Preoperative Mutational Analysis of Circulating Tumor Cells (CTCs) and Plasma-cfDNA Provides Complementary Information for Early Prediction of Relapse: A Pilot Study in Early-Stage Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer

Direct comparison of an ultrasensitive real-time PCR assay with droplet digital PCR for the detection of PIK3CA hotspot mutations in primary tumors, plasma cell-free DNA and paired CTC-derived gDNAs

Introduction

Detection of PIK3CA mutations in primary tumors and liquid biopsy samples is of increasing importance for treatment decisions and therapy resistance in many types of cancer. The aim of the present study was to directly compare the efficacy of a relatively inexpensive ultrasensitive real-time PCR with the well-established and highly sensitive technology of ddPCR for the detection of the three most common hotspot mutations of PIK3CA, in exons 9 and 20, that are all of clinical importance in various types of cancer.

Patients and methods

We analyzed 42 gDNAs from primary tumors (FFPEs), 29 plasma-cfDNA samples, and 29 paired CTC-derived gDNAs, all from patients with ER+ metastatic breast cancer, and plasma from 10 healthy donors. The same blood draws were used for CTC isolation using EpCAM beads for positive immunomagnetic enrichment. All FFPEs and plasma-cfDNA samples were analyzed in parallel for PIK3CA mutations by ultrasensitive real-time PCR assay and droplet digital PCR.

Results

In gDNAs from FFPEs, using ultrasensitive real-time PCR, the p.E545K mutation was detected in 22/42(52.4%), and the p.E542K and p.H1047R mutations were detected in 14/42(33.3%) and 16/42(38.1%), respectively. Using ddPCR, the p.E545K mutation was detected in 22/42(52.4%), p.E542K in 17/42(40.5%), and p.H1047R in 19/42(45.2%) samples, revealing a concordance between the two methodologies of 81%, 78.6% and 78.6% for each mutation respectively. In plasma-cfDNA, using ultrasensitive real-time PCR, the p.E545K mutation was detected in 11/29(38%) and both p.E542K and p.H1047R mutations in 2/29(6.9%).In the same plasma-cfDNA samples using ddPCR, p.E545K was detected in 1/29(3.5%), p.E542K in 2/29(6.9%), and p.H1047R in 3/29(10.5%) samples, revealing a concordance of 65.5%,100% and 93.1% for each mutation respectively. In paired CTC-derived gDNAs p.E545K was detected in 11/29(38%), p.E542K in 3/29(10.3%), and p.H1047R in 7/29(24.1%) samples.

Conclusions

This low-cost, high-throughput and ultrasensitive real-time PCR assay provides accurate and specific detection of PIK3CA hotspot mutations in liquid biopsy samples and gives similar results to ddPCR. This assay can be performed in labs where digital PCR instrumentation is not available. In CTC-derived gDNA and paired plasma-cfDNA, PIK3CA mutations detected were not identical, revealing that CTC and plasma-cfDNA give complementary information.

Mutational differences between primary cancer tissue and circulating tumor cells in early-stage non-small cell lung cancer

Background

Early-stage non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) has a high recurrence rate despite proper management, including curative surgery. Circulating tumor cells (CTCs) are believed to play a key role in the distant metastasis of lung cancer. Immunofluorescence imaging studies of CTCs have revealed that they are associated with the prognosis of NSCLC. However, the mutational profiling of CTCs from early-stage NSCLC has not been extensively explored. We hypothesized that CTCs could be detected by mutational analysis using panel sequencing and would have distinct mutations associated with distant metastasis compared to those of primary cancer tissue in early-stage NSCLC. Thus, this study examined the DNA from CTCs using targeted panel sequencing to identify mutations and compared them with mutations found in primary cancer tissue in patients with resectable early-stage NSCLC.

Methods

Overall, 45 patients with resectable NSCLC were prospectively enrolled from September to December 2023. Matched whole blood samples and primary cancer tissues were collected during curative surgery. Then, 405-gene targeted panel sequencing was performed on DNA from primary cancer tissues and CTCs.

Results

In this study, 37 patients (82%) had adenocarcinoma, and 30 (67%) were classified as having pathologic stage 1 disease. Mutated genes were detected in all (100%) and 31 patients (69%) for primary cancer tissue and CTCs from panel sequencing, respectively. The partial concordance rate of mutations between primary cancer tissue and CTCs was 17.8%, with the top 10 mutated genes differing significantly. Among primary cancer tissue samples, mutated genes differed by stage and histologic type; these findings were not observed in CTCs. CTCs predominantly displayed mutations in tumor suppressor genes, whereas primary cancer tissues exhibited mutations in both oncogenes and tumor suppressor genes.

Conclusions

CTCs exhibited unique mutations, showing low concordance with mutations found in primary cancer tissue. CTCs may possess specific mutations independent from those of primary cancer tissue in early-stage NSCLC.

