Geometric and Dosimetric Evaluation of Deep Learning-Based Automatic Delineation on CBCT-Synthesized CT and Planning CT for Breast Cancer Adaptive Radiotherapy: A Multi-Institutional Study

Uncertainty estimation- and attention-based semi-supervised models for automatically delineate clinical target volume in CBCT images of breast cancer

OBJECTIVES

Accurate segmentation of the clinical target volume (CTV) of CBCT images can observe the changes of CTV during patients' radiotherapy, and lay a foundation for the subsequent implementation of adaptive radiotherapy (ART). However, segmentation is challenging due to the poor quality of CBCT images and difficulty in obtaining target volumes. An uncertainty estimation- and attention-based semi-supervised model called residual convolutional block attention-uncertainty aware mean teacher (RCBA-UAMT) was proposed to delineate the CTV in cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) images of breast cancer automatically.

METHODS

A total of 60 patients who undergone radiotherapy after breast-conserving surgery were enrolled in this study, which involved 60 planning CTs and 380 CBCTs. RCBA-UAMT was proposed by integrating residual and attention modules in the backbone network 3D UNet. The attention module can adjust channel and spatial weights of the extracted image features. The proposed design can train the model and segment CBCT images with a small amount of labeled data (5%, 10%, and 20%) and a large amount of unlabeled data. Four types of evaluation metrics, namely, dice similarity coefficient (DSC), Jaccard, average surface distance (ASD), and 95% Hausdorff distance (95HD), are used to assess the model segmentation performance quantitatively.

RESULTS

The proposed method achieved average DSC, Jaccard, 95HD, and ASD of 82%, 70%, 8.93, and 1.49 mm for CTV delineation on CBCT images of breast cancer, respectively. Compared with the three classical methods of mean teacher, uncertainty-aware mean-teacher and uncertainty rectified pyramid consistency, DSC and Jaccard increased by 7.89-9.33% and 14.75-16.67%, respectively, while 95HD and ASD decreased by 33.16-67.81% and 36.05-75.57%, respectively. The comparative experiment results of the labeled data with different proportions (5%, 10% and 20%) showed significant differences in the DSC, Jaccard, and 95HD evaluation indexes in the labeled data with 5% versus 10% and 5% versus 20%. Moreover, no significant differences were observed in the labeled data with 10% versus 20% among all evaluation indexes. Therefore, we can use only 10% labeled data to achieve the experimental objective.

CONCLUSIONS

Using the proposed RCBA-UAMT, the CTV of breast cancer CBCT images can be delineated reliably with a small amount of labeled data. These delineated images can be used to observe the changes in CTV and lay the foundation for the follow-up implementation of ART.

A systematic literature review: deep learning techniques for synthetic medical image generation and their applications in radiotherapy

The aim of this systematic review is to determine whether Deep Learning (DL) algorithms can provide a clinically feasible alternative to classic algorithms for synthetic Computer Tomography (sCT). The following categories are presented in this study: ∙ MR-based treatment planning and synthetic CT generation techniques. ∙ Generation of synthetic CT images based on Cone Beam CT images. ∙ Low-dose CT to High-dose CT generation. ∙ Attenuation correction for PET images. To perform appropriate database searches, we reviewed journal articles published between January 2018 and June 2023. Current methodology, study strategies, and results with relevant clinical applications were analyzed as we outlined the state-of-the-art of deep learning based approaches to inter-modality and intra-modality image synthesis. This was accomplished by contrasting the provided methodologies with traditional research approaches. The key contributions of each category were highlighted, specific challenges were identified, and accomplishments were summarized. As a final step, the statistics of all the cited works from various aspects were analyzed, which revealed that DL-based sCTs have achieved considerable popularity, while also showing the potential of this technology. In order to assess the clinical readiness of the presented methods, we examined the current status of DL-based sCT generation.

