Uncovering New Insights and Misconceptions on the Effectiveness of Phosphate Solubilizing Rhizobacteria in Plants: A Meta-Analysis

Phosphate solubilization and plant growth properties are promoted by a lactic acid bacterium in calcareous soil

On the basis of good phosphate solubilization ability of a lactic acid bacteria (LAB) strain Limosilactobacillus sp. LF-17, bacterial agent was prepared and applied to calcareous soil to solubilize phosphate and promote the growth of maize seedlings in this study. A pot experiment showed that the plant growth indicators, phosphorus content, and related enzyme activity of the maize rhizospheric soils in the LF treatment (treated with LAB) were the highest compared with those of the JP treatment (treated with phosphate solubilizing bacteria, PSB) and the blank control (CK). The types of organic acids in maize rhizospheric soil were determined through LC-MS, and 12 acids were detected in all the treatments. The abundant microbes belonged to the genera of Lysobacter, Massilia, Methylbacillus, Brevundimonas, and Limosilactobacillus, and they were beneficial to dissolving phosphate or secreting growth-promoting phytohormones, which were obviously higher in the LF and JP treatments than in CK as analyzed by high-throughput metagenomic sequencing methods. In addition, the abundance values of several enzymes, Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) orthology, and Carbohydrate-Active Enzymes (CAZys), which were related to substrate assimilation and metabolism, were the highest in the LF treatment. Therefore, aside from phosphate-solubilizing microorganisms, LAB can be used as environmentally friendly crop growth promoters in agriculture and provide another viable option for microbial fertilizers. KEY POINTS: • The inoculation of LAB strain effectively promoted the growth and chlorophyll synthesis of maize seedlings. • The inoculation of LAB strain significantly increased the TP content of maize seedlings and the AP concentration of the rhizosphere soil. • The inoculation of LAB strain increased the abundances of the dominant beneficial functional microbes in the rhizosphere soil.

Nutrient availability and plant phenological stage influence the substrate microbiome in container-grown Impatiens walleriana 'Xtreme Red'

BACKGROUND

The microbiome plays a fundamental role in plant health and performance. Soil serves as a reservoir of microbial diversity where plants attract microorganisms via root exudates. The soil has an important impact on the composition of the rhizosphere microbiome, but greenhouse ornamental plants are commonly grown in soilless substrates. While soil microbiomes have been extensively studied in traditional agriculture to improve plant performance, health, and sustainability, information about the microbiomes of soilless substrates is still limited. Thus, we conducted an experiment to explore the microbiome of a peat-based substrate used in container production of Impatiens walleriana, a popular greenhouse ornamental plant. We investigated the effects of plant phenological stage and fertilization level on the substrate microbiome.

RESULTS

Impatiens plants grown under low fertilization rates were smaller and produced more flowers than plants grown under optimum and high fertilization. The top five bacterial phyla present in the substrate were Proteobacteria, Actinobacteria, Bacteriodota, Verrucomicrobiota, and Planctomycetota. We found a total of 2,535 amplicon sequence variants (ASV) grouped into 299 genera. The substrate core microbiome was represented by only 1.8% (48) of the identified ASV. The microbiome community composition was influenced by plant phenological stage and fertilizer levels. Phenological stage exhibited a stronger influence on microbiome composition than fertilizer levels. Differential abundance analysis using DESeq2 identified more ASVs significantly affected (enriched or depleted) in the high fertilizer levels at flowering. As observed for community composition, the effect of plant phenological stage on microbial community function was stronger than fertilizer level. Phenological stage and fertilizer treatments did not affect alpha-diversity in the substrate.

CONCLUSIONS

In container-grown ornamental plants, the substrate serves as the main microbial reservoir for the plant, and the plant and agricultural inputs (fertilization) modulate the microbial community structure and function of the substrate. The differences observed in substrate microbiome composition across plant phenological stage were explained by pH, total organic carbon (TOC) and fluoride, and across fertilizer levels by pH and phosphate (PO4). Our project provides an initial diversity profile of the bacteria occurring in soilless substrates, an underexplored source of microbial diversity.

