The Impact of Cell-Free DNA Analysis on the Management of Retinoblastoma

[Liquid biopsy in retinoblastomas]

The liquid biopsy is playing an increasingly more important role in the diagnosis and treatment of retinoblastomas. The possibility of safe and uncomplicated retrieval and examination of aqueous humour from the anterior chamber contributes significantly to the differential diagnosis and to a better understanding of the disease. It helps with the prognosis both in terms of eye-preserving treatment and in estimating the risk of metastatic disease and helps with genetic uncertainties in unilateral disease. It is expected that the further development of liquid biopsy methods will form the basis for a personalized diagnosis and treatment of children with a retinoblastoma in the future.

Epidemiology, Diagnosis and Genetics of Retinoblastoma: ICMR Consensus Guidelines

Retinoblastoma (RB) is the most common intraocular tumor in childhood. It is mainly caused by mutations in both alleles of the RB1 tumor suppressor gene that is found on chromosome 13 and regulates the cell cycle. Approximately 8000 children are diagnosed with RB globally each year, with an estimated 1500 cases occurring in India. The survival rate of RB has improved to more than 90% in the developed world. Leukocoria and proptosis are the most common presenting features of RB in Asian Indian populations. Most cases of RB are diagnosed by fundus examination followed by ultrasound. The International Classification of Retinoblastoma is the most used scheme for the staging and classification of intraocular RB in India. Prenatal testing and preimplantation genetic testing for RB may be beneficial in high-risk families. Histopathologic risk factors such as massive choroidal invasion and post-laminar optic nerve help in predicting the occurrence of metastasis in children with RB, while presence of microscopic residual disease requires aggressive adjuvant treatment in eyes enucleated for group E RB. The review provides a consensus document on diagnosis and genetics of RB in India.

Aqueous Humor Liquid Biopsy as a Companion Diagnostic for Retinoblastoma: Implications for Diagnosis, Prognosis, and Therapeutic Options: Five Years of Progress

PURPOSE

To define the prospective use of the aqueous humor (AH) as a molecular diagnostic and prognostic liquid biopsy for retinoblastoma (RB).

METHODS

This is a prospective, observational study wherein an AH liquid biopsy is performed at diagnosis and longitudinally through therapy for patients with RB. Tumor-derived cell-free DNA is isolated and sequenced for single nucleotide variant analysis of the RB1 gene and detection of somatic copy number alterations (SCNAs). The SCNAs are used to determine tumor fraction (TFx). Specific SCNAs, including 6p gain and focal MycN gain, along with TFx, are prospectively correlated with intraocular tumor relapse, response to therapy, and globe salvage.

RESULTS

A total of 26 eyes of 21 patients were included with AH taken at diagnosis. Successful ocular salvage was achieved in 19 of 26 (73.1%) eyes. Mutational analysis of 26 AH samples identified 23 pathogenic RB1 variants and 2 focal RB1 deletions; variant allele fraction ranged from 30.5% to 100% (median 93.2%). At diagnosis, SCNAs were detectable in 17 of 26 (65.4%) AH samples. Eyes with 6p gain and/or focal MycN gain had significantly greater odds of poor therapeutic outcomes (odds ratio = 6.75, 95% CI = 1.06-42.84, P = .04). Higher AH TFx was observed in eyes with vitreal progression (TFx = 46.0% ± 40.4) than regression (22.0 ± 29.1; difference: -24.0; P = .049).

CONCLUSIONS

Establishing an AH liquid biopsy for RB is aimed at addressing (1) our inability to biopsy tumor tissue and (2) the lack of molecular biomarkers for intraocular prognosis. Current management decisions for RB are made based solely on clinical features without objective molecular testing. This prognostic study shows great promise for using AH as a companion diagnostic. NOTE: Publication of this article is sponsored by the American Ophthalmological Society.

