A Lipidomic Analysis of Leaves of Esca-Affected Grapevine Suggests a Role for Galactolipids in the Defense Response and Appearance of Foliar Symptoms

Applicability of metabolomics to improve sustainable grapevine production

Metabolites represent the end product of gene expression, protein interaction and other regulatory mechanisms. The metabolome reflects a biological system's response to genetic and environmental changes, providing a more accurate description of plants' phenotype than the transcriptome or the proteome. Grapevine (Vitis vinifera L.), established for the production of wine grapes, table grapes, and raisins, holds immense agronomical and economic significance not only in the Mediterranean region but worldwide. As all plants, grapevines face the adverse impact of biotic and abiotic stresses that negatively affect multiple stages of grape and wine industry, including plant and berry development pre- and post-harvest, fresh grapes processing and consequently wine quality. In the present review we highlight the applicability of metabolome analysis in the understanding of the mechanisms involved in grapevine response and acclimatization upon the main biotic and abiotic constrains. The metabolome of induced morphogenic processes such as adventitious rooting and somatic embryogenesis is also explored, as it adds knowledge on the physiological and molecular phenomena occurring in the explants used, and on the successfully propagation of grapevines with desired traits. Finally, the microbiome-induced metabolites in grapevine are discussed in view of beneficial applications derived from the plant symbioses.

Alteration in lipid metabolism is involved in nitrogen deficiency response in wheat seedlings

Changes of membrane lipid composition contribute to plant adaptation to various abiotic stresses. Here, a comparative study was undertaken to investigate the mechanisms of how lipid alteration affects plant growth and development under nitrogen (N) deficiency. Two wheat cultivars: the N deficiency-tolerant cultivar Xiaoyan 6 (XY) and the N deficiency-sensitive cultivar Aikang 58 (AK) were used to test if the high N-deficiency tolerance was related with lipid metabolism. The results showed that N deficiency inhibited the morpho-physiological parameters in both XY and AK cultivars, which showed a significant decrease in biomass, N content, photosynthetic efficiency, and lipid contents. However, these decreases were more pronounced in AK than XY. In addition, XY showed a notable increase in fatty acid unsaturation, relatively well-maintained chloroplast ultrastructure, and minimized damage of lipid peroxidation and enhanced PSII activity under N-deficient condition, as compared with AK. Transcription levels of many genes involved in lipid biosynthesis and fatty acid desaturation were up-regulated in response to N deficiency in two wheat cultivars, while the expressions were much higher in XY than AK under N deficiency. These results highlight the importance of alterations in lipid metabolism in N deficiency tolerance in wheat. High levels of lipid content and unsaturated fatty acids maintained the membrane structure and function, contributing to high photosynthesis and antioxidant capacities, thereby improved the tolerance to N deficiency.

In Vivo and Real-Time Metabolic Profiling of Plant-Microbe Interactions in Leaves, Stems, and Roots of Bacterially Inoculated Chardonnay Plantlets using SpiderMass

There is growing interest in limiting the use of fungicides and implementing innovative, environmentally friendly strategies, such as the use of beneficial bacteria-triggered immunity, to protect grapevines from natural pathogens. Therefore, we need rapid and innovative ways to translate the knowledge of the molecular mechanisms underlying the activation of grapevine defenses against pathogens to induced resistance. Here, we have implemented an in vivo minimally invasive approach to study the interaction between plants and beneficial bacteria based on metabolic signatures. Paraburkholderia phytofirmans strain PsJN and PsJN-grapevine were used as bacterial and plant-bacterium interaction models, respectively. Using an innovative tool, SpiderMass, based on water-assisted laser desorption ionization with an IR microsampling probe, we simultaneously detect metabolic and lipidomic species. A metabolomic spectrum was thus generated, which was used to build a library and identify the most variable and discriminative peaks between the two conditions. We then showed that caftaric acid (m/z 311.04), caftaric acid dimer (m/z 623.09), derived caftaric acid (m/z 653.15), and quercetin-O-glucuronide tended to accumulate in grapevine leaves after root bacterization with PsJN. In addition, together with these phenolic messengers, we identified lipid biomarkers such as palmitic acid, linoleic acid, and α-linoleic acid as important messengers of enhanced defense mechanisms in Chardonnay plantlets. Taken together, SpiderMass is the next-generation methodology for studying plant-microorganism metabolic interactions with the prospect of in vivo real-time analysis in viticulture.

Lipid mediated plant immunity in susceptible and tolerant soybean cultivars in response to Phytophthora sojae colonization and infection

BACKGROUND

Soybean is one of the most cultivated crops globally and a staple food for much of the world's population. The annual global crop losses due to infection by Phytophthora sojae is currently estimated at $20B USD, yet we have limited understanding of the role of lipid mediators in the adaptative strategies used by the host plant to limit infection. Since root is the initial site of this infection, we examined the infection process in soybean root infected with Phytophthora sojae using scanning electron microscopy to observe the changes in root morphology and a multi-modal lipidomics approach to investigate how soybean cultivars remodel their lipid mediators to successfully limit infection by Phytophthora sojae.