Enhancement of mangrove growth performance using fish emulsion and halotolerant plant growth-promoting actinobacteria for sustainable management in the UAE

The combination of fish emulsion (FE) and the actinobacterial isolate, Streptomyces griseorubens UAE1 (Sg) capable of producing plant growth regulators (PGRs) and 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) deaminase, was evaluated on mangrove (Avicennia marina) in the United Arab Emirates. Under greenhouse and field conditions, sediments amended with the biostimulant FE effectively enhanced mangrove growth compared to those inoculated with Sg only. Plant growth promotion by Sg was more pronounced in the presence of FE (+FE/+Sg) than in individual applications. Our data showed that Sg appeared to use FE as a source of nutrients and precursors for plant growth promotion. Thus, in planta PGR levels following the combined +FE/+Sg were significantly induced. This is the first report in the field of marine agriculture that uses FE as a nutrient base for soil microorganisms to promote mangrove growth. This study will support mangrove restoration along the Arabian Gulf coastline as a nature-based solution to changing climate and economic activities.

Application of Bacillus spp. Phosphate-Solubilizing Bacteria Improves Common Bean Production Compared to Conventional Fertilization

The use of phosphate-solubilizing bacteria (PSB) can be a sustainable strategy to increase phosphorus availability and promote satisfactory crop yields. The objective of this study was to evaluate whether inoculation with PSB in common bean increases (i) growth, (ii) nutrition, (iii) yield, and (iv) grain quality, and (v) reduces the chemical phosphorus application dose to obtain maximum yields. The experiment was conducted in an Oxisol using a randomized block design in a 4 × 4 factorial scheme, with four replicates, using the cultivar IAC 2051. The first factor was four doses of P2O5 (0, 20, 40 and 60 kg ha-1), and the second factor was four doses of PSB (0, 100, 200 and 300 mL ha-1). For leaf area and leaf chlorophyll content, the association of PSB inoculation with a P2O5 dose of 40 kg ha-1 promoted the best conditions for the common bean. P2O5 application increased yield by 79 kg ha-1 for each 10 kg ha-1 added. PSB inoculation at a dose of 192 mL ha-1 promoted P export of 15.3 kg ha-1, and the PSB dose of 159 mL ha-1 increased yield by 389 kg ha-1 (12%) compared to the control. Grain quality remained within the standards required by the consumer market, being little affected by the treatments. Improvements in common bean growth and nutritional and physiological status promoted by P2O5 application and PSB were essential in increasing yield, so these are sustainable production strategies.

Phosphorus deficiency alters root length, acid phosphatase activity, organic acids, and metabolites in root exudates of soybean cultivars

Phosphorus (P) deficiency alters the root morphological and physiological traits of plants. This study investigates how soybean cultivars with varying low-P tolerance values respond to different P levels in hydroponic culture by assessing alterations in root length, acid phosphatase activity, organic acid exudation, and metabolites in root exudates. Three low-P-tolerant cultivars ('Maetsue,' 'Kurotome,' and 'Fukuyutaka') and three low-P-sensitive cultivars ('Ihhon,' 'Chizuka,' and 'Komuta') were grown under 0 (P0) and 258 μM P (P8) for 7 and 14 days after transplantation (DAT). Low-P-tolerant cultivars increased root length by 31% and 119%, which was lower than the 62% and 144% increases in sensitive cultivars under P0 compared to P8 at 7 and 14 DAT, respectively. Acid phosphatase activity in low-P-tolerant cultivars exceeded that in sensitive cultivars by 5.2-fold and 2.0-fold at 7 and 14 DAT. Root exudates from each cultivar revealed 177 metabolites, with higher organic acid exudation in low-P-tolerant than sensitive cultivars under P0. Low-P-tolerant cultivars increased concentrations of specific metabolites (oxalate, GABA, quinate, citrate, AMP, 4-pyridoxate, and CMP), distinguishing them from low-P-sensitive cultivars under P0. The top five metabolomic pathways (purine metabolism, arginine and proline metabolism, TCA cycle, glyoxylate and dicarboxylate metabolism, alanine, aspartate, and glutamate metabolism) were more pronounced in low-P-tolerant cultivars at 14 DAT. These findings indicate that increasing root length was not an adaptation strategy under P deficiency; instead, tolerant cultivars exhibit enhanced root physiological traits, including increased acid phosphatase activity, organic acid exudation, specific metabolite release, and accelerated metabolic pathways under P deficiency.