Recent Advancements and Innovations in Pediatric Precision Oncology

Precision oncology incorporates comprehensive genomic profiling into the individualized clinical care of pediatric cancer patients. In recent years, comprehensive pan-cancer analyses have led to the successful implementation of genomics-based pediatric trials and accelerated approval of novel targeted agents. In addition, disease-specific studies have resulted in molecular subclassification of myriad cancer types with subsequent tailoring of treatment intensity based on the patient's prognostic factors. This review discusses the progress of the field and highlights developments that are leading to more personalized cancer care and improved patient outcomes. Increased understanding of the evolution of precision oncology over recent decades emphasizes the tremendous impact of improved genomic applications. New technologies and improved diagnostic modalities offer further promise for future advancements within the field.

An overview of RB1 transcript alterations detected during retinoblastoma genetic screening

Identification of pathogenic RB1 variants aids in the clinical management of families with retinoblastoma. We routinely screen DNA for RB1 variants, but transcript analysis can also be used for variant screening, and to help decide variant pathogenicity. DNA was screened by conformation analysis followed by Sanger sequencing. Large deletion/insertions were detected by polymorphism analysis, MLPA and quantitative-PCR. Methylation-specific PCR was used to detect hypermethylation. RNA screening was performed when a DNA pathogenic variant was missing, or to determine effects on splicing.Two hundred and thirteen small coding variants were predicted to affect splicing in 207 patients. Splice donor (sd) variants were nearly twice as frequent as splice acceptor (sa) with the most affected positions being sd + 1 and sa-1. Some missense and nonsense codons altered splicing, while some splice consensus variants did not. Large deletion/insertions can disrupt splicing, but RNA analysis showed that some of these are more complex than indicated by DNA testing. RNA screening found pathogenic variants in 53.8% of samples where DNA analysis did not. RB1 splicing is altered by changes at consensus splice sites, some missense and nonsense codons, deep intronic changes and large deletion/insertions. Common alternatively spliced transcripts may complicate analysis. An effective molecular screening strategy would include RNA analysis to help determine pathogenicity.

An anti-GD2 aptamer-based bifunctional spherical nucleic acid nanoplatform for synergistic therapy targeting MDM2 for retinoblastoma

Retinoblastoma (RB) is a type of pediatric solid tumor in the fundus. The lack of precision therapies combined with the difficulty of delivering small interfering RNA (siRNA) into the eyes means that there is currently no nucleic acid-based therapy for RB in clinical practice. Here, we reported on anti-GD2 and glutathione-responsive spherical nucleic acids (SNAs), loaded with siRNA and the inhibitor NVP-CGM097, which jointly blocked the oncogenic factor n in RB cells (Y79 and WERI-RB-1). The SNAs were formed through the self-assembly of bifunctional cholesterol amphiphiles containing aptamers that specifically targeted GD2-positive RB cells, allowing for the formation of an SNA with a dense DNA shell. The aptamer/siRNA component functioned both as a carrier and a payload, enhancing the specific recognition and delivery of both components and constituting an active agent for MDM2 regulation. Following SNA endocytosis by RB cells, siRNA and NVP-CGM097 were released from the SNA particles by glutathione, which synergistically blocked the MDM2-p53 pathway, increasing p53 protein content and inducing cell apoptosis. This study showed a potent antitumor effect following intravitreal injection of SNAs in Y79 tumor-bearing mice through clinical manifestation and tumor pathological analysis. In hematological analysis and hepatotoxicity assays, SNAs were safer for mice than melphalan, the favored drug for treating RB in clinical practice. Our results illustrated the potential of intravitreally injected SNAs as a precision medicine for treating RB.

