Radio-Frequency Safety Assessment of Stents in Blood Vessels During Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Effect of surgical modification of deep brain stimulation lead trajectories on radiofrequency heating during MRI at 3T: from phantom experiments to clinical implementation

OBJECTIVE

Radiofrequency (RF) tissue heating around deep brain stimulation (DBS) leads is a well-known safety risk during MRI, resulting in strict imaging guidelines and limited allowable protocols. The implanted lead's trajectory and orientation with respect to the MRI electric fields contribute to variations in the magnitude of RF heating across patients. Currently, there are no surgical requirements for implanting the extracranial portion of the DBS lead, resulting in substantial variations in clinical lead trajectories and consequently RF heating. Recent studies have shown that incorporating concentric loops in the extracranial lead trajectory can reduce RF heating. However, optimal positioning of the loops and the quantitative benefit of trajectory modification in terms of added safety margins during MRI remain unknown. In this study, the authors systematically evaluated the characteristics of DBS lead trajectories that minimize RF heating during 3T MRI to develop the best surgical practices for safe access to postoperative MRI, and they present the first surgical implementation of these modified trajectories.

METHODS

The authors performed experiments to assess the maximum temperature increase of 244 distinct lead trajectories. They investigated the effect of the position, number, and size of the concentric loops on the skull. Experiments were performed in an anthropomorphic phantom implanted with a commercial DBS system, and RF exposure was generated by applying a high specific absorption rate sequence (B1+rms = 2.7 µT). The authors conducted test-retest experiments to assess the reliability of measurements. Additionally, they evaluated the effect of imaging landmarks and perturbations to the DBS device configuration on the efficacy of low-heating trajectories. Finally, two neurosurgeons implanted the recommended modified trajectories in patients, and the authors characterized their RF heating in comparison with unmodified trajectories.

RESULTS

The maximum temperature increase ranged from 0.09°C to 7.34°C. The authors found that increasing the number of loops and positioning them closer to the surgical burr hole, particularly for the contralateral lead, substantially reduced RF heating. These trajectory modifications were easily incorporated during the surgical procedure and resulted in a threefold reduction in RF heating.

CONCLUSIONS

Surgically modifying the extracranial portion of the DBS lead trajectory can substantially reduce RF heating during 3T MRI. The authors' results indicate that simple adjustments to the lead's configuration, such as small, concentric loops near the burr hole, can be readily adopted during DBS lead implantation to improve patient safety during MRI.

Computational modeling of the thermal effects of flow on radio frequency-induced heating of peripheral vascular stents during MRI

Purpose. The goal of this study was to develop and validate a computational model that can accurately predict the influence of flow on the temperature rise near a peripheral vascular stent during magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).Methods. Computational modeling and simulation of radio frequency (RF) induced heating of a vascular stent during MRI at 3.0 T was developed and validated with flow phantom experiments. The maximum temperature rise of the stent was measured as a function of physiologically relevant flow rates.Results. A significant difference was not identified between the experiment and simulation (P > 0.05). The temperature rise of the stent during MRI was over 10 °C without flow, and was reduced by 5 °C with a flow rate of only 58 ml min-1, corresponding to a reduction of CEM43from 45 min to less than 1 min.Conclusion. The computer model developed in this study was validated with experimental measurements, and accurately predicted the influence of flow on the RF-induced temperature rise of a vascular stent during MRI. Furthermore, the results of this study demonstrate that relatively low flow rates significantly reduce the temperature rise of a stent and the surrounding medium during RF-induced heating under typical scanning power and physiologically relevant conditions.

Age Matters: A Comparative Study of RF Heating of Epicardial and Endocardial Electronic Devices in Pediatric and Adult Phantoms during Cardiothoracic MRI

This study focused on the potential risks of radiofrequency-induced heating of cardiac implantable electronic devices (CIEDs) in children and adults with epicardial and endocardial leads of varying lengths during cardiothoracic MRI scans. Infants and young children are the primary recipients of epicardial CIEDs, though the devices have not been approved as MR conditional by the FDA due to limited data, leading to pediatric hospitals either refusing the MRI service to most pediatric CIED patients or adopting a scan-all strategy based on results from adult studies. The study argues that risk-benefit decisions should be made on an individual basis. We used 120 clinically relevant epicardial and endocardial device configurations in adult and pediatric anthropomorphic phantoms to determine the temperature rise during RF exposure at 1.5 T. The results showed that there was significantly higher RF heating of epicardial leads than endocardial leads in the pediatric phantom, but not in the adult phantom. Additionally, body size and lead length significantly affected RF heating, with RF heating up to 12 °C observed in models based on younger children with short epicardial leads. The study provides evidence-based knowledge on RF-induced heating of CIEDs and highlights the importance of making individual risk-benefit decisions when assessing the potential risks of MRI scans in pediatric CIED patients.

