Against the Odds: Hybrid Zones between Mangrove Killifish Species with Different Mating Systems

Male secreted short glycoproteins link sperm competition to the reproductive isolation of species

Sperm competition is found across multicellular organisms1,2,3,4 using both external and internal fertilization.5,6 Sperm competition and post-copulatory cryptic female choice can promote incompatibility between species due to the antagonistic coevolution of the sexes within a species.7,8,9,10,11 This between-species incompatibility is accelerated and markedly asymmetrical when sexual mode differs, producing the "weak inbreeder, strong outcrosser" (WISO) pattern.12 Here, we show that male secreted short (MSS) sperm glycoproteins of nematodes constitute a gametic effector of WISO. In obligately outcrossing Caenorhabditis, MSS is dispensable for baseline fertility but required for intraspecific sperm competitiveness.13 MSS is lost in self-fertile lineages, likely as a response to selection for a hermaphrodite-biased sex ratio.14 Selfing hermaphrodites that mate with males of closely related outcrossing species are rapidly sterilized due to ovarian sperm invasion.11 The simplification of the male proteome in selfing species suggests that many factors could contribute to invasivity.13,15,16 However, restoration of just MSS to the self-fertile C. briggsae is sufficient to induce mild invasivity. Further, MSS+ sperm appear to derive their competitive advantage from this behavior, directly linking interspecies incompatibility with intraspecific competition. MSS-related proteins (MSRPs) remaining in the C. briggsae genome are similar in structure, expression, and localization to MSS but are not necessary for normal sperm competitiveness. Further, overexpression of the MSRP most similar to MSS, Cbr-MSRP-3, is insufficient to enhance competitiveness. We conclude that outcrossing species retain sperm competition factors that contribute to their reproductive isolation from selfing relatives that lost them.

Transcriptomic data support phylogenetic congruence and reveal genomic changes associated with the repeated evolution of annualism in aplocheiloid killifishes (Cyprinodontiformes)

Repeated evolution of novel life histories that are correlated with ecological variables offers opportunities to study convergence in genetic, developmental, and metabolic features. Nearly half of the 800 species of Aplocheiloid killifishes, a clade of teleost fishes with a circumtropical distribution, are "annual" or seasonal species that survive in ephemeral bodies of water that desiccate and are unfeasible for growth, reproduction, or survival for weeks to months every year. But the repeated evolution of adaptations that are key features of the annual life history among these fishes remains poorly known without a robust phylogenetic framework. We present a large-scale phylogenomic reconstruction of aplocheiloid killifishes evolution using newly sequenced transcriptomes obtained from a diversity of killifish lineages representing putative independent origins of annualism. Ancestral state estimation shows that developmental dormancy (diapause), a key trait of the killifish annual life cycle, may have originated up to seven times independently among African and South American lineages. To further explore the genetic basis of this unique trait, we measure changes in evolutionary rates among orthologous genes across the killifish tree of life by quantifying codon evolution using dN/dS ratios. We show that some genes have higher dN/dS ratios in lineages leading to species with annual life history. Many of them constitute key developmental genes or nuclear-encoded metabolic genes that control oxidative phosphorylation. Lastly, we compare these genes with higher ω to genes previously associated to developmental dormancy and metabolic shifts in killifishes and other vertebrates, and thereby identify molecular evolutionary signatures of repeated transitions to extreme environments.

Microbiome and epigenetic variation in wild fish with low genetic diversity

Non-genetic sources of phenotypic variation, such as the epigenome and the microbiome, could be important contributors to adaptive variation for species with low genetic diversity. However, little is known about the complex interaction between these factors and the genetic diversity of the host, particularly in wild populations. Here, we examine the skin microbiome composition of two closely-related mangrove killifish species with different mating systems (self-fertilising and outcrossing) under sympatric and allopatric conditions. This allows us to partition the influence of the genotype and the environment on their microbiome and (previously described) epigenetic profiles. We find the diversity and community composition of the skin microbiome are strongly shaped by the environment and, to a lesser extent, by species-specific influences. Heterozygosity and microbiome alpha diversity, but not epigenetic variation, are associated with the fluctuating asymmetry of traits related to performance (vision) and behaviour (aggression). Our study identifies that a proportion of the epigenetic diversity and microbiome differentiation is unrelated to genetic variation, and we find evidence for an associative relationship between microbiome and epigenetic diversity in these wild populations. This suggests that both mechanisms could potentially contribute to variation in species with low genetic diversity.

