3D Printing and Bioprinting to Model Bone Cancer: The Role of Materials and Nanoscale Cues in Directing Cell Behavior

Borate bioactive glass enhances 3D bioprinting precision and biocompatibility on a sodium alginate platform via Ca2+ controlled self-solidification

Sodium alginate (SA) has gained widespread acclaim as a carrier medium for three-dimensional (3D) bioprinting of cells and a diverse array of bioactive substances, attributed to its remarkable biocompatibility and affordability. The conventional approach for fabricating alginate-based tissue engineering constructs entails a post-treatment phase employing a calcium ion solution. However, this method proves ineffectual in addressing the predicament of low precision during the 3D printing procedure and is unable to prevent issues such as non-uniform alginate gelation and substantial distortions. In this study, we introduced borate bioactive glass (BBG) into the SA matrix, capitalizing on the calcium ions released from the degradation of BBG to incite the cross-linking reaction within SA, resulting in the formation of BBG-SA hydrogels. Building upon this fundamental concept, it unveiled that BBG-SA hydrogels greatly enhance the precision of SA in extrusion-based 3D printing and significantly reduce volumetric contraction shrinkage post-printing, while also displaying certain adhesive properties and electrical conductivity. Furthermore, in vitro cellular experiments have unequivocally established the excellent biocompatibility of BBG-SA hydrogel and its capacity to actively stimulate osteogenic differentiation. Consequently, BBG-SA hydrogel emerges as a promising platform for 3D bioprinting, laying the foundation for the development of flexible, biocompatible electronic devices.

3D modular bioceramic scaffolds for the investigation of the interaction between osteosarcoma cells and MSCs

Recent advances in bone tissue engineering have shown promise for bone repair post osteosarcoma excision. However, conflicting research on mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) has raised concerns about their potential to either promote or inhibit tumor cell proliferation. It is necessary to thoroughly understand the interactions between MSCs and tumor cells. Most previous studies only focused on the interactions between cells within the tumor tissues. It has been challenging to develop an in vitro model of osteosarcoma excision sites replicating the complexity of the bone microenvironment and cell distribution. In this work, we designed and fabricated modular bioceramic scaffolds to assemble into a co-culture model. Because of the bone-like composition and mechanical property, tricalcium phosphate bioceramic could mimic the bone microenvironment and recapitulate the cell-extracellular matrix interaction. Moreover, the properties for easy assembly enabled the modular units to mimic the spatial distribution of cells in the osteosarcoma excision site. Under this co-culture model, MSCs showed a noticeable tumor-stimulating effect with a potential risk of tumor recurrence. In addition, tumor cells also could inhibit the osteogenic ability of MSCs. To undermine the stimulating effects of MSCs on tumor cells, we present the methods of pre-differentiated MSCs, which had lower expression of IL-8 and higher expression of osteogenic proteins. Both in vitro and in vivo studies confirm that pre-differentiated MSCs could maintain high osteogenic capacity without promoting tumor growth, offering a promising approach for MSCs' application in bone regeneration. Overall, 3D modular scaffolds provide a valuable tool for constructing hard tissue in vitro models. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Bone tissue engineering using mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) and biomaterials has shown promise for bone repair post osteosarcoma excision. However, conflicting researches on MSCs have raised concerns about their potential to either promote or inhibit tumor cell proliferation. It remains challenges to develop in vitro models to investigate cell interactions, especially of osteosarcoma with high hardness and special composition of bone tissue. In this work, modular bioceramic scaffolds were fabricated and assembled to co-culture models. The interactions between MSCs and MG-63 were manifested as tumor-stimulating and osteogenesis-inhibiting, which means potential risk of tumor recurrence. To undermine the stimulating effect, pre-differentiation method was proposed to maintain high osteogenic capacity without tumor-stimulating, offering a promising approach for MSCs' application in bone regeneration.

