The Role of Nuclear-Encoded Mitochondrial tRNA Charging Enzymes in Human Inherited Disease

Phenotyping mitochondrial glutamyl-tRNA synthetase deficiency (EARS2): A case series and systematic literature review

Mitochondrial glutamyl-aminoacyl tRNA synthetase deficiency, stemming from biallelic mutations in the EARS2 gene, was first described in 2012. With <50 cases reported globally, this condition exhibits a distinct phenotype of neonatal or childhood-onset, often referred to as leukoencephalopathy with thalamus and brainstem involvement and high lactate (LTBL). It has also been one of the few reversible mitochondrial disorders described. The natural history of these patients is poorly documented, ranging from clinical and radiological improvement to early death. Herein, we detail three cases from our centre, including follow-up on the Portuguese patient reported by Steenweg et al., These cases illustrate the phenotypic spectrum: i) rapidly progressive neonatal presentation with lactic acidemia and corpus callosum agenesis, leading to early death; ii) early onset with a severe, slowly progressive course; iii) early onset with a milder phenotype, showing some improvement and mild neurological symptoms. Additionally, we conducted a systematic literature review on cases of EARS2-deficient patients, focusing on clinical manifestations, laboratory findings, radiological aspects, and disease progression over time, along with respective data analysis. "Patients with EARS2 deficiency typically present within the first year of life with a well-defined neurometabolic disorder picture, often including hypotonia and/or spasticity, along with neurodevelopmental delay or regression. There are no pathognomonic features specific to EARS2 deficiency, and no genotype-phenotype correlation has been identified." Comparing to initial characterization by Steenweg et al., this analysis reveals an expanded disease spectrum. We propose a novel strategy for clustering phenotypes into severe, moderate, or mild disease based on initial presentation, seemingly correlating with disease progression. The paucity of data on the disease's natural history highlights the need for a multicentric approach to enhance understanding and management. TAKE-HOME MESSAGE: Analysis of all cases published with EARS2 deficiency allows for establish disease spectrum and a novel strategy for clustering phenotypes which correlate to disease progression.

Investigation in yeast of novel variants in mitochondrial aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases WARS2, NARS2, and RARS2 genes associated with mitochondrial diseases

Aminoacyl-transfer RiboNucleic Acid synthetases (ARSs) are essential enzymes that catalyze the attachment of each amino acid to their cognate tRNAs. Mitochondrial ARSs (mtARSs), which ensure protein synthesis within the mitochondria, are encoded by nuclear genes and imported into the organelle after translation in the cytosol. The extensive use of next generation sequencing (NGS) has resulted in an increasing number of variants in mtARS genes being identified and associated with mitochondrial diseases. The similarities between yeast and human mitochondrial translation machineries make yeast a good model to quickly and efficiently evaluate the effect of variants in mtARS genes. Genetic screening of patients with a clinical suspicion of mitochondrial disorders through a customized gene panel of known disease-genes, including all genes encoding mtARSs, led to the identification of missense variants in WARS2, NARS2 and RARS2. Most of them were classified as Variant of Uncertain Significance. We exploited yeast models to assess the functional consequences of the variants found in these genes encoding mitochondrial tryptophanyl-tRNA, asparaginyl-tRNA, and arginyl-tRNA synthetases, respectively. Mitochondrial phenotypes such as oxidative growth, oxygen consumption rate, Cox2 steady-state level and mitochondrial protein synthesis were analyzed in yeast strains deleted in MSW1, SLM5, and MSR1 (the yeast orthologues of WARS2, NARS2 and RARS2, respectively), and expressing the wild type or the mutant alleles. Pathogenicity was confirmed for most variants, leading to their reclassification as Likely Pathogenic. Moreover, the beneficial effects observed after asparagine and arginine supplementation in the growth medium suggest them as a potential therapeutic approach.