Influence of the mutation load on the genomic composition of hybrids between outcrossing and self-fertilizing species

Hybridization is a natural process whereby two diverging evolutionary lineages reproduce and create offspring of mixed ancestry. Differences in mating systems (e.g., self-fertilization and outcrossing) are expected to affect the direction and extent of hybridization and introgression in hybrid zones. Among other factors, selfers and outcrossers are expected to differ in their mutation loads. This has been studied both theoretically and empirically; however, conflicting predictions have been made on the effects mutation loads of parental species with different mating systems can have on the genomic composition of hybrids. Here, we develop a multi-locus, selective model to study how the different mutation load built up in selfers and outcrossers as a result of selective interference and homozygosity impact the long-term genetic composition of hybrid populations. Notably, our results emphasize that genes from the parental population with lesser mutation load get rapidly overrepresented in hybrid genomes, regardless of the hybrids own mating system. When recombination tends to be more important than mutation, outcrossers' genomes tend to be of higher quality and prevail. When recombination rates are low, however, selfers' genomes may reach higher quality than outcrossers' genomes and prevail in the hybrids. Taken together, these results provide concrete insights into one of the multiple factors influencing hybrid genome ancestry and introgression patterns in hybrid zones containing species with different mating systems.

Genotyping-by-sequencing (GBS) as a tool for interspecies hybrid detection

Genotyping-by-sequencing (GBS) is an extremely useful, modern and relatively inexpensive approach to discovering high-quality single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), which seem to be the most promising markers for identifying hybrid individuals between different species, especially those that can create backcrosses. In addition, GBS could become an invaluable tool in finding backcrosses, even several generations back. Its potential for the use of restriction enzymes and species is almost unlimited. It can also be successfully applied to species for which a reference genome is not established. In this paper, we describe the GBS technique, its main advantages and disadvantages, and the research carried out using this method concerning interspecies hybridisation and the identification of fertile hybrids. We also present future approaches that could be of interest in the context of the GBS method.

Additive and non-additive epigenetic signatures of natural hybridisation between fish species with different mating systems

Hybridization is a major source of evolutionary innovation. In plants, epigenetic mechanisms can help to stabilize hybrid genomes and contribute to reproductive isolation, but the relationship between genetic and epigenetic changes in animal hybrids is unclear. We analysed the relationship between genetic background and methylation patterns in natural hybrids of two genetically divergent fish species with different mating systems, Kryptolebias hermaphroditus (self-fertilizing) and K. ocellatus (outcrossing). Co-existing parental species displayed highly distinct genetic (SNPs) and methylation patterns (37,000 differentially methylated cytosines). Hybrids had predominantly intermediate methylation patterns (88.5% of the sites) suggesting additive effects, as expected from hybridization between genetically distant species. The large number of differentially methylated cytosines between hybrids and parental species (n = 5,800) suggests that hybridization may play a role in increasing genetic and epigenetic variation. Although most of the observed epigenetic variation was additive and had a strong genetic component, we also found a small percentage of non-additive, potentially stochastic, methylation differences that might act as an evolutionary bet-hedging strategy and increase fitness under environmental instability.

Phylogenomics reveals extensive introgression and a case of mito-nuclear discordance in the killifish genus Kryptolebias

Introgression is a widespread evolutionary process leading to phylogenetic inconsistencies among distinct parts of the genomes, particularly between mitochondrial and nuclear-based phylogenetic reconstructions (e.g., mito-nuclear discordances). Here, we used mtDNA and genome-wide nuclear sites to provide the first phylogenomic-based hypothesis on the evolutionary relationships within the killifish genus Kryptolebias. In addition, we tested for evidence of past introgression in the genus given the multiple reports of undergoing hybridization between its members. Our mtDNA phylogeny generally agreed with the relationships previously proposed for the genus. However, our reconstruction based on nuclear DNA revealed an unknown lineage - Kryptolebias sp. 'ESP' - as the sister group of the self-fertilizing mangrove killifishes, K. marmoratus and K. hermaphroditus. All individuals sequenced of Kryptolebias sp. 'ESP' had the same mtDNA haplotype commonly observed in K. hermaphroditus, demonstrating a clear case of mito-nuclear discordance. Our analysis further confirmed extensive history of introgression between Kryptolebias sp. 'ESP' and K. hermaphroditus. Population genomics analyses indicate no current gene flow between the two lineages, despite their current sympatry and history of introgression. We also confirmed introgression between other species pairs in the genus that have been recently reported to form hybrid zones. Overall, our study provides a phylogenomic reconstruction covering most of the Kryptolebias species, reveals a new lineage hidden in a case of mito-nuclear discordance, and provides evidence of multiple events of ancestral introgression in the genus. These findings underscore the importance of investigating different genomic information in a phylogenetic framework, particularly in taxa where introgression is common as in the sexually diverse mangrove killifishes.