'All We Have to Decide Is What to Do with the Time That Is Given to Us' a Photovoice Study on Physical Activity in Nursing Homes

A 10-step participatory program for developing, implementing, and evaluating physical activity promoting actions in nursing homes in Germany

BACKGROUND

Since multidimensional barriers challenge nursing homes, a socio-ecological approach is needed for physical activity promotion in this setting. So far, little is known about how such an approach can be transferred into the successful development and implementation of PA-promoting actions together with stakeholders on-site. We aimed to investigate the actions and dimensions of PA-promoting actions and their sustainable implementation. To contribute to closing this gap, we present a 10-step program for co-developing and co-evaluating PA-promoting actions in nursing homes through an integrated counselling approach.

METHODS

We used a multiple case study approach that built upon manifold data sources, collected in 7 nursing homes over 3 years between 2021 and 2023. We collected fieldnotes and photologs from 14 future workshops (2 per home); 7 evaluation workshops (1 per home); 36 individual counsellings (2 sessions per resident), as well as 87 implementation protocols (action type and frequency), 11 evaluation questionnaires (changes among resources, cooperations, and collaborations); 7 goal attainment scales and 18 individual activity schedules. In addition, we retrieved and documented progress information at regular intervals by phone or email.

RESULTS

With staff, residents, relatives, and volunteers, we co-developed 112 ideas for PA promotion; from which 54 ideas were implemented and integrated into everyday life, differentiated into "activities of daily living," "structured activities," and "activity-friendly environments."; 18 residents in 4 homes participated in individual counselling to develop individual activity schedules. Eighteen actions were rated as "(much) more successful than expected"; 10 "(much) worse than expected," and 23 "as successful as expected." Three actions were not evaluated.

DISCUSSION

The participatory integrated counselling approach led to home-specific actions and promoted implementation into everyday life. The number and dimensions of actions implemented largely depended on the mission and vision of the respective home. The lack of staff could partially be compensated for by involving neighbourhoods, volunteers, and community organisations, such as local clubs.

CONCLUSION

To effectively promote PA in nursing homes, a tailored approach considering structural conditions, locations, volunteer engagement, and organisational visions is essential. Long-lasting partnerships and low-threshold opportunities prove promising. Future research should delve into structural-level change processes and outcomes in this context.

Empowerment through participation in community-based participatory research-effects of a physical activity promotion project among socially disadvantaged women

Introduction

Community-based participatory research (CBPR) approaches are associated with a range of positive impacts on empowerment. However, only a few studies have investigated the influence of different modes of target group participation on empowerment. The present study examined the empowerment processes and outcomes of women in difficult life situations through their participation as co-researchers in the form of Photovoice in "Stark durch Bewegung" (English: "Strong through Movement"), a CBPR project for physical activity (PA) promotion. The extent to which women's participation as co-researchers leads to empowerment was compared with other forms of participation.

Methods

The Photovoice approach consisted of three components: (1) photo task, (2) focus group interviews, and (3) exhibition of photos. It was then extended through participant observation. A total of 18 women took part in Photovoice. They took photos, were involved in four focus groups, helped in the analysis of data, and supported their exhibition. Two additional short focus group interviews in which four more women participated were conducted at the end of the project. The interview guideline was based on the SHOWeD questions proposed within the framework of Photovoice and enriched with various other questions (e.g., self-efficacy, social contacts, and community involvement). The data were analyzed based on a grounded theory approach.

Results

"Stark durch Bewegung" contributed to women's empowerment in several ways. By participating in the project's PA programs, the women reported numerous empowerment effects, such as improved self-efficacy, perceived competencies like swimming and language skills, and social networks. By participating as co-researchers, they perceived empowering processes on organizational and community levels that are comparable with other forms of participation (e.g., participation in a cooperative planning group) but also differ from them at relevant points (e.g., encouraging them to reflect on their own PA behaviors). The willingness to get involved in Photovoice was estimated to be significantly higher than in other possible forms of participation.

Conclusion

Our findings support the notion that health promotion interventions with marginalized groups can contribute to their empowerment on multiple levels when participants become equal partners in the CBPR project. Involving women as co-researchers has advantages over other forms of participation in terms of their empowerment.

ICT-Based Individualized Training of Institutionalized Individuals With Dementia. Evaluation of Usability and Trends Toward the Effectiveness of the InCoPE-App

Physical activity interventions can alleviate the course of disease for individuals with dementia (IWD) who have been extraordinarily affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. Information and Communication Technology (ICT) provides new opportunities not only to mitigate negative effects of the pandemic but also to sustainably improve everyday life of IWD in nursing homes. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the ICT-based InCoPE-App, which was used to assess physical and cognitive performance and deliver individualized exercise for IWD, with regard to 1) user experience of nursing assistants, and 2) trends toward the effectiveness of the intervention on physical and cognitive performance of IWD. An 18-week individualized multidomain intervention (2 × 60 min/session) was delivered to an intervention group (IG; n = 10, mean age 88.4 ± 5.6, 70% female) by nursing assistants (n = 10, mean age 56.1 ± 10.4, 90% female) using the InCoPE-App. A control group (CG; n = 3, mean age 87.3 ± 3.5, 100% female) received conventional treatment. User experience was assessed among nursing assistants by different questionnaires, i.e., PSSUQ and ISONORM 9241/110-S for usability, and AttrakDiff2 for pragmatic (PQ), hedonic quality-identity and stimulation (HQI and HQS), and attractiveness (ATT). Trends toward the effectiveness of the intervention were assessed using MMSE (global cognitive function), FICSIT-4 (balance), 6MWT and TUG (mobility), and m30CST (function of lower limbs). Usability of the InCoPE-App was rated as high by nursing assistants (mean ± SD; overall PSSUQ 2.11 ± 0.75; overall ISONORM 9241/110-S 1.90 ± 0.88; ATT 1.86 ± 1.01; PQ 1.79 ± 1.03; HQI 1.8 ± 0.79; and HQS 1.37 ± 0.69). Dropout was high in the total sample (36.7%). Trends toward the effectiveness were observed within IG in nine IWD who showed positive or neutral trends in at least two physical performance outcomes. Seven participants had positive or neutral trends in the FICSIT-4, seven participants in m30CST, and four and seven participants in 6MWT and TUG, respectively. In conclusion, the InCoPE-App has good nursing assistant-rated usability, whereas training effects and intervention adherence were rather low most likely due to COVID-19 restrictions. Single-subject research revealed more positive than negative trends in IG of IWD. Further research is needed to evaluate feasibility, suitability, and effectiveness of the InCoPE-App.