Simplified modeling of implanted medical devices with metallic filamentary closed loops exposed to low or medium frequency magnetic fields

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Electric currents are induced in implanted medical devices with metallic filamentary closed loops (e.g., fixation grids, stents) when exposed to time varying magnetic fields, as those generated during certain diagnostic and therapeutic biomedical treatments. A simplified methodology to efficiently compute these currents, to estimate the altered electromagnetic field distribution in the biological tissues and to assess the consequent biological effects is proposed for low or medium frequency fields.

METHODS

The proposed methodology is based on decoupling the handling of the filamentary wire and the anatomical body. To do this, a circuital solution is adopted to study the metallic filamentary implant and this solution is inserted in the electromagnetic field solution involving the biological tissues. The Joule losses computed in the implant are then used as a forcing term for the thermal problem defined by the bioheat Pennes' equation. The methodology is validated against a model problem, where a reference solution is available.

RESULTS

The proposed simplified methodology is proved to be in good agreement with solutions provided by alternative approaches. In particular, errors in the amplitude of the currents induced in the wires result to be always lower than 3%. After the validation, the methodology is applied to check the interactions between the magnetic field generated by different biomedical devices and a skull grid, which represents a complex filamentary wire implant.

CONCLUSIONS

The proposed simplified methodology, suitable to be applied to closed loop wires in the low to intermediate frequency range, is found to be sufficiently accurate and easy to apply in realistic exposure scenarios. This modeling tool allows analyzing different types of small implants, from coronary and biliary duct stents to orthopedic grids, under a variety of exposure scenarios.

Engineering molecular nanoprobes to target early atherosclerosis: Precise diagnostic tools and promising therapeutic carriers

Atherosclerosis, an inflammation-driven chronic blood vessel disease, is a major contributor to devastating cardiovascular events, bringing serious social and economic burdens. Currently, non-invasive diagnostic and therapeutic techniques in combination with novel nanosized materials as well as established molecular targets are under active investigation to develop integrated molecular imaging approaches, precisely visualizing and/or even effectively reversing early-stage plaques. Besides, mechanistic investigation in the past decades provides many potent candidates extensively involved in the initiation and progression of atherosclerosis. Recent hotly-studied imaging nanoprobes for detecting early plaques mainly including optical nanoprobes, photoacoustic nanoprobes, magnetic resonance nanoprobes, positron emission tomography nanoprobes, and other dual- and multi-modality imaging nanoprobes, have been proven to be surface functionalized with important molecular targets, which occupy tailored physical and biological properties for atherogenesis. Of note, these engineering nanoprobes provide long blood-pool residence and specific molecular targeting, which allows efficient recognition of early-stage atherosclerotic plaques and thereby function as a novel type of precise diagnostic tools as well as potential therapeutic carriers of anti-atherosclerosis drugs. There have been no available nanoprobes applied in the clinics so far, although many newly emerged nanoprobes, as exemplified by aggregation-induced emission nanoprobes and TiO₂ nanoprobes, have been tested for cell lines in vitro and atherogenic animal models in vivo, achieving good experimental effects. Therefore, there is an urgent call to translate these preclinical results for nanoprobes into clinical trials. For this reason, this review aims to give an overview of currently investigated nanoprobes in the context of atherosclerosis, summarize relevant published studies showing applications of different kinds of formulated nanoprobes in early detection and reverse of plaques, discuss recent advances and some limitations thereof, and provide some insights into the development of the new generation of more precise and efficient molecular nanoprobes, with a critical property of specifically targeting early atherosclerosis.