RESULTS

The results reveal the presence of elevated biogenic crystals and more severe damaged cells in the root morphology of the infected susceptible cultivar compared to the infected tolerant cultivars. Furthermore, induced accumulation of stigmasterol was observed in the susceptible cultivar whereas, induced accumulation of phospholipids and glycerolipids occurred in tolerant cultivar.

CONCLUSION

The altered lipidome reported in this study suggest diacylglycerol and phosphatidic acid mediated lipid signalling impacting phytosterol anabolism appears to be a strategy used by tolerant soybean cultivars to successfully limit infection and colonization by Phytophthora sojae.

Effect of Drought Stress on Degradation and Remodeling of Membrane Lipids in Nostoc flagelliforme

Nostoc flagelliforme is a kind of terrestrial edible cyanobacteria with important ecological and economic value which has developed special mechanisms to adapt to drought conditions. However, the specific mechanism of lipidome changes in drought tolerance of N. flagelliforme has not been well understood. In this study, the ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry were employed to analyze the lipidome changes of N. flagelliforme under dehydration. A total of 853 lipid molecules were identified, of which 171 were significantly different from that of the control group. The digalactosyldiacylglycerol/monogalactosyldiacylglycerol (DGDG/MGDG) ratio was increased. The amount of wax ester (WE) was sharply decreased during drought stress, while Co (Q10) was accumulated. The levels of odd chain fatty acids (OCFAs) were increased under dehydration, positively responding to drought stress according to the energy metabolism state. In conclusion, the lipidomic data corroborated that oxidation, degradation, and biosynthesis of membrane lipids took place during lipid metabolism, which can respond to drought stress through the transformation of energy and substances. Besides, we constructed a lipid metabolic model demonstrating the regulatory mechanism of drought stress in N. flagelliforme. The present study provides insight into the defense strategies of cyanobacteria in lipid metabolic pathways.

Modification of Early Response of Vitis vinifera to Pathogens Relating to Esca Disease and Biocontrol Agent Vintec® Revealed By Untargeted Metabolomics on Woody Tissues

Esca disease is one of the most destructive grapevine trunk diseases. Phaeoacremonium minimum and Phaeomoniella chlamydospora are two of the known fungal pathogens associated with this disease. Today, biocontrol agents against Esca are mainly based on the use of the strain of the mycoparasite fungal genus Trichoderma such as the Vintec® product. The aim of this study was to investigate early response of woody tissues to Esca pathogens and identify metabolites that could be correlated with a biocontrol activity within a complex woody matrix. An untargeted liquid chromatography-high-resolution mass spectrometry metabolomic approach coupled to a spectral similarity network was used to highlight clusters of compounds associated with the plant response to pathogens and biocontrol. Dereplication highlighted the possible role of glycerophospholipids and polyphenol compounds, the latest mainly belonging to stilbenoids. Antifungal activity of some relevant biomarkers, evaluated in vitro on Phaeomoniella chlamydospora and Botrytis cinerea, suggests that some of these compounds can play a role to limit the development of Esca pathogens in planta.

Metabolite profile data of grapevine plants with brown wood streaking and grapevine leaf stripe (esca complex disease) symptoms

Leaf samples were obtained from Vitis vinifera ‘Malvasia Fina’ plants with well-characterized esca complex disease symptoms (n = 18) and from healthy uninfected plants (n = 6). Leaves from diseased plants were divided into three groups: asymptomatic (ASY), chlorotic (SY1), and scorched leaves (SY2). The metabolic profile of these leaves was then examined using an ultrahigh performance liquid chromatography system coupled to a Q-Exactive Hybrid Quadrupole-Orbitrap high resolution/accurate mass spectrometer interfaced with a heated electrospray ionization source. The number of small molecules measured in a sample was increased by varying the reconstitution solvent, chromatographic column, and ionization source. Data on accurate masses, peak areas, and relative levels of several metabolites were documented for each leaf sample, using the abovementioned approach. In this paper, data on 235 metabolites of known structural identity are reported, along with the biochemical pathways to which the metabolites belong. The remaining data related to lipid species and with a different focus of the research question are reported elsewhere. The broad coverage of metabolites reported here resulted in a greater coverage of the biochemical pathways involved in grapevine metabolism, which could provide a better understanding of the biochemical changes occurring during the onset and progression of foliar symptoms after invasion of woods by esca-associated pathogens. To determine which metabolites varied according to the study design, the detected ion features were processed using different statistical methods, including mean and median values, fold changes, Welch's two-sample t-test, false discovery rate, and quartiles represented by box and whisker plots. The goal of this statistical evaluation was to assess the responses of healthy, asymptomatic, and symptomatic leaf groups using a pairwise comparison, thus providing an opportunity for detecting statistically significant compounds and uncovering the dynamic metabolic models underlying disease latency and symptom expression.