Genetic Diagnosis of Retinoblastoma Using Aqueous Humour-Findings from an Extended Cohort

The identification of somatic RB1 variation is crucial to confirm the heritability of retinoblastoma. We and others have previously shown that, when tumour DNA is unavailable, cell-free DNA (cfDNA) derived from aqueous humour (AH) can be used to identify somatic RB1 pathogenic variation. Here we report RB1 pathogenic variant detection, as well as cfDNA concentration in an extended cohort of 75 AH samples from 68 patients. We show cfDNA concentration is highly variable and significantly correlated with the collection point of the AH. Cell-free DNA concentrations above 5 pg/µL enabled the detection of 93% of known or expected RB1 pathogenic variants. In AH samples collected during intravitreal chemotherapy treatment (Tx), the yield of cfDNA above 5 pg/µL and subsequent variant detection was low (≤46%). However, AH collected by an anterior chamber tap after one to three cycles of primary chemotherapy (Dx1+) enabled the detection of 75% of expected pathogenic variants. Further limiting our analysis to Dx1+ samples taken after ≤2 cycles (Dx ≤ 2) provided measurable levels of cfDNA in all cases, and a subsequent variant detection rate of 95%. Early AH sampling is therefore likely to be important in maximising cfDNA concentration and the subsequent detection of somatic RB1 pathogenic variants in retinoblastoma patients undergoing conservative treatment.

Circulating Tumor DNA Posttreatment Measurements and Clinical Correlates in Retinoblastoma

Importance

Plasma measurements of RB1 circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) after completion of treatment may be associated with the development of metastases in patients with retinoblastoma.

Objective

To determine if the absence of previously detectable plasma ctDNA is associated with metastasis-free survival in patients with a minimum of 1 year follow-up after treatment of retinoblastoma.

Design, Setting, and Participants

This cohort study was conducted from June 2019 to September 2023. Patients with retinoblastoma who had measurable ctDNA levels at diagnosis and had repeated ctDNA measurements after ocular treatment (enucleation or intra-arterial chemotherapy) with a minimum of 1 year of follow-up (mean [SD], 28.2 [10.3] months) were included in the study. Patients were recruited from a single-center, tertiary cancer hospital.

Exposure

Memorial Sloan Kettering's New York State-approved gene test, which interrogates 129 known cancer genes (called ACCESS), was performed on plasma samples before and after ocular treatments. All exons of the RB1 gene are included in the test and listed as ctDNA in this article.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Plasma ctDNA level before treatment, after completion of ocular treatment, and development or absence of metastases.

Results

A total of 24 patients (mean [SD] age, 20.7 [17.1] months; 15 female [62.5%]) were included in the study. None of the 23 patients who had a measurable ctDNA level and then no detectable ctDNA level after completion of ocular treatment developed metastases with a minimum of 1 year of follow-up. One patient had persistent measurable ctDNA after initial treatment and developed metastases.

Conclusion and Relevance

Patients with retinoblastoma who had a measurable ctDNA level at diagnosis did not develop metastases if the plasma ctDNA level became unrecordable after ocular treatment; 1 patient who had persistent measurable ctDNA after treatment did develop metastasis.

The Potential of Aqueous Humor Sampling in Diagnosis, Prognosis, and Treatment of Retinoblastoma

Retinoblastoma (RB) is a rare malignant tumor that arises in the developing retina in one or both eyes of children. Pathogenic variants of the RB1 tumor suppressor gene drive the majority of germline and sporadic RB tumors. Considering the risk of tumor spread, the biopsy of RB tumor tissue is contraindicated. Advancement of chemotherapy has led to preservation of more eye globes. However, this has reduced access to tumor material from enucleation specimens. Recently, liquid biopsy of aqueous humor (AH) has advanced the RB tumor- or eye-specific genetic analysis. In particular, nucleic acid analysis of AH demonstrates the genomic copy number profiles and RB1 pathogenic variants akin to that of enucleated RB eye tissue. This advance reduces the previous limitation that genetic assessment of the primary tumor could be done only after enucleation of the eye. Additionally, nucleic acid evaluation of AH allows the exploration of the genomic landscape of RB tumors at diagnosis and during and after treatment. This review explores how AH sampling and AH nucleic acid analysis in RB patients assist in diagnosis, prognosis, and comprehending the pathophysiology of RB, which will ultimately benefit individualized treatment decisions to carefully manage this ocular cancer in children.