Isolation and characterization of phosphate-solubilizing bacterium Pantoea rhizosphaerae sp. nov. from Acer truncatum rhizosphere soil and its effect on Acer truncatum growth

The Acer truncatum Bunge, widely distributed in North China, shows excellent tolerance to low-P soils. However, little information is available on potential phosphate-solubilizing bacterial (PSB) strains from the A. truncatum rhizosphere. The objectives of this work were to isolate and characterize PSB from A. truncatum rhizosphere soil and to evaluate the effect of inoculation with the selected strain on A. truncatum seedlings. The strains were characterized on the basis of phenotypic characteristics, carbon source utilization pattern, fatty acid methyl esters analysis, 16S rRNA gene and the whole-genome sequence. A Gram-negative and rod-shaped bacterium, designated MQR6^T, showed a high capacity to solubilize phosphate and produce indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and siderophores. The strain can solubilize tricalcium phosphate (TCP) and rock phosphate (RP), and the solubilization of TCP was about 60% more effective than RP. Phylogenetic analyses based on the 16S rRNA gene and whole-genome sequences revealed that strain MQR6^T formed a distinct phyletic lineage as a new species within the genus Pantoea. The digital DNA-DNA hybridization value between strain MQR6^T and the closely related strains was 19.5-23.3%. The major cellular fatty acids were summed feature 3 (C_16:1ω7c and/or C_16:1ω6c), summed feature 8 (C_18:1ω6c and/or C_18:1ω7c), C_14:0, C_16:0, and C_17:0 cyclo. Several genes related to IAA production, phosphonate transport, phosphate solubilization and siderophore biogenesis were found in the MQR6^T genome. Furthermore, inoculation with the strain MQR6^T significantly improved plant height, trunk diameter, dry weight and P accumulation in roots and shoot of A. truncatum seedlings compared to non-inoculated control. These plant parameters were improved even further in the treatment with both inoculation and P fertilization. Our results suggested that MQR6^T represented a new species we named Pantoea rhizosphaerae, as a plant growth-promoting rhizobacterium that can solubilize inorganic P and improve growth of A. truncatum seedlings, emerging as a potential strategy to improve A. truncatum cultivation.

Integrated use of polyphosphate and P-solubilizing bacteria enhanced P use efficiency and growth performance of durum wheat

Coupling phosphate-solubilizing bacteria (PSB) with P fertilizers, including polyphosphates (PolyP), was reported as eco-efficient approach to enhance P use efficiency. Although PSB have been recently reported to hydrolyze PolyP, the plant growth promoting mechanisms of PolyP-PSB co-application were not yet uncovered. This study aims to evaluate the effect of a PSB consortium (PSB_Cs) on growth, P use efficiency (PUE), and wheat yield parameters under PolyP (PolyB) application. Co-application of PolyB-PSB_Cs significantly enhanced wheat growth at 75 days after sowing (DAS) compared to 30 DAS. A significant increase in shoot dry biomass (47%), shoot inorganic P content (222%), PUE (91%), and root P absorption efficiency (RPAE, 99%) was noted compared to unfertilized plants. Similarly, the PolyB-PSB_Cs co-application enhanced morphological root traits at 30 DAS, while acid phosphatase activities (root and rhizosphere), RPAE, and PUE were significantly increased at 75 DAS. The improved wheat P acquisition could be attributed to a lower investment in root biomass production, and significant induction of acid phosphatase activity in roots and rhizosphere soil under PolyB-PSB_Cs co-application. Consequently, the PolyB-PSB_Cs co-application significantly improved aboveground performance, which is reflected by increased shoot nutrient contents (P 300%, K 65%), dry weight (54%), and number (50%) of spikes. Altogether, this study provides relevant evidence that co-application of PolyP-PSB_Cs can be an integrated and environmentally preferred P fertilization approach owing to the dual effects of PolyP and PSB_Cs on wheat PUE.