A comparative study of RF heating of deep brain stimulation devices in vertical vs. horizontal MRI systems

The majority of studies that assess magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) induced radiofrequency (RF) heating of the tissue when active electronic implants are present have been performed in horizontal, closed-bore MRI systems. Vertical, open-bore MRI systems have a 90° rotated magnet and a fundamentally different RF coil geometry, thus generating a substantially different RF field distribution inside the body. Little is known about the RF heating of elongated implants such as deep brain stimulation (DBS) devices in this class of scanners. Here, we conducted the first large-scale experimental study investigating whether RF heating was significantly different in a 1.2 T vertical field MRI scanner (Oasis, Fujifilm Healthcare) compared to a 1.5 T horizontal field MRI scanner (Aera, Siemens Healthineers). A commercial DBS device mimicking 30 realistic patient-derived lead trajectories extracted from postoperative computed tomography images of patients who underwent DBS surgery at our institution was implanted in a multi-material, anthropomorphic phantom. RF heating around the DBS lead was measured during four minutes of high-SAR RF exposure. Additionally, we performed electromagnetic simulations with leads of various internal structures to examine this effect on RF heating. When controlling for RMS B1+, the temperature increase around the DBS lead-tip was significantly lower in the vertical scanner compared to the horizontal scanner (0.33 ± 0.24°C vs. 4.19 ± 2.29°C). Electromagnetic simulations demonstrated up to a 17-fold reduction in the maximum of 0.1g-averaged SAR in the tissue surrounding the lead-tip in the vertical scanner compared to the horizontal scanner. Results were consistent across leads with straight and helical internal wires. Radiofrequency heating and power deposition around the DBS lead-tip were substantially lower in the 1.2 T vertical scanner compared to the 1.5 T horizontal scanner. Simulations with different lead structures suggest that the results may extend to leads from other manufacturers.

Proposed Safety Guidelines for Patient Assistants in an Open MRI Environment

The wide-open side of an open magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) system allows a patient to easily contact the patient assistant during MRI scans. A wide-open-shaped magnet is highly effective when interventional procedures are necessary. Patient assistants can provide comfort by holding a part of the patient's body. Because current regulations or guidelines are concerned with only patient radio frequency (RF) safety, investigations on the safety of patient assistants exposed to high-magnetic field MRI (up to 1.2 T) are required. In this study, five different poses of patient assistants were numerically simulated at a 1.2 T open MRI system to determine the impact of poses on the RF exposure level. The 10-g averaged specific absorption rate (SAR) levels were analyzed for the poses of each patient assistant wearing gloves. Compared with the patient, up to 29.8% of the patient SAR was observed in the patient assistant. When the patient assistant wore latex gloves, a 63.7% reduction in the 10-g averaged SAR level was observed, which could be a remedy to minimize possible RF hazards. To prevent possible RF hazards during MRI scans, certain clauses regarding the patient assistant's poses or wearing gloves must be added to the existing MRI screening forms.

Occupational exposure to electromagnetic fields in magnetic resonance environment: an update on regulation, exposure assessment techniques, health risk evaluation, and surveillance

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is one of the most-used diagnostic imaging methods worldwide. There are ∼50,000 MRI scanners worldwide each of which involves a minimum of five workers from different disciplines who spend their working days around MRI scanners. This review analyzes the state of the art of literature about the several aspects of the occupational exposure to electromagnetic fields (EMF) in MRI: regulations, literature studies on biological effects, and health surveillance are addressed here in detail, along with a summary of the main approaches for exposure assessment. The original research papers published from 2013 to 2021 in international peer-reviewed journals, in the English language, are analyzed, together with documents published by legislative bodies. The key points for each topic are identified and described together with useful tips for precise safeguarding of MRI operators, in terms of exposure assessment, studies on biological effects, and health surveillance.

Heating of Hip Arthroplasty Implants During Metal Artifact Reduction MRI at 1.5- and 3.0-T Field Strengths

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to quantify the spatial temperature rises that occur during 1.5- and 3.0-T magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of different types of hip arthroplasty implants using different metal artifact reduction techniques.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Using a prospective in vitro study design, we evaluated the spatial temperature rises of 4 different total hip arthroplasty constructs using clinical metal artifact reduction techniques including high-bandwidth turbo spin echo (HBW-TSE), slice encoding for metal artifact correction (SEMAC), and compressed sensing SEMAC at 1.5 and 3.0 T. Each MRI protocol included 6 pulse sequences, with imaging planes, parameters, and coverage identical to those in patients. Implants were immersed in standard American Society for Testing and Materials phantoms, and fiber optic sensors were used for temperature measurement. Effects of field strength, radiofrequency pulse polarization at 3.0 T, pulse protocol, and gradient coil switching on heating were assessed using nonparametric Friedman and Wilcoxon signed-rank tests.