In vivo evaluation of bioactivity of alginate/chitosan based osteoplastic nanocomposites loaded with inorganic nanoparticles

The influence of two nanostructured osteoplastic materials with different compositions: i) alginate (Alg) matrix, loaded with Zn2+ ions and nanostructured hydroxyapatite (HA) - S1/HA-Zn, and ii) chitosan (CS) matrix loaded with brushite nanoparticles (NPs, dicalcium phosphate dihydrate, DCPD) - S2/DCPD on the healing of an experimental femoral diaphysis defect was investigated. The structure of cellular elements and the lacunar tubular system of the regenerated bone tissue were studied by electron microscopy. Osteogenic cells on the surface and inside S1/HA-Zn formed bone tissue. On the 30th day, the latter had a reticulofibrous and later lamellar structure. On the 30th day, the S2/DCPD biomaterial was integrated mainly into connective tissue and, starting from the 90th day, into the bone tissue, which was formed only on its outer surface. Thus, it has been proven that both biomaterials contribute to the healing of bone wounds. The regenerative potential of the new bone tissue formation of S1/HA-Zn prevails over that of S2/DCPD.

Printing of 3D biomimetic structures for the study of bone metastasis: A review

Bone metastasis primarily occurs when breast, prostate, or lung cancers disseminate tumoral cells into bone tissue, leading to a range of complications in skeletal tissues and, in severe cases, paralysis resulting from spinal cord compression. Unfortunately, our understanding of pathophysiological mechanisms is incomplete and the translation of bone metastasis research into the clinic has been slow, mainly due to the lack of credible ex vivo and in vivo models to study the disease progression. Development of reliable and rational models to study how tumor cells become circulating cells and then invade and sequentially colonize the bone are in great need. Advances in tissue engineering technologies offers reliable 3D tissue alternatives which answer relevant research questions towards the understanding of cancer evolution and key functional properties of metastasis progression as well as prognosis of therapeutic approach. Here we performed an overview of cellular mechanisms involved in bone metastasis including a short summary of normal bone physiology and metastasis initiation and progression. Also, we comprehensively summarized current advances and methodologies in fabrication of reliable bone tumor models based on state-of-the-art printing technologies which recapitulate structural and biological features of native tissue. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: This review provides a comprehensive summary of the collective findings in relation to various printed bone metastasis models utilized for investigating specific bone metastasis diseases, related characteristic functions and chemotherapeutic drug screening. These tumoral models are comprehensively evaluated and compared, in terms of their ability to recapitulate physiological metastasis microenvironment. Various biomaterials (natural and synthetic polymers and ceramic based substrates) and printing strategies and design architecture of models used for printing of 3D bone metastasis models are discussed here. This review clearly out-lines current challenges and prospects for 3D printing technologies in bone metastasis research by focusing on the required perspective models for clinical application of these technologies in chemotherapeutic drug screening.

Advantages and limitations of using cell viability assays for 3D bioprinted constructs

Bioprinting shows promise for bioengineered scaffolds and three-dimensional (3D) disease models, but assessing the viability of embedded cells is challenging. Conventional assays are limited by the technical problems that derive from using multi-layered bioink matrices dispersing cells in three dimensions. In this study, we tested bioprinted osteogenic bioinks as a model system. Alginate- or gelatin-based bioinks were loaded with/without ceramic microparticles and osteogenic cells (bone tumor cells, with or without normal bone cells). Despite demonstrating 80%-90% viability through manual counting and live/dead staining, this was time-consuming and operator-dependent. Moreover, for the alginate-bioprinted scaffold, cell spheroids could not be distinguished from single cells. The indirect assay (alamarBlue), was faster but less accurate than live/dead staining due to dependence on hydrogel permeability. Automated confocal microscope acquisition and cell counting of live/dead staining was more reproducible, reliable, faster, efficient, and avoided overestimates compared to manual cell counting by optical microscopy. Finally, for 1.2 mm thick 3D bioprints, dual-photon confocal scanning with vital staining greatly improved the precision of the evaluation of cell distribution and viability and cell-cell interactions through thez-axis. In summary, automated confocal microscopy and cell counting provided superior accuracy for the assessment of cell viability and interactions in 3D bioprinted models compared to most commonly and currently used techniques.

