Diagnostic Vaccination in Clinical Practice

Practical considerations in diagnosing inborn errors of immunity according to the Middle East and North Africa guidelines

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The rate of inborn errors of immunity (IEI) in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region is generally higher than in other parts of the world. IEI patients in MENA exhibit more severe disease phenotypes. One of the most important reasons for this is delayed diagnosis. In this review, we examine issues pertinent to primary, secondary, and tertiary physicians in diagnosing IEI in children and discuss the key points for pediatricians according to the MENA guideline.

RECENT FINDINGS

Protocols and stepwise approaches designed by a panel of clinical immunologists included in the MENA-IEI registry network can help physicians facilitate the diagnosis of patients with IEI by providing recommendations. These recommendations for diagnostic approaches improve the care of patients within the MENA region and can also be applied to IEI patients in other parts of the world other regions.

SUMMARY

Physicians in the MENA region should be aware of IEI, obtain a detailed family history, request tests that can be ordered in primary care when IEI is suspected, and refer patients to clinical immunologists without delay. Primary and secondary care physicians should be aware that patients with IEI may present with noninfectious manifestations and increased infection frequency, severity, and atypical infections.

Evaluating patient immunocompetence through antibody response to pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine using a newly developed 23 serotype multiplexed assay

Assessing T-cell independent antibody response to polysaccharide vaccines is crucial for diagnosing humoral immune deficiencies. However, immunocompetence criteria based on S. pneumoniae vaccination remain unclear. We evaluated IgG antibody vaccine response in healthy individuals to establish interpretive criteria. Pre- and 4-week post-vaccination sera were collected from 79 adults. Antibody concentrations to PNEUMOVAX 23 serotypes were measured using a multiplexed platform. Immunocompetence was determined by fold increase in post-vaccination response, percentage of serotypes achieving 4- or 2-fold antibody ratio, and post-vaccination concentration ≥ 1.3 μg/mL. Immunogenicity varied widely across the 23 serotypes (26.6% to 94.9% for ≥4-fold increase, 51.9% to 98.7% for ≥2-fold increase). Immunocompetence based on historic criteria of ≥4-fold increase in antibody ratio to ≥70% of serotypes was low (72.2%), but increased to 98.7% with criteria of at least a 2-fold increase and/or post-vaccination concentration ≥ 1.3 μg/mL. Current criteria for assessing immunocompetence may be overly stringent and require updating.

Immunoglobulin repertoire restriction characterizes the serological responses of patients with predominantly antibody deficiency

BACKGROUND

Predominantly antibody deficiency (PAD) is the most common category of inborn errors of immunity and is underpinned by impaired generation of appropriate antibody diversity and quantity. In the clinic, responses are interrogated by assessment of vaccination responses, which is central to many PAD diagnoses. However, the composition of the generated antibody repertoire is concealed from traditional quantitative measures of serological responses. Leveraging modern mass spectrometry-based proteomics (MS-proteomics), it is possible to elaborate the molecular features of specific antibody repertoires, which may address current limitations of diagnostic vaccinology.

OBJECTIVES

We sought to evaluate serum antibody responses in patients with PAD following vaccination with a neo-antigen (severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2 vaccination) using MS-proteomics.

METHODS

Following severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2 vaccination, serological responses in individuals with PAD and healthy controls (HCs) were assessed by anti-S1 subunit ELISA and neutralization assays. Purified anti-S1 subunit IgG and IgM was profiled by MS-proteomics for IGHV subfamily usage and somatic hypermutation analysis.

RESULTS

Twelve patients with PAD who were vaccine-responsive were recruited with 11 matched vaccinated HCs. Neutralization and end point anti-S1 titers were lower in PAD. All subjects with PAD demonstrated restricted anti-S1 IgG antibody repertoires, with usage of <5 IGHV subfamilies (median: 3; range 2-4), compared to ≥5 for the 11 HC subjects (P < .001). IGHV3-7 utilization was far less common in patients with PAD than in HCs (2 of 12 vs 10 of 11; P = .001). Amino acid substitutions due to somatic hypermutation per subfamily did not differ between groups. Anti-S1 IgM was present in 64% and 50% of HC and PAD cohorts, respectively, and did not differ significantly between HCs and patients with PAD.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates the breadth of anti-S1 antibodies elicited by vaccination at the proteome level and identifies stereotypical restriction of IGHV utilization in the IgG repertoire in patients with PAD compared with HC subjects. Despite uniformly pauci-clonal antibody repertoires some patients with PAD generated potent serological responses, highlighting a possible limitation of traditional serological techniques. These findings suggest that IgG repertoire restriction is a key feature of antibody repertoires in PAD.

Value of diagnostic vaccination in diagnosis of humoral inborn errors of immunity

Inborn errors of immunity (IEIs) or primary immunodeficiency diseases, are disorders caused by genetic defects affecting immune function. Clinically, IEI presents mainly as recurrent or severe infections, immune dysregulation (autoimmunity or autoinflammatory disorders), and lymphoproliferation with or without dysmorphic features. Humoral IEIs are the largest subgroup of IEI, with a wide spectrum of quantitative and qualitative antibody defects. These disorders are normally diagnosed based on immunological evaluation; diagnostic vaccination is part of this evaluation. This review examines the importance and relevance of diagnostic vaccination in the diagnosis of humoral IEIs and different technologies which can be utilised in diagnosis.

Application of vaccine response in the evaluation of patients with suspected B-cell immunodeficiency: Assessment of responses and challenges with interpretation

Diagnostic vaccination is an integral component in the evaluation of patients suspected to have a B cell or humoral deficiency. Evaluation of antibody production in response to both protein- and polysaccharide-based vaccines aids in distinguishing between specific categories of humoral deficiency. Although assessment of pneumococcal polysaccharide responses is widely available and included in diagnostic guidelines, significant variability still exists in the measurement and interpretation of these responses. Interpretation can also be complicated by age, vaccination history and treatment with immunoglobulin replacement therapy. Despite the challenges and limitations of evaluating pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine responses, it can provide valuable diagnostic and prognostic information to guide therapeutic intervention. Future efforts are needed to further standardize measurement and interpretation of pneumococcal antibody responses to vaccination and to identify and establish other methods and/or vaccines as alternatives to pneumococcal vaccination to address the challenges in certain patient populations.

A low level of naturally occurring antibodies associates with functional antibody deficiency

Functional antibody deficiency is clinically assessed from antibody responses to vaccination. However, diagnostic vaccination is complex and may fail in practice. We hypothesized that the levels of naturally occurring antibodies against galactose-α-1,3-galactose (αGal) may represent alternative markers of functional antibody capacity. We included data from 229 patients with suspected primary immunodeficiency in a retrospective study. Antibody levels against αGal and twelve pneumococcal serotypes were determined with solid-phase immunoassays. Pneumococcal vaccinations and treatment with normal human immunoglobulin were assessed from medical records. Anti-αGal antibody levels correlated positively with anti-pneumococcal antibody levels measured before and after pneumococcal vaccination. Contrary to the anti-pneumococcal antibody levels, the anti-αGal antibody level showed potential for predicting subsequent immunoglobulin treatment - a marker of disease severity. Naturally occurring antibodies may reflect the functional capacity tested by diagnostic vaccination but add more useful clinical data. The clinical utility of this easy test should be evaluated in prospective studies.