Characterization of Non-heading Mutation in Heading Chinese Cabbage (Brassica rapa L. ssp. pekinensis)

Role of Brassica orphan gene BrLFM on leafy head formation in Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa)

Brassica orphan gene BrFLM, identified by two allelic mutants, was involved in leafy head formation in Chinese cabbage. Leafy head formation is a unique agronomic trait of Chinese cabbage that determines its yield and quality. In our previous study, an EMS mutagenesis Chinese cabbage mutant library was constructed using the heading Chinese cabbage double haploid (DH) line FT as the wild-type. Here, we screened two extremely similar leafy head deficiency mutants lfm-1 and lfm-2 with geotropic growth leaves from the library to investigate the gene(s) related to leafy head formation. Reciprocal crossing results showed that these two mutants were allelic. We utilized lfm-1 to identify the mutant gene(s). Genetic analysis showed that the mutated trait was controlled by a single nuclear gene Brlfm. Mutmap analysis showed that Brlfm was located on chromosome A05, and BraA05g012440.3C or BraA05g021450.3C were the candidate gene. Kompetitive allele-specific PCR analysis eliminated BraA05g012440.3C from the candidates. Sanger sequencing identified an SNP from G to A at the 271st nucleotide on BraA05g021450.3C. The sequencing of lfm-2 detected another non-synonymous SNP (G to A) located at the 266st nucleotide on BraA05g021450.3C, which verified its function on leafy head formation. We blasted BraA05g021450.3C on database and found that it belongs to a Brassica orphan gene encoding an unknown 13.74 kDa protein, named BrLFM. Subcellular localization showed that BrLFM was located in the nucleus. These findings reveal that BrLFM is involved in leafy head formation in Chinese cabbage.

Genome-wide identification and expression analysis of the AUX/IAA gene family in turnip (Brassica rapa ssp. rapa)

BACKGROUND

Auxin/indoleacetic acid (AUX/IAA) genes encoding short-lived proteins participate in AUX signaling transduction and play crucial roles in plant growth and development. Although the AUX/IAA gene family has been identified in many plants, a systematic analysis of AUX/IAA genes in Brassica rapa ssp. rapa has not yet been reported.

RESULTS

We performed a comprehensive genome-wide analysis and found 89 AUX/IAA genes in turnip based on the conserved AUX/IAA domain (pfam02309). Phylogenetic analysis of AUX/IAA genes from turnip, Arabidopsis, and cabbage revealed that these genes cluster into six subgroups (A1, A2, A3, A4, B1, and B2). The motif distribution was also conservative among the internal members of the clade. Enhanced yellow fluorescent protein (EYFP) signals of BrrIAA-EYFPs showed that BrrIAA members functioned as nucleoproteins. Moreover, transcriptional analysis revealed that the expression patterns of AUX/IAA genes in turnip were tissue-dependent. Because orthologs have similar biological functions and interaction networks in plant growth and development, BrrIAA66 in turnip possibly played a role in embryo axis formation, vascular development, lateral root formation, and floral organ development by interacting with BrrARF19 and BrrTIR1.

CONCLUSION

These results provide a theoretical basis for further investigation of BrrAUX/IAA genes and lay the foundation for functional analysis of BrrIAA66 in turnip.

Comparative transcriptome analysis provides insights into molecular pathway and genes associated with head-type formation and phenotypic divergence in Chinese cabbage

Background: The heading type of Chinese cabbage is a significant commercial trait with high economic value. At present, research on the phenotypic divergence and formation mechanism of heading type is limited. Results: Through comparative-transcriptome analysis, the formation and phenotypic divergence mechanism of the leafy head of diploid overlapping type cabbage, diploid outward-curling type cabbage, tetraploid overlapping type cabbage, and tetraploid outward-curling type cabbage were systematically and comprehensively investigated, and the phenotype-specific genes of four varieties were revealed. These phenotype-specific differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were considered crucial for cabbage heading type through WGCNA. Some transcription factors have been predicted as significant genes for phenotypic divergence, including the members of the bHLH, AP2/ERF-ERF, WRKY, MYB, NAC, and C2CH2 families. Phytohormone-related genes, including abscisic acid/auxin hormone, may play an important role in the phenotypic divergence of head type in cabbage. Conclusion: Comparative-transcriptome analysis supports a role for phytohormone-related genes and some transcription factors in head-type formation and divergence for four cultivars. These findings increase our understanding of the molecular basis for pattern formation and divergence of the leafy heads of Chinese cabbage and will contribute to developing more desirable leafy head patterns.

Auxin participates in regulating the leaf curl development of Wucai (Brassica campestris L.)