Special Issue of Cancers: "Retinoblastoma: Current Challenges and Promising New Approaches"

Despite being a rare pediatric cancer arising in the developing retina from red/green cone precursors, retinoblastoma is the most common eye cancer worldwide and occupies an emblematic position in oncology and human genetics for the following reasons:-Historically, the discovery of RB1 and the recessive nature of its mutations led to the prototypic description of anti-oncogenes or tumor suppressor genes [...].

A multicenter analysis of nucleic acid quantification using aqueous humor liquid biopsy in retinoblastoma – Implications for clinical testing

Purpose

Retinoblastoma (RB) is most often diagnosed with clinical features and not diagnosed with tumor biopsy. This study describes tumor-derived analyte concentrations from aqueous humor (AH) liquid biopsy and its use in clinical assays.

Design

Case series study.

Participants

Sixty-two RB eyes from 55 children and 14 control eyes from 12 children from 4 medical centers.

Methods

This study included 128 RB AH samples including: diagnostic (DX) samples, samples from eyes undergoing treatment (TX), samples after completing treatment (END), and during bevacizumab injection for radiation therapy after completing RB treatment (BEV). Fourteen-control AH were analyzed for unprocessed analytes (double-stranded DNA [dsDNA], single-stranded DNA [ssDNA], micro-RNA [miRNA], RNA, and protein) with Qubit fluorescence assays. Double-stranded DNA from 2 RB AH samples underwent low-pass whole-genome sequencing to detect somatic copy number alterations. Logistic regression was used to predict disease burden given analyte concentrations.

Main Outcome Measures

Unprocessed analyte (dsDNA, ssDNA, miRNA, RNA and protein) concentrations.

Results

Results revealed dsDNA, ssDNA, miRNA, and proteins, but not RNA, were quantifiable in most samples (up to 98%) with Qubit fluorescence assays. Median dsDNA concentration was significantly higher in DX (3.08 ng/μl) compared to TX (0.18 ng/μl; P < 0.0001) at an order of 17 times greater and 20 times greater than END samples (0.15 ng/μl; P = 0.001). Using logistic regression, nucleic acid concentrations were useful in predicting higher versus lower RB disease burden. Retinoblastoma somatic copy number alterations were identified in a TX, but not in a BEV sample, indicating the correlation with RB activity.

Conclusions

Aqueous humor liquid biopsy in RB is a high-yield source of dsDNA, ssDNA, miRNA, and protein. Diagnostic samples are most useful for RB 1 gene mutational analyses. Genomic analysis may be more informative of tumor activity status than quantification alone and can be performed even with smaller analyte concentrations obtained from TX samples.

Financial Disclosures

Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found after the references.

Retinoblastoma: From genes to patient care

Retinoblastoma is the most common paediatric neoplasm of the retina, and one of the earliest model of cancer genetics since the identification of the master tumour suppressor gene RB1. Tumorigenesis has been shown to be driven by pathogenic variants of the RB1 locus, but also genomic and epigenomic alterations outside the locus. The increasing knowledge on this "mutational landscape" is used in current practice for precise genetic testing and counselling. Novel methods provide access to pre-therapeutic tumour DNA, by isolating cell-free DNA from aqueous humour or plasma. This is expected to facilitate assessment of the constitutional status of RB1, to provide an early risk stratification using molecular prognostic markers, to follow the response to the treatment in longitudinal studies, and to predict the response to targeted therapies. The aim of this review is to show how molecular genetics of retinoblastoma drives diagnosis, treatment, monitoring of the disease and surveillance of the patients and relatives. We first recap the current knowledge on retinoblastoma genetics and its use in every-day practice. We then focus on retinoblastoma subgrouping at the era of molecular biology, and the expected input of cell-free DNA in the field.