Enhanced Biomimetics of Three-Dimensional Osteosarcoma Models: A Scoping Review

This scoping review evaluated 3D osteosarcoma (OS) models' biomimicry, examining their ability to mimic the tumour microenvironment (TME) and their drug sensitivity. Adhering to PRISMA-ScR guidelines, the systematic search revealed 293 studies, with 70 selected for final analysis. Overall, 64% of 3D OS models were scaffold-based, compared to self-generated spheroid models. Scaffolds generated using native matrix were most common (42%) with collagen I/hydroxyapatite predominating. Both scaffold-based and scaffold-free models were used equally for drug screening. The sensitivity of cancer cells in 3D was reported to be lower than that of cells in 2D in ~90% of the drug screening studies. This correlates with the observed upregulation of drug resistance. OS cells cultured in extracellular matrix (ECM)-mimetic scaffolds and native biomaterials were more resistant than cells in 2D. Co-cultures of OS and stromal cells in 3D models enhanced osteogenic differentiation, ECM remodelling, mineralisation, and angiogenesis, suggesting that tumour-stroma crosstalk promotes disease progression. Seven studies demonstrated selective toxicity of chemotherapeutics towards OS cells while sparing stromal cells, providing useful evidence for developing biomimetic tumour-stroma models to test selective drug toxicity. In conclusion, this review highlights the need to enhance biomimicry in 3D OS models for TME recapitulation, especially in testing novel therapeutics. Future research should explore innovative 3D biomimetic models, biomaterials, and advancements in personalised medicine.

Premetastatic Niche Mimicking Bone-On-A-Chip: A Microfluidic Platform to Study Bone Metastasis in Cancer Patients

Primary cancer modulates the bone microenvironment to sow the seeds of dormancy and metastasis in tumor cells, leading to multiple organ metastasis and death. In this study, 3D printing and bone-on-a-chip (BOC) are combined to develop a BOC platform that mimics the pre-metastatic niches (PMNs) and facilitates elucidation of the interactions between bone-resident cells and metastatic tumor cells under the influence of primary cancer. Photocrosslinkable gelatin methacrylate (GelMA) is used as a 3D culturing hydrogel to encapsulate cells, and circulate tumor culture medium (CM) adjacent to the hydrogel to verify the critical role of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) and osteoclasts (RAW264.7s). Three niches: the dormancy niche, the perivascular niche, and the "vicious cycle" niche, are devised to recapitulate bone metastasis in one chip with high cell viability and excellent nutrient exchange. With respect to tumor dormancy and reactivation, the invadopodia formation of A549 lung cancer cells in communication with MSCs and RAW264.7 via the cortactin pathway is researched. As a proof of concept, the functionality and practicality of the platform are demonstrated by analyzing the invadopodia formation and the influence of various cells, and the establishment of the dynamic niches paves the way to understanding PMN formation and related drug discovery.

Incorporation/Enrichment of 3D Bioprinted Constructs by Biomimetic Nanoparticles: Tuning Printability and Cell Behavior in Bone Models

Reproducing in vitro a model of the bone microenvironment is a current need. Preclinical in vitro screening, drug discovery, as well as pathophysiology studies may benefit from in vitro three-dimensional (3D) bone models, which permit high-throughput screening, low costs, and high reproducibility, overcoming the limitations of the conventional two-dimensional cell cultures. In order to obtain these models, 3D bioprinting offers new perspectives by allowing a combination of advanced techniques and inks. In this context, we propose the use of hydroxyapatite nanoparticles, assimilated to the mineral component of bone, as a route to tune the printability and the characteristics of the scaffold and to guide cell behavior. To this aim, both stoichiometric and Sr-substituted hydroxyapatite nanocrystals are used, so as to obtain different particle shapes and solubility. Our findings show that the nanoparticles have the desired shape and composition and that they can be embedded in the inks without loss of cell viability. Both Sr-containing and stoichiometric hydroxyapatite crystals permit enhancing the printing fidelity of the scaffolds in a particle-dependent fashion and control the swelling behavior and ion release of the scaffolds. Once Saos-2 cells are encapsulated in the scaffolds, high cell viability is detected until late time points, with a good cellular distribution throughout the material. We also show that even minor modifications in the hydroxyapatite particle characteristics result in a significantly different behavior of the scaffolds. This indicates that the use of calcium phosphate nanocrystals and structural ion-substitution is a promising approach to tune the behavior of 3D bioprinted constructs.