Wucai (Brassica campestris L. ssp. chinensis var. rosularis Tsen) belongs to the Brassica genus of the Cruciferae family, and its leaf curl is a typical feature that distinguishes Wucai from other nonheading cabbage subspecies. Our previous research found that plant hormones were involved in the development of the leaf curl in Wucai. However, the molecular mechanisms and the hormones regulating the formation of leaf curl in Wucai have not yet been reported. This study aimed to understand the molecular functions related to hormone metabolism during the formation of leaf curl in Wucai. A total of 386 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were identified by transcriptome sequencing of two different morphological parts of the same leaf of Wucai germplasm W7-2, and 50 DEGs were found to be related to plant hormones, which were mainly involved in the auxin signal transduction pathway. Then, we measured the content of endogenous hormones in two different forms of the same leaf of Wucai germplasm W7-2. A total of 17 hormones with differential content were identified, including auxin, cytokinins, jasmonic acids, salicylic acids, and abscisic acid. And we found that treatment with auxin transport inhibitor N-1-naphthylphthalamic acid can affect the leaf curl phenotype of Wucai and pak choi (Brassica rapa L. subsp. Chinensis). These results indicated that plant hormones, especially auxin, are involved in developing the leaf curl of Wucai. Our findings provide a potentially valuable reference for future research on the development of leaf curls.

Genetic dissection of morphological variation in rosette leaves and leafy heads in cabbage (Brassica oleracea var. capitata)

Correlations between morphological traits of cabbage rosette leaves and heads were found. Genome-wide association studies of these traits identified 50 robust quantitative trait loci in multiple years. Half of these loci affect both organs. Cabbage (Brassica oleracea var. capitata) is an economically important vegetable crop cultivated worldwide. Cabbage plants go through four vegetative stages: seedling, rosette, folding and heading. Rosette leaves are the largest leaves of cabbage plants and provide most of the energy needed to produce the leafy head. To understand the relationship and the genetic basis of leaf development and leafy head formation, 308 cabbage accessions were scored for rosette leaf and head traits in three-year field trials. Significant correlations were found between morphological traits of rosette leaves and heads, namely leaf area with the head area, height and width, and leaf width with the head area and head height, when heads were harvested at a fixed number of days after sowing. Fifty robust quantitative trait loci (QTLs) for rosette leaf and head traits distributed over all nine chromosomes were identified with genome-wide association studies. All these 50 loci were identified in multiple years and generally affect multiple traits. Twenty-five of the QTL were associated with both rosette leaf and leafy head traits. We discuss thirteen candidate genes identified in these QTL that are expressed in heading leaves, with an annotation related to auxin and other phytohormones, leaf development, and leaf polarity that likely play a role in leafy head development or rosette leaf expansion.

BrAN contributes to leafy head formation by regulating leaf width in Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa L. ssp. pekinensis)

Leafy head is an important agronomic trait that determines the yield and quality of Chinese cabbage. The molecular mechanism underlying heading in Chinese cabbage has been the focus of research, and wide leaves are a prerequisite for leafy head formation. In our study, two allelic leafy heading-deficient mutants (lhd1 and lhd2) with narrow leaf phenotypes were screened in an ethyl methanesulfonate mutagenized population from a heading Chinese cabbage double haploid line 'FT'. Genetic analysis revealed that the mutant trait was controlled by a recessive nuclear gene, which was found to be BraA10g000480.3C by MutMap and Kompetitive allele-specific PCR analyses. As BraA10g000480.3C was the ortholog of ANGUSTIFOLIA in Arabidopsis, which has been found to regulate leaf width by controlling cortical microtubule arrangement and pavement cell shape, we named it BrAN. BrAN in mutant lhd1 carried an SNP (G to A) on intron 2 that co-segregated with the mutant phenotype, and disrupted the exon-intron splice junction generating intron retention and a putative truncated protein. BrAN in mutant lhd2 carried an SNP (G to A) on exon 4 leading to a premature stop codon. The ectopic overexpression of BrAN restored normal leaf phenotype due to abnormal cortical microtubule arrangement and pavement cell shape in the Arabidopsis an-t1 mutant. However, transformation of Bran did not rescue the an-t1 phenotype. These results indicate that BrAN contributes to leafy head formation of Chinese cabbage.

BrCPS1 Function in Leafy Head Formation Was Verified by Two Allelic Mutations in Chinese Cabbage (Brassica rapa L. ssp. pekinensis)

The formation of the leafy heads of Chinese cabbage is an important agricultural factor because it directly affects yield. In this study, we identified two allelic non-heading mutants, nhm4-1 and nhm4-2, from an ethyl methanesulfonate mutagenic population of a heading Chinese cabbage double haploid line "FT." Using MutMap, Kompetitive Allele-Specific PCR genotyping, and map-based cloning, we found that BraA09g001440.3C was the causal gene for the mutants. BraA09g001440.3C encodes an ent-copalyl diphosphate synthase 1 involved in gibberellin biosynthesis. A single non-synonymous SNP in the seventh and fourth exons of BraA09g001440.3C was responsible for the nhm4-1 and nhm4-2 mutant phenotypes, respectively. Compared with the wild-type "FT," the gibberellin content in the mutant leaves was significantly reduced. Both mutants showed a tendency to form leafy heads after exogenous GA₃ treatment. The two non-heading mutants and the work presented herein demonstrate that gibberellin is related to leafy head formation in Chinese cabbage.

