Pectocin M1 (PcaM1) Inhibits Escherichia coli Cell Growth and Peptidoglycan Biosynthesis through Periplasmic Expression

The Biology of Colicin M and Its Orthologs

The misuse of antibiotics during the last decades led to the emergence of multidrug resistant pathogenic bacteria. This phenomenon constitutes a major public health issue. Consequently, the discovery of new antibacterials in the short term is crucial. Colicins, due to their antibacterial properties, thus constitute good candidates. These toxin proteins, produced by E. coli to kill enteric relative competitors, exhibit cytotoxicity through ionophoric activity or essential macromolecule degradation. Among the 25 colicin types known to date, colicin M (ColM) is the only one colicin interfering with peptidoglycan biosynthesis. Accordingly, ColM develops its lethal activity in E. coli periplasm by hydrolyzing the last peptidoglycan precursor, lipid II, into two dead-end products, thereby leading to cell lysis. Since the discovery of its unusual mode of action, several ColM orthologs have also been identified based on sequence alignments; all of the characterized ColM-like proteins display the same enzymatic activity of lipid II degradation and narrow antibacterial spectra. This publication aims at being an exhaustive review of the current knowledge on this new family of antibacterial enzymes as well as on their potential use as food preservatives or therapeutic agents.

CbrA Mediates Colicin M Resistance in Escherichia coli through Modification of Undecaprenyl-Phosphate-Linked Peptidoglycan Precursors

Colicin M is an enzymatic bacteriocin produced by some Escherichia coli strains which provokes cell lysis of competitor strains by hydrolysis of the cell wall peptidoglycan undecaprenyl-PP-MurNAc(-pentapeptide)-GlcNAc (lipid II) precursor. The overexpression of a gene, cbrA (formerly yidS), was shown to protect E. coli cells from the deleterious effects of this colicin, but the underlying resistance mechanism was not established. We report here that a major structural modification of the undecaprenyl-phosphate carrier lipid and of its derivatives occurred in membranes of CbrA-overexpressing cells, which explains the acquisition of resistance toward this bacteriocin. Indeed, a main fraction of these lipids, including the lipid II peptidoglycan precursor, now displayed a saturated isoprene unit at the α-position, i.e., the unit closest to the colicin M cleavage site. Only unsaturated forms of these lipids were normally detectable in wild-type cells. In vitro and in vivo assays showed that colicin M did not hydrolyze α-saturated lipid II, clearly identifying this substrate modification as the resistance mechanism. These saturated forms of undecaprenyl-phosphate and lipid II remained substrates of the different enzymes participating in peptidoglycan biosynthesis and carrier lipid recycling, allowing this colicin M-resistance mechanism to occur without affecting this essential pathway.IMPORTANCE Overexpression of the chromosomal cbrA gene allows E. coli to resist colicin M (ColM), a bacteriocin specifically hydrolyzing the undecaprenyl-PP-MurNAc(-pentapeptide)-GlcNAc (lipid II) peptidoglycan precursor of targeted cells. This resistance results from a CbrA-dependent modification of the precursor structure, i.e., reduction of the α-isoprenyl bond of C₅₅-carrier lipid moiety that is proximal to ColM cleavage site. This modification, observed here for the first time in eubacteria, annihilates the ColM activity without affecting peptidoglycan biogenesis. These data, which further increase our knowledge of the substrate specificity of this colicin, highlight the capability of E. coli to generate reduced forms of C₅₅-carrier lipid and its derivatives. Whether the function of this modification is only relevant with respect to ColM resistance is now questioned.

Impact of FiuA Outer Membrane Receptor Polymorphism on the Resistance of Pseudomonas aeruginosa toward Peptidoglycan Lipid II-Targeting PaeM Pyocins

