Design of Icephobic Surfaces by Lowering Ice Adhesion Strength: A Mini Review

Enhancing Icephobic Coatings: Exploring the Potential of Dopamine-Modified Epoxy Resin Inspired by Mussel Catechol Groups

A nature-inspired approach was employed through the development of dopamine-modified epoxy coating for anti-icing applications. The strong affinity of dopamine's catechol groups for hydrogen bonding with water molecules at the ice/coating interface was utilized to induce an aqueous quasi-liquid layer (QLL) on the surface of the icephobic coatings, thereby reducing their ice adhesion strength. Epoxy resin modification was studied by attenuated total reflectance infrared spectroscopy (ATR-FTIR) and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR). The surface and mechanical properties of the prepared coatings were studied by different characterization techniques. Low-temperature ATR-FTIR was employed to study the presence of QLL on the coating's surface. Moreover, the freezing delay time and temperature of water droplets on the coatings were evaluated along with push-off and centrifuge ice adhesion strength to evaluate their icephobic properties. The surface of dopamine-modified epoxy coating presented enhanced hydrophilicity and QLL formation, addressed as the main reason for its remarkable icephobicity. The results demonstrated the potential of dopamine-modified epoxy resin as an effective binder for icephobic coatings, offering notable ice nucleation delay time (1316 s) and temperature (-19.7 °C), reduced ice adhesion strength (less than 40 kPa), and an ice adhesion reduction factor of 7.2 compared to the unmodified coating.

Phase change surfaces with porous metallic structures for long-term anti/de-icing application

HYPOTHESIS

Ice mitigation has received increasing attention due to the severe safety and economic threats of icing hazards to modern industries. Slippery icephobic surface is a potential ice mitigation approach due to its ultra-low ice adhesion strength, great humidity resistance, and effective delay of ice nucleation. However, this approach currently has limited practical applications because of serious liquid depletion in the icing/de-icing process.

EXPERIMENTS

A new strategy of phase change materials (PCM)-impregnation porous metallic structures (PIPMSs) was proposed to develop phase changeable icephobic surfaces in this study, and aimed to solve the rapid depletion via the phase changeable interfacial interactions.

FINDINGS

Evaluation of surface icephobicity and interfacial analysis proved that the phase changeable surfaces (PIPMSs) worked as an effective and durable icephobic platform by significantly delaying ice nucleation, providing long-term humid tolerance, low ice adhesion strength of as-prepared samples (less than 5 kPa), and signally improved maintaining capacity of impregnated PCMs (less than 10 % depletion) after 50 icing/de-icing cycles. To explore the interfacial responses, phase change models consisting of the unfrozen quasi-liquid layer and solid lubricant layer at the ice/PIPMSs interfaces were established, and the involved icephobic mechanisms of PIPMSs were studied based on the analysis of interfacial interactions.

On the Durability of Icephobic Coatings: A Review

Ice formation and accumulation on surfaces has a negative impact in many different sectors and can even represent a potential danger. In this review, the latest advances and trends in icephobic coatings focusing on the importance of their durability are discussed, in an attempt to pave the roadmap from the lab to engineering applications. An icephobic material is expected to lower the ice adhesion strength, delay freezing time or temperature, promote the bouncing of a supercooled drop at subzero temperatures and/or reduce the ice accretion rate. To better understand what is more important for specific icing conditions, the different types of ice that can be formed in nature are summarized. Similarly, the alternative methods to evaluate the durability are reviewed, as this is key to properly selecting the method and parameters to ensure the coating is durable enough for a given application. Finally, the different types of icephobic surfaces available to date are considered, highlighting the strategies to enhance their durability, as this is the factor limiting the commercial applicability of icephobic coatings.

Characterizing Surface Ice-Philicity Using Molecular Simulations and Enhanced Sampling

The formation of ice, which plays an important role in diverse contexts ranging from cryopreservation to atmospheric science, is often mediated by solid surfaces. Although surfaces that interact favorably with ice (relative to liquid water) can facilitate ice formation by lowering nucleation barriers, the molecular characteristics that confer icephilicity to a surface are complex and incompletely understood. To address this challenge, here we introduce a robust and computationally efficient method for characterizing surface ice-philicity that combines molecular simulations and enhanced sampling techniques to quantify the free energetic cost of increasing surface-ice contact at the expense of surface-water contact. Using this method to characterize the ice-philicity of a family of model surfaces that are lattice matched with ice but vary in their polarity, we find that the nonpolar surfaces are moderately ice-phobic, whereas the polar surfaces are highly ice-philic. In contrast, for surfaces that display no complementarity to the ice lattice, we find that ice-philicity is independent of surface polarity and that both nonpolar and polar surfaces are moderately ice-phobic. Our work thus provides a prescription for quantitatively characterizing surface ice-philicity and sheds light on how ice-philicity is influenced by lattice matching and polarity.