BrKAO2 mutations disrupt leafy head formation in Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa L. ssp. pekinensis)

The role of BrKAO2 in leafy head formation was confirmed by using two allelic Chinese cabbage mutants. Chinese cabbage yield and quality are determined by leafy head formation. Cloning and characterising the key genes regulating leafy head formation are essential for its varietal improvement. We used an EMS-mutagenised population of the heading type 'FT' Chinese cabbage line and identified two allelic non-heading mutants, i.e. nhm3-1 and nhm3-2. Genetic analysis showed that the mutant trait was controlled by a single recessive gene. MutMap and Kompetitive Allele Specific PCR genotyping revealed that BraA05g012440.3C was the candidate gene, which encodes ent-kaurenoic acid oxidase 2 in gibberellin (GA) biosynthetic pathway. It was named BrKAO2. Two non-synonymous mutations in the second BrKAO2 exon, respectively, accounted for the mutant phenotypes of nhm3-1 and nhm3-2. BrKAO2 was expressed during all leaf development stages, and there were no significant differences between the wild type and mutants in terms of BrKAO2 expression. The mutant phenotypes were restored to the wild type via exogenous GA3 application. RNA-Seq was performed on wild-type 'FT', nhm3-1, and nhm3-1 + GA3 rosette leaves, and several key genes involved in GA biosynthesis, signal transduction, and leafy head development were identified. These findings indicate that BrKAO2 is responsible for the leafy head formation in nhm3 mutants.

The Adaxial/Abaxial Patterning of Auxin and Auxin Gene in Leaf Veins Functions in Leafy Head Formation of Chinese Cabbage

Leaf curling is an essential prerequisite for the formation of leafy heads in Chinese cabbage. However, the part or tissue that determines leaf curvature remains largely unclear. In this study, we first introduced the auxin-responsive marker DR5::GUS into the Chinese cabbage genome and visualized its expression during the farming season. We demonstrated that auxin response is adaxially/abaxially distributed in leaf veins. Together with the fact that leaf veins occupy considerable proportions of the Chinese cabbage leaf, we propose that leaf veins play a crucial supporting role as a framework for heading. Then, by combining analyses of QTL mapping and a time-course transcriptome from heading Chinese cabbage and non-heading pak choi during the farming season, we identified the auxin-related gene BrPIN5 as a strong candidate for leafy head formation. PIN5 displays an adaxial/abaxial expression pattern in leaf veins, similar to that of DR5::GUS, revealing an involvement of BrPIN5 in leafy head development. The association of BrPIN5 function with heading was further confirmed by its haplo-specificity to heading individuals in both a natural population and two segregating populations. We thus conclude that the adaxial/abaxial patterning of auxin and auxin genes in leaf veins functions in the formation of the leafy head in Chinese cabbage.

Construction of a high-density mutant population of Chinese cabbage facilitates the genetic dissection of agronomic traits

Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa ssp. pekinensis) is an economically important vegetable crop throughout the world, especially in Asia. High-quality genome sequences are available for Chinese cabbage, but gene functional studies remain challenging. To promote functional genomic studies of Chinese cabbage, we generated an ethyl methane sulfonate (EMS) mutant population of ∼8000 M₂ plants using the double haploid inbred line A03 as the parent. The genome of A03 was sequenced and used as a reference for high-throughput functional characterization of gene mutations at the whole-genome level. A total of 300 M₂ to M₅ EMS mutants were phenotypically screened and then sequenced, revealing 750 629 SNPs and 46 272 InDel mutations that cover 98.27% of all predicted genes in the A03 genome. A forward-genetics approach was successfully used to identify two genes with chloroplast-related functions that are responsible for the yellow leaf mutant trait. A reverse-genetics approach was also used to identify associations between mutations in five genes of the glucosinolate biosynthetic pathway and variations in glucosinolate content of the mutant plants. In addition, we built the Chinese cabbage EMS mutation database (CCEMD, www.bioinformaticslab.cn/EMSmutation/home) to increase the usability of this mutant population resource. In summary, we performed large-scale screening of a heading Chinese cabbage EMS mutant collection at the phenotypic and genotypic levels, which will facilitate gene mining of Chinese cabbage and might also be useful for the study of other Brassica crops.