Evaluating AI-generated CBCT-based synthetic CT images for target delineation in palliative treatments of pelvic bone metastasis at conventional C-arm linacs

PURPOSE

One-table treatments with treatment imaging, preparation and delivery occurring at one treatment couch, could increase patients' comfort and throughput for palliative treatments. On regular C-arm linacs, however, cone-beam CT (CBCT) imaging quality is currently insufficient. Therefore, our goal was to assess the suitability of AI-generated CBCT based synthetic CT (sCT) images for target delineation and treatment planning for palliative radiotherapy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

CBCTs and planning CT-scans of 22 female patients with pelvic bone metastasis were included. For each CBCT, a corresponding sCT image was generated by a deep learning model in ADMIRE 3.38.0. Radiation oncologists delineated 23 target volumes (TV) on the sCTs (TVsCT) and scored their delineation confidence. The delineations were transferred to planning CTs and manually adjusted if needed to yield gold standard target volumes (TVclin). TVsCT were geometrically compared to TVclin using Dice coefficient (DC) and Hausdorff Distance (HD). The dosimetric impact of TVsCT inaccuracies was evaluated for VMAT plans with different PTV margins.

RESULTS

Radiation oncologists scored the sCT quality as sufficient for 13/23 TVsCT (median: DC = 0.9, HD = 11 mm) and insufficient for 10/23 TVsCT (median: DC = 0.7, HD = 34 mm). For the sufficient category, remaining inaccuracies could be compensated by +1 to +4 mm additional margin to achieve coverage of V95% > 95% and V95% > 98%, respectively in 12/13 TVsCT.

CONCLUSION

The evaluated sCT quality allowed for accurate delineation for most targets. sCTs with insufficient quality could be identified accurately upfront. A moderate PTV margin expansion could address remaining delineation inaccuracies. Therefore, these findings support further exploration of CBCT based one-table treatments on C-arm linacs.

Prior information guided auto-segmentation of clinical target volume of tumor bed in postoperative breast cancer radiotherapy

BACKGROUND

Accurate delineation of clinical target volume of tumor bed (CTV-TB) is important but it is also challenging due to surgical effects and soft tissue contrast. Recently a few auto-segmentation methods were developed to improve the process. However, those methods had comparatively low segmentation accuracy. In this study the prior information was introduced to aid auto-segmentation of CTV-TB based on a deep-learning model.

METHODS

To aid the delineation of CTV-TB, the tumor contour on preoperative CT was transformed onto postoperative CT via deformable image registration. Both original and transformed tumor contours were used for prior information in training an auto-segmentation model. Then, the CTV-TB contour on postoperative CT was predicted by the model. 110 pairs of preoperative and postoperative CT images were used with a 5-fold cross-validation strategy. The predicted contour was compared with the clinically approved contour for accuracy evaluation using dice similarity coefficient (DSC) and Hausdorff distance.

RESULTS

The average DSC of the deep-learning model with prior information was improved than the one without prior information (0.808 vs. 0.734, P < 0.05). The average DSC of the deep-learning model with prior information was higher than that of the traditional method (0.808 vs. 0.622, P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The introduction of prior information in deep-learning model can improve segmentation accuracy of CTV-TB. The proposed method provided an effective way to automatically delineate CTV-TB in postoperative breast cancer radiotherapy.