In Situ Activation of Superhydrophobic Surfaces with Triple Icephobicity at Low Temperatures

Superhydrophobic surfaces have been widely studied due to their potential applications in aerospace fields. However, superhydrophobic surfaces with excellent water-repellent, anti-icing, and icephobic performances at low temperatures have rarely been reported. Herein, superhydrophobic surfaces with heating capability were prepared by etching square micropillar arrays on the surface of multiwalled carbon nanotube (MWCNT)/poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) films. The fabricated superhydrophobic surface has triple icephobicity, which can be activated even at low temperatures. The triple icephobicity is triggered by an applied voltage to achieve excellent water-repellent and icephobic capabilities, even at -40 °C. Additionally, theoretical calculations reveal that a droplet on a superhydrophobic surface loses heat at a rate of 8.91 × 10^-5 J/s, which is 2 orders of magnitude slower than a flat surface (2.15 × 10^-3 J/s). Also, at -40 °C, the mechanical interlocking force formed between the superhydrophobic surface and ice can be released by the heating property of the superhydrophobic surface. This low-energy, multifunctional superhydrophobic surface opens up new possibilities for bionic smart multifunctional materials in icephobic applications.

Thermo-responsive Fluorinated Organogels Showing Anti-fouling and Long-Lasting/Repeatable Icephobic Properties

Accumulations of ice on modern infrastructures often cause severe consequences. As such, there is significant interest in developing functional coatings/surfaces that can prevent this. One such approach has been demonstrated with slippery liquid-infused porous surfaces (SLIPS) and organogels where the ice adhesion strength is reduced to the critical point (less than 10 kPa) where it can be removed by natural forces such as gravity, wind, vibrations, and so forth. However, both designs are limited by lubricant depletion. If lubricant release and reabsorption (syneresis) of organogels can be arbitrarily controlled by the surrounding temperature, the loss due to unfavorable evaporation and drainage of infused lubricants can be minimized and its durability can be extended. This study demonstrates the tunable thermo-responsive syneresis of transparent fluorinated organogels (F-ORGs) prepared from a commercial silicone elastomer and a lubricant mixture of fluorinated silicone oil and either poly(dimethylsiloxane) or poly(methylphenylsiloxane). By carefully tuning the ratio of the two lubricants in the mixture, the corresponding F-ORGs demonstrated arbitrarily tunable critical syneresis temperatures from -15 to 40 °C, below which the lubricant is released on the surface and above which the lubricant is re-absorbed. The resulting surfaces showed not only exceptionally long-lasting/repeatable low ice adhesion strengths (≤10 kPa over 50 icing/de-icing cycles) but also significant improvements in their repellency toward a variety of organic liquids. Compared to non-fluorinated organogels, F-ORGs could offer improved protection against outdoor pollutants to further enhance their practicality.

Numerical Modelling of Droplets and Beads Behavior over Super-Hydrophobic and Hydrophilic Coatings under in-Flight Icing Conditions

Current technology has produced a wide range of advanced micro-structured surfaces, designed for achieving the best wettability and adhesion performances for each specific application. In the context of in-flight icing simulations, this opens new challenges since the current most popular and successful ice accretion prediction tools neglect the details of the droplet behavior opting for a continuous film model. Here, a phenomenological model, following, in a Lagrangian approach, the evolution of the single droplets from the impinging to the onset of rivulets, is developed to simulate the performances of super-hydrophobic surfaces in icing application. Possible rebound and droplet spread on the impact, coalescence, single ice bead formation and droplet to rivulet transition are taken into account. The first validation shows how the models are able to predict the anti-icing capability of a super-hydrophobic surface coupled with a heating system.

Effective Icephobicity of Silicone Oil-Infused Oleamide-Polydimethylsiloxane with Enhanced Lubrication Lifetime

Icing and freezing phenomena in cold weather cause serious damage and economic losses. Thus, the development of a new effective icephobic surface with low ice adhesion strength (τ_ice) that can easily remove ice by wind or gravity force is essentially required. In this study, we propose a silicone oil-infused oleamide-polydimethylsiloxane (SiOP) by a facile fabrication method to achieve the effective icephobic performance with enhanced lubrication lifetime. The proposed SiOP is composed of a composite containing oleamide and polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) and silicone oil impregnated into the polymeric networks of the composite. Oleamide has been used as a slip agent in industries to reduce the skin friction of polymer films. The weight of the oil impregnated in SiOP is approximately three times higher than that of silicone oil-infused PDMS (SiPDMS). Different from the SiPDMS surface on which oil dries easily, a slippery oil layer is stably formed on the SiOP surface. The fabricated SiOP surfaces have very low τ_ice values of approximately 1 kPa, which is much smaller than that of the SiPDMS surface. The SiOP with an oleamide content of 5 wt % exhibits the smallest τ_ice value of 0.88 kPa. The fabricated SiOP surfaces maintain their superior icephobicity for more than 30 icing/deicing cycles, demonstrating their enhanced lubrication lifetime. In addition, the ice freezing time of a water droplet of 7 μL in volume is significantly delayed on the SiOP surface compared with that on the SiPDMS surface. The present results demonstrate that the proposed SiOP surface can help provide superior icephobic performance with the aid of the incorporation of oleamide into the conventional SiPDMS. The developed icephobic SiOP can be utilized to satisfactorily resolve the lubricant drought problem of conventional icephobic surfaces by empolying oleamide as a complementary slip agent.