Making In Vitro Tumor Models Whole Again

As a reductionist approach, patient-derived in vitro tumor models are inherently still too simplistic for personalized drug testing as they do not capture many characteristics of the tumor microenvironment (TME), such as tumor architecture and stromal heterogeneity. This is especially problematic for assessing stromal-targeting drugs such as immunotherapies in which the density and distribution of immune and other stromal cells determine drug efficacy. On the other end, in vivo models are typically costly, low-throughput, and time-consuming to establish. Ex vivo patient-derived tumor explant (PDE) cultures involve the culture of resected tumor fragments that potentially retain the intact  TME of the original tumor. Although developed decades ago, PDE cultures have not been widely adopted likely because of their low-throughput and poor long-term viability. However, with growing recognition of the importance of patient-specific TME in mediating drug response, especially in the field of immune-oncology, there is an urgent need to resurrect these holistic cultures. In this Review, the key limitations of patient-derived tumor explant cultures are outlined and technologies that have been developed or could be employed to address these limitations are discussed. Engineered holistic tumor explant cultures may truly realize the concept of personalized medicine for cancer patients.

In vitro models of breast cancer bone metastasis: analyzing drug resistance through the lens of the microenvironment

Even though breast cancers usually have a good outcome compared to other tumors, the cancer can progress and create metastases in different parts of the organism, the bone being a predilection locus. These metastases are usually the cause of death, as they are mostly resistant to treatments. This resistance can be caused by intrinsic properties of the tumor, such as its heterogeneity, but it can also be due to the protective role of the microenvironment. By activating signaling pathways protecting cancer cells when exposed to chemotherapy, contributing to their ability to reach dormancy, or even reducing the amount of drug able to reach the metastases, among other mechanisms, the specificities of the bone tissue are being investigated as important players of drug resistance. To this date, most mechanisms of this resistance are yet to be discovered, and many researchers are implementing in vitro models to study the interaction between the tumor cells and their microenvironment. Here, we will review what is known about breast cancer drug resistance in bone metastasis due to the microenvironment and we will use those observations to highlight which features in vitro models should include to properly recapitulate these biological aspects in vitro. We will also detail which elements advanced in vitro models should implement in order to better recapitulate in vivo physiopathology and drug resistance.

Biomaterial-Assisted 3D In Vitro Tumor Models: From Organoid towards Cancer Tissue Engineering Approaches

Cancers are a leading cause of death around the world, accounting for nearly 10 million deaths yearly [...].

A bone-based 3D scaffold as an in-vitro model of microenvironment–DLBCL lymphoma cell interaction

About 30% of patients with diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL) relapse or exhibit refractory disease (r/r DLBCL) after first-line immunochemotherapy. Bone marrow (BM) involvement confers a dismal prognosis at diagnosis, likely due to the interaction between neoplastic cells and a complex tumor microenvironment (TME). Therefore, we developed a 3D in-vitro model from human decellularized femoral bone fragments aiming to study the role of mesenchymal stromal cells (MSC) and the extracellular matrix (ECM) in the adaptation, growth, and drug resistance of DLBCL lymphoma cells. The 3D spatial configuration of the model was studied by histological analysis and confocal and multiphoton microscopy which allowed the 3D digital reproduction of the structure. We proved that MSC adapt and expand in the 3D scaffold generating niches in which also other cell types may grow. DLBCL cell lines adhered and grew in the 3D scaffold, both in the presence and absence of MSC, suggesting an active ECM–lymphocyte interaction. We found that the germinal center B-cell (GCB)-derived OCI-LY18 cells were more resistant to doxorubicin-induced apoptosis when growing in the decellularized 3D bone scaffold compared to 2D cultures (49.9% +/- 7.7% Annexin V⁺ cells in 2D condition compared to 30.7% + 9.2% Annexin V⁺ 3D adherent cells in the ECM model), thus suggesting a protective role of ECM. The coexistence of MSC in the 3D scaffold did not significantly affect doxorubicin-induced apoptosis of adherent OCI-LY18 cells (27.6% +/- 7.3% Annexin V⁺ 3D adherent cells in the ECM/MSC model after doxorubicin treatment). On the contrary, ECM did not protect the activated B-cell (ABC)-derived NU-DUL-1 lymphoma cell line from doxorubicin-induced apoptosis but protection was observed when MSC were growing in the bone scaffold (40.6% +/- 5.7% vs. 62.1% +/- 5.3% Annexin V⁺ 3D adherent cells vs. 2D condition). These data suggest that the interaction of lymphoma cells with the microenvironment may differ according to the DLBCL subtype and that 2D systems may fail to uncover this behavior. The 3D model we proposed may be improved with other cell types or translated to the study of other pathologies with the final goal to provide a tool for patient-specific treatment development.