A Review of the Metrics Used to Assess Auto-Contouring Systems in Radiotherapy

Auto-contouring could revolutionise future planning of radiotherapy treatment. The lack of consensus on how to assess and validate auto-contouring systems currently limits clinical use. This review formally quantifies the assessment metrics used in studies published during one calendar year and assesses the need for standardised practice. A PubMed literature search was undertaken for papers evaluating radiotherapy auto-contouring published during 2021. Papers were assessed for types of metric and the methodology used to generate ground-truth comparators. Our PubMed search identified 212 studies, of which 117 met the criteria for clinical review. Geometric assessment metrics were used in 116 of 117 studies (99.1%). This includes the Dice Similarity Coefficient used in 113 (96.6%) studies. Clinically relevant metrics, such as qualitative, dosimetric and time-saving metrics, were less frequently used in 22 (18.8%), 27 (23.1%) and 18 (15.4%) of 117 studies, respectively. There was heterogeneity within each category of metric. Over 90 different names for geometric measures were used. Methods for qualitative assessment were different in all but two papers. Variation existed in the methods used to generate radiotherapy plans for dosimetric assessment. Consideration of editing time was only given in 11 (9.4%) papers. A single manual contour as a ground-truth comparator was used in 65 (55.6%) studies. Only 31 (26.5%) studies compared auto-contours to usual inter- and/or intra-observer variation. In conclusion, significant variation exists in how research papers currently assess the accuracy of automatically generated contours. Geometric measures are the most popular, however their clinical utility is unknown. There is heterogeneity in the methods used to perform clinical assessment. Considering the different stages of system implementation may provide a framework to decide the most appropriate metrics. This analysis supports the need for a consensus on the clinical implementation of auto-contouring.

Accuracy and Feasibility of Synthetic CT for Lung Adaptive Radiotherapy: A Phantom Study

OBJECTIVES

The respiratory variations will lead to inconsistency between the actual delivery dose and the planning dose. How the minor interfractional amplitude changes affect the geometry and dose delivery accuracy remains to be investigated in the context of lung adaptive radiotherapy.

METHODS

Planning 4-dimensional-computed tomography and kV-cone beam computed tomography were scanned based on the Computerized Imaging Reference Systems phantom, which was employed to simulate the minor interfractional amplitude variations. The corresponding synthetic computed tomography for a particular motion pattern can be generated from Velocity program. Then a clinically meaningful synthetic computed tomography was analyzed through the geometrical and dosimetric assessment.

RESULTS

The image quality of synthetic computed tomography was improved obviously compared with cone beam computed tomography. Mean absolute error was minimized when no significant interfractional motion occurs and Velocity can be qualified for dealing with the regular breathing motion patterns. The mean percent hounsfield unit difference of the synthetic hounsfield unit values per organ relative to the planning 4-dimensional-computed tomography image was 22.3%. Under the same conditions, the mean percent hounsfield unit difference of the cone beam computed tomography hounsfield unit values per organ, relative to the planning 4-dimensional-computed tomography image was 83.9%. Overall, the accuracy of hounsfield unit in synthetic computed tomography was improved obviously and the variability of the synthetic image correlates with the planning 4-dimensional-computed tomography image variability. Meanwhile, the dose-volume histograms between planning 4-dimensional-computed tomography and synthetic computed tomography almost coincided each other, which indicates that Velocity program can qualify lung adaptive radiotherapy well when there were no interfractional respiratory variations. However, for cases with obvious interfractional amplitude change, the volume covered at least by 100% of the prescription dose was only 59.6% for that synthetic image.

CONCLUSION

The synthetic computed tomography images generated from Velocity were close to the real images in anatomy and dosimetry, which can make clinical lung adaptive radiotherapy possible based on the actual patient anatomy during treatment.

A clinically relevant online patient QA solution with daily CT scans and EPID-based in vivo dosimetry: a feasibility study on rectal cancer

