Cardiac Xenotransplantation: Progress in Preclinical Models and Prospects for Clinical Translation

Extended survival of 9- and 10-gene-edited pig heart xenografts with ischemia minimization and CD154 costimulation blockade-based immunosuppression

BACKGROUND

Xenotransplantation has made significant advances recently using pigs genetically engineered to remove carbohydrate antigens, either alone or with addition of various human complement, coagulation, and anti-inflammatory ''transgenes''. Here we evaluated results associated with gene-edited (GE) pig hearts transplanted in baboons using an established costimulation-based immunosuppressive regimen and a cold-perfused graft preservation technique.

METHODS

Eight baboons received heterotopic abdominal heart transplants from 3-GE (GalKO.β4GalNT2KO.hCD55, n = 3), 9-GE (GalKO.β4GalNT2KO.GHRKO.hCD46.hCD55. TBM.EPCR.hCD47. HO-1, n = 3) or 10-G (9-GE+CMAHKO, n = 2) pigs using Steen's cold continuous perfusion for ischemia minimization. Immunosuppression (IS) included induction with anti-thymocyte globulin and αCD20, ongoing αCD154, MMF, and tapered corticosteroid.

RESULTS

All three 3-GE grafts functioned well initially, but failed within 5 days. One 9-GE graft was lost intraoperatively due to a technical issue and another was lost at POD 13 due to antibody mediated rejection (AMR) in a baboon with a strongly positive pre-operative cross-match. One 10-GE heart failed at POD113 with combined cellular and antibody mediated rejection. One 9-GE and one 10-GE hearts had preserved graft function with normal myocardium on protocol biopsies, but exhibited slowly progressive graft hypertrophy until elective necropsy at POD393 and 243 respectively. Elevated levels of IL-6, MCP-1, C-reactive protein, and human thrombomodulin were variably associated with conditioning, the transplant procedure, and clinically significant postoperative events.

CONCLUSION

Relative to reference genetics without thrombo-regulatory and anti-inflammatory gene expression, 9- or 10-GE pig hearts exhibit promising performance in the context of a clinically applicable regimen including ischemia minimization and αCD154-based IS, justifying further evaluation in an orthotopic model.

Cardiac Xenotransplantation: A Narrative Review

Cardiac xenotransplantation (cXT) has emerged as a solution to heart donor scarcity, prompting an exploration of its scientific, ethical, and regulatory facets. The review begins with genetic modifications enhancing pig hearts for human transplantation, navigating through immunological challenges, rejection mechanisms, and immune responses. Key areas include preclinical milestones, complement cascade roles, and genetic engineering to address hyperacute rejection. Physiological counterbalance systems, like human thrombomodulin and endothelial protein C receptor upregulation in porcine xenografts, highlight efforts for graft survival enhancement. Evaluating pig and baboon donors and challenges with non-human primates illuminates complexities in donor species selection. Ethical considerations, encompassing animal rights, welfare, and zoonotic disease risks, are critically examined in the cXT context. The review delves into immune control mechanisms with aggressive immunosuppression and clustered regularly interspaced palindromic repeats associated protein 9 (CRISPR/Cas9) technology, elucidating hyperacute rejection, complement activation, and antibody-mediated rejection intricacies. CRISPR/Cas9's role in creating pig endothelial cells expressing human inhibitor molecules is explored for rejection mitigation. Ethical and regulatory aspects emphasize the role of committees and international guidelines. A forward-looking perspective envisions precision medical genetics, artificial intelligence, and individualized heart cultivation within pigs as transformative elements in cXT's future is also explored. This comprehensive analysis offers insights for researchers, clinicians, and policymakers, addressing the current state, and future prospects of cXT.

The pig as an optimal animal model for cardiovascular research

Cardiovascular disease is a worldwide health problem and a leading cause of morbidity and mortality. Preclinical cardiovascular research using animals is needed to explore potential targets and therapeutic options. Compared with rodents, pigs have many advantages, with their anatomy, physiology, metabolism and immune system being more similar to humans. Here we present an overview of the available pig models for cardiovascular diseases, discuss their advantages over other models and propose the concept of standardized models to improve translation to the clinical setting and control research costs.