Exploring the potential of multiomics liquid biopsy testing in the clinical setting of lung cancer

The transformative role of artificial intelligence (AI) and multiomics could enhance the diagnostic and prognostic capabilities of liquid biopsy (LB) for lung cancer (LC). Despite advances, the transition from tissue biopsies to more sophisticated, non-invasive methods like LB has been impeded by challenges such as the heterogeneity of biomarkers and the low concentration of tumour-related analytes. The advent of multiomics - enabled by deep learning algorithms - offers a solution by allowing the simultaneous analysis of various analytes across multiple biological fluids, presenting a paradigm shift in cancer diagnostics. Through multi-marker, multi-analyte and multi-source approaches, this review showcases how AI and multiomics are identifying clinically valuable biomarker combinations that correlate with patients' health statuses. However, the path towards clinical implementation is fraught with challenges, including study reproducibility and lack of methodological standardization, thus necessitating urgent solutions to solve these common issues.

Comprehensive liquid biopsy analysis for monitoring NSCLC patients under second-line osimertinib treatment

Background

The heterogeneous and complex genetic landscape of NSCLC impacts the clinical outcomes of patients who will eventually develop resistance to osimertinib. Liquid biopsy (LB) analysis as a minimally invasive approach is a key step to efficiently identify resistance mechanisms and adjust to proper subsequent treatments.

Materials and methods

In the present study, we combined plasma-cfDNA and CTC analysis from 30 NSCLC patients in samples collected before treatment and at the progression of disease (PD). We detected molecular alterations at the DNA mutation (EGFR, PIK3CA, KRAS G12C, BRAF V600E), DNA methylation (RASSF1A, BRMS1, FOXA1, SLFN1, SHISA3, RARβ,, WIF-1, RASSF10 and APC), gene expression (CK-19, CK-18, CK-8, AXL, TWIST-1, PD-L1, PIM-1, Vimentin, ALDH-1, and B2M) and chromosomal level (HER2 and MET amplification) as possible resistance mechanisms and druggable targets. We also studied the expression of PD-L1 in single CTCs using immunofluorescence.

Results

In some cases, T790M resistance EGFR mutation was detected at baseline in CTCs but not in the corresponding plasma cfDNA. PIK3CA mutations were detected only in plasma-cfDNA but not in corresponding CTCs. KRAS G12C and BRAF V600E mutations were not detected in the samples analyzed. MET amplification was detected in the CTCs of two patients before treatment whereas HER2 amplification was detected in the CTCs of three patients at baseline and in one patient at PD. DNA methylation analysis revealed low concordance between CTCs and cfDNA, indicating the complementary information obtained through parallel LB analysis. Results from gene expression analysis indicated high rates of vimentin-positive CTCs detected at all time points during osimertinib. Moreover, there was an increased number of NSCLC patients at PD harboring CTCs positive in PD-L1. AXL and PIM-1 expression detected in CTCs during treatment suggesting new possible therapeutic strategies.

Discussion

Our results reveal that comprehensive liquid biopsy analysis can efficiently represent the heterogeneous molecular landscape and provide prominent information on subsequent treatments for NSCLC patients at PD since druggable molecular alterations were detected in CTCs.

Detection of Circulating Tumor Cells and EGFR Mutation in Pulmonary Vein and Arterial Blood of Lung Cancer Patients Using a Newly Developed Immunocytology-Based Platform

BACKGROUND

Epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) tyrosine kinase inhibitors are powerful molecular targeted therapeutic agents for lung cancer. We recently developed an original immunocytology and glass slide-based circulating tumor cell (CTC) detection platform for both CTC enumeration and EGFR mutation analysis with DNA extracted from CTCs.

METHODS

Using this platform, we conducted a pilot clinical study for CTC enumeration in peripheral blood (PB), pulmonary arterial blood (PA), and pulmonary venous blood (PV) from 33 patients with lung cancer (Stage I-III) who underwent surgery, followed by digital PCR-based EGFR mutation analysis of CTCs in PV from 12 patients.

RESULTS

The results showed that CTC levels were significantly higher in PV and PA than in PB (p < 0.05, p < 0.01. respectively), with a notably greater number of small and large CTC clusters (p < 0.01). Genetic analysis of EGFR mutations of CTCs from PV (n = 12) revealed six mutations, including three Exon19del and three L856R, in CTCs and eight EGFR mutations, including five Exon19del and three L856R, in lung tumor tissue. CTC mutation status matched that of tissue samples in nine patients, was unmatched in two patients, and controversial in one patient, indicating a sensitivity of 0.75 (6/8) and specificity of 1.0 (4/4) with some false-negative results for the mutation analysis of CTCs.

CONCLUSIONS

This immunocytology-based CTC detection platform is a convenient method for detecting both CTC number and EGFR mutation status under microscopy, suggesting its potential as a liquid biopsy tool in the hospital for patients with lung cancer in some clinical settings.

