Is Homeopathic Arnica Effective for Postoperative Recovery? A Meta-analysis of Placebo-Controlled and Active Comparator Trials

Anti-inflammatory effects of Arnica montana (mother tincture and homeopathic dilutions) in various cell models

ETHNOPHARMACOLOGICAL RELEVANCE

The plant Arnica montana L. has been shown to alleviate inflammation, pain and swelling associated with trauma, and post-operative clinical conditions, yet the mechanism of action is not well understood.

AIM OF THE STUDY

The study was designed to investigate the effect of Arnica montana (A. montana) mother tincture and homeopathic dilutions on inflammation markers, oxidative stress and cell migration in diverse cell culture models.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We tested A. montana mother tincture and a range of homeopathic dilutions in different human and murine cell culture models to demonstrate their anti-inflammatory properties by measuring the inflammatory markers: tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNFα), interleukin-6 (IL-6), cyclooxygenase-2 (COX-2), monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1), intercellular adhesion molecule (ICAM-1), reactive oxygen species (ROS) and cell migration. The inflammatory markers were measured by ELISA assays. The intracellular oxidative stress (ROS) in microglial cells was measured using Deep Red CellROX probe. The cell migration was examined by wound healing using the Oris Cell migration assay.

RESULTS

These data showed the ability of A. montana (mother tincture and mainly 1C dilution) to significantly reduce TNFα production in inflamed macrophages compared with vehicle (control). They significantly reduced both IL-6 and MCP-1 in inflamed human microglial cells and significantly decreased COX-2 expression in inflamed murine fibroblasts. Moreover, A. montana mother tincture reduced the cell migration whereas 9C dilution significantly enhanced the migration of fibroblast cells compared with vehicle. The expression of ICAM-1 was significantly reduced with A. montana mother tincture and 1C, 3C, 5C, and 9C dilutions in inflamed human endothelial cells compared with vehicle. A. montana mother tincture and 1C, 3C, 5C and 9C dilutions induced a significant and consistent effect on ROS production in inflamed murine microglial cells. A. montana 1C had the largest impact on ROS production.

CONCLUSIONS

Mother tincture and 1C dilution of A. montana showed anti-inflammatory properties assessed by measurement of several markers (pro-inflammatory cytokines, adhesion molecule, ROS) in various human and murine cell models. In addition, A. montana 3C, 5C, 9C dilutions have anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects as highlighted on both primary endothelial cells and murine microglial cells.

Systematic reviews and meta-analyses in Homeopathy: Recommendations for summarising evidence from homeopathic intervention studies (Sum-HomIS recommendations)

BACKGROUND

Mainly due to the use of different inclusion criteria and quality assessments, systematic reviews (SRs) and meta-analyses (MAs) with homeopathic intervention studies (HOMIS) have shown inconsistent results. We aimed to build recommendations for "Summarizing evidence from Homeopathic Intervention Studies" (Sum-HomIS recommendations) in order to approach standardization.

METHODS

Against the background of a framework-project to update the evidence from homeopathic intervention studies, we launched an expert panel on how to assess the quality of HOMIS and how to summarize evidence from HOMIS. The results of a literature review and the expert communications in advance of the panel as well as the consensus from the discussions are presented here. We added specific considerations for homeopathic veterinary research.

RESULTS

On top of the general guidelines when planning a review we report five basic Sum-HomIS recommendations. These are: 1) A broad literature search including special archives and consideration of so-called grey-literature; 2) The inclusion of controlled observational studies alongside randomized controlled trials; 3) The choice of a clear clinical research question in the terms that, if possible, the review project includes studies with predominantly homogeneous populations, interventions, comparators and outcomes (PICOs); 4) The use of a global quality assessment including the assessment of external, model and internal validity; 5) A summary of evidence using the GRADE-approach if the body of evidence is sufficiently large and homogenous or a descriptive summary if it is not so.

CONCLUSIONS

We present recommendations for designing, conducting, and reporting SRs and MAs with HOMIS.