White Rot Fungi (Hymenochaetales) and Esca of Grapevine: Insights from Recent Microbiome Studies

Esca is a major grapevine trunk disease that heavily affects vineyards in the Northern hemisphere. The etiology and epidemiology of this disease have been subject of dispute ever since the earliest disease reports. The reason behind such debate is the presence of multiple internal and external symptoms, as well as several putative and confirmed wood pathogens. While the role of pathogenic fungi, as causal agents of wood symptoms, has been thoroughly assessed, their role in the expression of leaf symptoms remains to be fully elucidated. In this review, we analyzed etiological and epidemiological data, with a special focus on the microbiological aspect of esca and the involvement of Hymenochaetales (Basidiomycota). Vineyard studies have associated leaf symptoms with the presence of white rot, most frequently caused by Fomitiporia mediterranea (Hymenochaetales), while tracheomycotic fungi are commonly found, with similar abundance, in symptomatic and asymptomatic vines. Pathogenicity trials have excluded a direct effect of Hymenochaetales species in triggering leaf symptoms, while the data concerning the role of tracheomycotic fungi remains controversial. Recent microbiome studies confirmed that F. mediterranea is more abundant in leaf-symptomatic vines, and treatments that effectively control leaf symptoms, such as sodium arsenite spray and trunk surgery, act directly on the abundance of F. mediterranea or on the presence of white rot. This suggest that the simultaneous presence of Hymenochaetales and tracheomycotic fungi is a pre-requisite for leaf symptoms; however, the relation among fungal pathogens, grapevine and other biotic and abiotic factors needs further investigation.

Dataset of levels and masses of lipid species in healthy, asymptomatic and symptomatic leaves of vitis vinifera L. 'Malvasia fina' affected by ESCA complex disease

The dataset presented in this paper comprises the masses of 208 lipid species and other compounds of lipid metabolism, and their levels in leaves of vines with brown wood streaking and grapevine leaf stripe, two symptomatic expressions of Esca complex disease (ESCA). Healthy, asymptomatic and symptomatic leaves were collected from the cultivar Malvasia Fina grown in a vineyard. The lipidome of these leaves was characterized using a platform consisting of an Ultrahigh Performance Liquid Chromatography and a Gas chromatography equipment coupled to a Q-Exactive Hybrid Quadrupole-Orbitrap high resolution/accurate Mass Spectrometer interfaced with a heated electrospray ionization source. The analysis permitted the detection of 158 molecular species of known identity and 50 species of unknown structural identity. The area counts of these molecular species is reported in the dataset, along with fold changes (log2-ratio), P-values (Welch's two-sample t-test), and q-values (false discovery rate) from all pairwise comparisons among experimental groups. These statistical data are intended to serve as means of identification for lipid species whose levels were altered by the disease, and which could be used as biomarkers of symptom emergence and disease progression. Because of few studies on the subject, the association between modulation of lipid biosynthetic pathways and disease progression in grapevine has remained poorly understood. The analysis of the data described here has already provided new perspectives regarding the pathogenesis of ESCA leaf symptom formation. Reanalysis of these data would undoubtedly unravel some physiological roles played by lipids in the adaptation of vine plants to stressful conditions.

A Lipidomic Analysis of Leaves of Esca-Affected Grapevine Suggests a Role for Galactolipids in the Defense Response and Appearance of Foliar Symptoms

Both qualitative and quantitative changes occur in the lipid composition of Vitis vinifera L. tissues, which may compromise the defense response against Esca complex disease, a widespread and damaging trunk disease. In this study, a lipidomic analysis of grapevine leaves is conducted to assess how lipid membrane remodeling relates to the emergence and progression of Esca foliar symptoms. In total, 208 molecular species (including lipids, four hormones, and some other compounds of the metabolism of lipids) were detected. Lipid species were readily assigned to the classes fatty acyls, glycerolipids, glycerophospholipids, sphingolipids, sterols, and prenol lipids. Using different clustering analyses, distinct metabolic pathways stimulated at different stages of disease development were characterized. These analyses revealed consistent changes in the abundance of 13 galactolipids and two diacylglycerolipids. Overall, the observations indicated an increment in the levels of these lipid species in leaves of asymptomatic vines and a progressive drop with increasing foliar symptom severity in symptomatic vines. Five fatty acids also appear to exert a central role in the etiopathogenesis of Esca complex disease because of their accumulation in leaves of asymptomatic vines, namely, heptadecanoic, linoleic, γ-linolenic, arachidonic, and stearic acids. Symptomatic leaves were characterized by high levels of all lipid classes, except for galactolipids, lyso-galactolipids, and compounds relevant to the biosynthesis of chlorophylls and carotenoids, that exhibited decreased levels. The data also suggested a jasmonic acid-associated signaling mechanism activation upon the invasion of woods by Esca-associated fungi, compared with abscisic and salicylic acids. Further research is required for validation of these results with additional molecular analyses using more vine cultivars.