTf in acetone results in the change of its coordination environment, and this protonated species does not trigger O2 reduction. Detailed kinetic studies indicate that 1-H+ undergoes reduction by two-electrons and the reduced species binds O2 to form a Cu(II)-superoxo intermediate. This is followed by a rate-determining proton-coupled electron-transfer (PCET) reduction to generate the Cu(II)-hydroperoxo intermediate. While catalytic O2 reduction in acetone occurs predominantly via a 4e-/4H+ pathway, product selectivity (H2O vs. H2O2) in DMF depends upon the concentration of the reductant (Fc*). While dioxygen reduction to H2O2 is favoured at low [Fc*], mechanistic studies suggest that O2 reduction with high [Fc*] proceeds via a [2e- + 2e-] mechanism, where the released H2O2 during catalysis is further reduced to water.

2,6-Diaminopyridine-Based Polyurea as an ORR Electrocatalyst of an Anion Exchange Membrane Fuel Cell

In order to yield more Co(II), 2,6-diaminopyridine (DAP) was polymerized with 4,4-methylene diphenyl diisocyanates (MDI) in the presence of Co(II) to obtain a Co-complexed polyurea (Co-PUr). The obtained Co-PUr was calcined to become Co, N-doped carbon (Co-N-C) as the cathode catalyst of an anion exchange membrane fuel cell (AEMFC). High-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HR-TEM) of Co-N-C indicated many Co-Nx (Co covalent bonding with several nitrogen) units in the Co-N-C matrix. X-ray diffraction patterns showed that carbon and cobalt crystallized in the Co-N-C catalysts. The Raman spectra showed that the carbon matrix of Co-N-C became ordered with increased calcination temperature. The surface area (dominated by micropores) of Co-N-Cs also increased with the calcination temperature. The non-precious Co-N-C demonstrated comparable electrochemical properties (oxygen reduction reaction: ORR) to commercial precious Pt/C, such as high on-set and half-wave voltages, high limited reduction current density, and lower Tafel slope. The number of electrons transferred in the cathode was close to four, indicating complete ORR. The max. power density (P_max) of the single cell with the Co-N-C cathode catalyst demonstrated a high value of 227.7 mWcm^-2.

Theoretical study of the effect of coordination environment on the activity of metal macrocyclic complexes as electrocatalysts for oxygen reduction

Transition metal macrocyclic complexes are appealing catalysts for electrochemical oxygen reduction reaction (ORR). Here, we perform first-principles calculations to gain a comprehensive understanding on the structure-property relationship of the metal macrocyclic complex systems. Various modifications of the complexes are considered, including centered metal, axial ligand, coordination atom, substituent, and macrocycles. Based on simulation, introduction of appropriate apical ligand can improve the performance of all the three metals, whereas replacement of nitrogen with oxygen or carbon as the coordination atoms may enhance the Ni-centered systems. The antiaromatic ring stabilizes the ∗OOH intermediate, whereas the macrocycle with reduced electron density inhibits the binding with oxygen. By regulating the coordination environment, the overpotential can be significantly reduced. This work may assist the rational design of ORR catalysts and is of great significance for the future development of oxygen reduction catalysts.

•

Metal macrocyclic complexes are potential electrocatalysts for ORR

•

An understanding on structure-property relationship is gained based on simulation

•

Various modifications are considered to improve the performance

Donor-acceptor interactions of gold(III) porphyrins with cobalt(II) phthalocyanine: chemical structure of products, their spectral characterization and DFT study

In the context of the development of coordination energy-harvesting systems, the axial bonding of cobalt(II) octakis(3,5-di-tert-butylphenoxy)phthalocyanine (1) with gold(III) 2,3,7,8,12,18-hexamethyl,13,17-diethyl,5-(pyridin-4-yl)- and (2,3,7,8,12,18-hexamethyl,13,17-diethyl,5-(pyridin-3-yl)porphin (2 and 3), the structure, the spectral/electrochemical properties of the resulting donor-acceptor complexes and photoinduced electron transfer in them are studied. The process of the dyad formation passing as self-assembly in the donor-acceptor phthalocyanine-porphyrin systems was explored using UV-Visible, IR, and ¹H NMR spectroscopy and mass spectrometry. The geometric and electronic structures of the dyads were identified using density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent DFT calculations. The electron transfer in the coordination complexes studied was confirmed by recording the radical ion pairs namely 1˙⁺:2˙^-/1˙⁺:3˙^- and measuring the kinetics of the photoinduction and decay of these states by a femtosecond laser photolysis technique. The effect of the gold(III) porphyrin macrocycle nature in the lifetime of radical ion pairs was shown. The redox potential values for the coordination dyads and the photoelectrochemical parameters defining their perspective in design and understanding of PET systems were observed using the cyclic voltammetry/amperometry methods and the short-circuited electrochemical cell Ti|a dyad film|0.5 M Na₂SO₄|Pt, respectively.

