Species Discrimination of Stomoxys Flies S. bengalensis, S. calcitrans, and S. sitiens (Diptera: Muscidae) Using Wing Geometric Morphometrics

First insights into using outline-based geometric morphometrics of wing cell contours to distinguish three morphologically similar species of Tabanus (Diptera: Tabanidae)

Accurate species identification of horse flies (Diptera: Tabanidae) is crucial due to their role as vectors for various pathogens, which is essential for understanding their biology, devising strategies to control their populations, and enhancing disease surveillance. This study assessed the efficacy of outline-based geometric morphometrics (GM) by analyzing the wing cell contours of discal, first submarginal, and second submarginal cells to distinguish three morphologically similar Tabanus species commonly found in Thailand, T. megalops, T. rubidus, and T. striatus. Statistical analysis demonstrated significant size differences between T. rubidus and the two other species (P < 0.05), with T. rubidus exhibiting larger wing cells. Tabanus megalops and T. striatus had similar sizes; their size differences were not statistically significant. The accuracy of size analysis based on validated classification tests was relatively low, ranging from 64.67% to 68.67%. Nonetheless, all wing cell contours showed significant shape differences between the three species, as confirmed by Mahalanobis distance comparisons using 1000 permutation tests (P < 0.05). The shape of the first submarginal cell contour showed the highest classification accuracy (86.67%). Outline-based GM offers a significant advantage for analyzing fly specimens with incomplete wings that have intact cells. For damaged specimens, analyzing the contour of the first submarginal cell through this technique can be a viable alternative.

Evaluation of the wing cell contour to distinguish between Stomoxys bengalensis and Stomoxys sitiens (Diptera: Muscidae) using outline-based morphometrics

The blood-sucking flies of the genus Stomoxys Geoffroy, 1762 (Diptera: Muscidae) are significant ectoparasites that can cause irritation and transmit pathogens to both animals and humans. Within the genus Stomoxys, two species, Stomoxys bengalensis and Stomoxys sitiens, have similar morphology and coexist in the same habitat. Accurate species identification of these flies is crucial for understanding disease vectors and implementing effective control measures. In this study, we assessed the effectiveness of outline-based geometric morphometrics (GM) by analyzing the wing cell contour of the first posterior cell (R5) to distinguish between species and sexes of S. bengalensis and S. sitiens. Our results demonstrate that the outline-based GM method is highly effective in distinguishing between species and sexes of these flies based on contour shape, with accuracy scores ranging from 90.0% to 97.5%. Therefore, outline-based GM emerges as a promising alternative to landmark-based GM or as a supplementary tool in conjunction with traditional morphology-based methods for species identification.

Genetic and morphometric differentiation between two morphs of Haematobosca sanguinolenta (Diptera: Muscidae) from Thailand

Haematobosca is a genus of biting fly within the subfamily Stomoxyinae of the family Muscidae. It is currently recognized to include 16 species worldwide. These species, acting as ectoparasites, are considered to have significant importance in the veterinary and medical fields. To address the color polymorphism related to the genus Haematobosca in Thailand, herein, we focused on the normal (legs mainly black) and yellow (legs mainly yellow) morphs of Haematobosca sanguinolenta and examined them for genetic differences using three molecular markers: the cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1 (cox1) and cytochrome b (cytb) genes from the mitochondrial genome as well as the internal transcribed spacer 2 (ITS2) region from the nuclear ribosomal DNA. In addition, we analyzed wing differences between the two morphs using geometric morphometrics (GM). The genetic divergences between the two morphs showed that cytb gene showed the greatest divergence, for which the average distance was 5.6%. This was followed by the combination of cox1-cytb-ITS2, exhibiting an average divergence of 4.5%, ITS2 with a divergence of 4.1%, and finally cox1, showing the lowest divergence of 3.5%. Phylogenetic analyses distinctly separated the two morphs of H. sanguinolenta; this separation was supported by high bootstrap values (97-100%). These results were further corroborated by three species delimitation methods, i.e. assemble species by automatic partitioning (ASAP), automated barcode gap discovery (ABGD), and Poisson tree processes (PTP), all of which suggested that the two morphs likely represent separate species. In addition, a GM study identified a statistically significant difference in wing shape between the two morphs of H. sanguinolenta (P < 0.05). This combination of genetic and morphometric results strongly supports the existence of two distinct species within H. sanguinolenta in Thailand.