Objective. Adaptive radiation therapy (ART) could protect organs at risk (OARs) while maintain high dose coverage to targets. However, there is still a lack of efficient online patient quality assurance (QA) methods, which is an obstacle to large-scale adoption of ART. We aim to develop a clinically relevant online patient QA solution for ART using daily CT scans and EPID-based in vivo dosimetry. Approach. Ten patients with rectal cancer at our center were included. Patients’ daily CT scans and portal images were collected to generate reconstructed 3D dose distributions. Contours of targets and OARs were recontoured on these daily CT scans by a clinician or an auto-segmentation algorithm, then dose-volume indices were calculated, and the percent deviation of these indices to their original plans were determined. This deviation was regarded as the metric for clinically relevant patient QA. The tolerance level was obtained using a 95% confidence interval of the QA metric distribution. These deviations could be further divided into anatomically relevant or delivery relevant indicators for error source analysis. Finally, our QA solution was validated on an additional six clinical patients. Main results. In rectal cancer, the 95% confidence intervals of the QA metric for PTV ΔD 95 (%) were [−3.11%, 2.35%], and for PTV ΔD 2 (%) were [−0.78%, 3.23%]. In validation, 68% for PTV ΔD 95 (%), and 79% for PTV ΔD 2 (%) of the 28 fractions are within tolerances of the QA metrics. one patient’s dosimetric impact of anatomical variations during treatment were observed through the source of error analysis. Significance. The online patient QA solution using daily CT scans and EPID-based in vivo dosimetry is clinically feasible. Source of error analysis has the potential for distinguishing sources of error and guiding ART for future treatments.

Development and validation of a scatter-corrected CBCT image-guided method for cervical cancer brachytherapy

Background and purpose

Multiple patient transfers have a nonnegligible impact on the accuracy of dose delivery for cervical cancer brachytherapy. We consider using on-site cone-beam CT (CBCT) to resolve this problem. However, CBCT clinical applications are limited due to inadequate image quality. This paper implements a scatter correction method using planning CT (pCT) prior to obtaining high-quality CBCT images and evaluates the dose calculation accuracy of CBCT-guided brachytherapy for cervical cancer.

Materials and methods

The CBCT of a self-developed female pelvis phantom and five patients was first corrected using empirical uniform scatter correction in the projection domain and further corrected in the image domain. In both phantom and patient studies, the CBCT image quality before and after scatter correction was evaluated with registered pCT (rCT). Model-based dose calculation was performed using the commercial package Acuros®BV. The dose distributions of rCT-based plans and corrected CBCT-based plans in the phantom and patients were compared using 3D local gamma analysis. A statistical analysis of the differences in dosimetric parameters of five patients was also performed.

Results

In both phantom and patient studies, the HU error of selected ROIs was reduced to less than 15 HU. Using the dose distribution of the rCT-based plan as the baseline, the γ pass rate (2%, 2 mm) of the corrected CBCT-based plan in phantom and patients all exceeded 98% and 93%, respectively, with the threshold dose set to 3, 6, 9, and 12 Gy. The average percentage deviation (APD) of D90 of HRCTV and D2cc of OARs was less than 1% between rCT-based and corrected CBCT-based plans.

Conclusion

Scatter correction using a pCT prior can effectively improve the CBCT image quality and CBCT-based cervical brachytherapy dose calculation accuracy, indicating promising prospects in both simplified brachytherapy processes and accurate brachytherapy dose delivery.

Deep learning methods for enhancing cone-beam CT image quality towards adaptive radiation therapy: A systematic review

The use of deep learning (DL) to improve cone-beam CT (CBCT) image quality has gained popularity as computational resources and algorithmic sophistication have advanced in tandem. CBCT imaging has the potential to facilitate online adaptive radiation therapy (ART) by utilizing up-to-date patient anatomy to modify treatment parameters before irradiation. Poor CBCT image quality has been an impediment to realizing ART due to the increased scatter conditions inherent to cone-beam acquisitions. Given the recent interest in DL applications in radiation oncology, and specifically DL for CBCT correction, we provide a systematic theoretical and literature review for future stakeholders. The review encompasses DL approaches for synthetic CT generation, as well as projection domain methods employed in the CBCT correction literature. We review trends pertaining to publications from January 2018 to April 2022 and condense their major findings - with emphasis on study design and deep learning techniques. Clinically relevant endpoints relating to image quality and dosimetric accuracy are summarised, highlighting gaps in the literature. Finally, we make recommendations for both clinicians and DL practitioners based on literature trends and the current DL state of the art methods utilized in radiation oncology. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.