Genetic Engineering of Donor Pig for the First Human Cardiac Xenotransplantation: Combatting Rejection, Coagulopathy, Inflammation, and Excessive Growth

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The first successful pig to human cardiac xenotransplantation in January 2022 represented a major step forward in the fields of heart failure, immunology, and applied genetic engineering, using a 10-gene edited (GE) pig. This review summarizes the evolution of preclinical modelling data which informed the use of each of the 10 genes modified in the 10-GE pig: GGTA1, Β4GalNT2, CMAH, CD46, CD55, TBM, EPCR, CD47, HO-1, and growth hormone receptor.

RECENT FINDINGS

The translation of the 10-GE pig from preclinical modelling to clinical compassionate xenotransplant use was the culmination of decades of research combating rejection, coagulopathy, inflammation, and excessive xenograft growth. Understanding these 10 genes with a view to their combinatorial effects will be useful in anticipated xenotransplant clinical trials.

A Standardized Approach to Orthotopic (Life-supporting) Porcine Cardiac Xenotransplantation in a Nonhuman Primate Model

Cardiac xenotransplantation from swine has been proposed to "bridge the gap" in supply for heart failure patients requiring transplantation. Recent preclinical success using genetically modified pig donors in baboon recipients has demonstrated survival greater than 6 mo, with a modern understanding of xenotransplantation immunobiology and continued experience with large animal models of cardiac xenotransplantation. As a direct result of this expertise, the Food and Drug Administration approved the first in-human transplantation of a genetically engineered cardiac xenograft through an expanded access application for a single patient. This clinical case demonstrated the feasibility of xenotransplantation. Although this human study demonstrated proof-of-principle application of cardiac xenotransplantation, further regulatory oversight by the Food and Drug Administration may be required with preclinical trials in large animal models of xenotransplantation with long-term survival before approval of a more formalized clinical trial. Here we detail our surgical approach to pig-to-primate large animal models of orthotopic cardiac xenotransplantation, and the postoperative care of the primate recipient, both in the immediate postoperative period and in the months thereafter. We also detail xenograft surveillance methods and common issues that arise in the postoperative period specific to this model and ways to overcome them. These studies require multidisciplinary teams and expertise in orthotopic transplantation (cardiac surgery, anesthesia, and cardiopulmonary bypass), immunology, genetic engineering, and experience in handling large animal donors and recipients, which are described here. This article serves to reduce the barriers to entry into a field with ever-growing enthusiasm, but demands expertise knowledge and experience to be successful.

Isolation of porcine adult cardiomyocytes: Comparison between Langendorff perfusion and tissue slicing-assisted enzyme digestion

Tissue slicing-assisted digestion (TSAD) of adult cardiomyocytes has shown significant improvements over conventional chunk methods. However, it remains unclear how this method compares to Langendorff perfusion, the current standard of adult cardiomyocyte isolation. Using adult Bama minipigs, we performed cardiomyocyte isolation via these two distinct methods, and compared the resulting cellular quality, including viability, cellular structure, gene expression, and electrophysiological properties, of cardiomyocytes from 3 distinct anatomical regions, namely the left ventricle, right ventricle, and left atrial appendage. Our results revealed largely indistinguishable cell quality in all of the measured parameters. These findings suggest that that TSAD can be reliably used to isolate adult mammalian cardiomyocytes as a reliable alternative to perfusion in cardiomyocyte isolation from larger mammals, particularly when Langendorff perfusion is not feasible.

Cardiac Surgeons Highlight the Need for Innovation Stewardship: Noteworthy in 2022

Modern cardiac surgery has rapidly evolved to treat complex cardiovascular disease. This past year boasted noteworthy advances in xenotransplantation, prosthetic cardiac valves, and endovascular thoracic aortic repair. Newer devices often offer incremental design changes while demanding significant cost increases that leave surgeons to decide if the benefit to patients justifies the increased cost. As innovations are introduced, surgeons must continuously aim to harmonize short- and long-term benefits with financial costs). We must also ensure quality patient outcomes while embracing innovations that will advance equitable cardiovascular care.