RESULTS

Across all implant constructs and MRI protocols, the maximum heating at any single point reached 13.1°C at 1.5 T and 1.9°C at 3.0 T. The temperature rises at 3.0 T were similar to that of background in the absence of implants (P = 1). Higher temperature rises occurred at 1.5 T compared with 3.0 T (P < 0.0001), and circular compared with elliptical radiofrequency pulse polarization (P < 0.0001). Compressed sensing SEMAC generated equal or lower degrees of heating compared with HBW-TSE at both field strengths (P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Magnetic resonance imaging of commonly used total hip arthroplasty implants is associated with variable degrees of periprosthetic tissue heating. In the absence of any perfusion effects, the maximum temperature rises fall within the physiological range at 3.0 T and within the supraphysiologic range at 1.5 T. However, with the simulation of tissue perfusion effects, the heating at 1.5 T also reduces to the upper physiologic range. Compressed sensing SEMAC metal artifact reduction MRI is not associated with higher degrees of heating than the HBW-TSE technique.

Patient's body composition can significantly affect RF power deposition in the tissue around DBS implants: ramifications for lead management strategies and MRI field-shaping techniques

Patients with active implants such as deep brain stimulation (DBS) devices have limited access to magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) due to risks associated with RF heating of implants in MRI environment. With an aging population and increased prevalence of neurodegenerative disease, the indication for MRI exams in patients with such implants increases as well. In response to this growing need, many groups have investigated strategies to mitigate RF heating of DBS implants during MRI. These efforts fall into two main categories: MRI field-shaping methods, where the electric field of the MRI RF coil is modified to reduce the interaction with implanted leads, and lead management techniques where surgical modifications in the trajectory reduces the coupling with RF fields. Studies that characterize these techniques, however, have relied either on simulations with homogenous body models, or experiments with box-shaped single-material phantoms. It is well established, however, that the shape and heterogeneity of human body affects the distribution of RF electric fields, which by proxy, alters the heating of an implant inside the body. In this contribution, we applied numerical simulations and phantom experiments to examine the degree to which variations in patient's body composition affects RF power deposition. We then assessed effectiveness of RF-heating mitigation strategies under variant patient body compositions. Our results demonstrated that patient's body composition substantially alters RF power deposition in the tissue around implanted leads. However, both techniques based on MRI field-shaping and DBS lead management performed well under variant body types.

Development, validation, and pilot MRI safety study of a high-resolution, open source, whole body pediatric numerical simulation model

Numerical body models of children are used for designing medical devices, including but not limited to optical imaging, ultrasound, CT, EEG/MEG, and MRI. These models are used in many clinical and neuroscience research applications, such as radiation safety dosimetric studies and source localization. Although several such adult models have been reported, there are few reports of full-body pediatric models, and those described have several limitations. Some, for example, are either morphed from older children or do not have detailed segmentations. Here, we introduce a 29-month-old male whole-body native numerical model, "MARTIN", that includes 28 head and 86 body tissue compartments, segmented directly from the high spatial resolution MRI and CT images. An advanced auto-segmentation tool was used for the deep-brain structures, whereas 3D Slicer was used to segment the non-brain structures and to refine the segmentation for all of the tissue compartments. Our MARTIN model was developed and validated using three separate approaches, through an iterative process, as follows. First, the calculated volumes, weights, and dimensions of selected structures were adjusted and confirmed to be within 6% of the literature values for the 2-3-year-old age-range. Second, all structural segmentations were adjusted and confirmed by two experienced, sub-specialty certified neuro-radiologists, also through an interactive process. Third, an additional validation was performed with a Bloch simulator to create synthetic MR image from our MARTIN model and compare the image contrast of the resulting synthetic image with that of the original MRI data; this resulted in a "structural resemblance" index of 0.97. Finally, we used our model to perform pilot MRI safety simulations of an Active Implantable Medical Device (AIMD) using a commercially available software platform (Sim4Life), incorporating the latest International Standards Organization guidelines. This model will be made available on the Athinoula A. Martinos Center for Biomedical Imaging website.