Series-Spatial Transcriptome Profiling of Leafy Head Reveals the Key Transition Leaves for Head Formation in Chinese Cabbage

Chinese cabbage is an important leaf heading vegetable crop. At the heading stage, its leaves across inner to outer show significant morphological differentiation. However, the genetic control of this complex leaf morphological differentiation remains unclear. Here, we reported the transcriptome profiling of Chinese cabbage plant at the heading stage using 24 spatially dissected tissues representing different regions of the inner to outer leaves. Genome-wide transcriptome analysis clearly separated the inner leaf tissues from the outer leaf tissues. In particular, we identified the key transition leaf by the spatial expression analysis of key genes for leaf development and sugar metabolism. We observed that the key transition leaves were the first inwardly curved ones. Surprisingly, most of the heading candidate genes identified by domestication selection analysis obviously showed a corresponding expression transition, supporting that key transition leaves are related to leafy head formation. The key transition leaves were controlled by a complex signal network, including not only internal hormones and protein kinases but also external light and other stimuli. Our findings provide new insights and the rich resource to unravel the genetic control of heading traits.

YABBY Genes in the Development and Evolution of Land Plants

Mounting evidence from genomic and transcriptomic studies suggests that most genetic networks regulating the morphogenesis of land plant sporophytes were co-opted and modified from those already present in streptophyte algae and gametophytes of bryophytes sensu lato. However, thus far, no candidate genes have been identified that could be responsible for "planation", a conversion from a three-dimensional to a two-dimensional growth pattern. According to the telome theory, "planation" was required for the genesis of the leaf blade in the course of leaf evolution. The key transcription factors responsible for leaf blade development in angiosperms are YABBY proteins, which until recently were thought to be unique for seed plants. Yet, identification of a YABBY homologue in a green alga and the recent findings of YABBY homologues in lycophytes and hornworts suggest that YABBY proteins were already present in the last common ancestor of land plants. Thus, these transcriptional factors could have been involved in "planation", which fosters our understanding of the origin of leaves. Here, we summarise the current data on functions of YABBY proteins in the vegetative and reproductive development of diverse angiosperms and gymnosperms as well as in the development of lycophytes. Furthermore, we discuss a putative role of YABBY proteins in the genesis of multicellular shoot apical meristems and in the evolution of leaves in early divergent terrestrial plants.

The mutation of ent-kaurene synthase, a key enzyme involved in gibberellin biosynthesis, confers a non-heading phenotype to Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa L. ssp. pekinensis)

The presence of a leafy head is a vital agronomic trait that facilitates the evaluation of the yield and quality of Chinese cabbage. A non-heading mutant (nhm1) was identified in an ethyl methanesulfonate mutagenesis population of the heading Chinese cabbage double haploid line FT. Segregation analysis revealed that a single recessive gene, Brnhm1, controlled the mutant phenotype. Using MutMap, Kompetitive allele-specific PCR, and cloning analyses, we demonstrated that BraA07g042410.3C, which encodes an ent-kaurene synthase involved in the gibberellin biosynthesis pathway, is the nhm1 mutant candidate gene. A single-nucleotide mutation (C to T) in the fourth exon of BraA07g042410.3C caused an amino acid substitution from histidine to tyrosine. Compared to that of the wild-type FT, BraA07g042410.3C in the leaves of the nhm1 mutant had lower levels of expression. In addition, gibberellin contents were lower in the mutant than in the wild type, and the mutant plant phenotype could be restored to that of the wild type after exogenous GA₃ treatment. These results indicate that BraA07g042410.3C caused the non-heading mutation. This is the first study to demonstrate a relationship between gibberellin content in the leaves and leafy head formation in Chinese cabbage. These findings facilitate the understanding of the mechanisms underlying leafy head development in Chinese cabbage.

Patterning a Leaf by Establishing Polarities

Leaves are the major organ for photosynthesis in most land plants, and leaf structure is optimized for the maximum capture of sunlight and gas exchange. Three polarity axes, the adaxial-abaxial axis, the proximal-distal axis, and the medial-lateral axis are established during leaf development to give rise to a flattened lamina with a large area for photosynthesis and blades that are extended on petioles for maximum sunlight. Adaxial cells are elongated, tightly packed cells with many chloroplasts, and their fate is specified by HD-ZIP III and related factors. Abaxial cells are rounder and loosely packed cells and their fate is established and maintained by YABBY family and KANADI family proteins. The activities of adaxial and abaxial regulators are coordinated by ASYMMETRIC LEAVES2 and auxin. Establishment of the proximodistal axis involves the BTB/POZ domain proteins BLADE-ON-PETIOLE1 and 2, whereas homeobox genes PRESSED FLOWER and WUSCHEL-RELATED HOMEOBOX1 mediate leaf development along the mediolateral axis. This review summarizes recent advances in leaf polarity establishment with a focus on the regulatory networks involved.