Improvement of Methodology for Manual Energy Intake Estimation From Passive Capture Devices

I2N: image to nutrients, a sensor guided semi-automated tool for annotation of images for nutrition analysis of eating episodes

Introduction

Dietary assessment is important for understanding nutritional status. Traditional methods of monitoring food intake through self-report such as diet diaries, 24-hour dietary recall, and food frequency questionnaires may be subject to errors and can be time-consuming for the user.

Methods

This paper presents a semi-automatic dietary assessment tool we developed - a desktop application called Image to Nutrients (I2N) - to process sensor-detected eating events and images captured during these eating events by a wearable sensor. I2N has the capacity to offer multiple food and nutrient databases (e.g., USDA-SR, FNDDS, USDA Global Branded Food Products Database) for annotating eating episodes and food items. I2N estimates energy intake, nutritional content, and the amount consumed. The components of I2N are three-fold: 1) sensor-guided image review, 2) annotation of food images for nutritional analysis, and 3) access to multiple food databases. Two studies were used to evaluate the feasibility and usefulness of I2N: 1) a US-based study with 30 participants and a total of 60 days of data and 2) a Ghana-based study with 41 participants and a total of 41 days of data).

Results

In both studies, a total of 314 eating episodes were annotated using at least three food databases. Using I2N's sensor-guided image review, the number of images that needed to be reviewed was reduced by 93% and 85% for the two studies, respectively, compared to reviewing all the images.

Discussion

I2N is a unique tool that allows for simultaneous viewing of food images, sensor-guided image review, and access to multiple databases in one tool, making nutritional analysis of food images efficient. The tool is flexible, allowing for nutritional analysis of images if sensor signals aren't available.

Energy intake estimation using a novel wearable sensor and food images in a laboratory (pseudo-free-living) meal setting: quantification and contribution of sources of error

OBJECTIVES

Dietary assessment methods not relying on self-report are needed. The Automatic Ingestion Monitor 2 (AIM-2) combines a wearable camera that captures food images with sensors that detect food intake. We compared energy intake (EI) estimates of meals derived from AIM-2 chewing sensor signals, AIM-2 images, and an internet-based diet diary, with researcher conducted weighed food records (WFR) as the gold standard.

SUBJECTS/METHODS

Thirty adults wore the AIM-2 for meals self-selected from a university food court on one day in mixed laboratory and free-living conditions. Daily EI was determined from a sensor regression model, manual image analysis, and a diet diary and compared with that from WFR. A posteriori analysis identified sources of error for image analysis and WFR differences.

RESULTS

Sensor-derived EI from regression modeling (R² = 0.331) showed the closest agreement with EI from WFR, followed by diet diary estimates. EI from image analysis differed significantly from that by WFR. Bland-Altman analysis showed wide limits of agreement for all three test methods with WFR, with the sensor method overestimating at lower and underestimating at higher EI. Nutritionist error in portion size estimation and irreconcilable differences in portion size between food and nutrient databases used for WFR and image analyses were the greatest contributors to image analysis and WFR differences (44.4% and 44.8% of WFR EI, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

Estimation of daily EI from meals using sensor-derived features offers a promising alternative to overcome limitations of self-report. Image analysis may benefit from computerized analytical procedures to reduce identified sources of error.