Characterizing DNA methylation signatures of retinoblastoma using aqueous humor liquid biopsy

Retinoblastoma (RB) is a cancer that forms in the developing retina of babies and toddlers. The goal of therapy is to cure the tumor, save the eye and maximize vision. However, it is difficult to predict which eyes are likely to respond to therapy. Predictive molecular biomarkers are needed to guide prognosis and optimize treatment decisions. Direct tumor biopsy is not an option for this cancer; however, the aqueous humor (AH) is an alternate source of tumor-derived cell-free DNA (cfDNA). Here we show that DNA methylation profiling of the AH is a valid method to identify the methylation status of RB tumors. We identify 294 genes directly regulated by methylation that are implicated in p53 tumor suppressor (RB1, p53, p21, and p16) and oncogenic (E2F) pathways. Finally, we use AH to characterize molecular subtypes that can potentially be used to predict the likelihood of treatment success for retinoblastoma patients.

Liquid biopsy in Retinoblastoma: A review

PURPOSE

Retinoblastoma (RB) is the most common intraocular malignancy in children. The diagnosis of RB is mainly based on clinical features and imaging characteristics. Prognosis is based on stage of disease and response to treatment. In salvaged globes, direct tumor biopsy for genetic analysis and prognostication is an absolute contraindication at this point of time for the fear of extraocular tumor spread. Currently, there is a search for surrogate markers to allow accurate diagnosis and for prognostication, to predict the chances of globe salvage in RB. Therefore, biofluids such as plasma or aqueous humor have been studied to detect circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) or cell-free DNA (cfDNA), respectively, to allow for treatment decision making, monitoring treatment response, and prognostic counselling.

METHODS

A search of electronic databases (PubMed, Google Scholar and MEDLINE) of all articles on liquid biopsy in retinoblastoma published in English was performed. The keywords used for the search included "retinoblastoma", "liquid biopsy", "aqueous humor" "circulating tumor cells", "cell-free DNA", "cfDNA", "circulating tumor DNA", "ctDNA", "tumor fraction", "RB1 mutation" and "SNCA". Additionally, historic articles on the advent of liquid biopsy in medicine were also reviewed. Pertinent cross-references from the studies were reviewed. Retrospective interventional and observational case series, observational case series, prospective cohort studies, reviews, case reports, surgical techniques, invited commentary and letters were included.

RESULTS

A total of 40 relevant articles were selected. Biomarkers in aqueous humor, serum and cerebrospinal fluid and their clinical applications are discussed.

CONCLUSION

Harvesting aqueous humor from eyes with retinoblastoma has been found safe and superior to blood for the detection of chromosomal changes. cfDNA from aqueous can be a surrogate marker to detect somatic copy number alterations and other genetic alterations in RB. ctDNA in plasma also has potential to help in diagnosis and prognosis of RB. Liquid biopsy in RB is an emerging topic, which could pave way for a better understanding of mechanisms for treatment response, resistance and recurrence in RB as well as possibly provide specific therapeutic targets to improve globe salvage.

Monitoring Retinoblastoma by Machine Learning of Aqueous Humor Metabolic Fingerprinting

The most common intraocular pediatric malignancy, retinoblastoma (RB), accounts for ≈10% of cancer in children. Efficient monitoring can enhance living quality of patients and 5-year survival ratio of RB up to 95%. However, RB monitoring is still insufficient in regions with limited resources and the mortality may even reach over 70% in such areas. Here, an RB monitoring platform by machine learning of aqueous humor metabolic fingerprinting (AH-MF) is developed, using nanoparticle enhanced laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (LDI MS). The direct AH-MF of RB free of sample pre-treatment is recorded, with both high reproducibility (coefficient of variation < 10%) and sensitivity (low to 0.3 pmol) at sample volume down to 40 nL only. Further, early and advanced RB patients with area-under-the-curve over 0.9 and accuracy over 80% are differentiated, through machine learning of AH-MF. Finally, a metabolic biomarker panel of 7 metabolites through accurate MS and tandem MS (MS/MS) with pathway analysis to monitor RB is identified. This work can contribute to advanced metabolic analysis of eye diseases including but not limited to RB and screening of new potential metabolic targets toward therapeutic intervention.