A comparative study of circulating tumor cell isolation and enumeration technologies in lung cancer

Circulating tumor cells (CTCs) have potential as diagnostic, prognostic, and predictive biomarkers in solid tumors. Despite Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval of CTC devices in various cancers, the rarity and heterogeneity of CTCs in lung cancer make them technically challenging to isolate and analyze, hindering their clinical integration. Establishing a consensus through comparative analysis of different CTC systems is warranted. This study aimed to evaluate seven different CTC enrichment methods across five technologies using a standardized spike-in protocol: the CellMag™ (EpCAM-dependent enrichment), EasySep™ and RosetteSep™ (blood cell depletion), and the Parsortix® PR1 and the new design Parsortix® Prototype (PP) (size- and deformability-based enrichment). The Parsortix® systems were also evaluated for any differences in recovery rates between cell harvest versus in-cassette staining. Healthy donor blood (5 mL) was spiked with 100 fluorescently labeled EpCAMhigh H1975 cells, processed through each system, and the isolation efficiency was calculated. The CellMag™ had the highest recovery rate (70 ± 14%), followed by Parsortix® PR1 in-cassette staining, while the EasySep™ had the lowest recovery (18 ± 8%). Additional spike-in experiments were performed with EpCAMmoderate A549 and EpCAMlow H1299 cells using the CellMag™ and Parsortix® PR1 in-cassette staining. The recovery rate of CellMag™ significantly reduced to 35 ± 14% with A549 cells and 1 ± 1% with H1299 cells. However, the Parsortix® PR1 in-cassette staining showed cell phenotype-independent and consistent recovery rates among all lung cancer cell lines: H1975 (49 ± 2%), A549 (47 ± 10%), and H1299 (52 ± 10%). Furthermore, we demonstrated that the Parsortix® PR1 in-cassette staining method is capable of isolating heterogeneous single CTCs and cell clusters from patient samples. The Parsortix® PR1 in-cassette staining, capable of isolating different phenotypes of CTCs as either single cells or cell clusters with consistent recovery rates, is considered optimal for CTC enrichment for lung cancer, albeit needing further optimization and validation.

Molecular Profiling of Circulating Tumour Cells and Circulating Tumour DNA: Complementary Insights from a Single Blood Sample Utilising the Parsortix® System

The study of molecular drivers of cancer is an area of rapid growth and has led to the development of targeted treatments, significantly improving patient outcomes in many cancer types. The identification of actionable mutations informing targeted treatment strategies are now considered essential to the management of cancer. Traditionally, this information has been obtained through biomarker assessment of a tissue biopsy which is costly and can be associated with clinical complications and adverse events. In the last decade, blood-based liquid biopsy has emerged as a minimally invasive, fast, and cost-effective alternative, which is better suited to the requirement for longitudinal monitoring. Liquid biopsies allow for the concurrent study of multiple analytes, such as circulating tumour cells (CTCs) and circulating tumour DNA (ctDNA), from a single blood sample. Although ctDNA assays are commercially more advanced, there is an increasing awareness of the clinical significance of the transcriptome and proteome which can be analysed using CTCs. Herein, we review the literature in which the microfluidic, label-free Parsortix® system is utilised for CTC capture, harvest and analysis, alongside the analysis of ctDNA from a single blood sample. This detailed summary of the literature demonstrates how these two analytes can provide complementary disease information.

Circulating H3K27 Methylated Nucleosome Plasma Concentration: Synergistic Information with Circulating Tumor DNA Molecular Profiling

The molecular profiling of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) is a helpful tool not only in cancer treatment, but also in the early detection of relapse. However, the clinical interpretation of a ctDNA negative result remains challenging. The characterization of circulating nucleosomes (carrying cell-free DNA) and associated epigenetic modifications (playing a key role in the tumorigenesis of different cancers) may provide useful information for patient management, by supporting the contributive value of ctDNA molecular profiling. Significantly elevated concentrations of H3K27Me3 nucleosomes were found in plasmas at the diagnosis, and during the follow-up, of NSCLC patients, compared to healthy donors (p-value < 0.0001). By combining the H3K27Me3 level and the ctDNA molecular profile, we found that 25.5% of the patients had H3K27Me3 levels above the cut off, and no somatic alteration was detected at diagnosis. This strongly supports the presence of non-mutated ctDNA in the corresponding plasma. During the patient follow-up, a high H3K27Me3-nucleosome level was found in 15.1% of the sample, despite no somatic mutations being detected, allowing the identification of disease progression from 43.1% to 58.2% over molecular profiling alone. Measuring H3K27Me3-nucleosome levels in combination with ctDNA molecular profiling may improve confidence in the negative molecular result for cfDNA in lung cancer at diagnosis, and may also be a promising biomarker for molecular residual disease (MRD) monitoring, during and/or after treatment.