Experimental Designs to Study the Aggregation and Colonization of Biofilms by Video Microscopy With Statistical Confidence

Real-time monitoring of biofilm growth identifies andrographolide as a potent antifungal compound eradicating Candida biofilms

Candida species cause life-threatening infections with high morbidity and mortality rates and their resistance to conventional therapy is closely linked to biofilm formation. Thus, the development of new approaches to study Candida biofilms and the identification of novel therapeutic strategies could yield improved clinical outcomes. In the current study, we have set up an impedance-based in vitro system to study Candida spp. biofilms in real-time and to evaluate their sensitivity to two conventional antifungal groups used in clinical practice - azoles and echinocandins. Both fluconazole and voriconazole were unable to inhibit biofilm formation in most strains tested, while echinocandins showed biofilm inhibitory capacity at relatively low concentrations (starting from 0.625 mg/L). However, assays performed on 24 h Candida albicans and C. glabrata biofilms revealed that micafungin and caspofungin failed to eradicate mature biofilms at all tested concentrations, evidencing that once formed, Candida spp. biofilms are extremely difficult to eliminate using currently available antifungals. We then evaluated the antifungal and anti-biofilm effect of andrographolide, a natural compound isolated from the plant Andrographis paniculata with known antibiofilm activity on Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. Optical density measures, impedance evaluation, CFU counts, and electron microscopy data showed that andrographolide strongly inhibits planktonic Candida spp. growth and halts Candida spp. biofilm formation in a dose-dependent manner in all tested strains. Moreover, andrographolide was capable of eliminating mature biofilms and viable cell numbers by up to 99.9% in the C. albicans and C. glabrata strains tested, suggesting its potential as a new approach to treat multi-resistant Candida spp. biofilm-related infections.

Tools of the Trade: Image Analysis Programs for Confocal Laser-Scanning Microscopy Studies of Biofilms and Considerations for Their Use by Experimental Researchers

Confocal laser-scanning microscopy (CLSM) is the bedrock of the microscopic visualization of biofilms. Previous applications of CLSM in biofilm studies have largely focused on observations of bacterial or fungal elements of biofilms, often seen as aggregates or mats of cells. However, the field of biofilm research is moving beyond qualitative observations alone, toward the quantitative analysis of the structural and functional features of biofilms, across clinical, environmental, and laboratory conditions. In recent times, several image analysis programs have been developed to extract and quantify biofilm properties from confocal micrographs. These tools not only vary in their scope and relevance to the specific biofilm features under study but also with respect to the user interface, compatibility with operating systems, and raw image requirements. Understanding these considerations is important when selecting tools for quantitative biofilm analysis, including at the initial experimental stages of image acquisition. In this review, we provide an overview of image analysis programs for confocal micrographs of biofilms, with a focus on tool selection and image acquisition parameters that are relevant for experimental researchers to ensure reliability and compatibility with downstream image processing.

Imaging and plate counting to quantify the effect of an antimicrobial: A case study of a photo-activated chlorine dioxide treatment

AIM

Assess removal versus kill efficacies of antimicrobial treatments against thick biofilms with statistical confidence.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A photo activated chlorine dioxide treatment (Photo ClO₂ ) was tested in two independent experiments against thick (>100 μm) Pseuodmonas aeruginosa biofilms. Kill efficacy was assessed by viable plate counts. Removal efficacy was assessed by 3D confocal scanning laser microscope imaging (CSLM). Biovolumes were calculated using an image analysis approach that models the penetration limitation of the laser into thick biofilms using Beer's Law. Error bars are provided that account for the spatial correlation of the biofilm's surface. The responsiveness of the biovolumes and plate counts to the increasing contact time of Photo ClO₂ were quite different, with a massive 7 log reduction in viable cells (95% CI: 6.2, 7.9]) but a more moderate 73% reduction in biovolume (95% CI: [60%, 100%]). Results are leveraged to quantitatively assess candidate CSLM experimental designs of thick biofilms .

CONCLUSIONS

Photo ClO₂ kills but only partially removes the biofilm from the surface. To maximize statistical confidence in assessing removal, imaging experiments should use fewer pixels in each z-slice, and more importantly, at least 2 independent experiments even if there is only a single field of view in each experiment.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF STUDY

There is limited penetration depth when collecting 3D confocal images of thick biofilms. Removal can be assessed by optimally fitting Beer's Law to all of the intensities in a 3D image and by accounting for the spatial correlation of the biofilm's surface. For thick biofilms, other image analysis approaches are biased or do not provide error bars. We generate unbiased estimates of removal and assess candidate CSLM experimental designs of thick biofilms with different pixilations, numbers of fields of view and numbers of experiments using the included design tool.