Mussel-Inspired Durable TiO2/PDA-Based Superhydrophobic Paper with Excellent Self-Cleaning, High Chemical Stability, and Efficient Oil/Water Separation Properties

Oceanic oil spill and the discharge of industrial oily wastewaters can cause significant threats to the ecological environment and human health. Herein, we design a durable TiO₂/PDA-based superhydrophobic paper for efficient oil/water separation. Bioinspired from mussel adhesive proteins, the mechanical durability of the as-prepared superhydrophobic paper is enhanced by the deposition of polydopamine (PDA) onto cellulosic fibers via self-polymerization of dopamine. The TiO₂/PDA-based superhydrophobic paper shows a high water contact angle of 168.2° and an oil contact angle of ∼0°, exhibiting excellent superhydrophobicity and superoleophilicity. Furthermore, the as-prepared superhydrophobic paper possesses excellent chemical stability, thermal stability, and mechanical durability in terms of being immersed in corrosive solutions and solvents and boiling water and being subjected to the sandpaper abrasion test, respectively. More importantly, the separation efficiency of the TiO₂/PDA-based superhydrophobic paper for an oil/water mixture is 97.2%, and it maintains a separation efficiency above 94.3% even after 15 cyclic separation processes. Furthermore, the separation efficiency for water-in-oil emulsions is higher than 93.7% after 15 cyclic separation tests, showing its excellent recyclable stability for water-in-oil emulsions. Therefore, the rationally designed TiO₂/PDA-based superhydrophobic paper shows great potential in the practical applications of self-cleaning, antifouling, and oil/water separation.

Facile Preparation of Robust Superhydrophobic/Superoleophilic TiO2-Decorated Polyvinyl Alcohol Sponge for Efficient Oil/Water Separation

Oily wastewater and oil spills pose a threat to the environment and human health, and porous sponge materials are highly desired for oil/water separation. Herein, we design a new superhydrophobic/superoleophilic TiO₂-decorated polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) sponge material for efficient oil/water separation. The TiO₂-PVA sponge is obtained by firmly anchoring TiO₂ nanoparticles onto the skeleton surface of pristine PVA sponge via the cross-linking reactions between TiO₂ nanoparticles and H₃BO₃ and KH550, followed by the chemical modification of 1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluorodecyltrichlorosilane. The as-prepared TiO₂-PVA sponge shows a high water contact angle of 157° (a sliding angle of 5.5°) and an oil contact angle of ∼0°, showing excellent superhydrophobicity and superoleophilicity. The TiO₂-PVA sponge exhibits excellent chemical stability, thermal stability, and mechanical durability in terms of immersing it in the corrosive solutions and solvents, boiling it in water, and the sandpaper abrasion test. Moreover, the as-prepared TiO₂-PVA sponge possesses excellent absorption capacity of oils or organic solvents ranging from 4.3 to 13.6 times its own weight. More importantly, the as-prepared TiO₂-PVA sponge can separate carbon tetrachloride from the oil-water mixture with a separation efficiency of 97.8% with the aid of gravity and maintains a separation efficiency of 96.5% even after 15 cyclic oil/water separation processes. Therefore, the rationally designed superhydrophobic/superoleophilic TiO₂-PVA sponge shows great potential in practical applications of dealing with oily wastewater and oil spills.

Enhanced Surface Icephobicity on an Elastic Substrate

Ice accumulation on exposed surfaces is unavoidable as time elapses and the temperature decreases sufficiently. To mitigate icing problems, various types of icephobic substrates have been rationally designed, including superhydrophobic substrates (SHSs), aqueous lubricating layers, organic lubricating layers, organogels, polyelectrolyte brush layers, electrolyte-based hydrogels, elastic substrates, and multicrack initiator-promoted surfaces. Among these surfaces, elastic substrates show excellent enhanced surface icephobicity during dynamic processes (i.e., water-impacting and de-icing tests). Herein, we summarize recent progress in elastic icephobic substrates and discuss the reasons that surface icephobicity can be enhanced on elastic substrates in terms of enhanced water repellency and further lowering the ice adhesion strength. For enhanced water repellency, we focus on reducing the contact time of water impacting such that water droplets can be easily shed from an elastic substrate before ice occurs. Reducing the contact time of water impacting various substrates (i.e., micro/nanostructured rigid SHSs, macrotextured rigid SHSs, and elastic SHSs) is discussed, followed by exploring their mechanisms. We argue that the ice adhesion strength can be further lowered on an elastic substrate by rationally tuning the elastic modulus and surface textures (i.e., surface textured and hollow subsurface textured) and combining elastic substrate with other passive anti-icing strategies (or functioning passive icephobic substrates with an electrothermal or photothermal stimulus). In short, the introduction of an elastic substrate into a passive or active icephobicity surface opens an avenue toward designing a versatile icephobic surface, providing great potential for outdoor anti-icing applications.