Reconnoitering the capabilities of nodule endophytic Pantoea dispersa for improved nodulation and grain yield of chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.)

Microorganisms belonging to root and soil provide a wide range of services and benefits to the plant by promoting plant growth and controlling phytopathogens. This study aimed to isolate endophytic bacteria from the root nodules of chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.) and determine their potential in improving plant growth. A total of nineteen different bacterial morphotypes were isolated from root nodules of chickpea and characterized in vitro for plant growth promotion abilities. All bacterial isolates were able to produce indole acetic acid at varying levels, out of which MCA19 was screened as the most efficient indole acetic acid producer (10.25 µg mL^-1). MCA8, MCA9, MCA10, MCA11, MCA16, MCA17 and MCA19 were positive for phosphate solubilization, out of which MCA9 was best phosphate solubilizer (18.8 µg mL^-1). All bacterial strains showed varying ability to grow on nitrogen-free media. Hydrogen cyanide, pectinase, and cellulase production ability were also observed in isolates, in which MCA9, MCA12, MCA17 and MCA19 were found best. Based on in vitro testing, five isolates MCA2, MCA9, MCA11, MCA17 and MCA19 were selected for further studies. Bacterial isolates MCA9, MCA11, MCA17 and MCA19 were identified by 16S rRNA gene sequence analysis as Pantoea dispersa while MCA2 as Rhizobium pusense. This is the first report on the existence of Pantoea dispersa in the root nodules of chickpea. In pot experiment, a maximum increase of 30% was recorded in plant dry weight upon the application of MCA19. Under field conditions, bacterial isolates, MCA2, MCA11 and MCA19 significantly enhanced nodulation and yield parameters of chickpea, compared to control. Pantoea dispersa MCA19 displayed the highest plant growth-promoting potential by increasing 38% grain yield. Our results indicate that Pantoea dispersa MCA19 is a promising biofertilizer for future applications.

Innovative Rhizosphere-Based Enrichment under P-Limitation Selects for Bacterial Isolates with High-Performance P-Solubilizing Traits

The use of phosphate solubilizing bacteria (PSB) as inoculants for the rhizosphere is a well-known strategy to mitigate P-deficiency in plants. However, despite the multiple modes of action to render P available for plants, PSB often fail to deliver in the field as their selection is often based on a single P-solubilizing trait assessed in vitro. Anticipating these shortcomings, we screened 250 isolates originating from rhizosphere-based enriched consortia for the main in vitro P-solubilizing traits, and subsequently grouped the isolates through trait-based HCPC (hierarchical clustering on principal components). Representative isolates of each cluster were tested in an in planta experiment to compare their in vitro P-solubilizing traits with their in planta performance under conditions of P-deprivation. Our data convincingly show that bacterial consortia capable to mitigate P-deficiency in planta were enriched in bacterial isolates that had multiple P-solubilizing traits in vitro and that had the capacity to mitigate plant P-stress in planta under P-deprived conditions. Furthermore, although it was assumed that bacteria that looked promising in vitro would also have a positive effect in planta, our data show that this was not always the case. Opposite, lack of performance in vitro did not automatically result in a lack of performance in planta. These results corroborate the strength of the previously described in planta-based enrichment and selection technique for the isolation of highly efficient rhizosphere competent PSB. IMPORTANCE With the growing awareness on the ecological impact of chemical phosphate fertilizers, research concerning the use of phosphate solubilizing bacteria (PSB) as a sustainable alternative for, or addition to these fertilizers is of paramount importance. In previous research, we successfully implemented a plant-based enrichment technique for PSB, which simultaneously selected for the rhizosphere competence and phosphate solubilizing characteristics of bacterial suspensions. Current research follows up on our previous findings, whereas we screened 250 rhizobacteria for their P-solubilizing traits and were able to substantiate the results obtained from the enriched suspensions at a single-isolate level. With this research, we aim for a paradigm shift toward the plant-based selection of PSB, which is a more holistic approach compared to the plate-based methods. We emphasize the strength of the previously described plant-based enrichment and selection technique for the isolation of highly efficient and diverse PSB.