A Singular and Widespread Group of Mobile Genetic Elements: RNA Circles with Autocatalytic Ribozymes

Diversity and evolution of viroids and viroid-like agents with circular RNA genomes revealed by metatranscriptome mining

Viroids, the agents of several plant diseases, are the smallest and simplest known replicators that consist of covalently closed circular (ccc) RNA molecules between 200 and 400 nucleotides in size. Viroids encode no proteins and rely on host RNA polymerases for replication, but some contain ribozymes involved in replication intermediate processing. Although other viroid-like agents with cccRNAs genomes, such as satellite RNAs, ribozyviruses and retrozymes, have been discovered, until recently, the spread of these agents in the biosphere appeared narrow, and their actual diversity and evolution remained poorly understood. Extensive, targeted metatranscriptome mining dramatically expanded the known diversity of cccRNAs genomes. These searches identified numerous, diverse viroid-like cccRNAs, many found in environments devoid of plant and animal material, suggesting replication in unicellular eukaryotic and/or prokaryotic hosts. Several cccRNAs are targeted by CRISPR systems, supporting their association with bacteria. In addition to small cccRNAs in the viroid size range, a broad variety of ribozyviruses and novel viruses with cccRNAs genomes, with genomes reaching nearly 5 kilobases, were discovered. Thus, metatranscriptome mining shows that the diversity of viroid-like cccRNAs genomes is far greater than previously suspected, prompting reassessment of the relevance of these replicators for understanding the primordial RNA world.

Viroids and Retrozymes: Plant Circular RNAs Capable of Autonomous Replication

Among the long non-coding RNAs that are currently recognized as important regulatory molecules influencing a plethora of processes in eukaryotic cells, circular RNAs (circRNAs) represent a distinct class of RNAs that are predominantly produced by back-splicing of pre-mRNA. The most studied regulatory mechanisms involving circRNAs are acting as miRNA sponges, forming R-loops with genomic DNA, and encoding functional proteins. In addition to circRNAs generated by back-splicing, two types of circRNAs capable of autonomous RNA-RNA replication and systemic transport have been described in plants: viroids, which are infectious RNAs that cause a number of plant diseases, and retrozymes, which are transcripts of retrotransposon genomic loci that are capable of circularization due to ribozymes. Based on a number of common features, viroids and retrozymes are considered to be evolutionarily related. Here, we provide an overview of the biogenesis mechanisms and regulatory functions of non-replicating circRNAs produced by back-splicing and further discuss in detail the currently available data on viroids and retrozymes, focusing on their structural features, replication mechanisms, interaction with cellular components, and transport in plants. In addition, biotechnological approaches involving replication-capable plant circRNAs are discussed, as well as their potential applications in research and agriculture.

Viroid-like RNA-dependent RNA polymerase-encoding ambiviruses are abundant in complex fungi

Ambiviruses are hybrid infectious elements encoding the hallmark gene of RNA viruses, the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, and self-cleaving RNA ribozymes found in many viroids. Ambiviruses are thought to be pathogens of fungi, although the majority of reported genomes have been identified in metatranscriptomes. Here, we present a comprehensive screen for ambiviruses in more than 46,500 fungal transcriptomes from the Sequence Read Archive (SRA). Our data-driven virus discovery approach identified more than 2,500 ambiviral sequences across the kingdom Fungi with a striking expansion in members of the phylum Basidiomycota representing the most complex fungal organisms. Our study unveils a large diversity of unknown ambiviruses with as little as 27% protein sequence identity to known members and sheds new light on the evolution of this distinct class of infectious agents with RNA genomes. No evidence for the presence of ambiviruses in human microbiomes was obtained from a comprehensive screen of respective metatranscriptomes available in the SRA.

Mining metatranscriptomes reveals a vast world of viroid-like circular RNAs

Viroids and viroid-like covalently closed circular (ccc) RNAs are minimal replicators that typically encode no proteins and hijack cellular enzymes for replication. The extent and diversity of viroid-like agents are poorly understood. We developed a computational pipeline to identify viroid-like cccRNAs and applied it to 5,131 metatranscriptomes and 1,344 plant transcriptomes. The search yielded 11,378 viroid-like cccRNAs spanning 4,409 species-level clusters, a 5-fold increase compared to the previously identified viroid-like elements. Within this diverse collection, we discovered numerous putative viroids, satellite RNAs, retrozymes, and ribozy-like viruses. Diverse ribozyme combinations and unusual ribozymes within the cccRNAs were identified. Self-cleaving ribozymes were identified in ambiviruses, some mito-like viruses and capsid-encoding satellite virus-like cccRNAs. The broad presence of viroid-like cccRNAs in diverse transcriptomes and ecosystems implies that their host range is far broader than currently known, and matches to CRISPR spacers suggest that some cccRNAs replicate in prokaryotes.