An Osteosarcoma Model by 3D Printed Polyurethane Scaffold and In Vitro Generated Bone Extracellular Matrix

Simple Summary

Development of new therapeutics to treat osteosarcoma is fundamental to decreasing its current health impact. 3D in vitro models are gaining tremendous momentum as, compared to traditional 2D in vitro models and in vivo models, can speed up new treatment discovery and provide clarification of the pathology development, by ultimately offering a reproducible and biomimetic tool. However, engineering a 3D osteosarcoma in vitro model is challenging, since the reliability of the models strictly depends on their ability to correctly mimic the physical, mechanical, and biological properties of the pathological tissue to be replicated. Here, we designed 3D printed polyurethane scaffolds enriched by in vitro pre-generated bone extracellular matrix, synthesized by osteo-differentiated human mesenchymal stromal cells, to replicate in vitro an osteosarcoma model, which can be potentially used to study tumor progression and to assess new treatments.

Abstract

Osteosarcoma is a primary bone tumor characterized by a dismal prognosis, especially in the case of recurrent disease or metastases. Therefore, tools to understand in-depth osteosarcoma progression and ultimately develop new therapeutics are urgently required. 3D in vitro models can provide an optimal option, as they are highly reproducible, yet sufficiently complex, thus reliable alternatives to 2D in vitro and in vivo models. Here, we describe 3D in vitro osteosarcoma models prepared by printing polyurethane (PU) by fused deposition modeling, further enriched with human mesenchymal stromal cell (hMSC)-secreted biomolecules. We printed scaffolds with different morphologies by changing their design (i.e., the distance between printed filaments and printed patterns) to obtain different pore geometry, size, and distribution. The printed PU scaffolds were stable during in vitro cultures, showed adequate porosity (55–67%) and tunable mechanical properties (Young’s modulus ranging in 0.5–4.0 MPa), and resulted in cytocompatible. We developed the in vitro model by seeding SAOS-2 cells on the optimal PU scaffold (i.e., 0.7 mm inter-filament distance, 60° pattern), by testing different pre-conditioning factors: none, undifferentiated hMSC-secreted, and osteo-differentiated hMSC-secreted extracellular matrix (ECM), which were obtained by cell lysis before SAOS-2 seeding. Scaffolds pre-cultured with osteo-differentiated hMSCs, subsequently lysed, and seeded with SAOS-2 cells showed optimal colonization, thus disclosing a suitable biomimetic microenvironment for osteosarcoma cells, which can be useful both in tumor biology study and, possibly, treatment.

Hydrogel-Based Fiber Biofabrication Techniques for Skeletal Muscle Tissue Engineering

The functional capabilities of skeletal muscle are strongly correlated with its well-arranged microstructure, consisting of parallelly aligned myotubes. In case of extensive muscle loss, the endogenous regenerative capacity is hindered by scar tissue formation, which compromises the native muscle structure, ultimately leading to severe functional impairment. To address such an issue, skeletal muscle tissue engineering (SMTE) attempts to fabricate in vitro bioartificial muscle tissue constructs to assist and accelerate the regeneration process. Due to its dynamic nature, SMTE strategies must employ suitable biomaterials (combined with muscle progenitors) and proper 3D architectures. In light of this, 3D fiber-based strategies are gaining increasing interest for the generation of hydrogel microfibers as advanced skeletal muscle constructs. Indeed, hydrogels possess exceptional biomimetic properties, while the fiber-shaped morphology allows for the creation of geometrical cues to guarantee proper myoblast alignment. In this review, we summarize commonly used hydrogels in SMTE and their main properties, and we discuss the first efforts to engineer hydrogels to guide myoblast anisotropic orientation. Then, we focus on presenting the main hydrogel fiber-based techniques for SMTE, including molding, electrospinning, 3D bioprinting, extrusion, and microfluidic spinning. Furthermore, we describe the effect of external stimulation (i.e., mechanical and electrical) on such constructs and the application of hydrogel fiber-based methods on recapitulating complex skeletal muscle tissue interfaces. Finally, we discuss the future developments in the application of hydrogel microfibers for SMTE.