Functional Characterization and Expression Analyses Show Differential Roles of Maternal and Zygotic Dgcr8 in Early Embryonic Development

Knockout, Knockdown, and the Schrödinger Paradox: Genetic Immunity to Phenotypic Recapitulation in Zebrafish

Previous research has highlighted significant phenotypic discrepancies between knockout and knockdown approaches in zebrafish, raising concerns about the reliability of these methods. However, our study suggests that these differences are not as pronounced as was once believed. By carefully examining the roles of maternal and zygotic gene contributions, we demonstrate that these factors significantly influence phenotypic outcomes, often accounting for the observed discrepancies. Our findings emphasize that morpholinos, despite their potential off-target effects, can be effective tools when used with rigorous controls. We introduce the concept of graded maternal contribution, which explains how the uneven distribution of maternal mRNA and proteins during gametogenesis impacts phenotypic variability. Our research categorizes genes into three types-susceptible, immune, and "Schrödinger" (conditional)-based on their phenotypic expression and interaction with genetic compensation mechanisms. This distinction provides new insights into the paradoxical outcomes observed in genetic studies. Ultimately, our work underscores the importance of considering both maternal and zygotic contributions, alongside rigorous experimental controls, to accurately interpret gene function and the mechanisms underlying disease. This study advocates for the continued use of morpholinos in conjunction with advanced genetic tools like CRISPR/Cas9, stressing the need for a meticulous experimental design to optimize the utility of zebrafish in genetic research and therapeutic development.

Genetic Deletion of miR-430 Disrupts Maternal-Zygotic Transition and Embryonic Body Plan

MiR-430 is considered an important regulator during embryonic development, but genetic loss-of-function study is still lacking. Here we demonstrated that genetic deletion of the miR-430 cluster resulted in developmental defects in cell movement, germ layer specification, axis patterning and organ progenitor formation in zebrafish. Transcriptome analysis indicated that the maternally provided transcripts were not properly degraded whereas the zygotic genome expressed genes were not fully activated in the miR-430 mutants. We further found that a reciprocal regulatory loop exists between miR-430 and maternally provided transcripts: the maternally provided transcripts (Nanog, Dicer1, Dgcr8, and AGOs) are required for miR-430 biogenesis and function, whereas miR-430 is required for the clearance of these maternally provided transcripts. These data provide the first genetic evidence that miR-430 is required for maternal-zygotic transition and subsequent establishment of embryonic body plan.