Certain Pseudomonas aeruginosa strains produce a homolog of colicin M, namely, PaeM, that specifically inhibits peptidoglycan biosynthesis of susceptible P. aeruginosa strains by hydrolyzing the lipid II intermediate precursor. Two variants of this pyocin were identified whose sequences mainly differed in the N-terminal protein moiety, i.e., the region involved in the binding to the FiuA outer membrane receptor and translocation into the periplasm. The antibacterial activity of these two variants, PaeM1 and PaeM2, was tested against various P. aeruginosa strains comprising reference strains PAO1 and PA14, PaeM-producing strains, and 60 clinical isolates. Seven of these strains, including PAO1, were susceptible to only one variant (2 to PaeM1 and 5 to PaeM2), and 11 were affected by both. The remaining strains, including PA14 and four PaeM1 producers, were resistant to both variants. The differences in the antibacterial spectra of the two PaeM homologs prompted us to investigate the molecular determinants allowing their internalization into P. aeruginosa cells, taking the PAO1 strain that is susceptible to PaeM2 but resistant to PaeM1 as the indicator strain. Heterologous expression of fiuA gene orthologs from different strains into PAO1, site-directed mutagenesis experiments, and construction of PaeM chimeric proteins provided evidence that the cell susceptibility and discrimination differences between the PaeM variants resulted from a polymorphism of both the pyocin and the outer membrane receptor FiuA. Moreover, we found that a third component, TonB1, a protein involved in iron transport in P. aeruginosa, working together with FiuA and the ExbB/ExbD complex, was directly implicated in this discrimination.IMPORTANCE Bacterial antibiotic resistance constitutes a threat to human health, imposing the need for identification of new targets and development of new strategies to fight multiresistant pathogens. Bacteriocins and other weapons that bacteria have themselves developed to kill competitors are therefore of great interest and a valuable source of inspiration for us. Attention was paid here to two variants of a colicin M homolog (PaeM) produced by certain strains of P. aeruginosa that inhibit the growth of their congeners by blocking cell wall peptidoglycan synthesis. Molecular determinants allowing recognition of these pyocins by the outer membrane receptor FiuA were identified, and a receptor polymorphism affecting the susceptibility of P. aeruginosa clinical strains was highlighted, providing new insights into the potential use of these pyocins as an alternative to antibiotics.

The ColM Family, Polymorphic Toxins Breaching the Bacterial Cell Wall

Bacteria host an arsenal of antagonism-mediating molecules to combat for ecologic space. Bacteriocins represent a pivotal group of secreted antibacterial peptides and proteins assisting in this fight, mainly eliminating relatives. Colicin M, a model for peptidoglycan-interfering bacteriocins in Gram-negative bacteria, appears to be part of a set of polymorphic toxins equipped with such a catalytic domain (ColM) targeting lipid II. Diversifying recombination has enabled parasitism of different receptors and has also given rise to hybrid bacteriocins in which ColM is associated with another toxin module. Remarkably, ColM toxins have recruited a diverse array of immunity partners, comprising cytoplasmic membrane-associated proteins with different topologies. Together, these findings suggest that different immunity mechanisms have evolved for ColM, in contrast to bacteriocins with nuclease activities.

A Natural Chimeric Pseudomonas Bacteriocin with Novel Pore-Forming Activity Parasitizes the Ferrichrome Transporter

Modular bacteriocins represent a major group of secreted protein toxins with a narrow spectrum of activity, involved in interference competition between Gram-negative bacteria. These antibacterial proteins include a domain for binding to the target cell and a toxin module at the carboxy terminus. Self-inhibition of producers is provided by coexpression of linked immunity genes that transiently inhibit the toxin's activity through formation of bacteriocin-immunity complexes or by insertion in the inner membrane, depending on the type of toxin module. We demonstrate strain-specific inhibitory activity for PmnH, a Pseudomonas bacteriocin with an unprecedented dual-toxin architecture, hosting both a colicin M domain, potentially interfering with peptidoglycan synthesis, and a novel colicin N-type domain, a pore-forming module distinct from the colicin Ia-type domain in Pseudomonas aeruginosa pyocin S5. A downstream-linked gene product confers PmnH immunity upon susceptible strains. This protein, ImnH, has a transmembrane topology similar to that of Pseudomonas colicin M-like and pore-forming immunity proteins, although homology with either of these is essentially absent. The enhanced killing activity of PmnH under iron-limited growth conditions reflects parasitism of the ferrichrome-type transporter for entry into target cells, a strategy shown here to be used as well by monodomain colicin M-like bacteriocins from pseudomonads. The integration of a second type of toxin module in a bacteriocin gene could offer a competitive advantage against bacteria displaying immunity against only one of both toxic activities.IMPORTANCE In their continuous struggle for ecological space, bacteria face a huge load of contenders, including phylogenetically related strains that compete for the same niche. One important group of secreted antibacterial proteins assisting in eliminating these rivals are modular bacteriocins of Gram-negative bacteria, comprising a domain for docking onto the cell envelope of a target cell, a translocation domain enabling subsequent cellular entry, and a toxin module that kills target cells via enzymatic or pore-forming activity. We here demonstrate the antagonistic function of a Pseudomonas bacteriocin with unique architecture that combines a putative enzymatic colicin M-like domain and a novel pore-forming toxin module. For target cell recognition and entry, this bacteriocin hybrid takes advantage of the ferrichrome transporter, also parasitized by enzymatic Pseudomonas bacteriocins devoid of the pore-forming module. Bacteriocins with an expanded toxin potential may represent an inventive bacterial strategy to alleviate immunity in target cells.