Evidence of carbon-supported porphyrins pyrolyzed for the oxygen reduction reaction keeping integrity

Fe(III) 5,10,15,20-(tetraphenyl)porphyrin chloride (FeTPP) and Co(III) 5,10,15,20-(tetraphenyl)porphyrin chloride (CoTPP) were adsorbed on carbon Vulcan and studied as electrocatalysts for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) before and after pyrolysis. The pyrolysis process was also simulated through ab initio molecular dynamic simulations and the minimum energy path for the O₂ dissociation after the interaction with the metal center of the FeTPP and CoTPP were calculated. After the pyrolysis the FeTPP showed the best performances reducing O₂ completely to H₂O with increased limiting current and lower overpotential. Tafel slops for the various catalysts did not change after the pyrolytic process suggesting that the mechanism for the ORR is not affected by the heat treatment. TEM images, X-ray diffraction, XPS spectroscopy, ⁵⁷Fe Mössbauer, and DFT simulations, suggest that there is no breakdown of the macrocyclic complex at elevated temperatures, and that the macro cyclic geometry is preserved. Small variations in the Metal-O₂ (M-O₂) binding energies and the M–N bond length were observed which is attributed to the dispersive interaction between the macrocycles and the irregular surface of the Vulcan substrate induced by the heat treatment and causing better interaction with the O₂ molecule. The theoretical strategy herein applied well simulate and explain the nature of the M–N–C active sites and the performances towards the ORR.

Systematic Study of Effective Hydrothermal Synthesis to Fabricate Nb-Incorporated TiO2 for Oxygen Reduction Reaction

Fuel cells are expected to serve as next-generation energy conversion devices owing to their high energy density, high power, and long life performance. The oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) is important for determining the performance of fuel cells; therefore, using catalysts to promote the ORR is essential for realizing the practical applications of fuel cells. Herein, we propose Nb-incorporated TiO₂ as a suitable alternative to conventional Pt-based catalysts, because Nb doping has been reported to improve the conductivity and electron transfer number of TiO₂. In addition, Nb-incorporated TiO₂ can induce the electrocatalytic activity for the ORR. In this paper, we report the synthesis method for Nb-incorporated TiO₂ through a hydrothermal process with and without additional load pressures. The electrocatalytic activity of the synthesized samples for the ORR was also demonstrated. In this process, the samples obtained under various load pressures exceeding the saturated vapor pressure featured a high content of Nb and crystalline TiNb₂O₇, resulting in an ellipsoidal morphology. X-ray diffraction results also revealed that, on increasing the Nb doping amounts, the diffraction peak of the anatase TiO₂ shifted to a lower angle and the full width at half maximum decreased. This implies that the Ti atom is exchanged with the Nb atom during this process, resulting in a decrease in TiO₂ crystallinity. At a doping level of 10%, Nb-incorporated TiO₂ exhibited the best electrocatalytic activity in terms of the oxygen reduction current (i_ORR) and onset potential for the ORR (E_ORR); this suggests that 10% Nb-doped samples have the potential for enhancing electrocatalytic activity.

Understanding the factors governing the water oxidation reaction pathway of mononuclear and binuclear cobalt phthalocyanine catalysts

The rational design of efficient catalysts for electrochemical water oxidation highly depends on the understanding of reaction pathways, which still remains a challenge. Herein, mononuclear and binuclear cobalt phthalocyanine (mono-CoPc and bi-CoPc) with a well-defined molecular structure are selected as model electrocatalysts to study the water oxidation mechanism. We found that bi-CoPc on a carbon support (bi-CoPc/carbon) shows an overpotential of 357 mV at 10 mA cm⁻², much lower than that of mono-CoPc/carbon (>450 mV). Kinetic analysis reveals that the rate-determining step (RDS) of the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) over both electrocatalysts is a nucleophilic attack process involving a hydroxy anion (OH⁻). However, the substrate nucleophilically attacked by OH⁻ for bi-CoPc is the phthalocyanine cation-radical species (Co^II–Pc–Pc˙⁺–Co^II–OH) that is formed from the oxidation of the phthalocyanine ring, while cobalt oxidized species (Pc–Co^III–OH) is involved in mono-CoPc as evidenced by the operando UV-vis spectroelectrochemistry technique. DFT calculations show that the reaction barrier for the nucleophilic attack of OH⁻ on Co^II–Pc–Pc˙⁺–Co^II–OH is 1.67 eV, lower than that of mono-CoPc with Pc–Co^III–OH nucleophilically attacked by OH⁻ (1.78 eV). The good agreement between the experimental and theoretical results suggests that bi-CoPc can effectively stabilize the accumulated oxidative charges in the phthalocyanine ring, and is thus bestowed with a higher OER performance.

bi-CoPc can stabilize accumulated oxidative charges in phthalocyanine ring, which leads to the OER proceeding through a nucleophilic attack of OH^- on the phthalocyanine cation-radical species that is formed from the oxidation of phthalocyanine ring.

Enhanced Oxygen Reduction Reaction Performance Using Intermolecular Forces Coupled with More Exposed Molecular Orbitals of Triphenylamine in Co-porphyrin Electrocatalysts

Triphenylamine (TPA) has often been used as a building block to construct functional organic materials yet is rarely employed in oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) due to its strong electron-donating ability. This versatile segment bears a three-dimensional spatial structure whose effect has not been fully explored in catalytic systems. To this end, five symmetric cobalt porphyrins with carbazole and TPA derivatives have been synthesized and their ORR performance has been evaluated in acid medium. It was found that all compounds produced mainly hydrogen peroxide in oxygen reduction, with CP1 attaching benzyl derivatives and XCP4 possessing TPA-carbazole substituents at the meso-position of porphyrin, showing similar but more positive ORR potential as compared to the other analogues. Importantly, XCP4 achieved the greatest response current and the largest electron transfer numbers and H₂O₂ yields among the investigated molecules. Detailed electrochemical measurements suggested that the dipole-induced partial charges on the porphyrin in tandem with the more exposed molecular orbitals on TPA contributed to this enhancement, with the former attracting more protons to the affinity of reactive sites and the latter increasing the collision frequency between the electrocatalyst and H⁺ in solution. This is the first attempt to integrate the intermolecular forces with more exposed molecular orbitals in altering the electrochemical process.