Circular RNAs: Non-Canonical Observations on Non-Canonical RNAs

The existence of circular RNA (circRNA) research in mainstream science can be attributed to the contemporary synergism of big data and keen attention to detail by several research groups worldwide. Since the re-emergence of these non-canonical RNA transcripts, seminal advances have been made in understanding their biogenesis, interactome, and functions in diverse fields and a myriad of human diseases. However, most research outputs to date have focused on the ability of highly stable circRNAs to interact with, and impact signalling through, microRNAs. This is likely to be the result of seminal papers in the field ascribing a few remarkable circRNAs as "miRNA sponges". However, the stoichiometric ratio between the (often-lowly-expressed) circRNA and their (commonly-more-abundant) target is rarely in favour of a biologically relevant and functional consequence of these interactions. It is time for yet another revolution in circRNA research to uncover functions beyond their documented ability to bind miRNAs. This Special Issue aims to highlight non-canonical functions for this non-canonical family of RNA molecules.

In-Plant Persistence and Systemic Transport of Nicotiana benthamiana Retrozyme RNA

Retrozymes are nonautonomous retrotransposons with hammerhead ribozymes in their long terminal repeats (LTRs). Retrozyme transcripts can be self-cleaved by the LTR ribozyme, circularized, and can undergo RNA-to-RNA replication. Here, we demonstrate that the Nicotiana benthamiana genome contains hundreds of retrozyme loci, of which nine represent full-length retrozymes. The LTR contains a promoter directing retrozyme transcription. Although retrozyme RNA is easily detected in plants, the LTR region is heavily methylated, pointing to its transcriptional silencing, which can be mediated by 24 nucleotide-long retrozyme-specific RNAs identified in N. benthamiana. A transcriptome analysis revealed that half of the retrozyme-specific RNAs in plant leaves have no exact matches to genomic retrozyme loci, containing up to 13% mismatches with the closest genomic sequences, and could arise as a result of many rounds of RNA-to-RNA replication leading to error accumulation. Using a cloned retrozyme copy, we show that retrozyme RNA is capable of replication and systemic transport in plants. The presented data suggest that retrozyme loci in the N. benthamiana genome are transcriptionally inactive, and that circular retrozyme RNA can persist in cells due to its RNA-to-RNA replication and be transported systemically, emphasizing functional and, possibly, evolutionary links of retrozymes to viroids-noncoding circular RNAs that infect plants.

A beginner's guide to manual curation of transposable elements

BACKGROUND

In the study of transposable elements (TEs), the generation of a high confidence set of consensus sequences that represent the diversity of TEs found in a given genome is a key step in the path to investigate these fascinating genomic elements. Many algorithms and pipelines are available to automatically identify putative TE families present in a genome. Despite the availability of these valuable resources, producing a library of high-quality full-length TE consensus sequences largely remains a process of manual curation. This know-how is often passed on from mentor-to-mentee within research groups, making it difficult for those outside the field to access this highly specialised skill.

RESULTS

Our manuscript attempts to fill this gap by providing a set of detailed computer protocols, software recommendations and video tutorials for those aiming to manually curate TEs. Detailed step-by-step protocols, aimed at the complete beginner, are presented in the Supplementary Methods.

CONCLUSIONS

The proposed set of programs and tools presented here will make the process of manual curation achievable and amenable to all researchers and in special to those new to the field of TEs.

A life of research on circular RNAs and ribozymes: towards the origin of viroids, deltaviruses and life

The first examples of circular RNAs (circRNAs) were reported in the '70s as a family of minimal infectious agents of flowering plants; the viroids and viral satellites of circRNA. In some cases, these small circular genomes encode self-cleaving RNA motifs or ribozymes, including an exceptional circRNA infecting not plants but humans: the Hepatitis Delta Virus. Autocatalytic ribozymes not only allowed to propose a common rolling-circle replication mechanism for all these subviral agents, but also a tentative link with the origin of life as molecular fossils of the so-called RNA world. Despite the weak biologic connection between angiosperm plants and the human liver, diverse scientists, and most notably Ricardo Flores, firmly supported an evolutionary relationship between plant viroids and human deltavirus agents. The tireless and inspiring work done by Ricardo's lab in the field of infectious circRNAs fuelled multiple hypotheses for the origin of these entities, allowing advances in other fields, from eukaryotic circRNAs to small ribozymes in genomes from all life kingdoms. The recent discovery of a plethora of viral-like circRNAs with ribozymes in disparate biological samples may finally allow us to connect plant and animal subviral agents, confirming again that Ricardo's eye for science was always a keen eye.

Viroids and Viroid-like Circular RNAs: Do They Descend from Primordial Replicators?