Device Configuration and Patient's Body Composition Significantly Affect RF Heating of Deep Brain Stimulation Implants During MRI: An Experimental Study at 1.5T and 3T

Patients with deep brain stimulation (DBS) devices have limited access to magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) due to safety concerns associated with RF heating generated around the implant. The problem of predicting RF heating of conductive leads is complex with a large parameter space and several interplaying factors. Recently however, off-label use of MRI in patients with DBS devices has been reported based on limited safety assessments, raising the concern that potentially dangerous scenarios may have been overlooked. In this work, we present results of a systematic assessment of RF heating of a commercial DBS device during MRI at 1.5T and 3T, taking into account the effect of device configuration, imaging landmark, and patient's body composition. Ninety-six (96) RF heating measurements were performed using anthropomorphic phantoms implanted with a full DBS system. We evaluated eight clinically relevant device configurations, implanted in phantoms with different material compositions, and imaged at three different landmarks (head, shoulder, and lower chest) in 1.5 T and 3T scanners. We observed a substantial fluctuation in the RF heating depending on phantom's composition and device configuration. RF heating in the brain-mimicking gel varied from 0.1°C to 12°C during 1.5 T MRI and from <0.1°C to 4.5°C during 3T MRI. We also observed that certain device configurations consistently reduced RF heating across different phantom compositions, imaging landmarks, and MRI transmit frequencies.

Evaluating Accuracy of Numerical Simulations in Predicting Heating of Wire Implants During MRI at 1.5 T

Patients with long conductive implants such as deep brain stimulation (DBS) leads are often denied access to magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) exams due to safety concerns associated with radiofrequency (RF) heating of implants. Experimental temperature measurements in tissue-mimicking gel phantoms under MRI RF exposure conditions are common practices to predict in-vivo heating in the tissue surrounding wire implants. Such experiments are both expensive-as they require access to MRI units-and time-consuming due to complex implant setups. Recently, full-wave numerical simulations, which include realistic MRI RF coil models and human phantoms, are suggested as an alternative to experiments. There is however, little literature available on the accuracy of such numerical models against direct thermal measurements. This study aimed to evaluate the agreement between simulations and measurements of temperature rise at the tips of wire implants exposed to RF exposure at 64 MHz (1.5 T) for different implant trajectories typically encountered in patients with DBS leads. Heating was assessed in seven patient-derived lead configurations using both simulations and RF heating measurements during imaging of an anthropomorphic head phantom with implanted wires. We found substantial variation in RF heating as a function of lead trajectory; there was a 9.5-fold and 9-fold increase in temperature rise from ID1 to ID7 during simulations and experimental measurements, respectively. There was a strong correlation (r2 = 0.74) between simulated and measured temperatures for different lead trajectories. The maximum difference between simulated and measured temperature was 0.26 °C with simulations overestimating the temperature rise.

In silico trials: Verification, validation and uncertainty quantification of predictive models used in the regulatory evaluation of biomedical products

•

Regulators now consider also evidences produced in silico.

•

We need accepted methods to evaluate the credibility of models.

•

In this paper we describe the use of the ASME V&V-40 technical standard.

•

We also discuss its application to various types of modelling methods.

Historically, the evidences of safety and efficacy that companies provide to regulatory agencies as support to the request for marketing authorization of a new medical product have been produced experimentally, either in vitro or in vivo. More recently, regulatory agencies started receiving and accepting evidences obtained in silico, i.e. through modelling and simulation. However, before any method (experimental or computational) can be acceptable for regulatory submission, the method itself must be considered “qualified” by the regulatory agency. This involves the assessment of the overall “credibility” that such a method has in providing specific evidence for a given regulatory procedure. In this paper, we describe a methodological framework for the credibility assessment of computational models built using mechanistic knowledge of physical and chemical phenomena, in addition to available biological and physiological knowledge; these are sometimes referred to as “biophysical” models. Using guiding examples, we explore the definition of the context of use, the risk analysis for the definition of the acceptability thresholds, and the various steps of a comprehensive verification, validation and uncertainty quantification process, to conclude with considerations on the credibility of a prediction for a specific context of use. While this paper does not provide a guideline for the formal qualification process, which only the regulatory agencies can provide, we expect it to help researchers to better appreciate the extent of scrutiny required, which should be considered early on in the development/use of any (new) in silico evidence.