Wing geometric morphometrics and DNA barcoding to distinguish three closely related species of Armigeres mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae) in Thailand

Armigeres subalbatus, a mosquito species widely found in Thailand and other Asian countries, serves as a vector for filarial parasites, affecting both humans and animals. However, the surveillance of this vector is complicated because of its morphological similarity to two other species, Armigeres dohami and Armigeres kesseli. To differentiate these morphologically similar species, our study employed both wing geometric morphometrics (GM) and DNA barcoding, offering a comprehensive approach to accurately identify these closely related Armigeres species in Thailand. Our GM analyses based on shape demonstrated significant accuracy in differentiating Armigeres species. Specifically, the outline-based GM method focusing on the 3rd posterior cell exhibited an accuracy rate of 82.61%, closely followed by the landmark-based GM method with 81.54%. Both these GM techniques effectively distinguished Ar. subalbatus from Ar. dohami and Ar. kesseli. Regarding DNA barcoding, our investigation of pairwise intra- and interspecific divergences revealed a "barcoding gap". Furthermore, the results of species confirmation using both species delimitation methods including the automatic barcode gap discovery method (ABGD) and the Multi-rate Poisson tree process (mPTP) were consistent with those of morphological identification, sequence comparisons with the GenBank and Barcode of Life Data System (BOLD) databases, and the neighbor-joining tree construction. These consistent results emphasize the efficacy of DNA barcoding in the precise identification of Armigeres species.

Wing geometric morphometrics to distinguish and identify Haematobosca flies (Diptera: Muscidae) from Thailand

The hematophagous flies of the genus Haematobosca Bezzi, 1907 (Diptera: Muscidae) are important ectoparasites in domestic animals and wildlife. Two species of this genus have been recorded in Thailand, viz., Haematobosca sanguinolenta (Austen, 1909) and Haematobosca aberrans (Pont, Duvallet & Changbunjong, 2020). They have a similar morphology and coexist in the same habitat. The correct species identification of these flies is extremely important for understanding disease epidemiology and developing effective control measures. Geometric morphometrics (GM) has been confirmed to be a useful tool for differentiating and identifying morphologically similar insect species. Therefore, GM was used to distinguish and identify H. sanguinolenta and H. aberrans in Thailand. Adult flies of both sexes were collected using Nzi traps, morphologically identified, and analyzed by landmark-based GM of the wing. Results showed that GM was highly effective in distinguishing the two Haematobosca species based on their wing shape, with an overall accuracy score of 99.3%. We also revealed that our study material could be used as reference data to identify new field specimens collected from other geographic locations. We propose that wing GM can be used as a supplement to conventional morphology identification, particularly for Haematobosca specimen that has been damaged or has lost its diagnostic characteristics due to specimen collection and processing in the field.

Molecular characterization and genetic diversity of three Stomoxys flies S. bengalensis, S. calcitrans, and S. sitiens (Diptera: Muscidae) in Central Thailand

Stomoxys flies (Diptera: Muscidae) are hematophagous ectoparasites of medical and veterinary importance. In this study, three Stomoxys species, i.e. S. bengalensis, S. calcitrans, and S. sitiens, were collected from three provinces in Central Thailand with the aim of estimating the genetic divergence between species, for species identification, as well as within species, for a genetic diversity study based on the cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) gene. Our results showed that the average intraspecific genetic divergences of Stomoxys flies ranged from 0.11% in S. sitiens to 0.98% in S. calcitrans, whereas the average interspecific genetic divergences ranged from 5.24% between S. sitiens and S. bengalensis to 6.69% between S. calcitrans and S. bengalensis. In addition, there was no overlap between the intraspecific and interspecific genetic divergences. The COI sequence analysis revealed a high haplotype diversity and low nucleotide diversity, reflecting a rapid population expansion after past bottlenecks. Moreover, there was no significant difference (P > 0.05) in the pairwise population differentiation (Fst) among Stomoxys flies in Central Thailand, because of the lack of natural barriers, thus allowing genetic exchange between them. The monitoring of the haplotype network revealed that two lineages of S. calcitrans in Central Thailand were distributed in all study areas, including the Nakhon Pathom, Pathum Thani, and Saraburi Provinces. These findings may improve our understanding of the genetic patterns of these three Stomoxys flies, as well as the underlying biological mechanisms, which is knowledge that can be used for further effective control of these flies.