Viroids are a unique class of plant pathogens that consist of small circular RNA molecules, between 220 and 450 nucleotides in size. Viroids encode no proteins and are the smallest known infectious agents. Viroids replicate via the rolling circle mechanism, producing multimeric intermediates which are cleaved to unit length either by ribozymes formed from both polarities of the viroid genomic RNA or by coopted host RNAses. Many viroid-like small circular RNAs are satellites of plant RNA viruses. Ribozyviruses, represented by human hepatitis delta virus, are larger viroid-like circular RNAs that additionally encode the viral nucleocapsid protein. It has been proposed that viroids are direct descendants of primordial RNA replicons that were present in the hypothetical RNA world. We argue, however, that much later origin of viroids, possibly, from recently discovered mobile genetic elements known as retrozymes, is a far more parsimonious evolutionary scenario. Nevertheless, viroids and viroid-like circular RNAs are minimal replicators that are likely to be close to the theoretical lower limit of replicator size and arguably comprise the paradigm for replicator emergence. Thus, although viroid-like replicators are unlikely to be direct descendants of primordial RNA replicators, the study of the diversity and evolution of these ultimate genetic parasites can yield insights into the earliest stages of the evolution of life.

Genome Evolution from Random Ligation of RNAs of Autocatalytic Sets

The evolutionary origin of the genome remains elusive. Here, I hypothesize that its first iteration, the protogenome, was a multi-ribozyme RNA. It evolved, likely within liposomes (the protocells) forming in dry-wet cycling environments, through the random fusion of ribozymes by a ligase and was amplified by a polymerase. The protogenome thereby linked, in one molecule, the information required to seed the protometabolism (a combination of RNA-based autocatalytic sets) in newly forming protocells. If this combination of autocatalytic sets was evolutionarily advantageous, the protogenome would have amplified in a population of multiplying protocells. It likely was a quasispecies with redundant information, e.g., multiple copies of one ribozyme. As such, new functionalities could evolve, including a genetic code. Once one or more components of the protometabolism were templated by the protogenome (e.g., when a ribozyme was replaced by a protein enzyme), and/or addiction modules evolved, the protometabolism became dependent on the protogenome. Along with increasing fidelity of the RNA polymerase, the protogenome could grow, e.g., by incorporating additional ribozyme domains. Finally, the protogenome could have evolved into a DNA genome with increased stability and storage capacity. I will provide suggestions for experiments to test some aspects of this hypothesis, such as evaluating the ability of ribozyme RNA polymerases to generate random ligation products and testing the catalytic activity of linked ribozyme domains.

Viruses Defined by the Position of the Virosphere within the Replicator Space

Originally, viruses were defined as miniscule infectious agents that passed through filters that retain even the smallest cells. Subsequently, viruses were considered obligate intracellular parasites whose reproduction depends on their cellular hosts for energy supply and molecular building blocks. However, these features are insufficient to unambiguously define viruses as they are broadly understood today. We outline possible approaches to define viruses and explore the boundaries of the virosphere within the virtual space of replicators and the relationships between viruses and other types of replicators. Regardless of how, exactly, viruses are defined, viruses clearly have evolved on many occasions from nonviral replicators, such as plasmids, by recruiting host proteins to become virion components. Conversely, other types of replicators have repeatedly evolved from viruses. Thus, the virosphere is a dynamic entity with extensive evolutionary traffic across its boundaries. We argue that the virosphere proper, here termed orthovirosphere, consists of a distinct variety of replicators that encode structural proteins encasing the replicators' genomes, thereby providing protection and facilitating transmission among hosts. Numerous and diverse replicators, such as virus-derived but capsidless RNA and DNA elements, or defective viruses occupy the zone surrounding the orthovirosphere in the virtual replicator space. We define this zone as the perivirosphere. Although intense debates on the nature of certain replicators that adorn the internal and external boundaries of the virosphere will likely continue, we present an operational definition of virus that recently has been accepted by the International Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses.

Hepatitis delta virus-like circular RNAs from diverse metazoans encode conserved hammerhead ribozymes

Human hepatitis delta virus (HDV) is a unique infectious agent whose genome is composed of a small circular RNA. Recent data, however, have reported the existence of highly divergent HDV-like circRNAs in the transcriptomes of diverse vertebrate and invertebrate species. The HDV-like genomes described in amniotes such as birds and reptiles encode self-cleaving RNA motifs or ribozymes similar to the ones present in the human HDV, whereas no catalytic RNA domains have been reported for the HDV-like genomes detected in metagenomic data from some amphibians, fish, and invertebrates. Herein, we describe the self-cleaving motifs of the HDV-like genomes reported in newts and fish, which belong to the characteristic class of HDV ribozymes. Surprisingly, HDV-like genomes from a toad and a termite show conserved type III hammerhead ribozymes, which belong to an unrelated class of catalytic RNAs characteristic of plant genomes and plant subviral circRNAs, such as some viral satellites and viroids. Sequence analyses revealed the presence of similar HDV-like hammerhead ribozymes encoded in two termite genomes, but also in the genomes of several dipteran species. In vitro transcriptions confirmed the cleaving activity for these motifs, with moderate rates of self-cleavage. These data indicate that all described HDV-like agents contain self-cleaving motifs from either the HDV or the hammerhead class. Autocatalytic ribozymes in HDV-like genomes could be regarded as interchangeable domains and may have arisen from cellular transcriptomes, although we still cannot rule out some other evolutionary explanations.