A model organism pipeline provides insight into the clinical heterogeneity of TARS1 loss-of-function variants

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (ARSs) are ubiquitously expressed, essential enzymes that complete the first step of protein translation: ligation of amino acids to cognate tRNAs. Genes encoding ARSs have been implicated in myriad dominant and recessive phenotypes, the latter often affecting multiple tissues but with frequent involvement of the central and peripheral nervous systems, liver, and lungs. Threonyl-tRNA synthetase (TARS1) encodes the enzyme that ligates threonine to tRNATHR in the cytoplasm. To date, TARS1 variants have been implicated in a recessive brittle hair phenotype. To better understand TARS1-related recessive phenotypes, we engineered three TARS1 missense variants at conserved residues and studied these variants in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Caenorhabditis elegans models. This revealed two loss-of-function variants, including one hypomorphic allele (R433H). We next used R433H to study the effects of partial loss of TARS1 function in a compound heterozygous mouse model (R432H/null). This model presents with phenotypes reminiscent of patients with TARS1 variants and with distinct lung and skin defects. This study expands the potential clinical heterogeneity of TARS1-related recessive disease, which should guide future clinical and genetic evaluations of patient populations.

Dominant NARS1 mutations causing axonal Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease expand NARS1-associated diseases

Pathogenic variants in six aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase (ARS) genes are implicated in neurological disorders, most notably inherited peripheral neuropathies. ARSs are enzymes that charge tRNA molecules with cognate amino acids. Pathogenic variants in asparaginyl-tRNA synthetase (NARS1) cause a neurological phenotype combining developmental delay, ataxia and demyelinating peripheral neuropathy. NARS1 has not yet been linked to axonal Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease. Exome sequencing of patients with inherited peripheral neuropathies revealed three previously unreported heterozygous NARS1 variants in three families. Clinical and electrophysiological details were assessed. We further characterized all three variants in a yeast complementation model and used a knock-in mouse model to study variant p.Ser461Phe. All three variants (p.Met236del, p.Cys342Tyr and p.Ser461Phe) co-segregate with the sensorimotor axonal neuropathy phenotype. Yeast complementation assays show that none of the three NARS1 variants support wild-type yeast growth when tested in isolation (i.e. in the absence of a wild-type copy of NARS1), consistent with a loss-of-function effect. Similarly, the homozygous knock-in mouse model (p.Ser461Phe/Ser472Phe in mouse) also demonstrated loss-of-function characteristics. We present three previously unreported NARS1 variants segregating with a sensorimotor neuropathy phenotype in three families. Functional studies in yeast and mouse support variant pathogenicity. Thus, NARS1 is the seventh ARS implicated in dominant axonal Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease, further stressing that all dimeric ARSs should be evaluated for Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease.

The striking differences in the bioenergetics of brain and liver mitochondria are enhanced in mitochondrial disease

Mitochondrial disorders are hallmarked by the dysfunction of oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) yet are highly heterogeneous at the clinical and genetic levels. Striking tissue-specific pathological manifestations are a poorly understood feature of these conditions, even if the disease-causing genes are ubiquitously expressed. To investigate the functional basis of this phenomenon, we analyzed several OXPHOS-related bioenergetic parameters, including oxygen consumption rates, electron transfer system (ETS)-related coenzyme Q (mtCoQ) redox state and production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in mouse brain and liver mitochondria fueled by different substrates. In addition, we determined how these functional parameters are affected by ETS impairment in a tissue-specific manner using pathologically relevant mouse models lacking either Ndufs4 or Ttc19, leading to Complex I (CI) or Complex III (CIII) deficiency, respectively. Detailed OXPHOS analysis revealed striking differences between brain and liver mitochondria in the capacity of the different metabolic substrates to fuel the ETS, reduce the ETS-related mtCoQ, and to induce ROS production. In addition, ETS deficiency due to either CI or CIII dysfunction had a much greater impact on the intrinsic bioenergetic parameters of brain compared with liver mitochondria. These findings are discussed in terms of the still rather mysterious tissue-specific manifestations of mitochondrial disease.

Prognostic Performance of Hematological and Serum Iron and Metabolite Indices for Detection of Early Iron Deficiency Induced Metabolic Brain Dysfunction in Infant Rhesus Monkeys

BACKGROUND

The current pediatric practice of monitoring for infantile iron deficiency (ID) via hemoglobin (Hgb) screening at one y of age does not identify preanemic ID nor protect against later neurocognitive deficits.

OBJECTIVES

To identify biomarkers of iron-related metabolic alterations in the serum and brain and determine the sensitivity of conventional iron and heme indices for predicting risk of brain metabolic dysfunction using a nonhuman primate model of infantile ID.

METHODS

Simultaneous serum iron and RBC indices, and serum and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) metabolomic profiles were determined in 20 rhesus infants, comparing iron sufficient (IS; N = 10) and ID (N = 10) infants at 2 and 4 mo of age.

RESULTS

Reticulocyte hemoglobin (RET-He) was lower at 2 wk in the ID group. Significant IS compared with ID differences in serum iron indices were present at 2 mo, but Hgb and RBC indices differed only at 4 mo (P < 0.05). Serum and CSF metabolomic profiles of the ID and IS groups differed at 2 and 4 mo (P < 0.05). Key metabolites, including homostachydrine and stachydrine (4-5-fold lower at 4 mo in ID group, P < 0.05), were altered in both serum and CSF. Iron indices and RET-He at 2 mo, but not Hgb or other RBC indices, were correlated with altered CSF metabolic profile at 4 mo and had comparable predictive accuracy (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve scores, 0.75-0.80).

CONCLUSIONS

Preanemic ID at 2 mo was associated with metabolic alterations in serum and CSF in infant monkeys. Among the RBC indices, only RET-He predicted the future risk of abnormal CSF metabolic profile with a predictive accuracy comparable to serum iron indices. The concordance of homostachydrine and stachydrine changes in serum and CSF indicates their potential use as early biomarkers of brain metabolic dysfunction in infantile ID.

Phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase deficiency caused by biallelic variants in FARSA gene and literature review

BACKGROUND

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (ARSs) are indispensable enzymes for protein biosynthesis in cells. The phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (FARS1) located in cytoplasm which consists of two FARS alpha subunits (FARSA) and two FARS beta subunits (FARSB). Autosomal recessive inheritance of pathogenic variants of FARSA or FARSB can result in defective FARS1 which are characterized by interstitial lung disease, liver disease, brain abnormalities, facial dysmorphism and growth restriction.

METHODS

Exome sequencing was used to detect the candidate variants. The in silico prediction and expressional level analysis were performed to evaluate the pathogenicity of the variations. Additionally, we presented the patient's detailed clinical information and compared the clinical feature with other previously reported patients with FARSA-deficiency.

RESULTS

We identified compound heterozygous rare missense variants (c.1172 T > C/ p.Leu391Pro and c.1211G > A/ p.Arg404His) in FARSA gene in a Chinese male patient. The protein structure prediction and the analysis of levels of FARSA and FARSB subunits indicated both variants pathogenic. Clinical feature review indicated inflammatory symptoms in young infants may be an additional key feature. Thyroid dysfunction should be considered as a phenotype with variable penetrance.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results expanded the current phenotypic and genetic spectrum of FARSA-deficiency.

Disease models of mitochondrial aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase defects

Mitochondrial aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (mtARS) are enzymes critical for the first step of mitochondrial protein synthesis by charging mitochondrial tRNAs with their cognate amino acids. Pathogenic variants in all 19 nuclear mtARS genes are now recognized as causing recessive mitochondrial diseases. Most mtARS disorders affect the nervous system, but the phenotypes range from multisystem diseases to tissue-specific manifestations. However, the mechanisms behind the tissue specificities are poorly understood, and challenges remain in obtaining accurate disease models for developing and testing treatments. Here, some of the currently existing disease models that have increased our understanding of mtARS defects are discussed.

Recessive aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase disorders: lessons learned from in vivo disease models

Protein synthesis is a fundamental process that underpins almost every aspect of cellular functioning. Intriguingly, despite their common function, recessive mutations in aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (ARSs), the family of enzymes that pair tRNA molecules with amino acids prior to translation on the ribosome, cause a diverse range of multi-system disorders that affect specific groups of tissues. Neurological development is impaired in most ARS-associated disorders. In addition to central nervous system defects, diseases caused by recessive mutations in cytosolic ARSs commonly affect the liver and lungs. Patients with biallelic mutations in mitochondrial ARSs often present with encephalopathies, with variable involvement of peripheral systems. Many of these disorders cause severe disability, and as understanding of their pathogenesis is currently limited, there are no effective treatments available. To address this, accurate in vivo models for most of the recessive ARS diseases are urgently needed. Here, we discuss approaches that have been taken to model recessive ARS diseases in vivo, highlighting some of the challenges that have arisen in this process, as well as key results obtained from these models. Further development and refinement of animal models is essential to facilitate a better understanding of the pathophysiology underlying recessive ARS diseases, and ultimately to enable development and testing of effective therapies.